Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to merge finances

110 replies

Whatsyoursismine · 12/07/2021 21:23

Something came up elsewhere and I’d be interested in views….

DH and I don’t merge finances. I earn approx 3x more. We have a joint account that we pay into in proportion to our earnings for mortgage, bills, DCs stuff etc…

I work longer hours. I work harder. He could work harder but just isn’t motivated too (which is fine). He would accept I do 50% of childcare and children related stuff. I actually do more, but perhaps we can assume its 50/50 for present purposes.

Some people seem to think our finances should be merged. AIBU to think they shouldn’t. Obviously would be very different if he did more childcare/sacrified his career etc. But that’s not the case.

Hard hat on. Interested in thoughts…

OP posts:
Whatsyoursismine · 13/07/2021 07:32

I don’t know if it makes a difference but when I took maternity leave, I funded that from my savings (plus statutory allowance - am self employed) and continued to pay bills etc in same ratio as if I was working.

OP posts:
Purple21 · 13/07/2021 07:28

We have a joint account and share finances, DP is the higher earner.
I get raised eyebrows from people for it but it works well for us.
Just do what's best for you both who cares what people think.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 07:23

@drpet49

*But I know if the sexes were reversed & it was the man earning 3 times as much as the woman & not wanting to share finances there would've uproar on here.*

^This. YABU

But again: its not about creating financial parity in the marriage, its about protection for the child-bearing partner.

There's a moral and obligation for the partner who is earning money to support the partner who is not able to earn money due to bearing and raising children -- at least for the period when the children are dependent. When do you see men excluded from the workforce for years taking a serious hit to their finances because they are at home raising children? Almost never.

TECMH · 13/07/2021 07:21

I’ll be in similar circumstances except the only child will be mine who by then will be relatively financially independent but probably still at home for a while. My partner is of the view that all bills/savings come out of one account and are contributed to equally. But then the rest of our money remains our own - his rationale is he might want to buy himself something relatively expensive and doesn’t want to feel he’s doing this with my money (I’m the higher earner by about double), or feel he has to ask me. I understand that.

drpet49 · 13/07/2021 07:14

But I know if the sexes were reversed & it was the man earning 3 times as much as the woman & not wanting to share finances there would've uproar on here.

^This. YABU

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 07:13

The thing is that shared finances in marriage are designed to protect the partner who stays at home with the children (in the vast majority of cases the woman). They are a way of protecting this partner and the children from destitution.

To be blunt, most men don't need this protection (unless they are sick or disabled). They don't bear children, they rarely are the sole carer and their financial wellbeing isn't usually negatively impacted by marriage.

There is no intrinsic requirement for marriage to mean you take all of mine and I take all of yours.

It's not the job of a woman with children to carry a healthy, able bodied adult who can support himself.

I realise this is an over-simplification but the point I am making is that the shared finances bit of marriage came into place to support children, not as an intrinsic perk of marriage.

ThornAmongstRoses · 13/07/2021 07:13

My husband works more hours than me (I wanted to work part time after DC) and he brings home more than double what I do every month.

Our finances have been merged since I was pregnant with off DC (eight years ago) and anything else would feel strange.

It’s marriage, we work as one unit.

Merryoldgoat · 13/07/2021 07:10

But anyone who says they "don't attach meaning to money" has lived a very charmed existence indeed and is at risk if they don't give this any thought.

I can tell you now nothing about my upbringing was charmed.

I grew up in poverty with a mother and her partner. She didn’t work and he was emotionally and financially abusive.

I attach meaning to money - it means my kids are well fed and clothed, that I’m not hungry.

MiloAndEddie · 13/07/2021 06:47

Tbh it sounds like you’re almost using this as some kind of punishment because he doesn’t pull his weight or work hard enough. In which case, you’ve got more important things to worry about than merging your finances.
FWIW I think it makes life easier if you do, no keeping track of ‘oh well I bought the last takeaway, you can buy it now’ or ‘I need £3.50 for half this T-shirt I’ve just bought the kid’

TedMullins · 13/07/2021 01:03

You can’t 100% trust anyone. You just can’t, in the same way you can’t predict the future. You can no more guarantee that your marriage will last forever than you can guarantee you’ll make it to your 81st birthday or that you’ll win the lottery.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 13/07/2021 00:23

My parents have been married 50+ years and don't have a joint account.

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 00:15

@thepeopleversuswork

I 100% trust my husband not to cheat, gamble etc. If we were to drift apart I 100% trust that we will be sensible and fair with finances.

Well I am not going to get married, in large part because I don't want to be financially enmeshed with someone.

But without meaning to undermine your confidence in your marriage and with every hope that you are right, you just can't ever 100% trust someone. You only have to read these boards a couple of times to see how that can go for women who believe they trust someone 100%. Even if your trust is valid, infidelity isn't the only way women can be financially disadvantaged.

And I do think its perfectly sensible that women whose income and capital is generally disadvantaged by having children need to put theirs and their children's financial security first. Ahead of their husband if push comes to shove.

You probably shouldn't get married with your mindset.

I'm sorry to disappoint you but I do 100% trust my husband. That's why I chose him. I would never settle.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 00:11

I 100% trust my husband not to cheat, gamble etc. If we were to drift apart I 100% trust that we will be sensible and fair with finances.

Well I am not going to get married, in large part because I don't want to be financially enmeshed with someone.

But without meaning to undermine your confidence in your marriage and with every hope that you are right, you just can't ever 100% trust someone. You only have to read these boards a couple of times to see how that can go for women who believe they trust someone 100%. Even if your trust is valid, infidelity isn't the only way women can be financially disadvantaged.

And I do think its perfectly sensible that women whose income and capital is generally disadvantaged by having children need to put theirs and their children's financial security first. Ahead of their husband if push comes to shove.

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 00:05

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@Summerleaves

But genuinely how can you guarantee you will always trust someone? Of course you trust someone when you marry them (hopefully). But if you marry someone at 25 can you hand on heart say you know you'll be able to trust them at 55? You really can't. You very much hope so. But you can't know.

I'm not saying all men are trustworthy and all will cheat and leave. But its perfectly reasonable to want not to gamble your financial security on your assessment of the odds during the honeymoon period of a relationship.[/quote]
I wouldn't marry someone I didn't trust, it's what marriage is all about.

If you have a mindset where there's no trust why get married in the first place? It's the whole point of marriage, sharing and commitment. Without that it really is meaningless.

I 100% trust my husband not to cheat, gamble etc. If we were to drift apart I 100% trust that we will be sensible and fair with finances.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 00:04

@Viviennemary

Strange on MN when the man earns most of or all the money its family money but if the woman does then it's hers. Hmm
I've never believed in family money, tbh. I think except when one partner is at home bringing up children its far less risky to keep finances separate. So I would never consider a man's money to be mine.

But in all fairness the partner who stays at home to bring up the children is far far more likely to be the woman. And I do think its morally and socially correct that this person be supported by the breadwinning partner. So, while I don't think its ideal for a woman to be dependent on a man for money it is at least justifiable when she's bearing and rearing children full time. Men aren't financially vulnerable in the same way.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 00:01

@Summerleaves

But genuinely how can you guarantee you will always trust someone? Of course you trust someone when you marry them (hopefully). But if you marry someone at 25 can you hand on heart say you know you'll be able to trust them at 55? You really can't. You very much hope so. But you can't know.

I'm not saying all men are trustworthy and all will cheat and leave. But its perfectly reasonable to want not to gamble your financial security on your assessment of the odds during the honeymoon period of a relationship.

Viviennemary · 12/07/2021 23:55

Strange on MN when the man earns most of or all the money its family money but if the woman does then it's hers. Hmm

Summerleaves · 12/07/2021 23:53

@thepeopleversuswork

I am smug that my husband and I value eachother as people and don't attach meaning to money other than how it can enrich all our lives.

Let's see how smug you would feel if you found he was having an affair. Or hiding a gambling habit. Hopefully he's not.

But anyone who says they "don't attach meaning to money" has lived a very charmed existence indeed and is at risk if they don't give this any thought.

You can love someone and share your life with them and insure yourself against not having perfectly aligned interests for the rest of your life. That's just being sensible.

No, I wouldn't marry someone I didn't trust.

What's the point?

thepeopleversuswork · 12/07/2021 23:52

I am smug that my husband and I value eachother as people and don't attach meaning to money other than how it can enrich all our lives.

Let's see how smug you would feel if you found he was having an affair. Or hiding a gambling habit. Hopefully he's not.

But anyone who says they "don't attach meaning to money" has lived a very charmed existence indeed and is at risk if they don't give this any thought.

You can love someone and share your life with them and insure yourself against not having perfectly aligned interests for the rest of your life. That's just being sensible.

Summerleaves · 12/07/2021 23:47

Some of these responses are so passive aggressive and smug they make me want to vomit.

Nothing passive aggressive about it.

I am smug that my husband and I value eachother as people and don't attach meaning to money other than how it can enrich all our lives.

thepeopleversuswork · 12/07/2021 23:42

@shivawn

YANBU. You can do what you want in your own relationship. I am glad that my husband and I have enough trust, communication and compatibility to merge everything but it wouldn't work for every relationship.
Grin

I'm so glad that my husband and I are better in every way than you.

Some of these responses are so passive aggressive and smug they make me want to vomit.

OP I think you're being exceptionally sensible. Particularly as by his own admission he's less motivated to work than you. As you were.

pallisers · 12/07/2021 23:38

@Merryoldgoat

I think YABU.

I don’t really understand living as a family with supposedly aligned goals for your life and having such disparate finances.

It creates a power imbalance. You get to make the big decisions because you have the money. Even if you discuss it you being uncomfortable with the spend means it doesn’t happen.

I agree with this because this is how we live our lives. When we married we became a family. If I hadn't wanted that I wouldn't have married him. I've earned more, he has earned more at various times. but we were in it together.

But maybe OP uses her extra money for house/holidays etc without being the sole decision maker. Still it feels a bit you and me not us.

Summerleaves · 12/07/2021 23:22

@Merryoldgoat

I think YABU.

I don’t really understand living as a family with supposedly aligned goals for your life and having such disparate finances.

It creates a power imbalance. You get to make the big decisions because you have the money. Even if you discuss it you being uncomfortable with the spend means it doesn’t happen.

Exactly.

In our relationship money has no merit or value attached other than what it contributes to all our lives.

Merryoldgoat · 12/07/2021 23:20

I think YABU.

I don’t really understand living as a family with supposedly aligned goals for your life and having such disparate finances.

It creates a power imbalance. You get to make the big decisions because you have the money. Even if you discuss it you being uncomfortable with the spend means it doesn’t happen.

Summerleaves · 12/07/2021 23:19

@NavigatingAdolescence

I'll never, ever understand married people who don't share finances.

Each to their own of course but I don't get why you'd get married if you felt like this.

Because civil partnerships weren’t available when we got married. It’s a legal arrangement, that’s all.

But what's the legal arrangement for if not sharing?
Swipe left for the next trending thread