Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you know where “taking the knees” comes from?

114 replies

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 07:08

Stemming from the other thread asking what the problem is with taking the knee and some of the responses (a minority) describing it as a “divisive” act and one post saying it caused them to have a “visceral” reaction, I just wondered how many people knew where the act had come from? Particularly those people who are opposed to it.

YABU - I know where “taking the knee” originated from

YANBU - I don’t know where “taking the knee” originated from

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lessthanaballpark · 13/07/2021 23:13

Although it did make it more poignant.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 22:50

@WorkHardPlayHard1

I could be wrong but wasnt it because the police officer in US kneaded on guys neck and killed him? xx
It was not but this seems to be a common misconception.
WorkHardPlayHard1 · 13/07/2021 21:58

I could be wrong but wasnt it because the police officer in US kneaded on guys neck and killed him? xx

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 21:47

Thing is, it doesn't matter what black people do to protest. People will find a way to either criticise it, or minimise it, or use whataboutery in some way to distract, or insist it's not relevant, or link it to something vaguely related that they disapprove of.

SallySycamore · 13/07/2021 21:37

It means to submit to them giving up your needs. A kneeled proposal shows respect to the person you are asking to marry and to formalise the partnership.

Fealty is loyalty not subservience

But the liege/knight has the implicit power difference — that's what I think it's copying personally. Or kneeling in front of your mother or father for their blessing.

I honestly don't link kneeling to respect — apart from recently in this sporting/protest context. To me the most obvious signs of respect would be standing, and, situation dependent, bowing your head.

BiBabbles · 13/07/2021 21:29

I didn't say you did NewMum0305. You asked if knowing where it came from makes any difference. I answered: I never thought it had anything to do with subservience and I find it less inspiring than what others have connected it to. I've never had much feelings on kneeling in the first place. I'm all for multiple tactics on systemic issues, even those that are of little interest to me.

If Kapernick and Reid feel it was effective or a better way, great, but the story sounds like even the veteran involved knew it was a pointless compromise, but the 'white guy to boot' just had to tell Kapernick how he felt about the flag and the whole 'I want you to want to stand' thing -- that rings of a lot of Evangelical Americans I grew up with where we're meant to want to give ourselves to their worldview. To be joyfully subservient and loyal to the powers above us. As I said, I find it an uninspiring story and I don't see how it would make those who see it as divisive or subservient see it as any less those things.

I think what's been done with it since, the connections many others have made to the sporting traditions of kneeling for the injured, the civil rights movements where marching and kneeling in the face of abuse, the Abolitionist Medallion, among many others, matter far more than the origins anyways. Origins rarely matter as much as what people do with something. It'll be interesting to see where it'll taken from here after recent events.

TeardropsFallingOnHotSand · 13/07/2021 20:23

To me it is about national leadership. When a nations leaders are trying their best to turn around the slow tanker that is racism there is no need to kneel. When leadership condones racism, either purposefully or negligently, then kneeling is acceptable and right.

CorianderBee · 13/07/2021 20:21

It was refusing to stand for the pledge of allegiance as a defiant act against racism. Kind of a 'I won't stand to respect a flag that doesn't respect me' moment.

Wasn't it?

Lessthanaballpark · 13/07/2021 20:06

I thought it came from MLK.

I do think it’s darkly ironic that so many were opposed to taking the knee because they believe racism in football was over yet the events post match proved the opposite

Tommika · 13/07/2021 20:00

@SallySycamore

If taking a knee shows subservience then women must be the dominant sex in the West as men traditionally propose on one knee.

Well, in that moment yes — isn't that the point? They're offering their fealty to that woman in the same way a knight would to their liege.

Not really - being subservient for the moment of proposal only isn’t being subservient.

It means to submit to them giving up your needs. A kneeled proposal shows respect to the person you are asking to marry and to formalise the partnership.

Fealty is loyalty not subservience

YouLikeTheBadOnesToo · 13/07/2021 19:43

While it’s true that Colin Kaepernick was the first in recent times to take the knee (certainly with any kind of publicity) it has it origins deeper in history. Martin Luther King took the knee at marches in the 60s.

Interestingly, Colin Kaepernick originally intended to remain seated during the national anthem. A former army veteran suggested that he kneel instead, in order to avoid being labelled disrespectful. People kneel to be knighted, to pray, and soldiers kneel at the graves of their comrades. He thought kneeling would stop people being critical, unfortunately he was wrong in the case of some people.

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 19:28

That was at @BiBabbles, sorry

OP posts:
NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 19:27

I wasn’t suggesting that it was supposed to be inspiring at all - just pointing out that it wasn’t intended as a gesture of subservience (as some people seem to be wilfully misinterpreting it to be), but rather, one of respectful protest.

