Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd's older boyfriend

210 replies

detersiv · 13/07/2021 13:41

DD finished year 11 a few months ago, and she'll be 16 in a few weeks.

On Sunday, DS told me that DD has a boyfriend and he's 20 (DS found out from one of his friends at school as her boyfriends younger brother is in his year). I spoke to DD about it and she kept denying it. Yesterday, she admitted that she does and he's her friends older brother. I have never met him, but I do know DDs friend and have met her. DD goes around hers a lot.

I really don't know what to think! I haven't said anything bad about him but I feel uncomfortable about their relationship. Am I overreating? Is there anything I can do?

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 13/07/2021 17:22

When my dsis was 15 she went out with a 19 year old difference was my dad knew him and approved she didnt go behind his back

i still thought she was a bit young but was quite mature

GreenTeaBlackCoffeeAndRedWine · 13/07/2021 17:19

I can see why you'd feel uncomfortable. As a young adult I wouldn't be interested in dating anyone below a certain age, especially under 16. It is weird that he's even interested.

However, many young men are very immature. This has certainly been my experience. Girls tend to be more mature by the age of about 14 or 15, whereas for boys that maturity doesn't generally come in until they're about 18 or 19. Of course there are exceptions.

It's hard to judge until you've met the lad, so rather than banning her from seeing him, ask to meet him. Invite him over for tea. Then you'll get your impression of him and his maturity level.

Keep communication open too with your DD and speak to her about the lying too. Also about staying safe and if she ever feels uncomfortable you'll be there to help her.

viques · 13/07/2021 17:11

The thing is about a 16/20 relative age gap is that it falls awkwardly in the middle of what we perceive as acceptable.

We instinctively know that 12/16 is wrong
And 13/17
As is 14/18 .

We don’t bat an eyelid once we get to 23/27, and beyond that no one gives a stuff.

But those in between years are very difficult. On the whole it strikes me that the differences in what we as a society allow young people to do in social terms, eg driving, drinking, marrying, working say to me that the relationships are too imbalanced to be a comfortable fit and that that power/ experience/expectation imbalance affects the younger person disproportionally. Of course there are exceptions, there always are, but generally four year gaps don’t do the younger person many favours.

NoCauseRebel · 13/07/2021 17:10

I went out with a 20 year old when I was 15. We didn’t have sex, he was an immature 20 year old and I was a mature 15 year old.

He was very much of the “no sex until marriage” persuasion but I know that his mum was worried about him being with someone so young.

My parents never actually met him because I went to boarding school, but my mum had a talk with me about sex and contraception, and her view was very much that I needed to be sure I was safe and protected.

Banning me from seeing him would never have achieved anything.

We broke up after about a year because, well, I grew up and he didn’t, so the relationship essentially just ran its course.

It used to be a lot more common for younger girls to go out with older boys. Statistically boys are less mature than girls which is why so many 15/16 year olds don’t go out with boys their own age.

You need to talk to her, have an honest conversation about A, the fact she’s under age, B, the fact she needs to use protection, i.e. condoms and the pill if need be, and C, that you will always be there to talk to, no matter wat.

Wading in with talk of abuse etc is only going to drive you further apart and potentially bring them closer together.

And she’s friends with his sister. To keep them apart you would have to ban this friendship also, and that’s not realistic.

Suprima · 13/07/2021 17:01

@nokidshere

At no point has anyone mentioned them having sex. There's a whole load of conclusions being jumped to on this thread.

Just talk to her.

Don’t be deluded.

Of course they will be, if they aren’t already.

Suprima · 13/07/2021 16:59

Nice 20 year olds don’t go round courting 15 year old girls (sorry about your nigels)

There’s a reason why 20 year old girls don’t want to go out with him

He is an adult, she is still at school. The ‘oh if he was 24 and she was 20’ argument doesn’t hold up for this reason. It’s life stages.

Is this her first boyfriend?

