Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you employ a FT nanny/housekeeper, what is your household income?

89 replies

UncleBunclesHouse · 13/07/2021 19:41

I feel that we need this service but it just seems like something I’ve only thought was for the very wealthy, not ‘normal’ working people. I don’t know if I’m being unrealistic or out of my league to recruit for this position.

Not necessary for the answer but so as not to drip feed, I earn 6 figures and husband income is less clear as self employed. For various reasons we would need the nanny/housekeeper to be self employed also and invoice us their bill. I’d want a really good one who is doing it as a career and can be very proactive in running the home and engaging with the children to further their development, plus flexible as our jobs can sometimes mean unpredictable hours.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SnarkyWitch · 15/07/2021 22:16

Most nannies earn 5 figure a year incomes so your 6 figure income won’t cut it! SIL was a nannie she earned 35k plus car and live in, didn’t clean anything

Xenia · 15/07/2021 21:26
  1. You don't choose the law. She would have to be a PAYE employee and you would have to pay employer NI, employee NI and tax as we did.
  2. Nannies don't do house keeping so we had someone in addition who came mornings only Monday to Friday when we needed that help.
  3. What do people earn to afford that? Depends but obviously more than that grossed up before tax salary plus employer NI. So eg it might take £50k of your own before tax earnings, then you pay 40%+ tax on that, then the balance pays the nanny's employer NI, employee NI , tax and her pay (and food when caring for the children). I am a lawyer and have always worked full time so we used a daily nanny.
Octopuscake · 15/07/2021 21:20

@Crankley I agree people can take on whatever role they like and say yes or no to ant task or responsibility when hired.

The point I'm making is that some people on the thread said it simply wasn't possible to do nanny and housekeeper jobs well, with school age children. I was just a bit Hmm

DontDrinkDontSmokeWhatDoIDo · 15/07/2021 20:12

@Crankley

You're right - it's all about expectation setting.

And I imagine as the work world finds its feet with home working / hybrid wording, the nanny / childcare role will continue to evolve.

Crankley · 15/07/2021 17:04

Octopuscake Say you work as a PR executive, how would you feel about being asked to pick up some extra tasks from a lower level member of staff? Would you be happy with that? A lot of nannies are highly trained and skilled and I'm not surprised if they are not interested in doing a cleaner's/housekeeper's tasks. Of course there are exceptions to every rule.

Maggiesfarm · 15/07/2021 16:33

PS: I do get that most nannies don't do housekeeping which is fair enough, however there are people who are nanny-housekeepers and advertise themselves as such.

Maggiesfarm · 15/07/2021 16:10

Suggesting your six figure salary is normal is a kick in the teeth for the many people who earn substantially less

How so? The op is not likely to be advertising her income worldwide and this is an anonymous internet forum where people can surely share quite a lot of things, including finances where relevant. There are and will always be always people who earn more than others, that's life. Everyone will encounter problems regardless of income.

I cannot remember now whether the six figure income is a joint one: op and partner. I assume so. Good for them.

Cazzovuoi · 15/07/2021 09:47

Suggesting your six figure salary is normal is a kick in the teeth for the many people who earn substantially less

Oh chuff off, people are allowed to earn 6 figures and shouldn't apologise for it. Wealthy people are entitled to ask questions that might only apply to wealthy people. Racing to the bottom is not the way to deal with envy.

OP we have a housekeeper. We are her employers because she is with us full time. We're not in the UK so salary isn't comparable.

She works Monday to Friday, but very flexible. She starts at 7am to have breakfast ready for us and then she can manage her day as she likes. If she wants to go off for a few hours during the day she does, but makes up the time. I really don't care when she's here during the day as long as the work is done. She's not a nanny though, not sure if my post is helpful!

SmidgenofaPigeon · 15/07/2021 09:39

@Octopuscake I don’t think you get it!

I’m on a great salary WITHOUT taking on all those things- I’m also 30 weeks pregnant so will be leaving on maternity soon anyway- and the family employs a cleaner for all of that. I look after the children and that’s that. I do do all their beds and other laundry. I’m certainly not willing to take on the adult’s cooking and washing too, as many nannies don’t (although more often than not I make bigger portions of the from-scratch cooking I do for the kids so they tend to eat that anyway) If I wanted to be a nanny housekeeper I’m sure I could, but I don’t.

Octopuscake · 15/07/2021 09:06

*be able to not benefit! Not sure you'd benefit Smile

Octopuscake · 15/07/2021 09:06

Some nannies don't want to be housekeepers too - I get that, and it's a completely reasonable choice. But @SmidgenofaPigeon if you wanted to(which you don't, it's fine) you would actually benefit able to do more than childcare or cooking for the children / admin within your working day.

Obviously not as a nanny to 2 year old twins given as an example in another post - until school age it's mostly childcare. And I don't think it's possible to clean a house like a cleaner, and take care of children.

But in term time, on a full time nanny/housekeeper salary, if you are & want to be a nanny/housekeeper, it is surely possible to tidy a room, strip beds, each day shove washing on/hang it out including towels and whatever is in the basket, cook a family meal for 4+ people, and do admin like ensuring uniform is ready, ordering a few bits online, booking dentist appointments. Then at 3.30 help kids with homework and serve food. I say again, a SAHM would do this and more.

It doesn't matter that you have your own housework to do in the evening- so does everyone who works! The parents would still be sorting out their own lives, parenting at night, just not having to do all the washing and cooking at night.

Maggiesfarm · 14/07/2021 12:06

I can assure you that 'normal' working people do hire nannies and housekeepers or nanny/housekeeper. Practically everyone works nowadays which is a great leveller.

One of my ex neighbour's daughters trained as a nanny; not Norland but the local college. She was very good, she would also do some housekeeping. She worked for a couple of smashing families. When she married and had her first baby she went on maternity leave and then back to work for the same family, taking her baby with her.

I don't know what she earned (it was years ago), but she did well, ran a good car, she and husband bought a house before marrying. I know they paid good overtime if she was asked to do extra or stay later.

I worked part time for years and grandparents did free child minding and pick ups for me, husband staggered his hours too, but I did employ someone very part time to clean and child mind. I'm ordinary! Husband was a surveyor.

Look around, ask an agency for advice. Make sure you know exactly what you want from the person you hire, take up references yourself, don't just leave it to the agency.

Good luck.

LittleBearPad · 14/07/2021 11:42

Yes including my own last night. You’re the one rattling on about it!

Tenbob · 14/07/2021 11:39

@LittleBearPad

Regardless. The type of position the OP appears to be posting about wouldn’t meet the potential requirements for self-employment. Too many hours as when would a potential nanny/housekeeper have time to work for other people.
Yes, Which is what every single reply to this thread has told her Hmm
LittleBearPad · 14/07/2021 11:32

Regardless. The type of position the OP appears to be posting about wouldn’t meet the potential requirements for self-employment. Too many hours as when would a potential nanny/housekeeper have time to work for other people.

Tenbob · 14/07/2021 08:25

www.nannypaye.co.uk/can-a-nanny-be-self-employed

“ Exceptions: When might a nanny be self-employed?
As nannies generally fall into the first list, they cannot be considered self-employed. However in some cases HMRC do grant nannies self-employed status, for example, if the nanny works in a series of temporary positions, or works for three or more families at the same time…”

www.nannytax.co.uk/news/top-5-faqs-about-self-employed-nannies

“ In What Circumstances Can A Nanny Be Self-Employed?

It’s often assumed that if a nanny is working for more than one family, then the nanny can be self-employed however this is not the case. In some circumstances HMRC do grant nannies self-employed status, if for example, the nanny works in a series of temporary positions on short-term contracts. It may also be that the nanny works for three or more families at the same time”

Tenbob · 14/07/2021 08:14

@oblada

The guidance from the many nanny payroll companies is quite clear on this
If a nanny is working for 1 or 2 families on a long term basis, they cannot be legitimately self employed
If a nanny works for 3 or more families and has some flexibility over hours, they can potentially be self employed
Night nannies are only ever self employed, as are temporary nannies - all completely within the rules and guidance

If you think that’s wrong, take it up with them and HMRC.

If everyone providing domestic services had to be employed, no one would have cleaners

oblada · 14/07/2021 08:05

'The threshold for employment can self employment for household staff is usually advised as when they work for 3 or more families and have some flexibility over their hours'

That's not correct at all.
The line between workers and self employed isn't at all about working part time or full time. It's a about providing personal services or being able to send in a substitute and alternatively providing that service as part of a commercial relationship (like a freelance consultant for instance). I would consider it risky to treat any nanny as self employed.

SmokeyDevil · 14/07/2021 07:45

[quote UncleBunclesHouse]@SmokeyDevil FFS I wasn’t asking how much a nanny cost! And I made a thread about what I actually asked because it’s not really something I can ask about in RL. And what would be the ‘brag’ benefit in an anonymous forum where no one knows who I am and vice versa? Such odd issues you have with my post 🤷‍♀️[/quote]
But what you earn and what other people doesn't matter, how can you not see that? Your outgoings might be less than someone earning more than you, so they can't afford one, but you can. Or your outgoings are more than someone earning less than you, but they can afford one and you can't. So why does it matter what others earn? Do you think you have to be a certain type of earner before you are allowed a nanny? What's your thinking behind it, because it literally means nothing. What matters is your income and your outgoings, that's it. And we can't help you on that.

We could all pile on here saying 'I earn 350k a year and have a nanny, you can't possibly have one for less', or 'I earn 50k and manage to pay for one by living off rice, why can't you afford one'. It still makes no difference to you, because their circumstances are different to yours.

I am still surprised someone in your level of job can't see this.

ZforZebra · 14/07/2021 07:43

We are by no means wealthy but do have a nanny and a housekeeper. It works for us because we have very small kids and both have jobs that are very demanding with long hours and unpredictable frequent travel etc. In my experience it’s best to keep their roles separate and be very clear about what they’re meant to do. With time each might be happy to help out beyond their normal responsibilities (e.g the nanny will sometimes help with dishes that are not only the kids) but it is not something we expect her to do. You also need to accept that the more qualified and experienced you want them to be, the more you’ll need to pay (almost the whole of one salary goes to the nanny and housekeeper). And you will need to pay NI etc. because they will be your employee.

Tenbob · 14/07/2021 06:42

@MrsTWH

That’s not strictly true. Many people have part time cleaners, part time housekeepers, temporary nannies etc which can all be self employed.

The threshold for employment can self employment for household staff is usually advised as when they work for 3 or more families and have some flexibility over their hours

So if your housekeeper is doing similar hours for other families, and has a start time five or take an hour, she would be able to be self employed and for you to pay her gross

The difficulties arise with employed nannies working for multiple families when the nanny still expects a certain net salary - which is the usual way to negotiate their pay

Family 1 pays her £12/hour net, which works out at £17/hr gross, once they pay her tax and NI using the benefit of her personal allowance

But if family 2 also have to pay her £12/hr net, they are then paying closer to £20/hr gross because they don’t get any of it tax-free

So it is rarely worth families employing nannies as a second job, and when they get to family 3, it means she can be self employed, so all families pay £17/hr and she sorts out her own tax and NI

MrsTWH · 14/07/2021 00:44

My kids are too old to need a nanny (13/14) but we have just hired a housekeeper to do all the cleaning/washing/ironing/shopping/cooking etc. we’re paying £15 p/h for 16 hours per week, term time only. Equates to around £11k per year.
Household income is around the £250k mark before tax. If employing someone to work in your house they must be employed - they’re entitled to holiday pay, sick pay, pension, etc.

JohnnyEnglish · 13/07/2021 23:51

OP not sure why you’re getting such a hard time on here. This website is for parents to ask any parenting related questions. Yes I find so much animosity and meanness and wonder why anyone would want to be unpleasant to someone asking for advice. Anyway, returning to trying to be helpful. We have had nannies for the last 10 years. We have never found a nanny who was even a passable housekeeper. So we now only recruit nannies who want to concentrate on the DC and we do the cleaning ourselves. Having a nanny is a luxury and costs in the region of £30,000 with employers NI, holiday pay and pension. Extras are mileage, gifts, outings with DC, food for nanny’s snacks and lunch. We are SE not London. For the first 8 years we had nannies this was a huge financial strain but nursery and wrap around care didn’t work for us due to travel. Now people are working from home more we could cut the nanny’s hours a lot but we like her and she is fabulous with the DC so we don’t. If you’re lucky enough to find a decent nanny cling to them. It makes life much easier.

BeenThruMoreThanALilBit · 13/07/2021 23:48

What are you actually asking though?

If you can afford it, do it. If you can’t, don’t.

What difference does it make to your decision how much people who do have nannies generally earn? Why do you need to know that?

Also, having had a nanny and a cleaner when my children were younger, you need to adjust your attitude. These (probably) women you’re talking about are going to be entrusted with your children and your home. A proper nanny will likely spend much of their waking life with the nanny. You don’t extract “value” from such an employee. You give and you take because it’s best for your children, the nanny and - lastly - you. A cleaner less so, perhaps, depending on what you ask for.

And yes, you will have to manage both people. If you want someone to lift the mental load, ask your DH. Even a PA would need management.

Kipperandarthur · 13/07/2021 23:34

I have never had a nanny but many of my friends have. In each case their combined incomes were well over £250k. They also had a cleaner at least 3 times a week.

Some nannies did the shopping as well. Never cleaning. All couples had senior roles London based. My goddaughter is a Norland Nanny. She earns a lot but she works for demanding wealthy families where taking a helicopter can be standard. She always flies club class on family holidays etc.

I would say you need two roles being fulfilled here.