Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you know where “taking the knees” comes from?

114 replies

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 07:08

Stemming from the other thread asking what the problem is with taking the knee and some of the responses (a minority) describing it as a “divisive” act and one post saying it caused them to have a “visceral” reaction, I just wondered how many people knew where the act had come from? Particularly those people who are opposed to it.

YABU - I know where “taking the knee” originated from

YANBU - I don’t know where “taking the knee” originated from

OP posts:
daisycottage · 13/07/2021 15:25

Perhaps not, but I personally don't know anything about American sport, sportspeople etc. so why assume everyone else does?

We're not mini Americans in this country, just because we sort of share a language doesn't mean that we're the same. We have more in common with the French.

I've never heard of the fellow you refer to, I had to Google him.

stickygotstuck · 13/07/2021 15:24

@DrDetriment

I think the issue is that some people feel that taking the knee has come to symbolise support for the BLM movement and not as a simple anti racist stance. Some feel that BLM has a political agenda and set of beliefs that they don't agree with (e.g. defund the police) so it is against their beliefs to take the knee, which is a stance I would have to respect. It isn't as simple as if you don't take the knee you are a racist.
This.
Iggly · 13/07/2021 15:23

Again, people can say it’s subservient etc but to put that in the same sentence as claiming to support the protest - it’s insensitive and a bit unsupportive to be honest. Which then makes it seem disingenuous to claim you support their message.

Ultimately footballers have chosen to show their feelings in this way.

Ultimately it is not offensive.

It does what a protest should do. Gets people talking about the problem that is racism. That is the issue that needs engaging with and anything else is just a distraction.

People find it uncomfortable because they know racism is shit and they’ve not done enough to stand up to it.

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 15:21

An American doing it doesn’t make it an exclusively American thing. I assure you that the issues Colin Kaepernick was taking the knee over aren’t exclusive to America and it’s history…

OP posts:
daisycottage · 13/07/2021 15:12

We have a different history to America and there are many things that we don't identify with because of our history and background. We can't just be lumped in with Americans and their culture and social practices.

I'm sure there are other ways of showing solidarity against racism if you don't feel it's appropriate to kneel.

NeedNewKnees · 13/07/2021 15:10

There were similar protests in the 60s and 70s about refusing to say the Pledge Of Allegiance in American high schools and colleges.

NeedNewKnees · 13/07/2021 15:09

Subservience is to Bend The Knee (acknowledge someone as your sovereign/ruler/liege lord).

To not stand for your flag/national anthem and instead to Take A Knee is to adopt a respectful pose while refusing to stand at attention for a country that allows the levels of institutional racism and violence,

grapewine · 13/07/2021 15:09

@leathermouse

Actually, there is a great deal of history surrounding taking a knee, that goes way beyond Colin Kaepernick's recent revival. Martin Luther King was taking a knee in 1965.
This. It isn't new.
RubyFakeLips · 13/07/2021 15:06

But you can know ad understand where this comes from and still feel it subservient. Although I'm surprised to hear many people don't know the more recent background as it has been so widely publicised.

I've known the Colin Kaepernick story since it began, as I read some US news, I'm also aware it has been linked to MLK, but that wasn't behind CK originally choosing to do this.

I would say I'm actively anti-racist, I'm Jewish, my husband is Black, we completely support the goal. However, still don't like it as a gesture. I do believe kneeling is a subservient act, it historically has been and that isn't how I believe racism should be confronted. Think it was James Baldwin who said Freedom must be taken and taking the knee is too much of the middle ground.

In this house we're still fans of the raised fist as our large 1968 poster can testify Grin although that does have it's own negative connotations...

daisycottage · 13/07/2021 15:05

Perhaps this is why people are having a visceral reaction to it, because, historically, it's a sign of subservience.

daisycottage · 13/07/2021 15:01

I associate it with subservience, such as kneeling in church where you're subservient to God or, in a historical context where you'd have to kneel in front of a nobleman or the Lord of the Manor or The King.

Russian prisoners used to (may still do) have stars tattooed on their knees as a sign that 'I bow to no man'.

I'm 51 so perhaps it's an age thing.

Iggly · 13/07/2021 14:51

The main thing for me is what it means to those who are actually taking the knee. They’re kneeling.

Everyone else can overlay whatever nonsense they like about BLM but that’s not what it means to the footballers who did.

And that’s the point here.

Avocadowoman · 13/07/2021 14:48

If I see a person do a thumbs up sign while scuba diving I interpret it completely differently from on land.

Brilliant point which I think sums up how I feel about it. If you 'come to it out of the blue' it takes a bit of getting used to to understand exactly what it means. If I showed (say) a 4 year old or a 85 year old who has not followed sport or politics for a while a photo of a sports team taking the knee I am certain they would not only not know what it meant, but also not be able to guess.

However, if you do know exactly what it means and where it comes from, it seems odd to dislike it.

SallySycamore · 13/07/2021 14:11

I would say so. Once you know the context, you can interpret it differently. So at a sports event I know what it's representing (it maybe isn't the symbol I'd choose if designing it from scratch, but there's only so many things you can do, so some will have to double up).

If I see a person do a thumbs up sign while scuba diving I interpret it completely differently from on land.

tallduckandhandsome · 13/07/2021 14:05

@DrDetriment

I think the issue is that some people feel that taking the knee has come to symbolise support for the BLM movement and not as a simple anti racist stance. Some feel that BLM has a political agenda and set of beliefs that they don't agree with (e.g. defund the police) so it is against their beliefs to take the knee, which is a stance I would have to respect. It isn't as simple as if you don't take the knee you are a racist.
You can’t use the hypothesis that some people use the BLM banner for a political agenda as an excuse to dishonour the BLM movement and nitpick about taking the knee. That smacks of oppression. You’re respecting the status quo to further your own agenda.
NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 14:01

I agree that not knowing where it came from, it makes sense that people get a sense of subservience from it.

What I’m interested is if knowing where it came from makes any difference.

OP posts:
SallySycamore · 13/07/2021 13:59

I just find it interesting that many people are angered by what they see as an act of subservience when it is actually intended to be an act of respect, suggested by a veteran (and a white man, to boot).

An alternative act of respect (because standing up was the "usual" one).

I do know the background so it makes sense in a sporting/protest context, but traditionally kneeling has been showing subservience and/or asking for a blessing so if you don't know the reason it's being done I can see why it might seem a bit odd.

I'd say historically standing has been used more to show respect e.g. minute's silence, teacher entering the room, bride entering church, men used to stand if a lady entered the room etc — and indeed that was the one being used before Kaepernick protested by using something different (and I think he was right to, and that a positive action, like taking the knee was a much more polite, and in some ways stronger, symbol than just not moving).

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 13:59

Did you read my post with the link of where it came from? I just wondered if that impacts your view at all

OP posts:
Gothichouse40 · 13/07/2021 13:52

No, I have no idea of the origin of taking the knee. The exception being history from the middle ages where servants did it to their masters or monarchy. Hence the reason I find it subservient.

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 13:51

I feel the same about wearing the poppy - I know, and support, what it symbolises but I feel that the way it has been co-opted by some groups (hard right) isn’t something I’m comfortable with. So over recent years, I haven’t worn a poppy (though I have still made donations).

But I certainly wouldn’t criticise those who do, or assume that they share the beliefs of those I disagree with, especially if they’ve explicitly said that’s not the case (like the England football team has made clear that their taking the knee is not an expression of support for the BLM political group)

OP posts:
NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 13:47

I never said, and don’t believe, that those who don’t take the knee are racist.

I just wondered if those who felt it is a symbol of subservience understand where it came from.

OP posts:
DrDetriment · 13/07/2021 13:30

I think the issue is that some people feel that taking the knee has come to symbolise support for the BLM movement and not as a simple anti racist stance. Some feel that BLM has a political agenda and set of beliefs that they don't agree with (e.g. defund the police) so it is against their beliefs to take the knee, which is a stance I would have to respect. It isn't as simple as if you don't take the knee you are a racist.

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 13:24

(Not sure what PTSD a footballer taking the knee would cause though…)

OP posts:
NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 13:23

@picklemewalnuts Yes, that’s right - I am talking about the history of this particular movement. Was that not clear from my OP?

OP posts:
Bloodypunkrockers · 13/07/2021 13:21

Kneeling but on one knee

American

Swipe left for the next trending thread