Redlorryellow · 13/07/2021 16:59

Yanbu. I was in this exact age difference relationship when I was a teen and in retrospect (though at the time I didn’t see it this way, even when it made me very unhappy in the end), it was very wrong and damaging. I got a lot of quite strange and unhealthy ideas about sex from it and it also wrecked my self esteem.. the grooming then eventual discarding. I can only speak from my experience but I’m 30s now and I often think of it and feel sad and angry. Please don’t be like my mum who ignored the whole thing and didn’t protect me.

MintyCedric · 13/07/2021 16:55

As many people have said it's a weird stage in their lives when they are between child and adulthood, and just a few months can make a difference.

My daughter has just left school but is one of the eldest in her year so nearly 17. I would be a bit more wary than average about her dating a 20yo, but I think several PPs make a valid point about alienating her if you put your foot down too hard.

A strong talk with her about honesty and trying to get to know him seem like wise options rather than coming down like a ton of bricks.

hellogem · 13/07/2021 16:54

Trust me boys at age 20+ are not interested in girls in any other way except that they think they can control them, they know girls their own age won't take shit, but these younger naive girls don't know any better.
I remember being at school, 19-23 boys would do everything possible to get our attention, they would hang around outside of school, where we would have to walk past in order to get home, we were under 16, that didn't stop them. Absolutely disgusting they are. Anyone 18+ shouldn't look twice at girls in uniform

JustLoveYourselfALittle · 13/07/2021 16:54

When I was 16 I was seeing a 26 year old! I was 'warned' I was being stupid. But it made me more determined. We even had a flat together. He cheated, out partying because I wasn't old enough. When I was 18 he left. I remember being devastated but at the fact my parents were going to be proven right!
My ds dad was 16 yrs older and my next bf was 13 years older.

My now dh is 3 years younger happiest I've ever been.

MaMaD1990 · 13/07/2021 16:51

@nokidshere

I'd definitely be keeping a very close eye on things and probably have a word with his mother (assuming he lives at home) to set reasonable boundaries you expect to be followed whilst she's over there (if I read that right - your DD is friends with his younger sister?). I'd also speak to her about consent and safe sex.

You can't talk to his mother, don't be ridiculous. he's an adult as plenty of people are at pains to point out.

The child is still 15, if the mother doesn't trust her daughter then it's up to her to keep her at home and stop her seeing this grown up.

All of the above sounds bonkers right? Because it is. The job of a parent is to facilitate their teens through this weird stage of their lives. As far as they are concerned they know it all and are invincible so you just need to help them navigate it. Laying down the law and getting overly involved in their decisions is not the right way to go about it. I mean, in a few weeks time she could go off and marry him if she so wanted.

Keep the lines of communication open and show an interest without being controlling.

I disagree. If my 15 year old was going over to his house, where he lived with his parents, I would be speaking to them and setting boundaries I as the parent want setting - be it them not sleeping in the same room if she stays over etc. That's not being controlling, it's sensible and protecting the hold who 'believes they're invinsible', in my opinion. You of course don't need to agree.
grey12 · 13/07/2021 16:48

I wouldn't be comfortable with that.....

A 5 year gap at that age is a century!!

He what? likes inexperienced girls? She may have the body (I certainly did) but she's not mature (she isn't!!!). I would warn her about this kind of uneven relationship

Fuckitsstillraining · 13/07/2021 16:45

30+ years ago I was in your daughters position, it didn't end well. He was a nice guy, treated me well but we did sleep together and I did regret it. He was very serious about us and when I wanted to split up he made it difficult. It took me a long time to come to terms with him being the first guy I slept with. Weirdly we met a few years ago and discussed the past and he apologised saying he was a horny 20 year old who was to shy to date girls his own age. He's become a good friend, we are both married and happy but both struggled as a result of our relationship. Just talk to your daughter, keep communicating and don't lay down the law or you'll drive her straight to him, that's what my parents did and it only made the relationship last longer than it would have naturally.