OP posts:
ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 19:26

@Weebleweeble

Or are we pretending that there is no racism in the UK now?

Not at all - racism is throughout our UK society - but the police aren't shooting down black people in the streets.
Which is what BLM seems to be about to me.
I think we should do things differently in the UK, not take on US stuff.

Racism is indeed prevalent in the UK, and by taking a knee, UK football players hope to bring attention to that fact, and to help bring it to an end.

If that's too difficult for you to support I guess that's up to you.

BiBabbles · 13/07/2021 19:24

Interesting article OP. I thought, as a pp said, that it had to do with the (possibly American - I grew up in the States) concept used in some sports that if someone was injured on the field, we were meant to 'take a knee' until help came to prevent further injuries or getting in the way (and then we had to be taught not to do it every time someone fell).

I thought it was meant to be symbolic of those injured in our communities by systemic oppression. I'm pretty sure I've heard some others (again Americans) make that connection.

That it was just a veteran and American football player's idea of a compromise between sitting and standing/because kneeling has so many nice meanings does very little for me. It's great that it's come to mean more than that, but I don't see how that origin is meant to be inspiring.

I feel the same about wearing the poppy - I know, and support, what it symbolises but I feel that the way it has been co-opted by some groups (hard right) isn’t something I’m comfortable with. So over recent years, I haven’t worn a poppy (though I have still made donations).

Through etsy, I bought some custom felt poppy pins that say 'Never Again', like some of the original poppies after WW1 said, in part because of my discomfort at how some have used Lest We Forget.

Weebleweeble · 13/07/2021 19:00

Or are we pretending that there is no racism in the UK now?

Not at all - racism is throughout our UK society - but the police aren't shooting down black people in the streets.
Which is what BLM seems to be about to me.
I think we should do things differently in the UK, not take on US stuff.

SallySycamore · 13/07/2021 18:48

But as I was saying with the scuba diving earlier, going down on one knee to propose is a completely different context to taking the knee at the beginning of a sporting match to protest racism. One can be read as subservience and the other as respect.

SallySycamore · 13/07/2021 18:45

If taking a knee shows subservience then women must be the dominant sex in the West as men traditionally propose on one knee.

Well, in that moment yes — isn't that the point? They're offering their fealty to that woman in the same way a knight would to their liege.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 18:44

@Weebleweeble

It's not too american but imv it is, as it says, Black LIVES Matter -it's about the loss of black LIVES to US armed police. I don't think Brits should take on US problems. It makes it too big to fix. They'll never unarm US police - better we don't go there and try to fix our more fixable problems. In the UK the police aren't armed. Use CCTV etc to nail the yobs in the football crowds, insist recruitment is fair, etc etc - we can actually fix things but not armed US police,
My impression was that the UK football players who took a knee were protesting against all racism.

Or are we pretending that there is no racism in the UK now?

Tommika · 13/07/2021 18:38

Taking one knee isn’t subservient. That is an argument that gets brought up in objection to someone who takes a knee in protest.

One knee has been a symbol of respect for centuries of not millenia and is part of various ceremonies

If taking a knee shows subservience then women must be the dominant sex in the West as men traditionally propose on one knee

NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 18:34

@Weebleweeble my husband’s ex-partner’s uncle (a black man) died in police custody. Yes, US police are trigger happy but please don’t think it’s only a US problem.

Black people account for 3% of the UK population but 8% of deaths in police custody: www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/jun/11/black-deaths-in-police-custody-the-tip-of-an-iceberg-of-racist-treatment

And in any case, I think that Black Lives Matter has very much extended beyond protesting about deaths in police custody, about the rights of black people more generally and the fight against racism. Why shouldn’t people show their support for that?

OP posts:
ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 18:28

@DoyertyRascal

And what I will say is that I find it completely ridiculous and inappropriate that a whole swathes of white people decide that they don’t like the way black people are choosing to protest - it’s subservient, it’s too political, blah blah. So what? YOU want to choose how black people express their protest? Have some bloody respect!
Yes yes yes.
NewMum0305 · 13/07/2021 18:28

@Weebleweeble So it is possible for countries to adopt things from other countries without issue..?

OP posts:
Weebleweeble · 13/07/2021 18:28

It's not too american but imv it is, as it says, Black LIVES Matter -it's about the loss of black LIVES to US armed police.
I don't think Brits should take on US problems. It makes it too big to fix. They'll never unarm US police - better we don't go there and try to fix our more fixable problems.
In the UK the police aren't armed.
Use CCTV etc to nail the yobs in the football crowds, insist recruitment is fair, etc etc - we can actually fix things but not armed US police,

Weebleweeble · 13/07/2021 18:23

There's always been Halloween in Scotland - it went from there to the US