Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

my bf feeds his dog pasta

139 replies

pastadog · 13/07/2021 13:12

hi namechanged. i don’t live with my bf btw!
when i go round his house, i obviously see him feeding his dogs. most of the time, he has pots of uneaten pasta from the night before. this will usually have meat, tomato sauce etc on it. he puts a lot on top of their usual dog food, they seem healthy enough and i guess ‘back then’ people would feed their dogs their scraps, but this just seems a bit wrong?
not looking for advice etc just wanted to know if i’m right in thinking he shouldn’t do this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Heyha · 13/07/2021 22:48

@SchrodingersImmigrant I agree with you to be honest! But then birds eat maggots from roadkill as well don't they and that's another potential risk...

All those of us posting about the rules are doing is sharing the current status and facts, I wouldn't be able to say hand on heart that I completely see the sense in and agree with each of them. But in my opinion when you take on an animal you have to work within the frameworks that exist at the time, like them or not.

It's just that most animals people have as pets are only really covered by the Animal Welfare Act which is pretty easy to understand, explain and defend because it really only sets out the commons sense basics. Pet livestock sit in a strange limbo between two worlds, really, and that's what leads to some of the things not making a great deal of sense, certainly at face value, anyway.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 13/07/2021 22:20

Back garden sparrows don't count because they're not a farmed animal, so you're safe there.

Well yeah but if mealworms can be dangerous for spread of illnesses that it doesn't matter which bird it is, isn't it👀

Woeismethischristmas · 13/07/2021 22:16

@VeganVeal

My neighbour feeds his Great Dane boiled eggs, madness. You can imagine the stench
My dog loves eggs, I don’t think it makes her stinky I make her scrambled eggs for breakfast every day.
Bryonyshcmyony · 13/07/2021 22:12

@TheVolturi

I had a Jack Russell that lived to 17, that ate our leftovers along with his own food, all of his life. Fit and healthy, was never unwell.
Yes I have two dogs, 13 and 14, both healthy and energetic, they get all our leftovers unless there is a lot of onions or garlic (although my terriers favourite food ever is pasta with tomotao sauce and garlic leftovers , I even put grated cheese on top for him)
DobbyTheHouseElk · 13/07/2021 22:12

[quote Heyha]@DobbyTheHouseElk I was just saying generally but that's an interesting one about vegetarian- because you would have eggs and presumably dairy products in your kitchen they are classed as animal by-products as well so are treated the same as meat.

It's so complicated and it comes up often enough that I think they need to review how they put this across now tbh, I noticed there are moves in the EU to return to approving some animal by-products back into the food chain ..😬 www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jun/22/eu-to-lift-its-ban-on-feeding-animal-remains-to-domestic-livestock[/quote]
I can tell you now, I’m not stopping what I’m doing. I don’t think you are living in the real world.

TheVolturi · 13/07/2021 22:10

I had a Jack Russell that lived to 17, that ate our leftovers along with his own food, all of his life. Fit and healthy, was never unwell.

Heyha · 13/07/2021 22:06

@DobbyTheHouseElk I was just saying generally but that's an interesting one about vegetarian- because you would have eggs and presumably dairy products in your kitchen they are classed as animal by-products as well so are treated the same as meat.

It's so complicated and it comes up often enough that I think they need to review how they put this across now tbh, I noticed there are moves in the EU to return to approving some animal by-products back into the food chain ..😬 www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jun/22/eu-to-lift-its-ban-on-feeding-animal-remains-to-domestic-livestock

thecatsabsentcojones · 13/07/2021 22:03

Knew there was the vegan exception to the rule with chickens, although many vegans go the route of feeding eggs back to their chickens to replace lost nutrients. Guess that’s not in the rules!

I think it’s a particular joy to lob leftovers at the girls who then run like a sprinter for them, and before anyone says we don’t eat meat, the girls are un contaminated!

DeathByWalkies · 13/07/2021 22:02

@SchrodingersImmigrant

I feed mealworms to my backyard sparrows😳 No idea if they are defra approved.
Back garden sparrows don't count because they're not a farmed animal, so you're safe there.
pastadog · 13/07/2021 21:53

don’t know if i already mentioned it but his dogs are big dogs, can’t say breeds as don’t want to give too much info out lol but they are large dogs (one is a mix with german shepherd!)

OP posts:
3Britnee · 13/07/2021 21:53

Ok thanks, I'd have thought it obvious to only give them fruit, veg, peelings etc but obviously not.

I wouldn't feed chickens meat, I'd give that to the dogs (cats too if I had them). I'd have thought that's common sense.

Tossblanket · 13/07/2021 21:52

Dogs eat other animals shit.

I'm sure they appreciate some nice pasta.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 13/07/2021 21:52

@Heyha

No but if you have meat in your fridge, prepare it in the same kitchen etc that's enough of a contamination risk. Officially, again I know it seems a stretch but them's the rules, they work to the lowest common denominator of people that don't operate good food hygiene for the humans involved never mind the birds.

The only way to guarantee no contamination is no meat in the house, that's why there's the vegan household exception. Or don't let the veg in the house (garden waste, or separate cooking space elsewhere like a camping stove), that's the tiger thing that's ok.

Mealworms as a problem is because they are reared on god knows what in many cases (don't look it up if your squeamish) and therefore have the same problem of them being fed potentially contaminated meat and passing to your birds who then pass it on...and so on. There is/was somewhere in the UK that is regulated and produces food grade mealworms but I can't for the life of me think what it's called at the moment.

If you are referring to my comment I’m vegetarian.
Cryalot2 · 13/07/2021 21:50

Depends on breed of the dog.
I have a small breed and it only gets fed dry dog food and either cooked chicken or turkey.
I was told by my original vet when I took her to get her vaccines and chipped that that food was all she needed.
Like many small dogs we have to be careful as she has a delicate gut. By the way she never eats poo or anything like it.
Op I think you are right to be concerned.

Heyha · 13/07/2021 21:49

No but if you have meat in your fridge, prepare it in the same kitchen etc that's enough of a contamination risk. Officially, again I know it seems a stretch but them's the rules, they work to the lowest common denominator of people that don't operate good food hygiene for the humans involved never mind the birds.

The only way to guarantee no contamination is no meat in the house, that's why there's the vegan household exception. Or don't let the veg in the house (garden waste, or separate cooking space elsewhere like a camping stove), that's the tiger thing that's ok.

Mealworms as a problem is because they are reared on god knows what in many cases (don't look it up if your squeamish) and therefore have the same problem of them being fed potentially contaminated meat and passing to your birds who then pass it on...and so on. There is/was somewhere in the UK that is regulated and produces food grade mealworms but I can't for the life of me think what it's called at the moment.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 13/07/2021 21:47

We don’t feed meat. But do give them leftover veg. Boiled carrots etc. They love it when they see us approaching with a bowl of veg. They peck about and run off with their prize. They also eat grass, worms, gunge from the stream, leaves, flowers and goodness knows what else they find. They are free range and have a very happy life

Bryonyshcmyony · 13/07/2021 21:42

I don't feed meat to my hens.

Heyha · 13/07/2021 21:40

It's the risk of meat contamination in the scraps that is the problem (so say my hens get a disease from the meat in the spag bol, it then gets vectored away from my site by wild birds etc.

That's why there is an exception for fully vegan households to feed scraps, but to count as a fully vegan household you can't have a cat (cat food- obligate carnivore so all commercial cat food contains meat, although mine are happy omnivores tbh) and if you had a dog it would have to be fed a vegan diet and let's not go there...

That's also why you can have a non-meat cookup in your shed using separate utensils etc, and you can feed garden waste, as in trimmings, veg you've pulled out to compost etc, before it goes into the kitchen. Once it's in the kitchen it could be contaminated.

Really it's a case of a blanket ban and legislation when some people could potentially be sensible about avoiding contamination, but you only have to look at the origins of the last foot and mouth outbreak (well, not the very last smaller one that seemed to have dubious origins) to know that there's always someone who will cock it up for everyone else, with devastating consequences.

I know it sounds far-fetched but it you want a live example have a look at African Swine Fever- it's devastated pig populations across the world and could be brought into this country by someone feeding scraps with pork (from an affected country) contamination to their pigs, yes, even pet ones, which wildlife could then carry to other sites. It's a miracle we've kept it out so far tbh.

3Britnee · 13/07/2021 21:37

Yeah, I dont think the poster above should give their chickens chicken curry, that's how BSE started, by feeding cows dead cows, wasn't it?

But I dont see how other scraps would be a problem. Animals were fed scraps for eons.

3Britnee · 13/07/2021 21:34

[quote Devastatedyetagain]@3Britnee because if those scraps cause an infectious disease it could spread across the entire national flock by way of wild birds hence the reason all poultry was required to be kept in during the Birdflu outbreak.[/quote]
Ahh ok, thank you.

Bryonyshcmyony · 13/07/2021 21:29

I know it's law. I flout the law.

Devastatedyetagain · 13/07/2021 21:25

@3Britnee because if those scraps cause an infectious disease it could spread across the entire national flock by way of wild birds hence the reason all poultry was required to be kept in during the Birdflu outbreak.

3Britnee · 13/07/2021 21:16

If someone in the back end of beyond, for example, feeds their 2 chickens scraps, how does that affect Tesco's massive chicken farm 100's of miles away?

Devastatedyetagain · 13/07/2021 20:58

Actually I work in healthcare science & do understand the regulations and the rationale. It's for consumer protection and that's sensible for those who are selling to the public.

@DivorcedAndDelighted you clearly don't understand the rationale! It is not just about consumer protection and the food chain. These rules were bought in to prevent the spread of infectious diseases amongst livestock after the devastating impact of Foot and Mouth 20 plus years ago. The rules are in place to protect the national flock not just yours. Whilst I appreciate you feel you are doing nothing wrong, that would not be an acceptable excuse if you ever get a visit from Animal Health!

ConstanceGracy · 13/07/2021 20:25

@Contactlesslenses

My dog loves watermelon, strawberry trifle and popadoms
My cats love popadoms too