Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take a much younger lover?

241 replies

MadamePalm · 12/07/2021 20:38

Early 40s. Separated but not yet divorced. Two young DC.

I have absolutely no interest in another serious relationship at the moment. The thought of another man coming in and breaking my heart like ex DH did absolutely horrified me. However I do miss male company (and sex)

I have a young man (basically half my age) showing very strong interest in me. He's gorgeous, sweet, sexy and already ridiculously successful for someone so young. I'm really tempted to throw caution to the wind and have some fun. However all my friends are telling me to find someone closer to my own age. I've dated a few guys in their 40s recently and they've just done nothing for me.

Am I a terrible old perve? Should I just go for it? I feel so conflicted!

OP posts:
LobotomisedIceSkatingFan · 14/07/2021 08:46

I don't understand all this 'I have a son/nephew that age' claptrap. I don't use familial relationships as the reference point in these things because if I did I'd be constantly nauseated at the fact that my boyfriend is the same age as my brother (43).

WoolieLiberal · 14/07/2021 08:28

Ask yourself how you would feel if you had a daughter the age of the young man, and she decided to take a male lover who was your age.

If you would be OK with it, then that’s OK.

rantymcrantface66 · 14/07/2021 07:47

To be frank - ime it's more likely you're a fetish (older woman experience etc) or a bet.

This fetish is definitely a thing. Lots of young men on dating sites put a fake date of birth so they come up in the searches of older women then explain in their bio's that they are looking for older women. I see it more and more, I assume because of all the milf porn online

I don't think all the stuff people are posting warnings about matters to the OP, she isn't looking for a deep and meaningful relationship by the looks of things, she wants a fling.

Yet it's a problem that the men her own age are commitment phobes?

rantymcrantface66 · 14/07/2021 07:32

Sorry no I couldn't do it. I'm 41 and my nephews are that age and have friends with dc that age both I know would be pretty horrified if they were dating someone old enough to be their mum. Just because he's making lots of money doesn't mean he's any more mature. People will probably assume you're taking advantage and that his wealth is a contributing factor. All a bit icky.

StarlightLady · 14/07/2021 06:15

@CatAndHisKit - Taking a younger lover actually feels like taking a tonic! 💥

OP - get on with it! Get those knickers off! 😉

ViciousJackdaw · 14/07/2021 00:55

Oh just shag him OP, you do not need anyone's permission. Just make sure you don't get hurt and for crying out loud, use a johnny.

CatAndHisKit · 13/07/2021 21:28

I like the old term 'take a lover' Grin.

To me it conjures up a picture of a bored Victorian woman 'taking a tonic' (or a happy pill)!
Bit consumerist but flings are like that.

WeatherSystems · 13/07/2021 17:34

[quote StarlightLady]@WeatherSystems - lt wasn’t me was it? 🤫[/quote]
Lucky you if it was Wink

TheWernethWife · 13/07/2021 17:13

I'm 15 years older than my partner. Always gone for younger ones.

Go for it and enjoy.

Blackhawkdown2020 · 13/07/2021 17:08

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

StarlightLady · 13/07/2021 16:31

@WeatherSystems - lt wasn’t me was it? 🤫

IcedPurple · 13/07/2021 15:59

If it's just a fling - in other words just sex - and you have no expectations other than some 'fun' then I don't see the issue. It's unlikely to work out long term but if that's not what you're looking for then go for it. Yes, he's much younger but he's also an adult.

WeatherSystems · 13/07/2021 15:54

@ZoinksRun

I used to work with two very good looking guys in their twenties. You'd be surprised what younger men actually find attractive if they're being honest. They couldn't really care less about the 20 year olds with their huge eyelashes who were constantly on their phone. It was the mums on the school run, in their yoga gear, looking a bit harassed, the ones in their work uniform who had just finished a 10 hour shift, the older ladies who worked in the local estate agents. Beauty isn't confined to an age bracket. One of them left his university aged girlfriend for an older woman who had two kids and was recently divorced. They're literally the happiest couple I have ever met. He was 25 and she was ten years older. The heart wants what it wants!
DH has always been into older women. I’m only a few years older so not really an ‘older woman’ in any sense of the word, but he’d far rather date or sleep with a 40 something then a 20 something woman. One of his enjoyable memories is getting off with a woman 20yr his senior at a house party before we met! 🤣
proopher · 13/07/2021 15:02

I don't think all the stuff people are posting warnings about matters to the OP, she isn't looking for a deep and meaningful relationship by the looks of things, she wants a fling.

'He just wants you for a shag' it sounds like that's exactly what OP wants as well!

LuxOlente · 13/07/2021 13:11

Go for it. Bit baffled anyone would say no, really. 21 isn't an infant and it's not like you're going to drag him down the aisle.

God forbid some men are attracted to women not just for their looks, but for their maturity, confidence, competence, intellect and success.

BarefootHippieChick · 13/07/2021 13:05

I'd say go for it. It's just a fling. Interesting, a lot of young guys prefer older women because most of the time they've already done the marriage and kids bit and are just looking for fun, plus when women get to their 40s they tend to be more comfortable in their bodies which can be very sexy. Women in their 20s are often looking for the whole ring/marriage/kids thing, which most men aren't at that age.

(As told to me by some twenty something men i know 😁)

GrumpyTerrier · 13/07/2021 10:54

Quite a few jealous and judgmental responses here.

OP just go for it. He is an adult and you are an adult. As someone also in early 40s I can confirm that younger men do indeed fancy older women and it can be great.

Also there is nothing wrong with you for usually liking younger guys. If it was for older guys no one would care.

Take opportunities. Live your life and have a whale of a time.

ChargingBuck · 13/07/2021 10:46

@SomeKindOfFloppyWeirdo

Take him? Where? You’re low on gas and he’ll need a jacket!

I say no, purely because people your age will know where that quote comes from, and people his age won’t. I’m not sure that’s something I could overcome Grin

Funnily enough, my much-younger fling did WAY better on cultural references from my era, than I did on his.

OP, if this is any help to you - he was 30, & was 51.
We had a pretty-much perfect 18 month relationship.

We'd been acquaintances through a larger friendship group. He eventually confessed he'd been holding a candle for me for years, he was also smart, not work-shy, veeeeery attractive, funny, kind & honest.

We were careful of each other's feelings, & he was exceptionally patient while I summoned up the courage to embark on our fling. We discussed the importance of maintaining the friendship above the fucking, to respect each other & the wider group by not falling out with each other, & to never, never, take the idiotic step of falling in love.

I finished it 18 months in, because I didn't want to live with him, but he had not yet had that live-together experience. I wanted him to be able to have that, rather than slide inexorably into suddenly being a 40-year old carer propping up a 61-year old (with a 50% chance of a life-altering disease. NOT something I'd want to inflict on a human I care about).

We're still friends.
He has a younger (than him! by about 8 years?) live-in g/f now, & I'm happy for him.

It took some guts to finish it, but it was the right thing to do.
Just make sure you protect yourself emotionally OP, & him, & ensure he's on the same page.

ChargingBuck · 13/07/2021 10:26

@MadamePalm

So if he's too young then where the fuck do I find a man my own age who isn't either bitter, a commitment phone, tight with money, or just obsessed with talking about themselves? Because I'm seriously struggling when I date men in their 40s.

Maybe it's true that all the good ones are taken by then?

Get off the 'net & go & shag the man FFS.

Nobody here is going to be in bed with you, don't let 'em into your head either.

ChargingBuck · 13/07/2021 10:24

@SmileyClare

Well it sounds like you've made your mind up already Op. I'm not sure why you keep mentioning his successful business and him being "well off" though. You just want him for a sex buddy right?

Taking a younger lover is such an odd old fashioned term though. Like something out of a Mills and Boon novel Grin

Because for many people, fancying someone starts with their character, & OP admires his drive & success?

And there doesn't have to be a "just" about wanting a sex buddy. That has an implication of non-choosiness that I don't think exists for the OP.
It's possible to want a fling without losing all powers of discrimination.

With you on the Mills & Boon comment tho' ... it's a bit cringeworthy ... especially the "taking" part ...

ZoinksRun · 13/07/2021 10:21

I used to work with two very good looking guys in their twenties. You'd be surprised what younger men actually find attractive if they're being honest. They couldn't really care less about the 20 year olds with their huge eyelashes who were constantly on their phone. It was the mums on the school run, in their yoga gear, looking a bit harassed, the ones in their work uniform who had just finished a 10 hour shift, the older ladies who worked in the local estate agents. Beauty isn't confined to an age bracket.
One of them left his university aged girlfriend for an older woman who had two kids and was recently divorced. They're literally the happiest couple I have ever met. He was 25 and she was ten years older. The heart wants what it wants!

ChargingBuck · 13/07/2021 10:19

@WeatheringStorms22

He's a gorgeous, Well off young guy

So why isn't this gorgeous successful 23 year old finding a gorgeous, free, 23 year old for his fling?

Seriously, dig a little deeper op.

Seriously, don't.

OP doesn't want anything deep, so why would she 'dig deeper'?

The guy is probably more focused on his business, at this time in his life, than he is in establishing a LTR.

And your assumption that a 40-something woman is somehow 'lesser' fling material than a 23 year old is highly insulting to the OP, & a specimen sample of ageist misogyny.

ChargingBuck · 13/07/2021 10:12

@DrWankincense

The rule is half your age plus seven. And I think that works well in general. In early 40s I could just about see 27, 28 year old. But 23? It's a no for me, a bit of a step too far, sorry.
Nothing like a bit of arbitrary rule-obeying & society-wide finger wagging to get the motors running is there? Phwoar! (Not.)

Some of the responses here are so ridiculous.
Two consenting adults, what's the problem?

Dr Wankincence, I am in awe at your name. Star
But wtf is the relevance to OP that you would not shag her proposed paramour? As far as we know, you haven't been asked to!

sansucre · 13/07/2021 10:07

Go for it OP. Who cares what others think, it what you want that matters.

I have never really fancied men my own age or those who are older than me, so have mostly dated younger men. This one sounds like he's got his head screwed on given he's successful and owns his business, so you can be assured that he's not looking for financial support from you.

Not all younger men fetishise older women. Some just relish the fact older women are more confident and secure in themselves.

ChargingBuck · 13/07/2021 10:04

@chickenyhead

I'm sorry, if this was a man suggesting this with a young girl, he'd be slaughtered.

What is it you have in common?

You are at different life stages.

Good luck meeting the family

23 years old is not a "girl". 23 years old is not a "boy". Especially not this one, who is smart, successful, & self-reliant.

& what's with your judgemental crowing "good luck meeting the family"?

Why TF would OP be meeting his family?
I don't think you understand how respectful, sex-&-company-only relationships function.

Life stages are irrelevant, as they are not looking to share lives.
Other family members are irrelevant, as they are looking to shag each other, not their relatives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread