Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about how young people feel about love island

55 replies

getmetothebeachplease · 12/07/2021 21:28

Ok don't get me wrong I love love island, watch it every series. However I also feel quite crap about myself while watching it. I constantly think how bad I look compared to the women on there. I'm in my 30s and know that I don't look like that because of my own faults (I bloody love food! Haha) but it still makes me feel very insecure. But once I turn the programme off I don't think about it again and it doesn't affect me.
But I suppose my point is that at 30 I feel like I compare myself constantly to these ladies and during the programme even daydream about
Coming in to some money and being able to afford surgery to look better. But I also know that I can switch off from this and they don't represent the majority of people. What worries me is young people watching this and having the same thoughts but not being able to separate reality tv from real life. As a mother of a boy and girl I worry for both of them that people are being shown on tv to be 'perfect' and yet they still get judged on the programme for not being the most good looking ect. What does this message send?
Like I say I do watch the programme so
I will probably be roasted as a hypocrite but it just worries me for young people watching

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NonShallot · 13/07/2021 15:47

@Zampa

You cannot be a feminist and watch this programme

What a lot of nonsense.

Yes, the contestants are selected on their looks but that's only a very small part of it. The most popular contestants are the interesting, funny, clever contestants who win the hearts of viewers with their personality.

There have been some great women on the show, demonstrating positive traits such as valuing careers and female friendships.

It's a show about romantic and platonic relationships that provides key learning points for young people on how to conduct those relationships.

Sorry, and I'm talking nonsense?

'Key learning points for young people on how to conduct those relationships'

I would be utterly horrified if my DD emulated any of the behaviours on this programme, or indeed allowed any man to treat her how some of the men on this show treat those girls. This is NOT how relationships or friendships should be conducted and I seriously worry for anyone who thinks that this is okay.

LemonSherbetFancies · 13/07/2021 13:08

I get what you mean OP.
I have daughters and nieces in their 20's/30's and they all feel down after watching love Island.
I feel sorry for women these days. The standards they are held to. Needing on point eyebrows, fake tans, size zero figure, big boobs, etc. Just to be seen as 'beautiful.' The prettiest women I know are not perfect physically but they are natural and proud of that. Love Island gives a screwed perception of what beauty is.

leonpride · 13/07/2021 13:03

The definition of “feminist” is to support equal rights. No more than that. Are you really ok with not being a feminist? Confused

So... you can be a feminist and watch love island? Thanks for clarifying.

househousehousefox · 13/07/2021 12:24

@NonShallot

I don't think the issue is how these men and women look and how it might affect the self esteem, its more about how it is a horrific exercise in objectifying misogyny. The gaslighting and bitchiness that goes on in this program is horrifying.

You cannot be a feminist and watch this programme. What sort of example is this setting to the younger generation? The only way to get a partner is to look and act a certain way, that performing sexual acts on TV is okay, that its alright for men to judge women and rate them according to their looks? Hard pass, thanks.

I've only just started watching it, I've always been anti this lind of crap TV but actually I quite like it. It surprised me how familiar this is. Its like fast forwarding through single/dating life and seeing what people are actually like - shallow and selfish. Looks rarely are a compromise for most people. But its nice seeing the funny people get a chance because they are funny. I don't know anyone with false boobs or lips or even false nails for that matter. I've always been a bit 'why would you do that?' and seeing the girls on there speaking and laughing about it made me feel differently. Of course they want to be beautiful, everyone does. Its nice seeing the girls have friendships too, something I struggle with in life. I feel like I can take away alot from this 'shit show' thats quite valuable, for instance help and pointers on interacting with women. I have a dh and children already so not too bothered about talking to the boys but its also nice looking at how obvious it is to outside viewers peoples feelings are. even when they are trying to hide those feelings. Something to reflect on. Also it is just a bit of fun isn't it? I rolled my eyes at a boys comments about a girl not wanting children and wanting her to be a sahm (?) but then I realised that he's fine to want that. I wanted that for myself and its not necessarily as sexist as it sounds. Makes sense when you think about breast feeding and siblings.