IDreamOfLogCabins · 13/07/2021 16:42

Would depend on daughter's maturity as well as what the boy was like, but when I was 16 it wasn't uncommon to have 20 year old boyfriends. However I grew up in a small area where everyone knew everyone else, and a lot of social activity was mixed ages. If this is your daughter's friends brother, then do you not have some idea of what he's like?

Iminaglasscaseofemotion · 13/07/2021 16:41

At 15/16 I was sleeping with 19/20 year olds. At the time I thought it was fine, now I can see it was weird.

airbags · 13/07/2021 16:38

[quote PercyPigandMe]@nokidshere clearly doesn't have a 15 year old daughter or wouldn't be asking such stupid questions [/quote]
Quite!
If my 15 year old school child was dating a 20 year old man I'd be asking what he sees in a child!

This is so wrong.

beastlyslumber · 13/07/2021 16:36

@FindingMeno

Perfectly decent young men do exist and to leap to the conclusion that he must be an abuser is outrageous imo.
If he was perfectly decent he wouldn't be starting a relationship with an underage girl. It's a bit creepy, imo.

I'd ask to meet him, OP. Get him round one evening and see what you think of him. If he's a dodgy chancer, that might be enough to scare him off.

Comedycook · 13/07/2021 16:22

15 and 20 is really wrong. What kind of man at 20 is interested in a 15 year old. Grim.

moynomore · 13/07/2021 16:20

Perfectly decent young men do exist and to leap to the conclusion that he must be an abuser is outrageous imo.

If he's such a perfectly decent young man, he would stay far away from a 15 year old girl.

epponneee · 13/07/2021 16:15

I can understand being concerned and it is possible that it is inappropriate but I don't think that is a foregone conclusion.
It does depend on the maturity levels of the individuals involved and how long has it been going on for. if its been going on since she was 14 that is definitely inappropriate but if its only been a few weeks then may well not be. Also he shouldn't be having sex with her while she is underage but they might not be having sex so that could be irrelevant.
I think it is important to speak to your daughter and try and keep communication open. I'd be worried that she had kept it a secret. Also I would want to meet the boyfriend and judge for myself

HollowTalk · 13/07/2021 16:09

Why on earth would a normal 20-year-old be interested in somebody who is still at school?

davidrosejumper · 13/07/2021 16:06

The thing that would concern me most is that she has kept it a secret. Does your daughter normally not share much of her personal life, or is this a first to your knowledge? Have you been able to find out how long they have been dating?

I was also wondering if your daughter has other boys interested in her. If this is the first and only time someone has shown interest in her, I would find this more concerning, than when she thinks that she has alternatives. Simply because she may in the former case be less likely to stand up for herself and get out of situations she is uncomfortable with out of fear that this is her only opportunity to be with someone.

I personally find it an uncomfortably large age difference at that age, but before you go in all guns blazing and create a Romeo and Juliet-type situation of them against the world in her eyes, perhaps see who you are dealing with first, and how their interaction is. So ask them to spend some time together at your house with your family, instead of just meeting up elsewhere. If everything is above water, they should be willing to do so.

(Also, I agree with all the suggestions for talks with her about consent, and would perhaps add talking about respectful relationships in general, so your daughter would be able to recognise red flags such as pressure, control, and manipulation. There must be some websites out there you can look at together.)

1forAll74 · 13/07/2021 16:03

I would think nothing of this, it seems to happen quite frequently. You will have to keep watch, and be aware of how things pan out between the two people concerned,

nokidshere · 13/07/2021 15:52

At no point has anyone mentioned them having sex. There's a whole load of conclusions being jumped to on this thread.

Just talk to her.

mancarose · 13/07/2021 15:52

I had the same sort of relationship when I was that age, my DM banned it so obviously I carried on behind her back, id say sit her down and explain why it makes you uncomfortable but say that she's growing up to be an adult so it's her decision, but to make you feel better if she could invite him round for tea? Just so you can get to know him and that may ease your mind a lot? If you start trying to control her relationships now she will start to hide them from you which is way worse xx

Swipe left for the next trending thread