Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd's older boyfriend

210 replies

detersiv · 13/07/2021 13:41

DD finished year 11 a few months ago, and she'll be 16 in a few weeks.

On Sunday, DS told me that DD has a boyfriend and he's 20 (DS found out from one of his friends at school as her boyfriends younger brother is in his year). I spoke to DD about it and she kept denying it. Yesterday, she admitted that she does and he's her friends older brother. I have never met him, but I do know DDs friend and have met her. DD goes around hers a lot.

I really don't know what to think! I haven't said anything bad about him but I feel uncomfortable about their relationship. Am I overreating? Is there anything I can do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
youvegottenminuteslynn · 15/07/2021 23:43

And @DolphinBlue1 a good way to start thinking logically about what happened to you re meeting your partner is this - if you were single now (you're the age he was when you met) and met a boy of 15, would you date him? In principle, morally?

A 15 year old who wears a uniform to school and won't be able to vote, drive, drink... loads of stuff that we aren't allowed to do legally because we aren't developed and mature enough to do them responsibly or take on the burden of doing so.

Would you date a 15 year old boy now you are 26 under any circumstance? If not, why not?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 15/07/2021 23:39

@DolphinBlue1

There is no power imbalance, there never has been, I wasn't groomed.

There is always, always a power imbalance between someone of 15 and someone of 26. Always. It's absurd to say there wasn't. You couldn't have a full time job, you couldn't earn a full time wage, you couldn't legally vote, drive, go to certain venues, even play the lottery. Many of those things you couldn't do even after a year or two of being with him.

It's one thing to say it's worked out for you (so far) but another not to acknowledge there absolutely was a power imbalance. It's worrying you can't see that especially now you're a parent.

IncorrigibleTitmouse · 15/07/2021 23:23

@detersiv

DD finished year 11 a few months ago, and she'll be 16 in a few weeks.

On Sunday, DS told me that DD has a boyfriend and he's 20 (DS found out from one of his friends at school as her boyfriends younger brother is in his year). I spoke to DD about it and she kept denying it. Yesterday, she admitted that she does and he's her friends older brother. I have never met him, but I do know DDs friend and have met her. DD goes around hers a lot.

I really don't know what to think! I haven't said anything bad about him but I feel uncomfortable about their relationship. Am I overreating? Is there anything I can do?

My boyfriend was 20 when I was 16 and had just left school too (I'm also a summer baby).

Admittedly that was 20-odd years ago but I just wasn't interested in boys my own age because they were too immature and didn't want the same things I did from a relationship. I don't think it's all that unusual. My friends' boyfriends were all 3-5 years older too.

I'd definitely tell her you'd like to get to know him better, though.

Conchitastrawberry · 15/07/2021 23:03

I have a daughter a similar age and yes I’d be uncomfortable about it. I’d be the same I’d I had a 20 year old son and he had a 15 year old girlfriend. There’s no way I’d condone it to be honest and my husband would go mental.

Maggiesfarm · 15/07/2021 22:50

No.

I'm going to bow out of this now, I feel a bit depressed remembering me as a fourteen and fifteen year old - and this thread is not about me.

Op, follow your gut.

Pumperthepumper · 15/07/2021 21:57

@Maggiesfarm

Oh I don't know about specifically chasing a young girl, that's a different thing altogether, rather predatory. However, let's say forty five or more years ago, it wasn't uncommon for young teenagers to go out with a chap a few years older, with parents agreement.

It's obviously better if they are closer in age because they have more in common.

I don't know how I would feel about it because my girls had boyfriends in their own age group when they were at school. Now both over 30 they have partners of similar age to themselves.

Just looking back I remember girls going out with older chaps and nobody thought anything of it. Some have been married over forty years and still going strong.

I don’t think being married legitimises a relationship that began with an older man grooming a fifteen year old.
Maggiesfarm · 15/07/2021 21:28

Oh I don't know about specifically chasing a young girl, that's a different thing altogether, rather predatory. However, let's say forty five or more years ago, it wasn't uncommon for young teenagers to go out with a chap a few years older, with parents agreement.

It's obviously better if they are closer in age because they have more in common.

I don't know how I would feel about it because my girls had boyfriends in their own age group when they were at school. Now both over 30 they have partners of similar age to themselves.

Just looking back I remember girls going out with older chaps and nobody thought anything of it. Some have been married over forty years and still going strong.

Pumperthepumper · 15/07/2021 21:13

@Maggiesfarm

Pumper: If she was 18 and he was 22 they’d be more similar in terms of life stages. A fifteen year old is a world away from a 20 year old. ........ Yes they are.

