Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Six year old and a pocket knife

114 replies

AnxiousPixie · 12/07/2021 18:44

DH thinks it's ok for him to have one at six, I don't and have said no. DH had one at about the same age and doesn't see the problem. I think times have changed and knives just aren't an acceptable thing to 'play' with. I'm the bad guy.

Am I being unreasonable to say he is too young??

OP posts:
Gladioli23 · 12/07/2021 22:55

I think I got my first penknife (which I kept rather than my parents keeping) at about the age of 9. But then I was also allowed out to play in the woods a couple of miles away around the same age and needed it for cutting things while I was out and about.

We lived in the countryside all my childhood so a multitool was a totally normal part of my life: fixing bikes, cutting brambles if someone got really caught up, whittliy, den building. They were always legal carry and I still carry one today. Suspect that the countryside alters my perception though: my brother was given his first air rifle at the age of ten (his own so he didn't need to use my parents any more). Obviously that was for supervised use!

Kralia · 12/07/2021 22:48

"My 11 year old was threatened with one of these on Friday. Just no."

Presumably not by a 6 year old though!! And if someone is not buying their child a penknife because they are worried they will take it to school and use it to threaten another child, that suggests they have quite a serious problem child on their hands! All my children own penknives and I can categorically guarantee that they will not be either taking them to school or threatening another child with it. They are neither disturbed nor stupid!

DojoWojo · 12/07/2021 22:43

I'd have thought a child that was taught to use a knife responsibly, for good reason (camping etc) would actually be a hell of a lot less likely to be involved in knife crime than some twat who thinks knives are a status symbol.

But yy to pp. Locked away other than when in use with adult supervision.

Userg1234 · 12/07/2021 22:33

I had one a six. Cut myself. Learnt a valuable lession.

Seriously why does he need his own knife. How often will be be camping, woodworking etc. I would provide the tools he needs as and when he needs them

EleanorOlephantisjustfine · 12/07/2021 21:52

I never said I was horrified. I just don’t agree with it. That doesn’t mean I’ve had any kind of sheltered life. It’s ok, we can have differing opinions 😀

SuperCaliFragalistic · 12/07/2021 21:48

@Wellpark

If he takes it to school and it's discovered he will be permanently excluded.
Why on earth would he take it to school? And no, I am confident that an otherwise well behaved and settled 6 year old wouldn't be permanently excluded for taking a pen knife in their bag to school unless there was a lot more going on.

Some of you have absolutely no faith in your children's ability to learn about safety rules and risk.

Coasterfan · 12/07/2021 21:45

My 11 year old was threatened with one of these on Friday and is now too scared to go to school. Just no. I don’t know if the boy who has it was joking or serious but he should not have had it!

MaskingForIt · 12/07/2021 21:44

@LivingLaVidaCovidI used to take it to school!??!! to "fix things" like some unpaid child janitor and also ostensibly to "whittle wood" (What? Why?)

Haha, you’ve just reminded me. In primary school I used to unscrew the blade from pencil sharpeners and spent break time whittling pencils. Regular pencils weren’t great, but there were some waxy/MDF-type ones which carved beautifully!

SuperCaliFragalistic · 12/07/2021 21:40

My DS got a pocket knife for his 6th birthday this year. It has a safety catch so he accidently open it but it is very sharp. His cousin got one about the same age. He doesn't "play" with it any more than he plays with the readily available kitchen knives, matches and tools. He has learned to whittle, carve and safely cut string and such like with it and he is generally supervised. He also has a real tool set including saw, chisel, hammer etc. He loves wildlife and camping and knows that the knife is a tool, not a toy.

I would argue that children being taught how to safely use any adult equipment, including sharp knives, at primary age has absolutely no connection to the problem of knife crime in teenagers. I would in fact suggest the opposite is true.

Wellpark · 12/07/2021 21:37

If he takes it to school and it's discovered he will be permanently excluded.

Porcupineintherough · 12/07/2021 21:28

@EleanorOlephantisjustfine there are different types of being sheltered. One of them is being horrified about something that is common practice in a whole variety of countries included many who have far better outcomes both for children and society than the UK.

Our next door neighbour is in the police btw. His 5 year old goes to forest school and does bushcraft stuff. They were doing fire lighting the other day, cant imagine he'd be shocked at the idea of her using a pen knife under adult supervision. I know she uses saws and hammers.

TooBored1 · 12/07/2021 21:01

@Lilypansy Guess the thought of her using a real saw with actual sharp, metal teeth at 3 would be enough to call social services? What about learning how to light a 🔥 at 4? Too much?

Handing a child a sharp knife and walking out the room? reckless.

Teaching a child how to respect tools, learn independence, build confidence, contribute to the family in a meaningful way, develop life skills and a joy in their own abilities from a young age in a child-led and supervised manner? Excellent parenting.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 12/07/2021 20:52

Depends what for. Tehre is simply no nee for a pocket knife just because, but if he is into nature, camping, scouts etc, then yeah I had one at the same age. So did my brother. But only supervised.

SpaceRaiders · 12/07/2021 20:51

@bookh I do think people tend to immediately think the worst, like PP here referring to knife crime.

Kids need to learn to use dangerous objects safely. I could crack a coconut with a machete at age 6/7. Mine now see me use all manner of tools, and of course I show them how to use the tools safely. Weather it’s a drill or a saw. It’s all part of learning, it boosts confidence too.

@Kralia that’s very interesting reading.

mindutopia · 12/07/2021 20:49

Yes, I think it’s fine to be used with supervision - for things like cooking, camping, wood carving, bushcraft type things. My eldest is 8 and she got one a few years ago. Dh works in an industry related to camping and bushcraft so has taught her how to properly and safely use it. We wouldn’t just send her off to school with a knife to play with! It’s about learning to handle risk and make sensible decisions.

TotorosCatBus · 12/07/2021 20:45

Just to clarify - use knives for chopping veg. The teachers used all the chopped veg to make soup for everyone to have outside.

TotorosCatBus · 12/07/2021 20:44

My kids were taught how to use knives at their school nursery in England. Not reckless

gingerbiscuits · 12/07/2021 20:44

Is this a joke?? Of course he shouldn't have one!! It's ok to use a child's knife, SUPERVISED, at something like Cubs or Forest School etc but other than that....just NO!!

SemiFeralDalek · 12/07/2021 20:42

@Lilypansy

My children were chopping veg such as mushroom, courgettes etc, cheese etc by the time they were 3 A three year old using a knife? That sounds reckless to me.
You're joking? I'm incredibly risk averse but my ds has been chopping and cutting fruit and veg (supervised) since he was 2ish (He's 4. 5 now) His favourite thing was peeling and grating carrots.

Knives when used appropriately and with supervision are fine. Free range? Definitely not.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 12/07/2021 20:38

Children can learn all sorts of things if given the opportunity and the right tools.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 12/07/2021 20:38

My boys have been involved in Scouting since forever, so Swiss Army knives have been a thing here, but only hir camps and activities. DS2 has a fantastic wee side hustle going in whittling and wood carving now, as well...

EleanorOlephantisjustfine · 12/07/2021 20:35

[quote Porcupineintherough]@EleanorOlephantisjustfine I guess you've led a particularly sheltered life then.[/quote]
Nothing sheltered about 30 years in the Police.

Kralia · 12/07/2021 20:34

For the academically inclined, this is a really interesting article about knowledge acquisition in indigenous societies. Some of the pictures (of tiny toddlers with huge knives) will give people on this thread conniptions - but should also give you pause re the extent to which western societies have come to infantilise kids. A six year old not being allowed to cut up fruit is ridiculous imo. www.cambridgeblog.org/2015/06/playing-with-knives/

LST · 12/07/2021 20:33

@Lilypansy

My children were chopping veg such as mushroom, courgettes etc, cheese etc by the time they were 3 A three year old using a knife? That sounds reckless to me.
With adult supervision? Really?
VaguelyInteresting · 12/07/2021 20:32

@Lilypansy

My 3yo was too... and I’m not really the “reckless” type, what with my crippling “pure O” OCD which centres around fears of my child coming to harm

Pipe down.