Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that in the future obesity will be a mental illness

180 replies

postitgirl · 12/07/2021 19:18

ok , bear with me....
I've been watching a few programmes about anorexia, I don't know why, they've just 'popped up' on netflix and amazon, and it's so interesting how even though people with anorexia are literally starving themselves, they still don't eat. So I started thinking, I've been trying to lose weight for years and year and years, and it's so bloody hard, because there is a thing in my brain that equates pleasure with over-eating crap. I go on a diet, and my willpower lasts for a few days, if I'm lucky, and then this overwhelming urge to break the diet, to binge, to eat chocolate and all the bad things, not just a small square of chocolate, like a bar, plus ice-cream etc etc. Any of us who struggle know what i'ts like. And it's getting worse as I get older. I'm becoming more attached to that feeling of 'release' when I do overeat... I'ts like a stress reliever to my brain - I'm suddenly a nicer person to my kids, I feel chilled, I feel satisfied, I feel happy, but of course i'ts a vicious cycle of self-hatred etc etc.
So it just occurred to me that in the future, maybe the treatment for obesity will be similar to that of anorexia, with the blame being taken out of the equation, that it will be treated literally as a mental disease - a disease where your mind is taken over, in a similar way to the way anorexia takes over. just the way some of the young girls were talking about how it was the "anorexia talking" even thuogh they knew they were making themselves ill, and could even die, the anorexia wouldn't let them eat.
Just as someone who has struggled mentally with my weight for all these years - i'ts like the "fat" talking. Cos when I'm "sane" of course I want to stop doing it, I want to get fit, and slim etc etc. And I know what I should be eating and what I shouldnt I could probably get a degree in nutrition at this stage I've done so much research on what I should eat and not eat.
What do you all think - can anyone relate.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock · 12/07/2021 21:54

I think the problem with things like OA is that many people lack the emotionally literacy / are unable to talk honestly about their eating habits. Weight and food intake has become so tied up in moral concepts of greed, laziness, selfishness.
If alcoholics and drug addicts are able to manage to lay it all out among similar people who have an understanding of their situation, there is no shame in aa/na/oa only support.
Your post would put people off and unless they can afford private rehabilitation and one 2 one therapy its the best option.
I think it is an addiction, addiction brings on mh issues.
No-one with a peaceful happy mind self harms through substance destroying their loved ones.
Doctors should be referring patients to support groups that deal with the willpower and emotional side not low calorie diets.
If you're an addict you're an addict whatever the vice.

FastFood · 12/07/2021 21:46

I don't think its necessarily true.
Obesity isn't just a mental health issue, it's also a by-product of food industry, advertising and more.
How come an orange juice is considered healthy when its nothing but sugar?
How come food industry get away by claiming that cereals are perfectly suitable for a breakfast?

A lot of kids are overweight now, not because of mental health, but because of processed food laced with sugar, and constant snacking culture.

We can't just shrug it off by saying "ha...that's poor mental health".

SourAppleChew · 12/07/2021 21:42

Whilst I think there’s a huge psychological element, I think it’s more than that.

I say this because previous generations have endured much greater trauma than us yet largely remained slim. For example, think how many women lost partners/sons/brothers/fathers in the world wars. How many men experienced the horrors of trench warfare. Feet rotting off from trench foot whilst mortars exploded around them, and having to scoop up the flesh and dismembered limbs of their friends. And that’s before we even get to the blackout and bombing raids - pretty bad even without all the above if you reflect on how our society has reacted to lockdown etc.

And then there’s the aftermath. Men coming home a shadow of their former selves with PTSD and their partners having to live with this. All this trauma and yet they didn’t turn to the bakery/sweet shop for relief. I think a lot has to do the availability of crap food, the normalisation of fatness, and hugely reduced physical activity. I say this as somebody with ADHD who can eat shedloads and was almost obese before I took up lifting weights 3x a week and tracking calories.

AllWashedOut · 12/07/2021 21:33

This debate reminds me very much of the opioid debate in the States. Is the epidemic of addiction caused by the influx of easily obtainable drugs or the wide-open arms of the users that welcome it? Surely living in a healthy society based on community and connection is a great preventative to addiction in a population? This is what I believe. You need the drugs (ultraprocessed food) to satiate the desire (to feel good) but ultimately with no desire the drugs are harmless.

therocinante · 12/07/2021 21:32

@DazzlePaintedBattlePants

I don’t disagree that there are some (many?) people for whom obesity has its roots in mental ill health, but I reckon there are far more people for whom being overweight is just a direct consequence of it being so damn easy to consume more calories than you need. Not everything is a mental health issue.

Morning break used to be a cup of tea and a biscuit, now it’s a latte and a croissant. Lifestyles have changed so much since the 1970s and it’s never been easier to eat crap and be as inactive as possible. Hell, you don’t even have to walk to the chippie, Just Eat will deliver your junk food to your front door.

I do think you're right. Lots of people are overweight because it has never been easier to be overweight (or harder not to be), especially in cultures like ours.

I do also think that obesity can be caused by mental illness - as I said upthread I was diagnosed with BED, I eat compulsively and excessively. For me it's not making the unhealthy choice at lunchtime every day because Maccies is easier than making a salad, it's eating 4 packets of biscuits in the evening because sugar gives my brain a tiny dopamine hit and then the resulting shame and self-hatred leads me into a spiral of eating more to make me feel 'good' that lasts about as long as the mouthful does.

It's a bit like how recurrent headaches could be because you're always forgetting to drink enough water or it could be a symptom of a serious illness - the outcome looks the same on the surface, but the cause is very different.

ChubbyLittleManInACampervan · 12/07/2021 21:31

Anorexia is a mental illness, my niece is currently sectioned and tube-fed, under psychiatric care

Being obese is very common, most humans overeat to some extent, if they can afford to, and obesity is not a mental illness IMO and very different from anorexia.

The majority of the U.K. is struggling with weight, being either overweight or obese.

It’s the new “normal” in a sense

Not something that needs psychiatric intervention

AllWashedOut · 12/07/2021 21:26

100% agree with trauma-centred treatments from a previous poster. Any and all addictions are rooted in trauma and as such are mental healthy issues. I come from a family with many obese members and I had an eating disorder so this an area I've thought about very deeply. Sadly the MH side is so often played down by society. Phrases such as 'I'm not that bad', or ' I feel OK so it must be something else'. People are very reluctant to believe something like overeating is an addiction in response to a deep-rooted health issue for which trauma therapy is the best treatment. Why? I still don't understand. Perhaps because they think addicts have needles in their arms and they secretly despise them.

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 12/07/2021 21:22

I don’t disagree that there are some (many?) people for whom obesity has its roots in mental ill health, but I reckon there are far more people for whom being overweight is just a direct consequence of it being so damn easy to consume more calories than you need. Not everything is a mental health issue.

Morning break used to be a cup of tea and a biscuit, now it’s a latte and a croissant. Lifestyles have changed so much since the 1970s and it’s never been easier to eat crap and be as inactive as possible. Hell, you don’t even have to walk to the chippie, Just Eat will deliver your junk food to your front door.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/07/2021 21:14

I think it already is 🤷‍♀️

jebediahrankin · 12/07/2021 21:13

@postitgirl

ok , bear with me.... I've been watching a few programmes about anorexia, I don't know why, they've just 'popped up' on netflix and amazon, and it's so interesting how even though people with anorexia are literally starving themselves, they still don't eat. So I started thinking, I've been trying to lose weight for years and year and years, and it's so bloody hard, because there is a thing in my brain that equates pleasure with over-eating crap. I go on a diet, and my willpower lasts for a few days, if I'm lucky, and then this overwhelming urge to break the diet, to binge, to eat chocolate and all the bad things, not just a small square of chocolate, like a bar, plus ice-cream etc etc. Any of us who struggle know what i'ts like. And it's getting worse as I get older. I'm becoming more attached to that feeling of 'release' when I do overeat... I'ts like a stress reliever to my brain - I'm suddenly a nicer person to my kids, I feel chilled, I feel satisfied, I feel happy, but of course i'ts a vicious cycle of self-hatred etc etc. So it just occurred to me that in the future, maybe the treatment for obesity will be similar to that of anorexia, with the blame being taken out of the equation, that it will be treated literally as a mental disease - a disease where your mind is taken over, in a similar way to the way anorexia takes over. just the way some of the young girls were talking about how it was the "anorexia talking" even thuogh they knew they were making themselves ill, and could even die, the anorexia wouldn't let them eat. Just as someone who has struggled mentally with my weight for all these years - i'ts like the "fat" talking. Cos when I'm "sane" of course I want to stop doing it, I want to get fit, and slim etc etc. And I know what I should be eating and what I shouldnt I could probably get a degree in nutrition at this stage I've done so much research on what I should eat and not eat. What do you all think - can anyone relate.
A mental illness isn't just something "abnormal". It's also something combined with emotional/psychological distress. Being obese doesn't automatically cause distress.

EDs often come from trauma or are a symptom of trauma.

babyblues21 · 12/07/2021 21:04

And that's not to say I disagree that there may be a mental illness component to some aspects of over eating, for some people. But I take issue with the false comparison with anorexia.

babyblues21 · 12/07/2021 21:02

I believe anorexia is very different because fundamentally at its core, the sufferer has a very distorted body image and believes (wrongly) that they are overweight and therefore must restrict their dietary intake to an extreme level. People with this condition look in the mirror and believe they see an overweight person looking back at them, so they continue to restrict their eating further and further. People with obesity do not generally speaking overeat because of a fundamental issue with their body image. That's the difference between the two; so we cannot simply view obesity as the opposite disorder to anorexia. It makes no sense.

Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 12/07/2021 21:01

I went to a coffee shop today with my mum....none of the cake looked amazing but they had coffee cake and l had a slice even though it didn't look that great and was quite dry.
No idea why my rational brain made that bad choice because it was an absolute waste of calories and money.

MrsPsmalls · 12/07/2021 20:55

No definitely not. Nhs is underfunded. Mental health services are the most underfunded. You can be actively trying to kill yourself and still find no treatment available. No way will mental health services be able to fund anything other than crisis work in the future, so not a hope for long-term projects like obesity. Privately funded maybe, but never on the nhs.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 12/07/2021 20:52

If you are right op then at least 40% of adults are suffering from this mental illness right now. I've recently been away from my home town (in the wealthy south east) and was amazed to see the number of very overweight people around. My dh commented on it independently of me - he said "tbh the normal weight people are in the minority" and he was spot on. I'm not sure it is always helpful to see it as a mental illness?

MareofBeasttown · 12/07/2021 20:51

I am just uncomfortable with the pathologising of everything as a mental health issue.

seasonalremarks · 12/07/2021 20:51

But the French don't have a problem either. I do think our genetics and UPFs are more of a factor tbh.

PaulaPetunia · 12/07/2021 20:50

@Couchbettato I find that so odd.
It seems obvious to me that I really don't want certain foods in my house.

GrolliffetheDragon · 12/07/2021 20:47

Why is this trauma or unmet emotional needs not seen in Japan, for instance? I don't intend this to sound goady. Surely the British diet has something to do with this.

Mental distress can be expressed differently in different cultures.

PaperMonster · 12/07/2021 20:46

When my SIL was in ED hospital, there were obese patients there. I assume due to Binge Eating Disorders. There were very few of them, it was mostly anorexia patients.

MareofBeasttown · 12/07/2021 20:43

@Totallydefeated

Interesting. I think I agree with @AnneLovesGilbert. 2/3rds of adults in the UK can't have a mental illneSs

Depends how you define it. That proportion of people could easily be suffering from trauma/lack impulse control/have unmet emotional needs/be self-medicating, etc. These things are incredibly common. How many of us were brought up in a way that taught us to perfectly regulate our emotions, for example? Not many!!

Why is this trauma or unmet emotional needs not seen in Japan, for instance? I don't intend this to sound goady. Surely the British diet has something to do with this.
seasonalremarks · 12/07/2021 20:42

I think it's more likely it'll be considered a hormonal issue triggered by a combination of genetics and a modern western (ultraprocessed) diet.

Yes I think this is an accurate explanation

doesparentingsuck · 12/07/2021 20:37

@ComtesseDeSpair such a good point about women being in denial, however men and women irrespective of how open are about it both sexes still don't seem to be fixing the issue. And I believe it is mental health why people get obese. They are unhappy in their lives so full it with food what they believe to be happiness. It's a coping mechanism

TheRebelle · 12/07/2021 20:37

I think there’s certainly a psychological element to it, I grew up with parents who were obsessed with healthy eating and were very strict so I literally never had white bread, sweets, fast food or soft drinks growing up, I remember once buying some sweets on the way home from school when I was about 13 and when my mum found out she confiscated them and her and my dad lectured me about how I wasn’t allowed them and they were really disappointed in me.

Those are the foods I now crave and eat huge quantities of, because in my mind I don’t know when I’ll get them again, even though I know I can have them any time I want.

Ginlovingmumof4 · 12/07/2021 20:35

I agree that both anorexia and binge eating are eating disorders: they are both forms of disordered eating. Two of my DD have suffered from anorexia and have described the inability to fight this demon. It’s a mental illness that regresses but doesn’t disappear. I can see how binge eating could be the same.

Swipe left for the next trending thread