Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Six year old and a pocket knife

114 replies

AnxiousPixie · 12/07/2021 18:44

DH thinks it's ok for him to have one at six, I don't and have said no. DH had one at about the same age and doesn't see the problem. I think times have changed and knives just aren't an acceptable thing to 'play' with. I'm the bad guy.

Am I being unreasonable to say he is too young??

OP posts:
bookh · 12/07/2021 20:30

@SpaceRaiders I think context is everything here like you say.

For example, we are rural farmers. It wouldn't enter my mind for a child NOT to safely be taught how to use a multi tool, a knife and many other tools. From cutting baler twine to cleaning a stone out a horses shoe, to freeing a sheep from a fence. However, it would never leave the farm setting.

Lilypansy · 12/07/2021 20:28

My children were chopping veg such as mushroom, courgettes etc, cheese etc by the time they were 3
A three year old using a knife? That sounds reckless to me.

LST · 12/07/2021 20:24

@Lilypansy

Fuck me. Better stop teaching my child skills such as cutting his fruit, making a sandwich. You might think that's ok, but I wouldn't be giving a six year old a knife sharp enough to cut fruit with. Buttering bread with a cutlery knife, perhaps, when supervised.
My 7 year old cuts his own fruit and veg for snacks? What age do you think is ok?
SpaceRaiders · 12/07/2021 20:22

I presume he means in the context of going camping or fishing.

In many countries getting a pocket knife and knowing how to use it is a right of passage for preteens. I would be happy for my dd to have one and use it with adequate supervision. Hell, Dd7 often helps me chop up kindling with an axe in the winter!

VaguelyInteresting · 12/07/2021 20:21

I’ve said YABU because owning one is not the same as carrying one.

My 5 yo has a full set of (child size but functional) tools and craft knives, etc that he is allowed to use under close adult supervision i.e with me or his dad, and they’re safely away when not actively in use. Similarly he has supervised access to and uses knives, whittling tools etc at forest school under close supervision.

I wouldn’t want ANY child, 6 or 16 carrying a knife around outside of a camping/wilderness situation - but having them and learning to use them properly is a valuable life skill IMO.

We also just bought a flint and steel kit that we taught DS how to use this weekend and was a great success and really good for him- good opportunity to instill fire safety etc.

I don’t let him have toy guns, knives or other toy weaponry though- so he sees these things very much as “tools” rather than “toys”, and there’s no confusion.

PTW1234 · 12/07/2021 20:15

Just to pint out my Ds went to an exceptional nursery school an 3+ they did woodwork with actual saw and drank out of glass tumblers, the also used metal cutlery. (Nobody was stabbed, or injured)

Those saying shouldn’t handle a knife ever are as bit extreme

TooBored1 · 12/07/2021 20:09

@Lilypansy

babynameneeded @Lilypansy. At what age do you think they should learn then? Is there a special certificate they get on their birthday where a knife is suddenly safe

Of course not. What a ridiculous comment. As with all developmental milestones, it depends on the personality of the child. Use of knives to cut fruit etc can be introduced when a parent feels that a child is ready and sensible enough, but I think six is too young to have acquired the necessary manual dexterity. My seven year old granddaughter certainly isn't ready to handle sharp knives. At least, not in my home.

Glad I'm not in your home then! My children were chopping veg such as mushroom, courgettes etc, cheese etc by the time they were 3.
toffeebutterpopcorn · 12/07/2021 20:03

DS almost had his eye poked out by a rather aggressive child in reception who through that a large stick would make a super weapon.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 12/07/2021 20:01

any kind of knife can be used as a weapon. Six year olds should not be allowed to handle them. Not ever.

This comment explains the fucking appalling table manners some children have, if they aren't given a knife to cut their food at home.

Children need to be taught, supervised, to use knives safely as a tool not a weapon. You can buy kuhn rikon children's knives for kitchen prep for this reason.

Honestmary · 12/07/2021 19:59

Well this has tickled me as I’ve just read another thread about how dangerous unwashed strawberries are and yet here I am reading about giving a 6 year old a knife…… anyhoo, it’s a no from me. I see no reason for a child to own a knife

toffeebutterpopcorn · 12/07/2021 19:58

@CatsArePeople

My grandma used to have a little penknife

My mum has a pocket knife in her handbag at all times. Once she remembered she had it at an airport. She then went outside and burried it in a flower bed so the security didn't confiscate it. Then she retrieved it upon return a week later Grin

A while ago I was invited to the House of Parliament and managed to get in with a (small 6cm) Swiss Army knife in my handbag (I find them useful at events if I am managing them). I didn’t realise until I was raking for a business card. And it went through a metal detector too.
macshoto · 12/07/2021 19:55

Have had a 3 inch Opinel locking blade penknife since I was 8 or 9. Still have it now (40 or so years later). 6 might be a bit young - but i think it's good to learn about tools, how to use them properly, and to respect them.

In that sense, I think closely supervised use of a properly sharp blade is better than learning bad habits at younger age with something blunt.

Lilypansy · 12/07/2021 19:45

babynameneeded @Lilypansy. At what age do you think they should learn then? Is there a special certificate they get on their birthday where a knife is suddenly safe

Of course not. What a ridiculous comment. As with all developmental milestones, it depends on the personality of the child. Use of knives to cut fruit etc can be introduced when a parent feels that a child is ready and sensible enough, but I think six is too young to have acquired the necessary manual dexterity. My seven year old granddaughter certainly isn't ready to handle sharp knives. At least, not in my home.

PTW1234 · 12/07/2021 19:42

Is it related to a hobby? DS8 has just received something similar as a birthday gift but it’s linked to a hobby and will be put out of his reach when not being used for said hobby.

If it’s just to have then YANBU

warmfluffytowels · 12/07/2021 19:42

There’s nothing age appropriate about a six year old having a knife. I can’t believe anyone would think this was ok.

Why wouldn't it be okay?

How are children supposed to learn how to use things safely if adults keep banning everything?

LivingLaVidaCovid · 12/07/2021 19:42

I had a proper swiss army at 7 (the one with a big blade and all the whistles and bells) and always make this face when i think about it Confused

When i asked them about as an adult my parents just said they were surprised too as i had no interest in the outdoors and was a polly pocket obsessive but i seemed to REALLY want one... so they gave in and santa got it for me (This was christmas 1990!!!)

I used to take it to school!??!! to "fix things" like some unpaid child janitor and also ostensibly to "whittle wood" (What? Why?)

As an adult, I am surprisingly well adjusted (with no criminal record)

ConfusedConfusedConfused

No way would i do the same for my kids....

TooBored1 · 12/07/2021 19:41

We had them as kids from about that age and mine (plus all cousins etc) too.

Used under supervision for specified tasks (mostly whittling) but a great way to show trust in a child and a belief in their ability to be safe and responsible.

Plus great fun!

Nohomemadecandles · 12/07/2021 19:40

Unless you seriously make your dinner with a pen knife, then it's not the same at all, us it?

If you have them in the same "box" then you're going to give yourself a Brazilian everytime you slip your kitchen knife into your pocket.

Knives stay in kitchens. Unless you're specifically on a camp and even then they don't need their own.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 12/07/2021 19:40

On Germany you can buy knives in toy shops- for whittling etc.

Our DDs both have knives that are nominally theres. They live in the tool box and come out if we are doing something that requires them. Same with other similar tools.

MinnieMountain · 12/07/2021 19:39

I’ve got a little Victorinox on my key ring. Our 7yo loves using it. I’ve promised him a child’s version for his 8th birthday if he’s sensible enough.

He knows it will be mainly kept at home and only used under supervision for at least the first year.

Kralia · 12/07/2021 19:39

"Buttering bread with a cutlery knife, perhaps, when supervised"

You feel the need to supervise your 6yo when they are buttering bread? How sharp are your cutlery knives?!!

TwoZeroTwoZero · 12/07/2021 19:37

@Lilypansy

Fuck me. Better stop teaching my child skills such as cutting his fruit, making a sandwich. You might think that's ok, but I wouldn't be giving a six year old a knife sharp enough to cut fruit with. Buttering bread with a cutlery knife, perhaps, when supervised.
Children in a variety of cultures around the world use huge knives to help prepare and cook food for themselves and their families and they do so without injury because they've learned from a very young age to use them safely. Why must we wrap them up in cotton wool?
Idontgiveagriffindamn · 12/07/2021 19:35

@babynameneeded

Carry one around in his pocket all day, no.

Learn how to use one safely and supervised, absolutely yes.

This kind of sums it up for me. Getting a pen knife does not equate to knife crime
AnxiousPixie · 12/07/2021 19:33

Thanks everyone for your views, it's really good to see the variety. I work in a field where I see the bad side if knives, which is why my gut said no. But I get everyone saying yes under supervision etc.

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 12/07/2021 19:33

My grandma used to have a little penknife

My mum has a pocket knife in her handbag at all times. Once she remembered she had it at an airport. She then went outside and burried it in a flower bed so the security didn't confiscate it. Then she retrieved it upon return a week later Grin