Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD1 and friends coping with poverty in SA

118 replies

Allington · 13/07/2021 14:38

They struggle daily for safety. And for some people food, let alone somewhere safe to live. Even a proper (I.e. Bullet proof) house often has an outside toilet with a tap to wash your hands

OP posts:
CastawayQueen · 13/07/2021 17:02

Ok, this makes sense - but why is the thread title 'DD1 and friends?'
Is her DD1 back in SA or something?
IMO OP is either unbalanced or in such a hurry to post she hasn't explained herself.
Also other people seem to have more context so I'm just going to unwatch thread as I'm still confused

user615632456321125 · 13/07/2021 16:54

What is your AIBU?

I don't understand the point of this thread or what you are trying to say.

SoHereWeAre01 · 13/07/2021 16:50

OP has a White saviour in Africa mentality. If you are not Black in South Africa, any fears and anxiety you have on crime is irrelevant as it's experienced from a position of privilege.

OP showed very little compassion on separate thread to someone's (White) family who's life and livelihood were under threat in the civil unrest currently in South Africa.

OP implied if you are White and a victim of crime (murder, rape, etc) in South Africa, it should be discounted because Black people are the main victims of crime, so effectively stop worrying and/ or complaining.

TrixieLou · 13/07/2021 16:49

@CastawayQueen OP is trying to make a point. She has said that only white people in SA get sympathy and that everyone ignores what the black citizens of SA go through on a daily basis. She has described what is happening to our families as a ‘pity party’. Apparently people only pay attention when it concerns white people.

TheGlassBlowersDaughter · 13/07/2021 16:48

Ah so is this really a thread about white people in SA shouldn't complain because black people in SA have, and had, it worse?
If you want to get into a hierarchy of oppression then yy that would be correct but as a white person, you don't get absolved from that. In fact, using your DD as a justification for why you're different, shows you're not that far removed from the privilege you're criticising.

However, personally I think opting for hierarchies of oppression misses the nuances and makes it less likely that there will be change. It's odd that you have an inter-racial household and yet have missed the subtleties. Our friends (inter-racial marriage) would never have tried to brush over the difficulties but perhaps they had a deeper understanding of the issues. Or perhaps, because they lived in a nice neighbourhood in SA, they couldn't opt for simplistic answers that said black people didn't have nice houses.
Sometimes broad brush strokes can be helpful but I think they are a misjudgement when dealing with such complicated matters. Life isn't an Avengers' movie. We don't need to divide people into good or bad, with no chance of redemption. Life is more messy than that, and in that mess there is hope for change.

CastawayQueen · 13/07/2021 16:44

[quote TrixieLou]Here is a link to the thread that sparked this thread.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4295152-My-heart-is-bleeding-for-my-country-tonight[/quote]
Very sorry that that's happening but still don't see point of this thread

AlfonsoTheMango · 13/07/2021 16:43

I'm not clear what the point of the OP's post is other than virtue-signalling and performative wokeism.

TrixieLou · 13/07/2021 16:36

Here is a link to the thread that sparked this thread.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4295152-My-heart-is-bleeding-for-my-country-tonight

Kanaloa · 13/07/2021 16:30

I honestly don’t have a clue if you’re reasonable or unreasonable because your update actually made me more confused. Your daughter doesn’t live in South Africa but some people have outdoor toilets there and contextual offered were made and your daughter got a scholarship?

It’s really not clear what your issue is at all.

Findmeatthebeach · 13/07/2021 16:29

I'm so confused by your post op. Do you live in SA? Can you explain your AIBU a bit more please?

EssentialHummus · 13/07/2021 16:29

Allington, I don't understand -- did you adopt your daughter in SA? Do you live there? Is it your daughter or your friends (or her friends?) who are coping with poverty, or someone else?

This (from another confused South African). Where are you, where’s your daughter, how old is she, who specifically are you referring to who is in poverty?

SouthAfricaMama · 13/07/2021 16:27
  • Black people’s shops are also being looted.
  • Black people will lose their jobs.
  • Black people will go sleep hungry.
  • Black people are also getting hurt in the riots.
  • Black and white are standing next to each other trying to protect their properties and family.

AND

  • Racism is still a massive problem in SA.
  • Poverty is still a massive problem in SA.
  • Crime is still a massive problem in SA.

It’s not either/or. It’s ok that people are scared, black or white or any other race. Calling those who are concerned today the white pity party, is nasty and shows that even with all your experience in SA, it didn’t help much with your being. It also implies that you think black people are all on the looters’ side, because today’s fear, worry and grieve is only for the white?
You are wrong. I have boys( nephews) out there in the streets, trying to help the police.
Yes, all the points you raise are things that need to change. But your comments today shows that deep down you are not that far away from the others who like to put POC in boxes that suits your thought patterns, beliefs and agenda.

AnotherKrampus · 13/07/2021 16:26

I come from a country where toilets were holes in the ground in the backyard.
What's your question exactly, my precious?

Yep! That ^ Well said @CastawayQueen

AnotherKrampus · 13/07/2021 16:25

OP has anyone ever looked at your overgrown Messiah/white woman saviour complex? The colonial attitude is just below the surface and your smug superiority is nauseating, thinking that you alone can speak out, making assumptions about the background of other MN users.

TrixieLou · 13/07/2021 16:18

@3Britnee You are exactly right! The OP has been incredibly disrespectful and insensitive to the families who are hurting and anxious about what their families are experiencing in SA at the moment. I started a thread because I was worried about my family last night. She has completely hijacked the thread and has ruined what was meant to be a safe space for people to talk about their very valid fears.

CastawayQueen · 13/07/2021 16:18

@Allington

They struggle daily for safety. And for some people food, let alone somewhere safe to live. Even a proper (I.e. Bullet proof) house often has an outside toilet with a tap to wash your hands
I come from a country where toilets were holes in the ground in the backyard. What's your question exactly, my precious?
RubyGoat · 13/07/2021 16:18

@quizqueen

People live in poverty everywhere, yet they still keep producing children.
Lack of affordable/reliable contraception & sufficient education about it It’s not always the woman’s choice It’s still the most reliable/only way to ensure you’re looked after in old age or illness, in some countries Higher infant mortality rate

It was similar in most of Europe only a few generations ago.

Gazelda · 13/07/2021 16:15

No one should live in the circumstances you describe OP.
Can you clarify what your AIBU is though? That people live like this? That other people are ignoring it? That others are complaining about their own situation when your DD has it so much worse?

I'm not clear where your DD currently lives. Or where you live?

quizqueen · 13/07/2021 16:10

People live in poverty everywhere, yet they still keep producing children.

3Britnee · 13/07/2021 16:09

@TheYearOfSmallThings

I agree, it would be better to say what you want to say clearly.
She thinks none of the white people in South Africa should complain about the rioting because black people have had it harder for longer basically.

What her bee in her bonnet is, is the equivalent of all lives matter to blm.

MaskingForIt · 13/07/2021 16:03

@Aski

privileged by having a white adoptive mum

As opposed to? Hmm

The racism is loud and clear, isn’t it?!
ParsleyDill · 13/07/2021 15:58

@Allington, I don't understand -- did you adopt your daughter in SA? Do you live there? Is it your daughter or your friends (or her friends?) who are coping with poverty, or someone else?

RubyGoat · 13/07/2021 15:57

@TiredButDancing

This is more about the threads of white South Africans complaining about their circumstances.

You should start that thread. Maybe it would open eyes of how so many white south africans remain intrinsically racist even though they honestly and truly believe they're not. My all time personal favourite was the facebook thread of a friend of a friend who was basically complaining because she didn't want to pay her nanny/cleaner according to the (at the time) newly-mandated-minimum wage by the government. It was particularly bizarre that her complaint was that she couldn't afford it but it was clear that she was living an extremely comfortable and happy life. NO one was suggesting that she HAD to have a nanny/cleaner, but she was outraged that she couldn't keep paying the woman working for her at a level that is not livable. It was BIZARRE.

My second favourite was a photo taken by my brother of him and our long-term family cleaner having coffee. He was giving her a lift to the station and they'd stopped to grab a drink. Cue endless comments, "Aaaah, that's so kind of you" and "aaah, she must have loved that". She's a grown-ass woman who has been cleaning up after him for some 30 odd years. The language was the language people use when I take my 6 year old DD out for high tea and post a picture. ICK.

  • not amusing. i
That’s sickening. Sad
AnotherKrampus · 13/07/2021 15:51

Glad you started your own thread to virtue-signal as a white person to show all MN just how much worthier you are.

MrsFin · 13/07/2021 15:45

As opposed to being poor and parentless i assume (or having a parent who wasn't able to parent).

In SA (assuming that's where DD and her mother are - the post isn't clear), "whites" have HUGE privilege.

You need to go there to understand what privilege means really.

Swipe left for the next trending thread