Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not allow the plasterer to play his radio?

417 replies

Shedbuilder · 13/07/2021 10:22

I have a plasterer booked for four days of fiddly work all over the house, repairing the mess left by the so-called specialist fitters we paid a small fortune to install triple glazing —but I'm not going there!

We both work from home and around us we have other households with people working from home and noise-sensitive older people. It's a hot day and our windows are open because it's hot and to keep the air moving just in case of Covid. So when he arrived yesterday with his giant radio we nipped the problem in the bud early on and said sorry, both working from home, both need to be able to think and make calls without background noise — no radio. Which he glumly accepted. Today he's had a brief conversation with us about how tedious his work is without music in the background, so we suggested he use his phone and some earbuds. But no, he doesn't want to run out of data and he doesn't have earbuds.

We've ordered some cheap earbuds and we'll see if we can rig up some kind of free wifi connection for him tomorrow, but he's really huffy and I'm wondering whether we'll see him again tomorrow. He's a good plasterer and we've waited two months to get him. Are we being unreasonable?

Yes = we are unreasonable
No = we're no unreasonable

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 13/07/2021 20:33

YABU, do you want your walls repaired or not?

You can't be working that hard or you wouldn't have time to post this thread.

TomForddr · 13/07/2021 20:20

@Macncheeseballs

People have to change with the times, and now more people are wfh, trades people need to adapt, he sounds like a brat
But they actually don’t though. They will always have their work in demand.

I know most who will quote a stupid amount because they actually want the client to say no. But if they do say yes then they are getting paid more anyway.

ancientgran · 13/07/2021 20:18

@Macncheeseballs

People have to change with the times, and now more people are wfh, trades people need to adapt, he sounds like a brat
But a very good much in demand brat.
TomForddr · 13/07/2021 20:17

Omg OP I could never be you. What a drain over such a simple thing that was already 50% over when you posted.

What a load of drama over a non event.

moovinon · 13/07/2021 20:09

I would just let him play his music. It's only for a few days.

Bombalinabimba · 13/07/2021 20:06

You don't have to, theoretically, but it'd be much better and nicer if you allowed it, and can always ask for it to be low volume.
Don't you have a room you can work in and shut the door? It's just a few days, tbh, you sound way too uptight. As you're working he's working too and has an optimal set of circumstances he prefers. You also risk that he might rush it, and you get a bad job done in the end...

Macncheeseballs · 13/07/2021 19:58

People have to change with the times, and now more people are wfh, trades people need to adapt, he sounds like a brat

BillyShears · 13/07/2021 19:56

This is pretty tight on your behalf in my opinion.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 13/07/2021 19:54

Yes YABVU. Good trades are like gold dust. You treat them like gods. Cup of tea, radio on, feed them.
This ensures that they will come back again and again when you want any more silly fiddly jobs done that nobody else will touch.
You never treat good trades poorly. Word gets round quickly, nobody will want to work for you.

Macncheeseballs · 13/07/2021 19:45

Warmfluffytowels - that's not really the same scenario

Macncheeseballs · 13/07/2021 19:44

I would have lent him a bluetooth radio with headphones

Alcemeg · 13/07/2021 19:41

I just don't know why headphones are such a problem. Especially bluetooth. My husband wears headphones so as not to disturb me when I'm working. I don't see why someone doing a job in the house can't do the same.

Zlk02 · 13/07/2021 19:03

OP, this is very timely because we have had the exact same issue very recently. I had a decorator start here the other day. He’s been before and plays music without asking, which is generally fine as I don’t work so it doesn’t bother me. DH is generally WFH these days. The decorator was in a massive strop with me the other day as apparently, DH had caught him on the way in and told him not to play music as it would disturb him. The decorator told me he was about to walk out! I had to explain to him that my husband has calls with various governments etc and he can’t exactly have Magic FM playing in the background. Hardly professional!

But this decorator doesn’t get it at all. He says, “I’m a music man and I’m going to play it anyway with the door shut.” Confused His attitude has really annoyed me actually (more than the music itself). So entitled! When you enter someone’s house, surely you are respectful of the people who live there? I couldn’t imagine imposing my workplace habits on a family, let alone when in someone else’s workplace. Many people are WFH these days and workmen are going to have to adapt accordingly. Luckily, he’s been right up at the top of the house so far, but as he works his way down, I know that at the first sign of the radio being on, DH will confront him and probably tell him to leave. He’s very blunt (I’m not)! How can I avoid this confrontation?

roxisolerenshaw · 13/07/2021 18:47

I've always got tradesmen in and out of the house and just accept that it's part of the package that they have the radio on. I work at home most of the time and if I'm in meetings etc or need to concentrate I use headphones to block out background noise. If noise is really bothersome I'd go to the office. Tbh it's never crossed my mind to ask anyone to make less noise or turn their music off.

warmfluffytowels · 13/07/2021 18:36

DH is a plasterer and using headphones/earphones/earbuds is banned on site as they block out too much surrounding noise and can potentially be quite dangerous.

IllForTooLong · 13/07/2021 17:51

He seems slightly bemused and it occurred to me that he may not have a smartphone. I've known others involved in wet trades who've ruined so many phones they've gone back to the easily-replaced dumb variety at work.

That just occurred to you @Shedbuilder
Are you sure you are working in the building industry? Because the issue with having a smart phone on-site came to me quite quickly and I’m not even working in that environment…..
It would obvious that doing site which are dusty and full of hasard of all sorts are not compatible with a smart phone…. Hmm

Plus, not everyone has a smartphone. Why did you assume that? Because he dares charging more than you as a daily rate?

IllForTooLong · 13/07/2021 17:47

@Shedbuilder radios are only loud when you put the volume up.
It’s not because you have a radio that can be loud that automatically the sound will be loud. You can CHOSE to have it a lower volume…..

IllForTooLong · 13/07/2021 17:45

Nothing to do with that @Alcemeg.
It has nothing to do with social class (are only mc or upper middle that are working from home? No wc then?)
It doesn’t even have anything to do with this country (it’s the same in other countries too).

It’s the fact that having a workman in your house is a two way Relationship and the ‘customer’ can’t impose everything to suit them and expect said trade man to just accept it ‘because they are the customer’.

Spanielstail · 13/07/2021 17:13

I'm have Asperger's and completely noise intolerant so there isn't a chance anyone would be playing a radio in my house whilst I worked. Low is worse as you get that awful bassy hum.

motogogo · 13/07/2021 17:11

Every tradesperson I've hired has had music on despite me wfh. Yabu

VoiceFaceArse · 13/07/2021 17:08

how quietly do you play your music??

Today, not very loud as one of my children is in bed poorly. I had it on in the kitchen whilst cooking and could hear it fine. Number 3 on Amazon Alexa. 🤷🏻‍♀️ We have Amazon Echos throughout the house so if no one is working or ill, it’s often played through the house. Not really sure what your point is though. Confused

Callybrate · 13/07/2021 17:02

Voicefacearse how quietly do you play your music?? Hardly seems worth bothering.

Alcemeg · 13/07/2021 17:00

@Cuppaand2biscuits

I come from a family of tradesman and I'll assure you, you'll get a much better finish and quality of job if you let him have his radio playing. If you've passed him off he might finish the job but not as carefully as he might have done.
Is this something to be proud of?

I don't get the bullying attitude on this thread, that we either kiss the ass of a tradesman or expect to be done over by them.

Extreme focus and concentration in a physically skilled job probably does benefit from music playing, but extreme focus and concentration in a mentally demanding job can be really undermined by it. And that's not just being precious.

There seems to be some real inverted snobbery here, that the dear ol' lads should be able to make themselves right at home while their sniffy upperclass employers wince, tee hee.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/07/2021 16:45

@DeflatedGinDrinker

I wouldn't trust a man who can't go £1 shop and get some headphones and who thinks using your wifi will use his data 😳
He probably doesn't have time to go to the shops in the middle of the working week. And what does his IT knowledge have to do with plastering?
IndigoC · 13/07/2021 16:38

@VoiceFaceArse

I have. On multiple occasions.

Then you politely ask them to turn it down. I don’t believe it for a second though.

Why would I make that up?

And no, I didn’t ask them to turn it down for the exact reasons many of given here, I wanted them happy and willing to complete the job. The noise didn’t bother me that much, the initial reply was in relation to earbuds v loud radio safety.