I think it all depends what the guy is like. He may be respectful, only the op will be able to find out, we don't know him.

Years ago it was quite normal for mid teen girls to date guys a few years older, nobody frowned on it.

Times have changed.

How many years ago was it ok for grown men to chase 15 year olds for a relationship?
toastantea · 15/07/2021 21:11

I think it all depends what the guy is like. He may be respectful, only the op will be able to find out, we don't know him.

Respectful 20 year olds don't go out with children.

Years ago it was quite normal for mid teen girls to date guys a few years older, nobody frowned on it.

Yes, it's a shame so many people were not protected.

Times have changed.

Good.

toastantea · 15/07/2021 21:09

The op's daughter will be sixteen in a few weeks and if they are still interested in each other, it won't seem so bad.

It definitely would.

If she was eighteen and he twenty two, nobody would bat an eyelid.

But she is not 18 so your point is irrelevant. Just turned 16 is not the same as 18.

If he is a decent chap he won't be pressurising her into anything for which she is not ready

A decent chap doesn't have an interest in someone who has just turned 16.

Also, as mentioned many times in this thread, it's not always about sex.

Maggiesfarm · 15/07/2021 21:09

Pumper: If she was 18 and he was 22 they’d be more similar in terms of life stages. A fifteen year old is a world away from a 20 year old.
........
Yes they are.

I think it all depends what the guy is like. He may be respectful, only the op will be able to find out, we don't know him.

Years ago it was quite normal for mid teen girls to date guys a few years older, nobody frowned on it.

Times have changed.

ScrollingLeaves · 15/07/2021 21:07

“Pumperthepumper
No 16 year old is mature enough to be in a relationship with a 24 year old, and it’s ridiculous to pretend otherwise. It’s not even the age gap, it’s two completely different life stages - one has finished education, can drive, drink, vote, get married, get a mortgage and the other isn’t even old enough to see The Wolf of Wall Street at the cinema.“

I agree with this point about life stages.
When people/girls left school at sixteen and got a job and they had been taught to be wives and mothers, it might have seemed normal to start going out with an older young man, who might well already have a job, with the view to this possibly leading to marriage after a couple of years.

I am not saying this is a good idea but it would have seemed less strange under those circumstances when a 16 year old went out with a 20year old man.

Now girls are much older at 16 in some ways, but much younger in others. There is also the pressure of the presumed right to have a full sexual relationship.

toastantea · 15/07/2021 21:04

Pumper, well that was not my experience, I don't want to sidetrack but I just wanted to point out that 16 year olds have been dating people within 5 or 10 years older than them forever, because of biology and sexual attraction,

Jesus Christ. No. Just no. Biology Hmm

Pumperthepumper · 15/07/2021 20:59

@Maggiesfarm

The op's daughter will be sixteen in a few weeks and if they are still interested in each other, it won't seem so bad. If she was eighteen and he twenty two, nobody would bat an eyelid.

If he is a decent chap he won't be pressurising her into anything for which she is not ready.

I remember going out with older chaps at 15 and they did try to pressurise me! However I was not a particularly good judge of character at that age Smile. I knew other girls who had boyfriends a few years older who had lovely relationships and ended up marrying them.

If she was 18 and he was 22 they’d be more similar in terms of life stages. A fifteen year old is a world away from a 20 year old.
Pumperthepumper · 15/07/2021 20:58

@GoWalkabout

Pumper, well that was not my experience, I don't want to sidetrack but I just wanted to point out that 16 year olds have been dating people within 5 or 10 years older than them forever, because of biology and sexual attraction, and often unproblematically - but OPs daughter of course needs guidance and protection, she needs the relationship to be out in the open not secret, and she needs her parents onside with her, her feelings are important here and are not the problem. He may be problematic, he may just be a young man who has met a young woman. However, as she is under 16 he will probably be best advised not to pursue a relationship with her.
‘Biology’ - it’s not biology, it’s predatory men.
Maggiesfarm · 15/07/2021 20:37

The op's daughter will be sixteen in a few weeks and if they are still interested in each other, it won't seem so bad. If she was eighteen and he twenty two, nobody would bat an eyelid.

If he is a decent chap he won't be pressurising her into anything for which she is not ready.

I remember going out with older chaps at 15 and they did try to pressurise me! However I was not a particularly good judge of character at that age Smile. I knew other girls who had boyfriends a few years older who had lovely relationships and ended up marrying them.

Ginpancakes · 15/07/2021 20:30

This was probably a fair description of me and my now DH more than 10 years ago. If you tell her to steer clear it’s going to have the complete opposite effect - invite him for dinner, suss him out and let DD make her own decision. It’s probably horrible as a mother I go through so I feel for you OP but is she capable of making her own choice at this age?? I’d say she is based on my own experience but only you can be the judge of that!

GoWalkabout · 15/07/2021 20:29

Pumper, well that was not my experience, I don't want to sidetrack but I just wanted to point out that 16 year olds have been dating people within 5 or 10 years older than them forever, because of biology and sexual attraction, and often unproblematically - but OPs daughter of course needs guidance and protection, she needs the relationship to be out in the open not secret, and she needs her parents onside with her, her feelings are important here and are not the problem. He may be problematic, he may just be a young man who has met a young woman. However, as she is under 16 he will probably be best advised not to pursue a relationship with her.

Pumperthepumper · 15/07/2021 19:37

@GoWalkabout

This used to be within social norms - I myself had a brilliant lasting 2 year first relationship with a 24 year old when I was just 16, he was considerate sexually, good looking, fun, teetotal, generally a great influence, our maturity matched - but society has become more aware of the risks of predators and grooming and while the biology of attraction has not changed, it is now seen as crossing a line.
No 16 year old is mature enough to be in a relationship with a 24 year old, and it’s ridiculous to pretend otherwise. It’s not even the age gap, it’s two completely different life stages - one has finished education, can drive, drink, vote, get married, get a mortgage and the other isn’t even old enough to see The Wolf of Wall Street at the cinema.
toastantea · 15/07/2021 19:35

It's also had, btw, a relationship when I was 17 with a man in his 20s. He was never abusive to me, I thought for many years that it was a normal and balanced relationship. One day I woke up and realised he chose me because I was young. I looked young. I satisfied his craving for young. I thought I was so grown up and he was using me because I was young. Predatory behaviour.

toastantea · 15/07/2021 19:33

myself had a brilliant lasting 2 year first relationship with a 24 year old when I was just 16, he was considerate sexually, good looking, fun, teetotal, generally a great influence, our maturity matched -

Bollocks you maturity matched. Who told you that, him? 16 year olds don't have the ability to possess the maturity of someone in their 20s. They simple don't. It's impossible.

It's a shame you can't see this for what it is. 24 year old adult men who have an interest in 16 year olds are far from normal.

You may have had a good sex life and fun etc but at the end of the day this man was with you because you were young. Young enough to satisfy his need but old enough not to get him arrested.

Anyone that says people in their 20s dating 16 year olds is normal or even remotely acceptable is fucking deluded. Head in sand.

GoWalkabout · 15/07/2021 19:21

This used to be within social norms - I myself had a brilliant lasting 2 year first relationship with a 24 year old when I was just 16, he was considerate sexually, good looking, fun, teetotal, generally a great influence, our maturity matched - but society has become more aware of the risks of predators and grooming and while the biology of attraction has not changed, it is now seen as crossing a line.

unsalted · 15/07/2021 19:10

@ScrollingLeaves

Thanks for your kind words. Honestly I'm in my mid thirties now in a happy relationship, but it still does affect me at times. Said ex is now married with 3 daughters, so I can only hope he's become a better person over the years. I've never ever spoken (or written) about it before, but I really felt reminded of it with some of this thread. Hopefully all the advice is of some help.

ScrollingLeaves · 15/07/2021 19:02

“unsalted

For me, what puts it in perspective is the fact that as a teacher, if a 15 year old in my class let slip that they were dating a 20 year old, I would be reporting it to the safeguarding lead.

I'm not sure what I think of the whole 'different maturity levels' thing. Please don't assume that being mature means she's not vulnerable. When I was 18, I was very mature for my age. I dated a 'nice guy' my own age who was far more immature than me. He was still able to manipulate me and coerce me into a sexual relationship, even physically restraining me till I 'agreed' to sleep with him in the very near future, despite me saying 'no' repeatedly.

I was mature, but still afraid to say no and not able to talk to anyone about it, because everyone assumed I could handle myself and I felt embarrassed to tell them the truth.”

I am sorry, that must feel sad and horrible for you ‘unsalted’ even now.

toastantea · 15/07/2021 18:59

I'm not sure what I think of the whole 'different maturity levels' thing. Please don't assume that being mature means she's not vulnerable.

There is a limit to how mature a 15 year old can be, so people citing 'maturity levels' are way off the mark. 15 year olds have limited maturity, due to being just 15. They haven't got the life skills or experience to pisses a level of maturity you would see in a 20 year old, even an immature one.

Sadly people would rather excuse this kind of abuse rather then face it.