Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD1 and friends coping with poverty in SA

118 replies

Allington · 13/07/2021 14:38

They struggle daily for safety. And for some people food, let alone somewhere safe to live. Even a proper (I.e. Bullet proof) house often has an outside toilet with a tap to wash your hands

OP posts:
Crockof · 13/07/2021 20:15

I was supportive but your continued agenda on the other thread shows your reality. Made worse by the fact you do not have real lived experience.

Maggiesfarm · 13/07/2021 20:06

@Allington

Yes, I am all for people knowing the 'very real' problems that exist in SA.
I get that.

For some time I worked with a few South African people who had decided to live here to escape the violence of SA.

Does your daughter intend to stay out there or will she come back to England after a while?

CiaoForNiao · 13/07/2021 20:01

the problem is a lot of us just don’t really know anything about SA. I’d like to know but I’m a bit confused on the posts as well.

Same here. Can anyone either explain it in a "SA for dummies" kind of way, or direct me to some basic, unbiased, history please.

reallybloodytired · 13/07/2021 19:54

@Allington, the problem is a lot of us just don’t really know anything about SA. I’d like to know but I’m a bit confused on the posts as well.

So you used to live in SA and adopted two black girls.

You now live in the U.K. with the younger of the two, and the older one is still in SA studying.

Am I correct so far?

Allington · 13/07/2021 19:52

Yes, I am all for people knowing the 'very real' problems that exist in SA.

OP posts:
Allington · 13/07/2021 19:51

? I was told to start a new thread, so I started a new thread?

I am sorry if the disparity between white South Africans (after colonialism and apartheid) is distressing. But denying the truth doesn't help anyone

OP posts:
AnotherKrampus · 13/07/2021 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Satears · 13/07/2021 19:39

@Allington stop hijacking Trixie’s thread and come back to your own one. This is your chance to get your voice heard but you’re not doing yourself any favours.

mbosnz · 13/07/2021 19:33

Oh don't worry, she's continuing her vitriol in the previous thread too.

user615632456321125 · 13/07/2021 19:30

It's quite some level of arrogance to think you can start a new thread as a continuance of your hijacking of someone else's support thread without explaining yourself or linking it, but merely continuing your vitriol where you left off as if everyone should have read everything you've posted elsewhere in order to know what point you're trying so callously to make.

debwong · 13/07/2021 19:20

This thread is like starting to read a novel halfway through.

Satears · 13/07/2021 19:12

What exactly is your message here @Allington? On Trixie’s thread you said it’s not ok for anyone to be threatened with rape or murder but to me it sounds like you are condoning what is currently happening in SA.

Allington · 13/07/2021 18:56

@AnotherKrampus

There is something so grating about virtual signalling white women who adopt black children and think that this somehow qualifies them to preach to other white people and pontificate on the plight of black people. It is at best patronising to black South African people and a new form of colonial arrogance.
Actually the adoption of DDs is only relevant because it exposed me to the day to day lives of their extended family. I wanted them to maintain those links, but that meant I experienced the chaos of family who didn't have the safety net that I had
OP posts:
Allington · 13/07/2021 18:54

@MrsTrustice

OP, you ignored my question where I said if you were still in SA and were in a location where rioters are approaching like the OP of another thread’s family, would you not be frightened? I highly doubt that. You seem to have very bizarre beliefs about the whole thing. I’m sure you’d be getting on just fine because you’re happy with your moral compass Confused

You also aren’t acknowledging that black South Africans working in pink and blue collar jobs will have been the first to suffer from the rioting. And the unemployed. Or those travelling home to unprotected areas from their jobs in gated communities But your post implies the rioting is the disgruntled black people and it’s only the nasty whites hiding because they are getting their just desserts Hmm

No. Not still in SA. But have DD1 and friends in communities that experience horrendous levels of violence as routine
OP posts:
Allington · 13/07/2021 18:51

Any other criticisms to respond to?

White saviourism? Because I pointed out that the people whose hearts were breaking about the current violence didn't break their hearts about the every day violence experienced by the majority (I.e. not white) of South Africans? That when 'they' are concerned most of the white population put it down to 'their' culture, not poverty.

When equality affects white communities suddenly it matters?

OP posts:
MrsTrustice · 13/07/2021 18:51

OP, you ignored my question where I said if you were still in SA and were in a location where rioters are approaching like the OP of another thread’s family, would you not be frightened? I highly doubt that. You seem to have very bizarre beliefs about the whole thing. I’m sure you’d be getting on just fine because you’re happy with your moral compass Confused

You also aren’t acknowledging that black South Africans working in pink and blue collar jobs will have been the first to suffer from the rioting. And the unemployed. Or those travelling home to unprotected areas from their jobs in gated communities But your post implies the rioting is the disgruntled black people and it’s only the nasty whites hiding because they are getting their just desserts Hmm

AnotherKrampus · 13/07/2021 18:46

There is something so grating about virtual signalling white women who adopt black children and think that this somehow qualifies them to preach to other white people and pontificate on the plight of black people. It is at best patronising to black South African people and a new form of colonial arrogance.

SouthAfricaMama · 13/07/2021 18:45

@Allington, again, why are you presuming the colour of my skin? Because I disagree with the way you went about things? Because I am worried about my family? Because my nephews are helping, not looting?

Why do you presume that, because you've adopted two black girls, you speak for all black people?

The reason why I think you're intoxicated is because you go from one topic to another, make little sense, you're antagonising and not taking in any information. Is that just how you normally interact?

Allington · 13/07/2021 18:45

@tunainatin

The situation in SA is extremely complex and upsetting and I personally couldn't stay there for any length of time. I visited with my family when I was young, and it had a huge impact which has affected many decisions I've made since. It sounds like due to your dd's background it is even closer to the bone for her. It's a bit hard to understand exactly what her circumstances are over there, but is there any pastoral care she can link into to talk things through?
Fortunately DD's university provides subsidised counselling. Despite being a formerly white institution they recognize the challenges faced by black young people accessing HE
OP posts:
tunainatin · 13/07/2021 18:45

Ooh I didn't read the full thread, don't really understand what's going on, sorry!

Allington · 13/07/2021 18:43

The post mumsnet has hidden said I haven't been responding because I have been at work

OP posts:
tunainatin · 13/07/2021 18:42

The situation in SA is extremely complex and upsetting and I personally couldn't stay there for any length of time. I visited with my family when I was young, and it had a huge impact which has affected many decisions I've made since. It sounds like due to your dd's background it is even closer to the bone for her. It's a bit hard to understand exactly what her circumstances are over there, but is there any pastoral care she can link into to talk things through?

AlfonsoTheMango · 13/07/2021 18:42

This thread just gets more and more bizarre.

Allington · 13/07/2021 18:41

@MrsTrustice

That you’re a hypocrite.
Grin I'll tell my friends that
OP posts:
Allington · 13/07/2021 18:40

[quote SouthAfricaMama]@Allington, did you hit the wine bottle early today?[/quote]
Why do you say that? What do you disagree with?

How many black South Africans are you friends with? Not an employer, people you and your children stay with as friends?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread