Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to merge finances

110 replies

Whatsyoursismine · 12/07/2021 21:23

Something came up elsewhere and I’d be interested in views….

DH and I don’t merge finances. I earn approx 3x more. We have a joint account that we pay into in proportion to our earnings for mortgage, bills, DCs stuff etc…

I work longer hours. I work harder. He could work harder but just isn’t motivated too (which is fine). He would accept I do 50% of childcare and children related stuff. I actually do more, but perhaps we can assume its 50/50 for present purposes.

Some people seem to think our finances should be merged. AIBU to think they shouldn’t. Obviously would be very different if he did more childcare/sacrified his career etc. But that’s not the case.

Hard hat on. Interested in thoughts…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MarianneUnfaithful · 14/07/2021 17:22

If it ain’t broke…

All fine as long as there is no seep of resentment.

Are you fine with him not wanting to earn more? Does your spending power for hold and home improvement give you more of a day? Will you both have a good retirement plan or will his smaller pot (if that is the case) tue you to weekends in Eastbourne while you long for East Asia?

NanooCov · 14/07/2021 17:12

I'm in a very similar financial position (earn 3x more than DH) although he does only work 4 days (mutual decision - he looks after DS3 on his non working day). We split finances proportionate to our income to meet all household / family expenses but the rest is our own to do with as we like so I have more disposable income left over. Works for us.

CastawayQueen · 13/07/2021 22:48

@thepeopleversuswork

please stop spreading the rubbish that being a higher earner is gendered and a matter of luck

It's not rubbish. Being a high earner is not intrinsically gendered. But there's no escaping the fact that taking time out to raise children damages your earning capacity. And the fact that in the overwhelming majority of cases it is the woman who performs this role.

That comment was made in the context of 'luck' in relation to choosing professions.

Also presumably a lawyer returning to work while earning less than her 'male,never taken time off work' counterparts is still a higher earner because she chose to become a lawyer, rather than something else that makes less money?

CastawayQueen · 13/07/2021 22:46

@Summerleaves

women are just as capable of choosing highly paid professions as men

I never said they weren't.

Low paid jobs are not due to gender but because of supply/demand and profit generated.

Of course it's not always true that women earn less than men but if you haven't noticed that the traditionally 'female' jobs like nursing are paid less than the traditionally 'male' jobs of engineering you haven't been paying attention.

Why don't you compare nursing with an equivalent professions (that provides a one-to-one service and have medium barriers to entry) like plumbing, welding or joinery? Also all male dominated. Instead you compare it to a profession that is very well paid because of high barriers to entry. This isn't even counting the profit element of the job...

This is not a discussion about what services should be valued more - just pointing out that the reason is not female domination.

TECHMH · 13/07/2021 20:52

@NakedAttraction for us all household bills will be shared and we’ll have our joint social pot - holidays, eating out, pub etc. We’ll have a joint savings pot too. If one of us goes on holiday without the other, it will come from our own money. If I decide to buy a pricey handbag, it comes from my money. I will continue to support big expenses for my child from my own money though if he came on holiday with us, my chap would insist our joint fund paid for him too. He like to dabble on the stock market and he does this with his own funds, as our approach to that type of risk is different. But that doesn’t impact out joint security

mindutopia · 13/07/2021 20:49

I think that sounds fine. We do exactly what you do. We’re both very equal partners when it comes to the dc, though I do take some more time off with them as I have annual leave (Dh is self employed so no paid leave). But we both work hard, have similar life and financial goals and like having our own money.

Hankunamatata · 13/07/2021 20:49

Holidays we both save in an account

Hankunamatata · 13/07/2021 20:48

We don't pool finances however we try to be equal so contribution to bill account which covers literally every bill and household expense inc childrens things/lessons and savings etc is proportional to wage so I pay say 10% and dh pays 90%

NakedAttraction · 13/07/2021 20:43

I’m just always intrigued with how this stuff works in practice. Do you holiday alone or with friends for example because he can’t afford it? Are you building up a pot of savings that won’t be shared with him?

Genuinely interested. We don’t pool finances because we don’t really need to, we each pay for whatever, which I admit is a very privileged position to be in. It tends to work out that I pay for most stuff and OH does the saving/investing (in each of our names and for the kids, before anyone thinks he’s just saving for himself, he’s topped my pension up for me for example)

StrawberrySundayz · 13/07/2021 20:37

YANBU. I always think in a relationship you should each be splitting bills and costs 50/50. The general MN opinion seems to be the opposite of that. I just can’t understand how my partner could pay more and still see me as a equal.

TECHMH · 13/07/2021 20:36

Quite an assumption there @Summerleaves with your power play comment! Baffling!

If my chap wants to buy himself a £6k bike with his own spending money/savings he absolutely does not need to discuss it with me. That would be controlling of me in the extreme. I could do likewise and he wouldn’t bat an eye but things I’d purchase naturally cost less, so he feels better if he funds his own hobby. He knows I’m happy to share finances regardless. We met in our late 40’s, we’re both financially stable. Now in our 50’s we trust each other as you and your husband do but don’t feel the need to demonstrate that by sharing all our finances.

Liverbird77 · 13/07/2021 13:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 10:11

please stop spreading the rubbish that being a higher earner is gendered and a matter of luck

It's not rubbish. Being a high earner is not intrinsically gendered. But there's no escaping the fact that taking time out to raise children damages your earning capacity. And the fact that in the overwhelming majority of cases it is the woman who performs this role.

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 10:10

women are just as capable of choosing highly paid professions as men

I never said they weren't.

Low paid jobs are not due to gender but because of supply/demand and profit generated.

Of course it's not always true that women earn less than men but if you haven't noticed that the traditionally 'female' jobs like nursing are paid less than the traditionally 'male' jobs of engineering you haven't been paying attention.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 10:09

The issue for me is not the joint finances, it's that you're not on the same page. I mean, while you're working and looking after the children, what is he doing? It doesn't sound like a partnership at all.

that's an entirely fair point.

The big picture question for me is how to you create a financial structure for a partnership which allows for the massive fluctuations in income and in financial goals and aspirations which happens throughout the lifetime of a marriage.

As has been said (not least by me), marriage is mainly designed to support the person who is rendered financially vulnerable through their inability to work. So in this circumstance "family money" is entirely right and appropriate.

But crafting a financial plan for a marriage which could potentially last 50+ years and incorporate big changes in the partners' earning capacity needs something with a bit more fine-tuning. And I do think its really important that although you may have shared bank accounts etc, you both, if possible, have access to your own money.

I don't know what the perfect solution to this is btw: I just think the kneejerk "it should all be pooled" doesn't really handle it.

CastawayQueen · 13/07/2021 10:04

@Summerleaves

They already contribute more when they put into the joint pot in proportion of earnings.

This is the crux.

I don't see an arbitrary amount of money as 'contributing'.

I see time, emotional support, practical help, quality companionship as contributing.

How much someone earns is largely a matter of luck. Men are often in professions which pay better because society values men's 'contribution' more than women's. That doesn't mean women are worth less in real terms. So I reject the value association of money. Money does not equal worth to me. We are equal.

The discussion is about joint finances - therefore the word 'contributing' is in the context of money. Also while it's not relevant to the discussion please stop spreading the rubbish that being a higher earner is gendered and a matter of luck. It is , yes based on life circumstance (you will have a much easier time of it being from a middle class family who make you aware of options) but women are just as capable of choosing highly paid professions as men. Low paid jobs are not due to gender but because of supply/demand and profit generated. Again - once women have children etc there is also an equality issue but if women wanted to earn more there's nothing stopping them from becoming programmers, lawyers, accountants. It's not like men enter these because they're 'oh so fun' and they luuuurve doing them.
Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 09:52

And I've been on solo holidays and with friends which cost hundreds. Just let him know to make sure it didn't clash with his plans, not asking for permission just checking in.

TiredButDancing · 13/07/2021 09:52

The issue for me is not the joint finances, it's that you're not on the same page. I mean, while you're working and looking after the children, what is he doing? It doesn't sound like a partnership at all.

I think if a couple prefer to have proportional amounts paid to a joint account and they each keep their own cash to spend, that's fine if it works for them (it would never work for me). But I don't really understand it when the couple's overall lives are just so different to each other and it doesn't feel ike there's any sort of shared goal. It's so weird.

I earn 5x what DH does. He does far more childcare than me as his hours are based on the assumption that he'll only work when he isn't needed for childcare. He also takes on plenty of other tasks and responsibilities. We do share all money. But more importantly, we both feel like we're working together towards a shared objective - a nice life, happy and stable children etc.

cervixuser · 13/07/2021 09:51

I have never understood not sharing finances when you are married, have children and share your lives in so many ways. On MN I seem to be very much in the minority but not so much in the real world. When DH and I first got together - living together - 34 years ago, he wrote out his earnings and expenses and showed me what was left and said that was ours to share. Over the years our salaries have fluctuated but we have always shared.

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 09:50

Oh and we don't discuss and agree every personal purchase, just the really big ones.

Eg husband has a boat that cost thousands.

Would have been a bit miffed if he'd just bought it at the expense of a summer holiday but we discussed and agreed.

I wanted a new bathroom, would not have unilaterally signed off on it. Discussed and agreed.

PegasusReturns · 13/07/2021 09:48

We don't begrudge eachother buying things for ourselves. There's no power play. We discuss and decide together.

I don’t want to “decide together” how to spend my money, it’s mine and I want to spend it as I please.

I’ve been married 20 years and we’re both very happy with separate finances.

Summerleaves · 13/07/2021 09:47

They already contribute more when they put into the joint pot in proportion of earnings.

This is the crux.

I don't see an arbitrary amount of money as 'contributing'.

I see time, emotional support, practical help, quality companionship as contributing.

How much someone earns is largely a matter of luck. Men are often in professions which pay better because society values men's 'contribution' more than women's. That doesn't mean women are worth less in real terms. So I reject the value association of money. Money does not equal worth to me. We are equal.

CastawayQueen · 13/07/2021 09:41

@Summerleaves
But why should personal purchases be discussed and decided together?
In a situation where nobody has sacrificed anything to raise children - why is the partner entitled to all of the higher income earner's extra earnings? They already contribute more when they put into the joint pot in proportion of earnings.
Of course this depends on the income disparity : 30K vs 90K is very different from 15K vs 45K.
But generally speaking it doesn't matter where the money is kept.

If budgeting is done properly and X amount is needed to run the household/pay for holidays/savings/etc - then X goes into joint account(s) with proportional contribution from each partner.

It's then clear how much money is left for each partner to do with as they wish. Why does either partner need to justify how they spend this - it doesn't impact the family as it's extra? I'd find that very controlling.

thepeopleversuswork · 13/07/2021 09:11

I do think it would be interesting to have a straw poll: in how many scenarios where posters advocate totally pooled finances is the woman the breadwinner or the significantly higher earner?

thesugarbumfairy · 13/07/2021 09:07

You have to do what's right for your own family. I have friends with separate finances and I can't quite fathom it all, but it really doesn't matter what I think.

For us, it works best to have all the money going into a joint account. DH earns 3x my salary, however he is clueless with money (he's an accountant!)
He has literally no idea about household expenditure. I organise everything, do all household admin, holiday bookings, school payments etc and all payments come from this joint account.
I take a set amount each month and send it to my individual account. I use that for 'me' stuff, for my small business expenses (which is separate from my day job), for clothes, makeup, trips out with friends and so on. All large purchases are discussed before purchasing.

When we moved home 3 years ago, it was completely led by me. I just asked him to sign on the dotted line. He's so clueless, its just a little bit frightening, but it suits us doing it this way. He trusts that I don't have a pot squirreled away somewhere. Which I could do and he wouldn't notice...

Swipe left for the next trending thread