Although I do agree its sad that lovely looking girls are chopping their faces but I also think that may be more about the competition rather than the prize if you know what I mean.

when the presenter and 2 contestants killed themselves I was all for axing the show. but after actually watching it I think its not as bad as I first thought.
fuck off goggle box tho

DillonPanthersTexas · 13/07/2021 07:49

And the men’s physics are even more worrying to think a youngster has to spend hours in the gym to be acceptable

Sadly steroid abuse by young men is a growing problem where taking shortcuts is a an attractive temptation. I often get the sense that while they are big lads they would be crap at sports. I am heavily involved in the coaching side of my sports club and I have lost count the number of times some Love Island esque gym monkey rocks up to the rugby training ground with an arrogant swagger only to see them blowing out their arses 10 mins later as they have zero aerobic fitness and the smaller lads are running rings around them.

Woodmarsh · 13/07/2021 07:00

@letthelightoflove in its extreme yes, men and women are different, I don't want to be treated equally in every single situation I just want to be treated well

Classicbrunette · 13/07/2021 03:45

I’m watching it for the first time ever to see what the fuss is all about.

It’s strangely addictive, although nothing happens (except for change of people) the pouting lips, plastic boobs are sad, I mean why would you do that to yourself ?
And the men’s physics are even more worrying to think a youngster has to spend hours in the gym to be acceptable.
And if they are going on personalities in the end, (and I don’t think any of them has a personality) why even bother with the good looks in the first place ?
Why not have a bunch of fat ugly youngsters on ? Maybe there will be one day.

Letthelightoflove · 13/07/2021 03:42

@Woodmarsh

You cannot be a feminist and watch this programme.

I don't want to be a feminist, I'm OK with that

The definition of “feminist” is to support equal rights. No more than that. Are you really ok with not being a feminist? Confused
Awwlookatmybabyspider · 13/07/2021 03:01

I've never watched it but I can imagine what they're all like.
Posing and pouty Clones with no individuality. Its so predictable.

Crankley · 13/07/2021 02:48

Why would anyone watch such utter garbage?

tallduckandhandsome · 13/07/2021 02:21

I tried it once and only lasted 10 minutes. Vacuous TV for vacuous minds. Sorry not sorry!

Mistressofnone · 12/07/2021 23:45

I enjoy Love Island. It's nice to turn my brain off after a hard day and watch some young-person antics. A few years ago I would have been envious of the girls on there, but now all I see are normal faces painted and plumped, totally unintimidating.

Imagine how much they crash diet beforehand, knowing they will have to walk around with their bum cheeks wobbling and underboobs on show.

As a teen I used to watch Big Brother and definitely didn't feel heavily influenced to strip & get flirty on TV.

I'd probably watch it with my kids when they're older and make light of the whole thing. Point out the smarter contestants or remark on how sad that an attractive girl feels the need to change her breasts before they have even finished developing etc.

whatswithtodaytoday · 12/07/2021 23:25

I find it strange that people want to emulate Love Island contestants, not because they're weird looking (though they are), but because they're thick as shit. Just utterly vacant. I tried watching to see what the fuss was about but they don't say anything, or have any thoughts. They just bimble about gossiping and wondering what people think of them. It was excruciating.

Fair enough wanting to be beautiful, but you need something else as well.

PattyPan · 12/07/2021 23:11

I don’t watch it because it’s on itv a load of crap. I’m 26. I’m not affected by it and most people I know who watch it seem to treat it as a bit of a joke. Have you tried seeing someone for your insecurities, like a life coach or something, to build up your confidence? I think you need to be more careful how you act insecure (or not) around your DC than worrying about something on tv

Zampa · 12/07/2021 23:00

Let's not try and pretend its some kind of valuable education programme

Oh, it's definitely not that. It's light hearted fun. It's also not the toxic poison that others (who've probably never watched it) try to make it out to be.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 12/07/2021 22:58

@Hyperion100

Love Island is poison for young minds. That might sound dramatic but its really not.
Agreed.
leonpride · 12/07/2021 22:53

What specifically do you object to? There aren't any sex acts. Examples of misogyny I may have missed?

