Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you employ a FT nanny/housekeeper, what is your household income?

89 replies

UncleBunclesHouse · 13/07/2021 19:41

I feel that we need this service but it just seems like something I’ve only thought was for the very wealthy, not ‘normal’ working people. I don’t know if I’m being unrealistic or out of my league to recruit for this position.

Not necessary for the answer but so as not to drip feed, I earn 6 figures and husband income is less clear as self employed. For various reasons we would need the nanny/housekeeper to be self employed also and invoice us their bill. I’d want a really good one who is doing it as a career and can be very proactive in running the home and engaging with the children to further their development, plus flexible as our jobs can sometimes mean unpredictable hours.

OP posts:
Butterflyfox · 13/07/2021 22:03

Just to go against the grain and say it is possible to get a nanny/housekeeper to happily do both roles but you need to be soo clear during the recruitment process. A previous nanny I had would carefully take the children’s cereal bowls off the table into the dishwasher after breakfast and leave mine to make the point she was a nanny not a housekeeper. I learned. My current one employed as nanny housekeeper for years now loves running the whole house, kids, errands, cooking, shopping. To answer your question directly I am not on a footballer/ banker income but a lone parent on a senior professional salary which I know is an enormous privilege. I prioritise this over any other spending as it affects all areas of my life for the better. The house is taken care of and I can focus on my job during the week and my kids at the weekend with no stress.

UncleBunclesHouse · 13/07/2021 22:02

@Littlemissweepy

I presumed OP means wealth in the class of footballers and royals etc vs high earning working professionals.
@Littlemissweepy correct - apologies if that came across badly, I wasn’t trying to offend
OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 13/07/2021 22:00

I first employed a nanny almost twenty years ago when our household income was about 120k

At that point it was cost effective as I had two in FT childcare although it did take all my salary plus more to pay the nanny.

We stopped needing a FT nanny about five years ago and decided to get a FT housekeeper after about a year. Because our housekeeper is a luxury rather than a necessity I could only justify it on the basis that I was earning many times what I was in 2002.

OP only you can know whether it’s affordable to you.

Tenbob · 13/07/2021 21:59

We have had successful nanny housekeepers for several years

They were very good and organised at using nap times to do housework when Dc were at long nap stage, and then when they were at nursery in the morning, they had lots of time to get everything done

The cleaner we previously employed did 4hrs twice a week, so the total hours over the course of the week were about the same.

But, we aren’t total slobs. We didn’t leave all the laundry, dishwasher, cooking etc to the nanny.

If you’re the sort of person that treats a cleaner like a skivvy, you would need 2 people

RonaldMcDonald · 13/07/2021 21:56

We employed a nanny and had a cleaner x2 a week
Our nanny cost about £41k
The cleaner £4K
Between us we earned about £185k

londonmummy1966 · 13/07/2021 21:53

It just doesn't work to have a nanny/hk I'm afraid. I had a full time all singing all dancing nanny who did everything child related and a few household things on top - eg made enough supper for the children that DH and I could have some too later in the evening and did the weekly shop for us. She was live in (but only worked Mon-Fri) and had a car for her own use in her own time as well as with DC. She'd probably be on about £35k gross if I was emplying her now (plus I'dd be picking up the tab on the benefit in kind of the car). I had a separate self employed cleaner who came in and cleaned the rest of the house and put the washing on/did the ironing and organised sending sheets etc out to the laundry service. (A further £12 or so an hour at current rates plus the laundry service.)

It was sometime ago now as DC are much older but I guess that our joint salaries would equate to about £350K in today's money. TBH I needed the childcare as DH worked abroad a hell of a lot (away most weeks in my second pregnancy) and I was client facing and often had to stay late - I did negotiate that overtime after 8.30pm at night meant that my firm reimbursed the overtime I paid my nanny though.

dworky · 13/07/2021 21:53

I can say however that I have never found anyone who is capable of both nannying and doing housekeeping well at the same time.
And nor should they be. Totally different things.

Scarby9 · 13/07/2021 21:49

I think if you are considering paying a full time 'normal' working person's salary - or even two - out of your salary, you must realise that you earn more than a 'normal' working person.

gogohm · 13/07/2021 21:44

Legally you must employ if you are their only or principal employer, unless they are paid through an agency in which case you pay the agency instead who sorts the pension, tax etc. You can't choose for them to be self employed

Sparechange · 13/07/2021 21:43

@Pricklypear12

It depends where you live

In most of London, you would struggle to get a decent 2-bed flat for much under £2k a month to rent, or £500k to buy, which is going to be a mortgage payment of about the same, plus outgoings

Nurseries are £2k a month per child

£100k salary is a take home of around £5k/month once you’ve made a pension contribution

So having a few hundred a month left over once you’ve paid your housing, bills food
Shopping and childcare is hardly living the high life
Add in an expected extra child who needs another £2k/month nursery place and you’re fucked

Pricklypear12 · 13/07/2021 21:36

(completely misses point of thread) Brew

Pricklypear12 · 13/07/2021 21:34

There's been some strange threads on MN lately where people earning 6 figure salaries feel they're struggling financially. Did anyone see the recent thread of someone considering an abortion due to financial reasons yet the combined income of the 2 parents was around 100k a year. I can only imagine that perhaps some people have huge outgoings due to gigantic mortgages or something??? I cannot imagine thinking I struggle when earning anything past 60k to be honest.

SmidgenofaPigeon · 13/07/2021 21:24

@Octopuscake surely SAHM are doing their own washing and cooking etc so it’s not exactly comparable to a nanny doing it! I’m not a nanny for adults, I still have all my own washing and cleaning and cooking to do at home!

SmidgenofaPigeon · 13/07/2021 21:18

@Octopuscake

Because I’m a nanny, not a cleaner. When I say I do everything related to the children, I sew, darn, batch cook, organise activities and play dates, sort their artwork/general tat that they accumulate everywhere, book holiday camps, plan activities, sort dentist and hair and doctor appointments. Stuff that my employer just wouldn’t deal with. I’ll load and unload the dishwasher. But I’m not employed to deal with adult’s dirty washing and I don’t expect to be their personal chef, either. Plus when the children aren’t at school, which don’t forget was a lot this year and last, I had home-schooling to deal with, and when they’re at home I don’t have time to do most of the stuff I mentioned above.

I do not live in either.

cariadlet · 13/07/2021 21:16

A household where there are 2 salaries, one of which is 6 figures and the other - although "unclear" is clearly not minimum wage - is hardly a "normal" working family.

I earn £40K so less than half of what you earn but still understand that I earn well over the average wage and I appreciate how well off I am.

I find the disclaimer in the op infuriating.

Tenbob · 13/07/2021 21:06

And also, the ‘competition’ to employ good nanny housekeepers is tough
They interview you as much as you interview them

Any hint that you’re going to run them ragged or take the piss with hours, and they’ll have other families to choose from
They know their worth, rightfully

It’s usual to pay a Christmas bonus (we give 2 weeks pay) but you can do that in cash rather than running it through the payroll

Octopuscake · 13/07/2021 21:02

If the children are school age why on earth can a nanny only cook and launder for them? I appreciate people are career nannies and don't want to be cleaners. But on a £42k salary you should be able to manage washing, some xleaning, cooking for the whole family. Like SAHMs do who don't have nannies.

I have always employed nannies and yes they focus on the children but now the kids are older they cook an evening meal for us all and hang out washing if it's there. I wouldn't expect them to arrange dinner parties or get my car MOTd but if I expressly employed someone as nanny housekeeper, I would expect a bit of light cleaning.

Littlemissweepy · 13/07/2021 21:01

I presumed OP means wealth in the class of footballers and royals etc vs high earning working professionals.

eurochick · 13/07/2021 21:00

Not many nannies want nanny/housekeeper roles but you might be lucky.

As others have said they will be an employee, with all that entails - NI, tax, pension, expenses, insurance, etc.

MrsKoala · 13/07/2021 20:59

When I had dd we hired a Nanny for 3 days a week 11am-8pm. She was more a mothers helper because I was home too (not working) and we shared looking after the older toddlers/kids and DD. She wasn't a housekeeper and never cooked or cleaned (apart from tidy the kids toys if she'd had them out). We had to pay an agency and a payroll company and it cost us just under £3k per month. H earned 6 figures (just) and it was crippling with our mortgage and £500 per month fares.

oblada · 13/07/2021 20:59

Also very much depends where you live.
Nannies near me are very happy with 12quids per hour. I'm in the north west. London/South won't be the same.

FlowersinJune · 13/07/2021 20:59

We had a full time nanny till last year. 35 k including pension and ni. There were also other costs mileage and insurance. As others say if they are only working for you they can’t be self employed.

Tenbob · 13/07/2021 20:59

They can’t be self-employed unless they work for 3 or more families, and have a degree of flexibility over their hours

We have a nanny housekeeper who does 8-6 four days a week and a half day on Fridays

We pay her £12/hr net, which gives us a tax and NI bill of around £2k per quarter on top of what we pay her directly (we use nanny PAYE as the payroll company and they work out the tax bill etc for us, and send payslips)

All in, it’s around £3k a month to have her

But, nurseries around here are £2k+ a month, plus we previously used doggy daycare which was £550 a month, plus a cleaner at £250 a month

So being able to combine these with one person was a financial and practical no-brainer

It was also a massive peace of mind to know that we didn’t have to live in fear of a ‘DC are ill, can you collect them from nursery and they can’t come back for 3 days’ call

TheatricalGiraffe · 13/07/2021 20:57

Please could you explain why you've put "very wealthy, not ‘normal’ working people" and "I earn 6 figures and husband income is less clear as self employed." in the same sentence as if you're classing yourself as not wealthy?

Littlemissweepy · 13/07/2021 20:50

Well I say full time she does 28 hours a week over 4 days + non compulsory over time when asked (of which since Covid there hasn’t been much due to lack of work travel) .

Swipe left for the next trending thread