Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Iceland’s 4 day a week ( work related)

83 replies

Hushmental · 13/07/2021 21:13

Just want to know what everyone’s opinion is on this one. They have proved that working just 4 days a week resulted in increased productivity and happy employees. I would love if that’s implemented but I know it’s far from happening anytime soon. So my poll is Yabu if you don’t support it and yanbu if you think it will work.

OP posts:
snotf · 14/07/2021 07:57

Perhaps I'm unusual as currently if I increase my hours I will get a pay raise as I will be able to take on my responsibility. However I like my balance & don't want more responsibility & hours.

snotf · 14/07/2021 07:53

You're just evading the point. If you have a full-time colleague who is on the same rate as you now, are you really telling me you'd be happy for them to get a 20% pay increase while your pay stays the same? Because I don't believe you.

It's not evasion, it's true & I have never worked anywhere with everyone on the same salary. You keep saying pay rise but I don't see it is getting a pay rise, their pay is staying the same.

snotf · 14/07/2021 07:50

The OP is about the Iceland experiment, which was about reducing hours, rather than just compressing them.

But it doesn't mean we have to copy the Iceland experiment, it would be interesting to know how they handle p/t workers.

Hardbackwriter · 14/07/2021 00:03

I work both reduced and compressed hours - I work 4.5 days over 4 - and love it. I do still do exactly the same workload as I did full-time in 90% of the time and for 90% of the pay, but for me I'm happy with that trade-off because I value my day off so much. I will admit though that if my organisation adopted a four day week for full-time pay as standard I'd definitely want the rest of my pay back!

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 14/07/2021 00:03

@snotf

Plus none of us earn the same anyway. We are earn different amounts & the f/t workers are more senior with more responsibility & already get paid a higher hourly rate.
You're just evading the point. If you have a full-time colleague who is on the same rate as you now, are you really telling me you'd be happy for them to get a 20% pay increase while your pay stays the same? Because I don't believe you.
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 14/07/2021 00:00

@snotf

Now the part-timer is still earning £20/hour but the full-timer is earning £24/hour.

But who said the f/t wouldn't work longer days?

The OP is about the Iceland experiment, which was about reducing hours, rather than just compressing them.
user27424799642256 · 14/07/2021 00:00

So you think that part-timers are going to be happy doing the same hours, for the same money, when their full-time colleagues have just had an effective 20% pay rise and a 20% reduction in hours? Dream on!

I do agree. I wonder if this was something encountered with the Iceland case and how it was handled.

HelloDaisy · 13/07/2021 23:56

We’ve talked about it before with our business as I was trying to find out if it would help the work/life balance for our employees. I’m all for finding other ways to work that would help everyone.

However we work in the building trade and in order for them to work only 4 days a week we would have to increase our charges to customers as our income would drop and I’m not sure any would be happy with that…

snotf · 13/07/2021 23:56

Plus none of us earn the same anyway. We are earn different amounts & the f/t workers are more senior with more responsibility & already get paid a higher hourly rate.

snotf · 13/07/2021 23:55

Do you really think that the part-timer is going to say,'That's fine by me, because my full-time colleague is now more productive' ?

No but this p/t is telling you that I would still stick to my 3 days at my pay rate rather than increase my hours at all. If I was offered a 5 day salary but to do the job in 4 days I would rather keep my 3 days.

snotf · 13/07/2021 23:53

Now the part-timer is still earning £20/hour but the full-timer is earning £24/hour.

But who said the f/t wouldn't work longer days?

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/07/2021 23:51

@user615632456321125

That's a lot of disparaging references to "magic" and "wishful" on the side of the proposal which you don't like. I note the good ol' "why should taxpayers fund..." being included too. Can you make your argument for maintaining the status quo without the political spin and by engaging with what others have said?

You dislike the idea, fine. This is a chat board, most of us have not seen the detailed research findings, aren't trained in economics or public sector financial management. We are not going to be able to make sense of this 4d(?) Jigsaw or formulate the next stages of the experiment or potential outcomes.

Not being able to visualize or understand doesn't mean it can't happen and be effective. I would be very interested in any data or research on how to begin taking the principles to other sectors.

Actually I don't dislike the idea at all. I've done a lot of work on tackling presenteeism. I think we would benefit greatly from a 4 day week.

It's precisely because I support the idea that I am so irritated by a refusal to engage with the practical difficulties that would need to be overcome.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/07/2021 23:47

Come off it, @snotf.

Say you're a worker on £20/hour now, regardless of whether you're full-time or part-time.

We bring in a 4 day week but the full-timers' salaries don't change.

Now the part-timer is still earning £20/hour but the full-timer is earning £24/hour.

Do you really think that the part-timer is going to say,'That's fine by me, because my full-time colleague is now more productive' ?

wheresmymojo · 13/07/2021 23:47

Also haven't Portugal had funding from the EU recently to trial this as part of their COVID recovery?

wheresmymojo · 13/07/2021 23:46

YANBU

Where I work we finish at 3pm on Fridays in the summer and I can't see that it makes any difference in productivity in my team but it does make us all a bit saner!

user615632456321125 · 13/07/2021 23:46

That's a lot of disparaging references to "magic" and "wishful" on the side of the proposal which you don't like. I note the good ol' "why should taxpayers fund..." being included too. Can you make your argument for maintaining the status quo without the political spin and by engaging with what others have said?

You dislike the idea, fine. This is a chat board, most of us have not seen the detailed research findings, aren't trained in economics or public sector financial management. We are not going to be able to make sense of this 4d(?) Jigsaw or formulate the next stages of the experiment or potential outcomes.

Not being able to visualize or understand doesn't mean it can't happen and be effective. I would be very interested in any data or research on how to begin taking the principles to other sectors.

snotf · 13/07/2021 23:40

So you think that part-timers are going to be happy doing the same hours, for the same money, when their full-time colleagues have just had an effective 20% pay rise and a 20% reduction in hours? Dream on!

I don't see it like that, their pay is remaining the same but they are doing less hours, not necessarily less work. I work 3 days a week & am happy with that. I know there are often quiet periods in the office & my f/t colleagues are getting paid to chat or surf the net, so what.

shakeitoffshakeacocktail · 13/07/2021 23:39

I bet you'd all despair if the you were on 4 days and schools went to 4 days 🤣

I guess we won't know as it's conjecture but can I not be part of the 4 day week dream too? Or is it too inconvenient for me and schools to be part of it?? I work in the kitchens

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/07/2021 23:37

@snotf

My team has 3 p/t & 2 f/t. The 2 f/t could drop a day each without needing to employ extra people for cover.
So you think that part-timers are going to be happy doing the same hours, for the same money, when their full-time colleagues have just had an effective 20% pay rise and a 20% reduction in hours? Dream on!

You might convince part-timers to continue their current hours, but they are going to expect the same pay uplift as the full-timers so your costs go up 20% across the board.

Hushmental · 13/07/2021 23:36

Some really interesting discussion here. Like some of you mentioned , some industries like healthcare may have to use a different approach or handle it differently. Government and some greedy corporates are going to find a way to not implement this anyway I think 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
RaininSummer · 13/07/2021 23:33

I worked 4 days a week for 10 years in my last job and am full time now in a new job. I feel quite burned out each week now and wonder how long I can keep it up.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 13/07/2021 23:31

On a 7 day a week service it’s 14.3% more staff not 20% surely?

Why? If staff are working 4 days a week instead of 5, you need 20% more of them.

There's no reason at all why a 4 day week couldn't work for 7 day services, provided we could find the money and staff to cover the gap. But I don't see how we can.

The entire population of Iceland is about the equivalent of Coventry. The challenges of implementing a 4 day week n the U.K. are several orders of magnitude greater. They aren't insurmountable, but we won't magic them away with wishful thinking.

tintodeverano2 · 13/07/2021 23:28

time.com/5948677/four-day-work-week-spain/

Spain are currently trialling a 4-day week there.

snotf · 13/07/2021 23:26

My team has 3 p/t & 2 f/t. The 2 f/t could drop a day each without needing to employ extra people for cover.

snotf · 13/07/2021 23:23

sorry my ! should be a ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread