Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Iceland’s 4 day a week ( work related)

83 replies

Hushmental · 13/07/2021 21:13

Just want to know what everyone’s opinion is on this one. They have proved that working just 4 days a week resulted in increased productivity and happy employees. I would love if that’s implemented but I know it’s far from happening anytime soon. So my poll is Yabu if you don’t support it and yanbu if you think it will work.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BackforGood · 15/07/2021 23:15

I think if you have asked for reduced, or compressed hours, you are probably very productive, as you appreciate how nice it is to have that "extra" day off.
I suspect, within a year or so of "everyone" working fewer days, and it slowly becoming "normal" to work 4 days and not 5, the novelty would wear off and - if you aren't there "proving yourself to be as valuable as FT colleagues" incentive isn't there, then the productivity levels would start to drop as people just began to accept a 3 day weekend as the norm after the novelty wore off.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 15/07/2021 09:45

The key is that whatever full time is has to attract the same total after tax full time salary and pension and holidays etc. etc. - actually the same, taking shift allowances etc into account where relevant - and obviously the same pro rata for part time employees (2 days per week would be 50% not 40%).

I can't see why it wouldn't work for healthcare in a 24/7/365 environment, except that more employees would be needed - it'd be incredibly shit to say everyone except those in healthcare gets a 4 day week and would lead to a lot of healthcare workers, especially the lower paid ones and those who've invested less time training, leaving healthcare and fewer young people choosing to work in healthcare - cue crisis impacting everyone a few years down the line.

As everyone knows from care in the community and inclusion in education, ideologically brilliant ideas which should improve quality of life and society as a whole are usually twisted into cost cutting measures by government and corporations and end up making everything immeasurably worse, especially for the groups whom they were sold hardest to as the start of a brave new world...

Mreggsworth · 15/07/2021 09:33

I think what your job entails plays a big part.

My job currently requires a lot of report writing, creativity and problem solving. It's one of those things that if I'm not in the mood or dont have the concentration, I can't force it. I'm freelance and work 5/6 days a week long hours, if I actually tracked my productivity properly and counted the time that i was actually doing work work and not staring into space or going on a YouTube rabbit hole, it probably could easily be condensed into 4 days a week. By Friday my ability to do anything that requires much thought is almost zilch, I'll spend 4 hours writing something I could do in an hour on Monday, yet I still sit at my desk the whole time trying to get it done.

However when I had a hands on job there were no peaks and troths with motivation and momentum, if something had to be done there and then there was no two ways about it, however less thought had to go into the task but it applied more physical effort. My productivity in that role would have definitely been more over 5 days than 4, and theres not really anyway you can condense that.

So that opens up another argument. That potentially more creative and decision making jobs could be more productive over 4 days, and more hands on labour roles are better over 5. And it just so happens that the former is typically associated with higher pay and the latter with lower pay.

IsItMeOrIsItYou · 14/07/2021 23:42

We have always done this at my work (NHS outpatients). 37.5 hours compressed into 4 days. People have different days off. There are more appointments available for patients because we start earlier and finish later than the 9-5 ‘norm’. Love having an extra day off, it’s great for making appointments and getting jobs done.

Finknottlesnewt · 14/07/2021 21:51

Civil service here -I have worked 'compressed hours' 4 days over 5 for a decade.. I can recommend a 4 day week and a 3 day weekend .

Hardbackwriter · 14/07/2021 17:39

For organisations that can just reduce their working day, that doesn't matter, as long as productivity stays the same.

I think even that might be tough - as I said, I do a full-time workload in 90% hours, which I think is probably the case for everyone in my organisation who works 0.9 (which is actually quite a lot of people at my level - it's a very female workplace and people commonly do this '4.5 days in 4' pattern when they return from mat leave). This works ok because I do indeed find I'm able to be more productive in the time I have and so fit (cram) it in. But there's a limit to that elasticity - if the organisation cut everyone's hours by 20% so mine would effectively become 0.72 - basically 3.5 days a week - then I couldn't do the same workload any more. At some point the 'work fewer hours but do it more productively' idea has to fall down because you just aren't doing enough hours no matter how hard you work in them.

Procrastination4 · 14/07/2021 15:00

Seemingly the Icelandic trial results haven’t been reported accurately and consequently it’s not been quite as successful as we are led to believe, apparently.

theconversation.com/the-success-of-icelands-four-day-week-trial-has-been-greatly-overstated-164083

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 14/07/2021 14:35

People working 100% aren't suddenly making proportionally more than me per hour

But only because your employers are now paying you the same salary for fewer hours as well. Upthread, some PPs were suggesting that the financial impact of a 4 day week could be reduced because lots of people work part-time anyway, so nothing would need to change for them. But, in practice, it's impossible for employers to give an effective pay rise to full-time employees (by reducing their hours) without giving part-timers the same benefit. So everyone's pay rate per hour goes up.

For organisations that can just reduce their working day, that doesn't matter, as long as productivity stays the same. But, if you are running a hospital, a train line, a water company or any other service that has to stay open for the same number of hours as now, it's a huge cost pressure. The NHS wage bill is about £48 billion. If we reduce normal working hours by 20%, without reducing salaries, that bill rises by another £10 billion. Same problem for all other industries/services that can't reduce their hours.

Woodmarsh · 14/07/2021 10:54

Sounds great in theory but so many industries it wouldn't work in

PuffinShop · 14/07/2021 10:12

I’m sure it is popular amongst those who have it, but it is not the case for most of us.

But it is true that most unions have negotiated a shorter working week and that covers the majority of workers in Iceland, though not all. Although of course the foreign media have distorted it as they always do.

PuffinShop · 14/07/2021 10:04

Essentially I think some people are looking at it in an odd way, if you are talking about what is happening in Iceland with the shortening of the working week. 40 hours = 100% is arbitrary. They just changed it so 100% = 36 hours instead (or my union did).
There have always been people who work over 100% and that won't change but they may be slightly fewer now. More part timers will be able to work 100% or closer to that. And a lot of people will have a better work life balance.

covidandborisandworld · 14/07/2021 10:01

I work In hospitality at a VERY popular tourist attraction. It's the top in the uk. It's open all year and weekends except Xmas day and Boxing Day.

We are allowed to choose 40 hour 32 hour 24 hour or 16 hour contracts and can up or decrease as we require every two years. We get 6 weeks holiday a year.

I can tell you that the people in the shorter hours are happier more proactive with customers less bitching and have a good work life balance than those on the 5
40 hour contracts. I will NEVER go on 40 hours.

However in my situation the money will change so you have to be able to afford it.

covidandborisandworld · 14/07/2021 09:53

I'd support a slightly longer working day and a day off too.

covidandborisandworld · 14/07/2021 09:53

I agree with it If production stays same then salary should stay same

Devondonkey · 14/07/2021 09:52

Doesn’t it only work it literally everyone in the country does it at the same time? Because otherwise can’t see how it isn’t just doing the same job for presumably 80% of the pay. Which I could do now. But…. Can’t.

reprehensibleme · 14/07/2021 09:51

DH does condensed hours so works a full time job in 4 days, has been doing it for about 6 years and it is brilliant. When he was working across 5 days, he always seemed to work several hours unpaid overtime a week but now because he's in the office for about 9.5 hours a day, the perception is that he's doing overtime even when he isn't!

He rarely had time off sick anyway, but can't remember having a sick day in the last 6 years. Stuff like car MOT and dentist appts are all made for his day off and it means we have a 'long weekend' every week - work/life balance has improved immeasurably.

Would have to stop everyone wanting Friday off though - DH thinks that part of the reason his request was approved was that he wanted Mondays off, not Fridays!

Whynotnowbaby · 14/07/2021 09:50

I live in Iceland and the reality is not quite what is reported in the media. The 4 day a week thing was a trial scheme for direct employees of Reykjavik council (maybe 1000 people) so not a universal whole-country initiative. I’m sure it is popular amongst those who have it, but it is not the case for most of us.

Rather than the four day a week initiative, I think there are compelling arguments to look at other aspects of Icelandic society that mean we have a much better work-life balance than the U.K. These mainly come down to a strong union presence and generally socialist outlook. Some examples:

  • everyone can have full weeks of time off, no matter what their job. A friend is a nurse and will not be working at all for the month of July (and will still have plenty of flexibility to take the odd day off throughout the rest of the year too).
  • I am a teacher, we have agreed numbers of teaching periods (26x40 minutes a week) which allows for plenty of time to mark, plan and form positive relationships with parents and the children themselves. Any extras are paid.
  • Childcare is very cheap and excellent.

I could go on but these are more embedded positives than the headline grabbing 4 days a week.

Of course it’s not great for everyone, there are unscrupulous employers who flout labour rules and take advantage of foreigners who are desperate for work.

PuffinShop · 14/07/2021 09:49

I haven't changed it yet, though, so I'm still 75% for now and of course my hours have been reduced. People working 100% aren't suddenly making proportionally more than me per hour, that makes no sense. The extra time is nice, but as I say since I was already not full time I don't really need it and I'll change my contract to get the extra money instead.

PuffinShop · 14/07/2021 09:44

It's not 4 days, most unions have reduced working hours for the same pay but people who worked 5 days still work 5 days. They are just a bit shorter.
It's brilliant, who wouldn't want shorter hours for the same pay. I work 75% so I didn't need the reduction in hours, but now I can go up to 80 or 85% without any significant change to my working day so it's essentially a pay rise for me.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 14/07/2021 09:33

@JingsMahBucket

The 'invest in more staff' argument is flawed. They can't plug the gaps now in primary care.

They could probably get more staff if they invested more in staff in terms of wages. Care staff and healthcare staff are paid a pittance as it is.

I'm sure they could, but we would need a willingness on behalf of the government and taxpayers to fund this. We would also need consumers to be willing to absorb the increased costs of services, retail, transport etc. I don't see any evidence of willingness to do so. I would also note that the burden of increased costs for essential goods will fall disproportionately on the poorest people.

Lots of people would like Friday off, but not many people want to pay 20% more for goods and services.

Iceland is a much richer country than the UK. Their per capita GDP is 21% higher than ours.

Again, I don't think the obstacles to a 4 day week in the UK are unsurmountable. But they are formidable, and would require a root and branch reform of our entire tax system, and a major shift in the attitude of taxpayers/voters. It's not as simple as "What's the issue, because no one gets any work done on Fridays?", as some PPs have implied.

JingsMahBucket · 14/07/2021 09:07

The 'invest in more staff' argument is flawed. They can't plug the gaps now in primary care.

They could probably get more staff if they invested more in staff in terms of wages. Care staff and healthcare staff are paid a pittance as it is.

Blurp · 14/07/2021 09:03

I would assume that part time workers would also get a relative pay rise, or work fewer hours. If you currently work 50% of the week (2.5 days), you'll earn half of what someone doing the same role full time earns.

If your work goes to a 4-day week, then either you work 2 days for the same pay as before, or you're now working more than 50% of the week so you'd get a pay rise.

cptartapp · 14/07/2021 08:53

MissLucy is spot on. The resentment would be incredible. Wouldn't make me as a part time nurse want to be more productive, quite the opposite. The 'invest in more staff' argument is flawed.They can't plug the gaps now in primary care.

Usual2usual · 14/07/2021 08:28

If my whole workplace dropped to 30 hours over 4 days (same as I am currently) I would expect to get a payrise or see the full timers get a pay cut, no way I would expect to be paid less for working the same hours!

bridgetreilly · 14/07/2021 08:27

I work 4 days, and would never ever change. I’m sure that I wouldn’t get more done if I did 5 days.

But there are different kinds of jobs. Some jobs have a direct link between time worked and productivity. Some jobs are about making sure there’s always a person there, e.g. on reception, at the checkout. Not every job can be condensed into less time.