It's reality TV, it's not much different from any other show. They want young, attractive people on there. It's hot, they wear bikinis and the men go shirtless.

Anyone who feels their mental health and confidence is affected should ideally not watch. The contestants on the show are fairly normal people in swimsuits.

Rhinothunder · 12/07/2021 22:50

@Scrunchies

Gosh I find this surprising. I watch it because I think they all look ridiculous and caricature like and that’s part of the fun.
Agreed! They look hilarious!
TeaAndBrie · 12/07/2021 22:49

My DD 15 watches it, if I didn’t let her I know she would secretly watch it. We have open conversations about the themes and outfits and have actually been able to have a good discussion on why they may behave how they do, as well as being able to see how much the producers influence what you see. There is nothing real on reality tv.
We discuss healthy Relationships and respecting your body and the lengths people will go to to get attention, and the fact that the attention can sour quite quickly.
It’s basically big brother with arse cheeks and underboob and in my DDs words they need to stay classy!

AuntieStella · 12/07/2021 22:48

@lolacola77

It's toxic. Pure poison. A feminist would not watch this. It's horrible towards men and women and promotes a very unhealthy attitude towards self image and sex.
I agree with the last bit of that - Hugo was pilloried for saying he didn't like 'fake' looks, by those who have had fillers/Botox/boobs done (one saying still in her teens)

But those who liked blondes weren't turned on, nor those who said they liked natural looks. All very peculiar (and probably set up)

(And of course Hugo is the one who has had extensive surgery to correct the club foot with which he was born, and who still walks a little differently - he's got a lot of fans now because the 'mean' girls turned on him)

Haudyourwheesht · 12/07/2021 22:47

@Zampa

You cannot be a feminist and watch this programme

What a lot of nonsense.

Yes, the contestants are selected on their looks but that's only a very small part of it. The most popular contestants are the interesting, funny, clever contestants who win the hearts of viewers with their personality.

There have been some great women on the show, demonstrating positive traits such as valuing careers and female friendships.

It's a show about romantic and platonic relationships that provides key learning points for young people on how to conduct those relationships.

GrinGrinGrin
AuntieStella · 12/07/2021 22:41

"Yes, the contestants are selected on their looks but that's only a very small part of it. The most popular contestants are the interesting, funny, clever contestants who win the hearts of viewers with their personality"

I think this is only true up to a point. Because we only see what the producers show us. We don't really get to know their personalities, and we vote on who we like to watch. That may well not be something worthy or edifying, just something entertaining

AuntieStella · 12/07/2021 22:39

I watch with my teen DD fir that reading.

She's way more knowing and cynical about it than I am, and can spot the hand of the producers in many of the set up scenes,

I don't think she or any of her friends believes it is remotely realistic, and I don't really think they are outliers - just normal teens brought up as digital natives.

DillonPanthersTexas · 12/07/2021 22:35

It's a show about romantic and platonic relationships that provides key learning points for young people on how to conduct those relationships.

Its a popularity contest with participants cynically eyeing up the best match that can see them to the end of the show as winners and the lucrative D rate celebrity circus that comes with it. If 'young people' are going to learn anything it is how not to treat relationships as shallow, vapid, duplicitous interactions that can be traded in the moment a better option comes along. Let's not try and pretend its some kind of valuable education programme.

jessyjo2 · 12/07/2021 22:34

When i initially see the girls come in, I always think they look perfect, absolutely stunning appearance. However as time goes on when u see them without make up, how artificial certain features are it actually makes me realise they really aren't perfect. Skin behind the make up no better than the average girl etc. Yes i do think love island is damaging in so many ways but also may make people realise that nobody is pefect behind the make up, airbrushed photos etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread