Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Iceland’s 4 day a week ( work related)

83 replies

Hushmental · 13/07/2021 21:13

Just want to know what everyone’s opinion is on this one. They have proved that working just 4 days a week resulted in increased productivity and happy employees. I would love if that’s implemented but I know it’s far from happening anytime soon. So my poll is Yabu if you don’t support it and yanbu if you think it will work.

OP posts:
snotf · 13/07/2021 23:23

Would you really need 20% more staff! Surely the vast majority of businesses have a combination of p/t & f/t workers & p/t workers wouldn't need to be reducing their hours, just changing the pattern.

Susannahmoody · 13/07/2021 23:22

No-one does anything on a Friday anyway

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/07/2021 23:18

@snotf

I'm sure there are potential benefits for all sectors but you haven't answered my fundamental question of how you run services that have to open 7 days a week with 20% fewer people?

Why would rotas not work? My GP has 7 GPs but only 2 f/t so they do this already to cover each day.

The rotas work, but you need 20% more staff to fill them if they are only working 80% of the hours that they do now. The fact that they may be more productive in the days that they are working is no help, because you still need cover for the 20% of time that they will now be off.
AppleKatie · 13/07/2021 23:13

On a 7 day a week service it’s 14.3% more staff not 20% surely?

Yes there would be budgetary implications but we can’t dismiss the fact that the Icelandic study has been successful and is now being widely adopted.

Different industries with different needs would obviously handle this in different ways.

I have worked part time for years and currently do a version of compressed hours. It works for me and I totally agree with the PP comments about being much more productive on part time hours and getting far more done than I did as a ‘full timer’.

The presenteeism reflect is strong in the nations pschye though.

snotf · 13/07/2021 23:12

I'm sure there are potential benefits for all sectors but you haven't answered my fundamental question of how you run services that have to open 7 days a week with 20% fewer people?

Why would rotas not work? My GP has 7 GPs but only 2 f/t so they do this already to cover each day.

TedHastingsweeDonkey · 13/07/2021 23:05

We are lucky that DH's work is super flexible. He has condensed his 5 day a week hours into 4 days a week, so although he is doing longer hours each day, has an extra day off that he spends with DS whilst I'm at work. One less day of childcare, and quality time he gets to spend with his son rather having to pay someone to do it. He's just as productive as before and his employer seems quite happy with the arrangement too, no complaints. He said it took a couple of weeks to get used to the longer days but just like with anything, once you get into a swing of things, it's fine. He says he'd not go back to 5 days again if there was a way. I'm looking to do this too when I go back FT. Good on Iceland!

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/07/2021 23:04

I'm sure there are potential benefits for all sectors but you haven't answered my fundamental question of how you run services that have to open 7 days a week with 20% fewer people?

It's naive to think that you can magic away the problems with a 'But we'll be more productive' wand. In your nursing example, people might well live longer as a result of more leisure time, but that actually increases the burden on the NHS because they will live with long-term conditions for longer. So more HCPs are needed for a healthy ageing population than one that drops dead of overwork at 60.

I'm supportive of a 4 day week over all, but wishing away the difficulties isn't going to get us there. Even if taxpayers were prepared to fund a 20% increase in public sector workforce costs, that still doesn't solve the question of how you recruit the extra staff. Healthcare and social care are already chronically understaffed and cannot recruit. The HCP workforce is rapidly ageing, particularly district nurses and GPs. We can't replace retirees at the moment. How are we going to magic up 20% more staff?

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 13/07/2021 22:59

I work in a school for a catering company

  1. Would this apply to schools???
  1. If it does that's 200 meals less/ week for my company

No way are they going to pay me the same when their sales are decreased by 1/5th I'd be forced to get a second job or receive more in universal credit

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 13/07/2021 22:57

Iceland the country

user615632456321125 · 13/07/2021 22:34

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

I can see how it would work for some industries, but what about all the services that have to function 7 days a week - utilities, police, healthcare, transport, retail etc etc? It's no use having more productive people 4 days a week when you need people actually staffing the services 7 days a week.

If you reduce a full-time equivalent working week from 5 days out of 7 to 4 days out of 7, you increase your workforce costs by 20% at a stroke. Yes, those individuals may be more productive but that doesn't produce much benefit because you still need to cover the day that they are no longer working. A highly productive nurse Monday to Thursday is no use to the patient who needs care on a Friday.

Lots of sectors like social care are barely able to function on current funding. If you increase their workforce costs by 20%, they will go under.

Sure, it definitely is more complex than the headline and it might not be directly applicable in the same way in every sector. But I guess you also have to look at the bigger picture of how it plays out in wider society and the economy rather than solely at individual business/organisation level?

For instance, Scandinavian prisons are run completely differently to here (loss of freedom is the punishment not the prison conditions - so the facilities are humane and decent like anyone should live in, the activities and training and support are designed to genuinely rehabilitate not traumatise, and the staff are better trained and remunerated), which took a much greater level of investment. However the result is that re-offending rates have dropped, communities are safer, and they don't need as many prisons. All of which are great on a big picture level.

So perhaps, using nursing per your example, investing more in nurses who provide better care to their patients means a healthier population and fewer people needing hospital care for as long. Fewer people leaving hospital traumatised or with health problems caused by neglect. The population working healthier hours and lifestyles could also have a positive knock on effect in terms of demand on hospitals.

People will have more time to exercise, and to spend money on leisure/social activities, which stimulates the economy and provides more tax income (both from individuals and businesses).

More people with caring responsibilities would be able to work. Some people would end up less burnt out from caring.

Society and the economy as a whole would change.

I'm not qualified to comment on precisely how, but I do know it's more complex than "how much money do we have in the pot for the wages" .

Todaytomorrowyesterday · 13/07/2021 22:21

I do 4 days now (I miss the FT money) but I’ve ended up just doing 5 days worth of work whilst being paid less.
Though I do enjoy my day off - yes it’s cleaning, walking dog etc but it means weekends are proper family time.

user615632456321125 · 13/07/2021 22:20

The 5 day working week has been proven time and time again to be ineffective and outdated.

It's kind of fascinating watching the resistance to change and insistence that a 5 day/37.5 hour working week is in some way meaningful or necessary or effective when the evidence shows it's not. The 37.5 hours working pattern is hardly ordained from above, but you'd think it sometimes from the defensive reactions.

I guess in the past there has been messaging around being lazy and weak if you don't work whatever "full time" was considered to be at that moment in time, and people perhaps feel like changing it or accepting less undermines their self-esteem or self image as a "hardworker" if they do fewer hours or accept they're not actually effective when working longer hours?

I did also read something last year about humans having a tendency to cling on to "doing things the way we always have" because it gives them a sense of meaning, even when there is a better way they could adopt (and when what they're clinging onto isn't actually meaningful). We are a meaning-seeking species.

snotf · 13/07/2021 22:17

I think it's a great idea. I think people would be far more productive in the 4days & do the equivalent of 5 days work anyway. I think people would be happy with 3 days off for family time, hobbies, recreation etc.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/07/2021 22:17

I can see how it would work for some industries, but what about all the services that have to function 7 days a week - utilities, police, healthcare, transport, retail etc etc? It's no use having more productive people 4 days a week when you need people actually staffing the services 7 days a week.

If you reduce a full-time equivalent working week from 5 days out of 7 to 4 days out of 7, you increase your workforce costs by 20% at a stroke. Yes, those individuals may be more productive but that doesn't produce much benefit because you still need to cover the day that they are no longer working. A highly productive nurse Monday to Thursday is no use to the patient who needs care on a Friday.

Lots of sectors like social care are barely able to function on current funding. If you increase their workforce costs by 20%, they will go under.

Cornishmumofone · 13/07/2021 22:12

I thought it was 35/36 hours over 4 days, which is what I do now. I work 8-6 M-F. I'm glad when Fridays come as I have a day off (DD is at preschool)... but I'm still working FT.

TheSpottedZebra · 13/07/2021 22:09

Is the thinking that the company closes for one weekday, or do people cover the 5 days between them, so have different days 'off' ?

user615632456321125 · 13/07/2021 22:06

@UthredofBattenberg

I'd support it, but there are the practicalities of the matter.

Do you have to work a longer 4 days to make up the extra day off? Have wages been cut by a 5th of not?

How have they made a viable?

Same salary.

Same length days. It is an actual reduction to working time not just a change in pattern. So 30 hours instead of 37.5.

There was no reduction in productivity because it turns out people aren't actually very productive when they're tired out. So it was more effective.

Tiredanawfullot · 13/07/2021 22:06

While I would love this and can see it would work in my sector, my husband owns a manufacturing site. If people aren’t there, the equipment isn’t running and products aren’t produced.

I am self employed and get an awful lot more don’t in a shorter period of time than I would have in the office.

UsernameNotAvailableApparently · 13/07/2021 22:04

I’d also really recommend looking at studies on how much time during a work week we are ‘productive’ and how much is just faffing/shallow work/procrastination. It’s fascinating, but then this is my specialist subject so I do love a nerd out on it Grin

Scarby9 · 13/07/2021 22:03

PS. And I should say that I really enjoy my job. I've just found I enjoy it even more four days a week!

101spacehoppers · 13/07/2021 22:02

A friend of mine implemented this in their company, with great success (4 days for the same pay). They had a research study attached to it and the findings were that yes people did produce slightly less, BUT - the increase in well being, staff retention and energy levels more than made up for it.

My organisation works a 4.5 day week which is great and prior to this I've done 4 days compressed for years. 4 day weeks are the best, when you're compensated the same. It doesn't work so well for hourly paid workers- you'd need to lift the baseline pay so people could choose to work fewer hours for the same money.

Scarby9 · 13/07/2021 22:02

I've been mostly working four days a week through the pandemic and I am not picking up the fifth day again.
I don't always manage not to work that last day, but even knowing I can stop early on one day makes me feel better. Having a day to turn round mid week, or an occasional long weekend is brilliant when I do manage it.
I'm definitely in favour.

Deliaskis · 13/07/2021 21:57

Our company are looking into this. They've looked at the data from Iceland, and also from some UK and US companies similar to ours who have implemented it, and it looks compelling. It seems that by and large people achieve more by working fewer hours. The model we're looking at is same take home pay, very slightly longer days (like 85% hours over 4 days), everybody works less but apparently actually gets more done. It sounds like nonsense but the numbers are pretty convincing.

Obviously only works in some sectors!

TeardropsFallingOnHotSand · 13/07/2021 21:57

Not surprised. Personally I think they should close on Sundays.

Usual2usual · 13/07/2021 21:56

I have worked 4 days a week for years now mostly for childcare reasons but even with both kids being at school come August I will be keeping it up.

I most definitley do 5 days worth of work in 4 days, my job doesn't allow for anything else (i.e. you have a workload and it needs done, if you are part time then you have the same work to do as a full timer and less hours to complete it in). I am used to it and don't find it stressful but I would say for sure that I am extremley productive and have learned to be super organised.

I am sure that the SNP had it in their manifesto for the Scottish election but we will see what comes of it.

I just think Britain is a bit stuck in its ways with the whole Mon-Fri 9-5 mentality that it won't really take off here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread