Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to merge finances

110 replies

Whatsyoursismine · 12/07/2021 21:23

Something came up elsewhere and I’d be interested in views….

DH and I don’t merge finances. I earn approx 3x more. We have a joint account that we pay into in proportion to our earnings for mortgage, bills, DCs stuff etc…

I work longer hours. I work harder. He could work harder but just isn’t motivated too (which is fine). He would accept I do 50% of childcare and children related stuff. I actually do more, but perhaps we can assume its 50/50 for present purposes.

Some people seem to think our finances should be merged. AIBU to think they shouldn’t. Obviously would be very different if he did more childcare/sacrified his career etc. But that’s not the case.

Hard hat on. Interested in thoughts…

OP posts:
Lalanbaba · 13/07/2021 09:05

I'm confused. But you have merged finances! You have a joint mortgage, you pay the bills proportional to your wages. And I'm going to go and say that you will not go on holiday on your own with the kids because he can't afford it.
Or be buying Loewes bags if your partner would struggle to buy basic clothing.
You probably are saving more and expecting to have a better pension, which is totally acceptable if you are earning more.

TedMullins · 13/07/2021 08:51

Aside* not aisle

TedMullins · 13/07/2021 08:50

I and I’m sure many others would hate to have to ‘discuss and decide together’ before making an expensive purchase if I wanted to. It makes far more sense to keep the leftover money after bills are paid in separate accounts so nobody has to do this. It’s pretty obvious why OP saved and funded her mat leave isn’t it, for those being obtuse? Because she earns 3x more so if she didn’t save for it how much would her partner realistically be able to put aisle?

justawrinkleintime · 13/07/2021 08:50

@YANBU. You can do what you want in your own relationship. I am glad that my husband and I have enough trust, communication and compatibility to allow each other the freedom to keep our money separate and still be able to pay the bills and have a nice life Wink

CeeceeBloomingdale · 13/07/2021 08:48

People here don’t seem to understand the difference between joint accounts and shared finances. We have separate accounts but all the money is considered ours, it’s just stored in two places. We are still a partnership, have trust and will move money between accounts as and when needed, it’s just more practical on a day to day level knowing what you have available to spend. DH earns 4 times the amount I do, but he pays the lion share of the bills, we have similar spends left once the direct debits have come out. It’s worked for the last 28 years, can’t see any reason to change it.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 08:46

@Summerleaves

The thing is that shared finances in marriage are designed to protect the partner who stays at home with the children (in the vast majority of cases the woman). They are a way of protecting this partner and the children from destitution

This is what marriage itself is for.

Yes it is: but its not designed simply to iron out disparities in the partners' finances or to render one partner wholly dependent on the other.

Obviously in practice the outcome of marriage is a shared pool of assets so legally what's his is hers and vice versa.

But there is very sound logic for both partners maintaining control over their own income and assets.

The argument that keeps being made here is that if you have trust in someone (a slightly arbitrary concept anyway), you should automatically be prepared to hand over all financial autonomy.

In fact the basic principle should be about providing a financial safety net for the partner who is raising children. It isn't just a blanket financial parity for its own sake: that incentivises abuse and dependency.

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 08:42

@Whatsyoursismine

I don’t know if it makes a difference but when I took maternity leave, I funded that from my savings (plus statutory allowance - am self employed) and continued to pay bills etc in same ratio as if I was working.
Why on earth are you even married?
Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 08:41

@TECMH

I’ll be in similar circumstances except the only child will be mine who by then will be relatively financially independent but probably still at home for a while. My partner is of the view that all bills/savings come out of one account and are contributed to equally. But then the rest of our money remains our own - his rationale is he might want to buy himself something relatively expensive and doesn’t want to feel he’s doing this with my money (I’m the higher earner by about double), or feel he has to ask me. I understand that.
We don't begrudge eachother buying things for ourselves. There's no power play. We discuss and decide together.
sodthefootball · 13/07/2021 08:40

I don't disagree with the split as a concept, but you're married.

Better hope you don't get divorced...

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 08:39

The thing is that shared finances in marriage are designed to protect the partner who stays at home with the children (in the vast majority of cases the woman). They are a way of protecting this partner and the children from destitution

This is what marriage itself is for.

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 08:38

@Merryoldgoat

But anyone who says they "don't attach meaning to money" has lived a very charmed existence indeed and is at risk if they don't give this any thought.

I can tell you now nothing about my upbringing was charmed.

I grew up in poverty with a mother and her partner. She didn’t work and he was emotionally and financially abusive.

I attach meaning to money - it means my kids are well fed and clothed, that I’m not hungry.

Well done on taking my quote out of context.
Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 08:36

@TedMullins

You can’t 100% trust anyone. You just can’t, in the same way you can’t predict the future. You can no more guarantee that your marriage will last forever than you can guarantee you’ll make it to your 81st birthday or that you’ll win the lottery.
I can and I do My marriage is not perfect and it may not last but I chose a man who will be fair if we ever do split. He's a decent man, sorry you don't understand. I feel so sorry for anyone who is married and having to constantly look over their shoulder. Must be tiring.
Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 13/07/2021 08:30

Different arrangements clearly work for different people, but this is my perspective, (and for information I'm a man.)

I have typically earned significantly (3 to 10 times) more than DW.
All income in our house is joint income. To my mind when there is a major inequality of earnings, any other solution risks bad feelings (and could look like financial abuse). If the salary situation was reversed in our house that would make no difference to our financial arrangements.
@Whatsyoursismine, I don't think you have made any comment about your DH's view on the arrangement. Is he completely happy with the arrangement?

RosesAndHellebores · 13/07/2021 08:27

Married 30 years and had a prenup because when we married I earned more and had capital. He, however, had better prospects and within three years I had given up work and didn't work for 8 years.

We have never had a joint account. When I didn't work I bought what we needed and gave him an account at the end of the month. He never questioned a single penny. Expenses included: food, an occasional lunch, children's stuff, occasional clothes and hairdressing, dentist, etc. I did everything at home - he worked murderous hours.

When I went back to work part-time, I earnt £8k (started at the bottom again). He was a very high earner by then and paid for everything - my earnings increased significantly over 10 years - he still pays the bills.

We have never had a joint account. He has bought a couple of very very expensive things without consultation. I sometimes buy very expensive shoes and raise an eyebrow if he notices. I know roughly what he has; he knows roughly what I have; we both know where each others paperwork is in the event of a crisis. When the children were small he transferred a sizeable sum to an account of mine to keep us going for 6 months in the event that anything happened to him.

I have facilitated his career (MNet crime) but overall I think we have invested equally into our family - more my emotion and domestic work when the children were younger.

If men and women are equal what DH and I did in reverse shouldn't really be an issue if the man stays at home. What we did worked because dh always valued what I did on the home front and supported me when I went back to work albeit from a work life balance pov it had to be local because of the children and rarely could he step in if they were ill although if he could he did (surgeon/pilot genre but not that).

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 08:25

Shared finances only work if one party has sacrificed their career to support the other.

Exactly this. It's not an automatic perk of marriage.

For women in particular, it’s very often them who end up with the children to raise single handed if a relationship fails so to have a good buffer is important.

And this.

Also worth noting that it isn't just the risk of a partner cheating or leaving which is a consideration. There are multiple reasons why a good, strong marriage is enhanced by both parties having some financial autonomy. It just makes for a healthier, more grown-up mindset and better protection in the event of a worst-case scenario.

That's not to say people shouldn't eg share an account for bills or whatever.

But the idea that just because you trust someone you hand over total control to one another's finances strikes me as a wilful misinterpretation of what marriage is about.

Ratched · 13/07/2021 08:24

Hmm, we did have joint account and everything went into it, but it did not work for us.
DH has a completely different attitude to money than me and it caused a lot of friction.
We now have separate accounts and are much happier.
And we have been married for 40 years!

frazzledasarock · 13/07/2021 08:18

No in these circumstances where your DH has not sacrificed his career to support yours, and doesn’t do the bulk of the childcare/housework your financial set up makes sense.

Shared finances only work if one party has sacrificed their career to support the other.

If OP does the bulk of the childcare and earns more why would she be expected to pay more towards the household than her DH?

According to OP nothing is stopping her DH from pursuing a higher paid career he’s chosen not to. Neither party is going without and the child are provided for.

So nope I’d not merge finances under these circumstances either. What’s the point in it?

RandomLondoner · 13/07/2021 08:14

I'm not saying no-one should have joint finances, there are scenarios where there are real benefits and/or negligible risks. Usually ones where earnings are fairly equal, or total earnings are not much more than total outgoings.

Tumbleweed101 · 13/07/2021 08:13

Having been in a relationship where my ex was a spender and I’m a saver and who left me with all the debts and the children to raise when he left I think it’s incredibly wise to keep money separate. Put in to the house pot according to earnings but for spending/saving definitely separate.

For women in particular, it’s very often them who end up with the children to raise single handed if a relationship fails so to have a good buffer is important.

Aprilx · 13/07/2021 08:10

DH and i do not have a shared bank account, but that is pure laziness in that we haven’t bothered to organise it, we absolutely both consider our money as shared money.

If you want to manage your money as separate and are both happy with that then of course that is fine. But there seems to be some flawed thinking in that if you do this and have separate bank accounts that the money is not joint assets. It is.

RandomLondoner · 13/07/2021 08:09

It's perfectly possible to share financial contributions fairly without sharing control over all money.

Trusting someone is something that only makes sense if the benefits outweigh the risks. If I need to jump from the window of a burning building, I will trust the firefighters to catch me, because the alternative seems worse. If the building is not on fire, it doesn't matter how much I trust the firefighters, I'm not jumping. (Presumably in the latter case it's a training exercise...)

In the very unlikely even that I married someone with a lot more money than me, if they tried to give me unfettered access to their bank account, I would refuse and lecture them for doing so. That level of trust isn't necessary to achieve fair shared finances, therefore they should not do it, regardless of how low they believe the risk may be.

BillyWhozz · 13/07/2021 08:06

@Whatsyoursismine

Something came up elsewhere and I’d be interested in views….

DH and I don’t merge finances. I earn approx 3x more. We have a joint account that we pay into in proportion to our earnings for mortgage, bills, DCs stuff etc…

I work longer hours. I work harder. He could work harder but just isn’t motivated too (which is fine). He would accept I do 50% of childcare and children related stuff. I actually do more, but perhaps we can assume its 50/50 for present purposes.

Some people seem to think our finances should be merged. AIBU to think they shouldn’t. Obviously would be very different if he did more childcare/sacrified his career etc. But that’s not the case.

Hard hat on. Interested in thoughts…

It's hard to say really. On the face of it it's a massive mumsnet double standard but without knowing a bit more details (without specifics) it might be fine or it might not be.

If he's ticking along nicely with a bit of spare change a month that's fine. If he's walking barefoot to work because his shoes have fallen apart and he can't afford a car then not so much.

Him working less will get picked up but IMO that's not as relevant as some will make out unless he's slashed his hours since he married you.

BarkingUpTheWrongRoseBush · 13/07/2021 07:51

We’ve been married 10 years and don’t have a joint account. We earn about the same now, as I’ve caught up.

He’s got kids, was supporting them and ex wife when we met. A lot. E.g. tickets to fly them all back to the states in the holidays to see their relatives.

We own a house together, and finances aren’t an issue, we’re lucky in that.

We occasionally talk about getting a joint account but he got burnt by ex regularly emptying their account so while he knows I’m quite careful and wouldn’t do that psychologically he’s happier with it separate. I’m happy with it as it is. Feeling of independence that’s important to me.

I occasionally transfer him money if he’s paid something big and vice versa. But it mostly probably works out. E.g I pick up oil costs, he pays electric but just because that’s who sorted it out in the beginning.

Purple21 · 13/07/2021 07:45

Yeah doesn't make a difference to me either, we saved together before hand.

Merryoldgoat · 13/07/2021 07:43

@Whatsyoursismine

I don’t know if it makes a difference but when I took maternity leave, I funded that from my savings (plus statutory allowance - am self employed) and continued to pay bills etc in same ratio as if I was working.
Not to me tbh. I only got statutory and we worked out TOGETHER how much we needed to save and how to split money fairly.

I think it’s weird to find it entirely yourself - like it’s your decision only.

Swipe left for the next trending thread