Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that in the future obesity will be a mental illness

180 replies

postitgirl · 12/07/2021 19:18

ok , bear with me....
I've been watching a few programmes about anorexia, I don't know why, they've just 'popped up' on netflix and amazon, and it's so interesting how even though people with anorexia are literally starving themselves, they still don't eat. So I started thinking, I've been trying to lose weight for years and year and years, and it's so bloody hard, because there is a thing in my brain that equates pleasure with over-eating crap. I go on a diet, and my willpower lasts for a few days, if I'm lucky, and then this overwhelming urge to break the diet, to binge, to eat chocolate and all the bad things, not just a small square of chocolate, like a bar, plus ice-cream etc etc. Any of us who struggle know what i'ts like. And it's getting worse as I get older. I'm becoming more attached to that feeling of 'release' when I do overeat... I'ts like a stress reliever to my brain - I'm suddenly a nicer person to my kids, I feel chilled, I feel satisfied, I feel happy, but of course i'ts a vicious cycle of self-hatred etc etc.
So it just occurred to me that in the future, maybe the treatment for obesity will be similar to that of anorexia, with the blame being taken out of the equation, that it will be treated literally as a mental disease - a disease where your mind is taken over, in a similar way to the way anorexia takes over. just the way some of the young girls were talking about how it was the "anorexia talking" even thuogh they knew they were making themselves ill, and could even die, the anorexia wouldn't let them eat.
Just as someone who has struggled mentally with my weight for all these years - i'ts like the "fat" talking. Cos when I'm "sane" of course I want to stop doing it, I want to get fit, and slim etc etc. And I know what I should be eating and what I shouldnt I could probably get a degree in nutrition at this stage I've done so much research on what I should eat and not eat.
What do you all think - can anyone relate.

OP posts:
habibibibi · 14/07/2021 06:23

@babyblues21

*I took take issue with the assumption that Anorexia is due to body image. I get so tired of this assumption. * It's not an assumption, it's based on my many years of clinical experience working with individuals with mental illness. And a PhD.
Anorexia is reinforced by body images in society and makes recovery more difficult. It is not caused by them. Anorexia is a biological genetic disease. That is the latest research If it were due to body image, how can you explain the genetic component? The fact that identical twins have a higher likelihood of both having anorexia compared with fraternal twins? Why is refeeding the therapy of choice for anorexia (aka the Maudsley approach or FBT) rather than trying to address body image?
Scr1bblyGum · 14/07/2021 06:20

Cahms don’t rely on BMI. It’s in the NICE guidelines I think.My dd has been hospitalised several times and has a lot of support from cahms. Pretty much all they have to throw at it. Her BMI hasn’t ever been horrendous and they’ve carried on treating her whatever ever her wfh is.

What has been a far bigger issue is the lack of resources and expertise re autism. There is a link between autism and anorexia for a section of patients.

habibibibi · 14/07/2021 06:19

@EmeraldShamrock

Anorexia isn't about food or losing weight to get slim if it a controlling disorder. Aneroxia is a loss of control when you can't get a grip on anything through MH issues food becomes your weapon. I was never fat before I was restricting food it was never about my weight. The warped power you now have over loved ones reinforced the need for this control eventually your stomach closes. It has similar secrets hiding your body shape. Comments on some teenagers weight won't cause aneroxia if they are otherwise NT. I know with my friend she just hasn't got motivation and loves takeaways and sugary foods, wine. She has a 3 y.o on reins because she can't keep up with her, It upsets her a lot but unless she makes a change it'll get harder.
Anorexia is a genetic biological brain disorder, triggered by weight loss for whatever reason.

By its nature, it's a controlling disorder but it is not caused by any lack of control in a person's life. My DD developed anorexia out of the blue, nothing to do with controlling her life. In fact, it causes you to be out of control and controlled by your disorder.

Oysterbabe · 14/07/2021 06:15

I don't doubt that mental health issues play a part for many obese people but I don't think it's the case for the majority. There's a lot of factors in play; a sedentary lifestyle, the convenience of cheap, processed food when you're very busy, aggressive marketing, lack of education etc. What's interesting is obesity rates vary a lot by area. When people talk about 2/3rds it sounds unbelievable. If I think of the parents I see at school drop off I think there's 1 overweight mum out of the 30 in DD's class.

habibibibi · 14/07/2021 06:10

@WindyWindsor

Being very underweight or overweight is not a mental illness or eating disorder in itself.

But these things can however be symptoms and complications from severe and untreated eating disorders. It also may not be caused by an eating disorder at all.

For example, anorexia is a mental illness, it's not being skeletal thin. Being very underweight is a complication of untreated severe anorexia.

There's a lot of ignorance around surrounding stuff like this even with doctors. If you're not very underweight then the treatment for anorexia is mostly non existent. Apparently the illness needs to leave you at deaths door before anyone will do anything about it.

I have a friend suffering from anorexia who is classed as obese. Some may say, well you can't be overweight and suffering from anorexia. Of course you can! She's disabled and is not able to exercise. She is plagued everyday by awful thoughts about her weight has in the past restricted food massively because of this. At some point she was living off water and one meal every other day and tracking her weight religiously. This is anorexia. And it took a giant fight for her to get therapy/treatment for it.

I agree completely that eating disorders, including binge eating, can lead to things like obesity. It's just beyond frustrating that you have to "look" like you have an eating disorder before people take it seriously. If only this could be recognised and treated earlier in life and not have to wait a decade before our bodies face the consequence of mental health issues.

In my opinion the whole attitude to EDs as a whole needs to change. This includes both those with EDs that lead them to lose weight and gain weight.

This is so true about BMI and Anorexia. But that's really in the UK. We had a different experience in another country where my DD was referred within weeks of developing anorexic behaviour, before she was even officially underweight. The longer you wait to intervene with anorexia, the harder the recovery. Our road was hard and long enough and it fills me with dread to think what would have happened if we'd have been in the UK dealing with GPs and CAMHS refusign to do anything based solely on BMI.
habibibibi · 14/07/2021 06:08

Anorexia is a biological and genetic brain disease and has appeared throughout history.

It's different to bulimia and compulsive over-eating which are more environmentally mediated. Therapy doesn't help with anorexia until weight restored, only feedng. Very different to the other EDs.

Of course not all obesity is a sign of mental illness. It might be genetics and how we respond to our obescogenic environment (really, the question is why aren't we all fat in developed countries?!) and, obviously, compulsive overeating is an eating disorder. But it's certainly far from all.

KindnessMyFriends · 14/07/2021 04:51

Overweight and obese people can be incredibly strong willed and disciplined in other areas of life; finances, work ethic, deadlines, parenting. Will power is nothing to do with obesity. It's a complex issue but mental health, obesogenic environments, malnourishment, genes, gut biome, hormones are all areas of research providing more and more useful information. I speak as someone who spent 56 years overweight/obese and the last 4 years at a healthy bmi.

SourAppleChew · 14/07/2021 04:04

One thing I notice about a lot of overweight people is that they believe they're committed to losing weight because they spend a lot of time thinking about it and talking about it. However, this isn't the same as actually going to gym of exercising. It might seem like an obvious statement but IME it's often accurate.

WindyWindsor · 13/07/2021 12:36

Being very underweight or overweight is not a mental illness or eating disorder in itself.

But these things can however be symptoms and complications from severe and untreated eating disorders. It also may not be caused by an eating disorder at all.

For example, anorexia is a mental illness, it's not being skeletal thin. Being very underweight is a complication of untreated severe anorexia.

There's a lot of ignorance around surrounding stuff like this even with doctors. If you're not very underweight then the treatment for anorexia is mostly non existent. Apparently the illness needs to leave you at deaths door before anyone will do anything about it.

I have a friend suffering from anorexia who is classed as obese. Some may say, well you can't be overweight and suffering from anorexia. Of course you can! She's disabled and is not able to exercise. She is plagued everyday by awful thoughts about her weight has in the past restricted food massively because of this. At some point she was living off water and one meal every other day and tracking her weight religiously. This is anorexia. And it took a giant fight for her to get therapy/treatment for it.

I agree completely that eating disorders, including binge eating, can lead to things like obesity. It's just beyond frustrating that you have to "look" like you have an eating disorder before people take it seriously. If only this could be recognised and treated earlier in life and not have to wait a decade before our bodies face the consequence of mental health issues.

In my opinion the whole attitude to EDs as a whole needs to change. This includes both those with EDs that lead them to lose weight and gain weight.

vivainsomnia · 13/07/2021 11:40

l totally disagree. You say it yourself OP, the issue is a lack of willpower. This is completely different to Anorexia which has nothing to do with willpower. the process that stops them from eating is much more complex and deeply rooted.

I totally get where you are coming from because I, like a vast section of our society, struggle with resisting temptation and have fallen into bad habits. That's a sign of social poor health, not mental health. Sadly, we are much less resilient and being so has become much more socially acceptable.

Of course, some obesity is a result of a mental illness, undoubtedly, but it doesn't make obesity one by its virtue. If overweight/obese people were offered half of their income for 5 years to lose the weight and keep it, most would manage it. Most Anorexic wouldn't.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 13/07/2021 11:34

I am obese but have very good mental health. Have had a few bouts of anxiety in my time but my weight didn't change then at all. I am obese because I have gained about a pound in weight every year for the last 30 years.

I don't binge, I don't noticeably overeat, I probably eat a lot less than the average person as I am short and sedentary and stick to two meals per day.

Being obese is easily done!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 13/07/2021 11:34

In some cases it is a manifestation of MH issues. Not all though. I went from normal to morbidly obese, now I am just bog standard obese. It wasn't MH issues. If it was for me labeled as MH issues I don't think I would ever start losing weight. Already the "oh well, maybe I am addicted to x foods" was a set back. I was just lazy and o ereating bit by bit while swimming in denial.

Cocomarine · 13/07/2021 11:27

@MoaningMel

I also don’t think it’s particularly helpful to pathologise the mental health of a massive section of the population, when actually it’s the environment they live in that is the problem.
Absolutely this.

I think it’s well recognised that some factors in obesity are linked to mental health. A side effect of MH disorders, or their medication, or in some cases entirely an MH issue in its own right. This is not a new thing at all, it is already well recognised.

However, there are plenty of people who are “just fat”.
From their environment - it’s harder for some people to be a healthy weight if they’re surrounded by processed food and they’ve working shifts that screw with their bodies, for example.
There are people who are just a bit overweight who are surrounded by others who are too, so that they simply don’t even realise they’re not a healthy weight.
But there are also people who are fat because they choose to eat too much, usually unhealthily. Sometimes, it really is as simple as people choosing the doughnut every day instead of once a week - and pathologising that choice isn’t helpful.

MoaningMel · 13/07/2021 11:06

I also don’t think it’s particularly helpful to pathologise the mental health of a massive section of the population, when actually it’s the environment they live in that is the problem.

MoaningMel · 13/07/2021 11:04

It may be related to mental illness for some people, but for most of the population who are overweight or obese it is a normal response to an obesogenic environment. And a lot of people do not realise what a healthy diet looks like, partly because a lot of crap is marketed as healthy (eg baby food packed with (natural) sugar)

MyDcAreMarvel · 13/07/2021 10:43

I don’t agree I know several people who are obese due to health conditions and medication. One very close relative eats 800 calories a day as a maintenance diet to keep their bmi at 30. There isn’t much else they can do.

EmeraldShamrock · 13/07/2021 10:37

Anorexia isn't about food or losing weight to get slim if it a controlling disorder.
Aneroxia is a loss of control when you can't get a grip on anything through MH issues food becomes your weapon.
I was never fat before I was restricting food it was never about my weight.
The warped power you now have over loved ones reinforced the need for this control eventually your stomach closes.
It has similar secrets hiding your body shape.
Comments on some teenagers weight won't cause aneroxia if they are otherwise NT.
I know with my friend she just hasn't got motivation and loves takeaways and sugary foods, wine.
She has a 3 y.o on reins because she can't keep up with her, It upsets her a lot but unless she makes a change it'll get harder.

Kanaloa · 13/07/2021 10:37

Rather than obesity being a mental illness, I would say that obesity is the symptom/result of a mental illness. Much like with anorexia, being very thin/malnutrition can be the symptoms/results of the mental illness, rather than them being the mental illness.

So I would say obesity is the physical result of mental illnesses like binge eating, overeating etc. In the future I think there will be more support for them, but at the moment there isn’t really much support as so much seems to be focused on treating the result (the obesity) rather than the mental illness, which is the eating.

Comedycook · 13/07/2021 10:30

I think it's actually quite easy in modern society to become overweight or obese. Severe morbid obesity is another issue and is often a symptom or result of mental illness or trauma. Some people turn to alcohol or drugs...for others, they use food as a drug. It's not surprising why. It's cheap, it's readily available, you dont need to meet a dodgy dealer to acquire it! It's gives you a dopamine hit and even if you want to stop, you actually can't because we all need to eat so you can't go cold turkey.

PasstheBucket89 · 13/07/2021 10:26

Yeah as another poster said, a lot of obesity that isn't sensory based is often trauma based,
one programme a mother was extremely obese and bedbound her daughter had to care for her, she and her siblings were badly neglected and often left alone in the house with little food whilst they were at the pub, she said i cant be abandoned now, which is all kinds of fucked up in regards to the daughter and the impact on her life, but yeah i thought that woman needs serious therapy not exploiting on tv!!! Angry

babyblues21 · 13/07/2021 10:25

And I did follow up by saying that I accept mental illness may be a driver for over eating in some people (not all - some). But I don't think the comparison with anorexia was helpful, for the reasons stated.

babyblues21 · 13/07/2021 10:24

My point being (for those who seem to have misunderstood)

Nobody overeats because of an intense fear of being "too thin".

However .. Many individuals with anorexia under-eat because of a fear of the opposite (ie of gaining weight).

Body image is irrelevant when it comes to the reasons for over eating - no-one overeats to avoid being thin. However body image is very often a factor in anorexia.

Hence my point about false comparison.

babyblues21 · 13/07/2021 10:21

[quote HostessTrolley]@babyblues21 I disagree - while body dysmorphia is a feature of anorexia it’s not the core or the cause[/quote]

I didn't say it was the cause.

I said it was a key feature. Which based on my own clinical experiences, it is.

babyblues21 · 13/07/2021 10:20

*I took take issue with the assumption that Anorexia is due to body image. I get so tired of this assumption.
*
It's not an assumption, it's based on my many years of clinical experience working with individuals with mental illness. And a PhD.

Cooldryplace · 13/07/2021 09:20

I do agree OP, I think it's clear that over eating is very much related to the state of our MH. However, with c. 1/3 of the adult population obese, it's just not possible to treat individual cases with proper MH care, so people will need to find a way to help themselves, even if it is officially classified as a mental illness. I don't think telling people that they're ill and putting them on long waiting lists for help that never comes or is inadequate (which it will have to be because of the sheer cost involved) would be helpful, probably counter productive while people wait for someone else to solve their issues. Obviously it would be good if excellent support was available, but how can it be with so many people affected?

Swipe left for the next trending thread