Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have fed her DC unwashed strawberries?

667 replies

brilliantdances · 12/07/2021 17:19

Neighbour will probably see this. Not sure I care. Perhaps she will see how silly she is!

She was desperate for someone to have her DD and I said I would, no worries, all fine.

Her DD shared a box of strawberries with DS today and long story short, she's picked her DC and her DC has told her this.

I have received a text saying ''Hi, thanks again for having Kate. Please can I ask though, next time wash the strawberries before giving them to her? They are dangerous if not washed properly and she could become so unwell. Would you really want that?''

I haven't replied and won't be. AIBU to have not washed them?! Would if I was at home but it was actually just a quick snack shared out

OP posts:
Thekindofwindowsfaceslookinat · 14/07/2021 17:45

If there was any real risk of eating unwashed produce, they wouldn’t be allowed to sell it/there would have to be more of a warning label than just ‘wash before use

The supermarkets don't need to - there is no immediate causative link between eating a punnet of strawberries and ill health. It is an accumulative exposure issue and the supermarkets are not liable for any harm arising out that.

I’d be surprised if there’s any less pesticide toxic residue on a washed strawberry than an unwashed one, I’d suggest that anyone who is worried buys organic

I only eat organic strawberries - I also don't think that simple washing removes enough of the chemicals, but is does help and it is a good idea.

Some people I know/work with in the US wash strawberries with alkaline water, which emulsifies some surface chemicals and makes them easier to rinse away.

Topseyt · 14/07/2021 16:58

Does nobody ever go strawberry picking anymore? My mother used to take me and my sister when we were children and we certainly ate a fair few straight from the field as we picked them.

Never did us any harm. We have both lived to tell the tale.

Strawberryshitfest · 14/07/2021 16:47

If there was any real risk of eating unwashed produce, they wouldn’t be allowed to sell it/there would have to be more of a warning label than just ‘wash before use’

Strawberryshitfest · 14/07/2021 16:41

But surely rinsing with water or even vinegar/Milton isn’t going to make any difference if the chemicals are so toxic that they soak into the fruit and then into the human body. If water could get rid of them then all the water in our bodies would get rid of them. I’d be surprised if there’s any less pesticide toxic residue on a washed strawberry than an unwashed one, I’d suggest that anyone who is worried buys organic.

Thekindofwindowsfaceslookinat · 14/07/2021 16:17

I thought I'd come back to this thread. Name calling over strawberries though? Confused

For the posters who are 'well, me and my kids eat them unwashed all the time and we're fine,' - again, the potential health issues are linked to the accumulative effect of imbibing pesticides and herbicides over a period of years. You're not going to 'feel' anything from eating unwashed strawberries, and chances are they would taste okay.

Strawberries have long been one of the 'Dirty Dozen': fresh produce that 'soaks up' or retains hazardous residues more readily than other fruit or vegetables.

Immune systems are built up by exposure. Science, innit?

This argument isn't relevant to exposure to herbicides, pesticides and soil additives (which are, in my view, a much more direct threat than other types of contamination).

Exposure to these things builds up nothing except what is sometimes called the 'toxic load.'

The parent was still wrong - her social skills leave much to be desired.

Porcupineintherough · 14/07/2021 16:03

@FinallyHere

Anyone who is wondering at the massive increase in allergies in the last decade, would not be surprised by the range of responses on this thread.

Anyone who thinks it 'risky' to eat strawberries which have not been bleached would do well to read up on the role of the human immune system.

I dont know what you've been reading but the only type of exposure that have been shown to lower the chances of allergies are: -Exposure to different food proteins during the first year (but for some kids this triggers alkwrgies)
  • Exposure to certain parasitic worms eg hookworm.

Just general grub and grime and viruses make no difference at all.

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2021 14:50

As long as you can’t taste the sweat/hair/germs it’s best just not to think about it.

Quite. Totally agree. 😆

Strawberryshitfest · 14/07/2021 14:48

@TheKeatingFive

I can’t believe people think that food factories are bastions of hygiene.

How fucking naive.

My daughter worked in a factory making cake bars for cafes/supermarkets for a while. She said everyone was literally dripping with sweat handling the food and she described a colleague with very hairy arms elbow deep mixing dough with bare arms. As long as you can’t taste the sweat/hair/germs it’s best just not to think about it.
SingingInTheShithouse · 14/07/2021 14:42

Meh, I'll take my occasional chances with a rainwater or sprinkle wash, when there isn't access to a tap. Nobody dies from it & it boost immunity & you might even get a bit of extra vitamin B12

Mayhemmumma · 14/07/2021 14:39

Oh wow! Precious.

I wash strawberries but I would never send that message, seriously?! You were doing her a favour.

I would have to take very deep breaths before replying.

TheKeatingFive · 14/07/2021 14:38

I can’t believe people think that food factories are bastions of hygiene.

How fucking naive.

3Britnee · 14/07/2021 14:37

@SingingInTheShithouse

I'll just think they are dirty bastards for not doing so

You might want to look into building immunity to those germs you fear. We get immunity from exposure, not avoidance. Lots of science on the problems lack of exposure causes.

I don't fear germs. Would you eat something a waiter handled all the way to your table? No, and most people would complain. And not eat it. So why all the arguments against washing actual dirt off your food?

I can't believe people are arguing the toss over eating dirty food 😂😂😂

entropynow · 14/07/2021 14:35

@TheKeatingFive

I'll just think they are dirty bastards for not doing so

And we'll think you're a hysterical neurotic.

All good Wink

Yup.

Immune systems are built up by exposure. Science, innit?

SingingInTheShithouse · 14/07/2021 14:27

I'll just think they are dirty bastards for not doing so

You might want to look into building immunity to those germs you fear. We get immunity from exposure, not avoidance. Lots of science on the problems lack of exposure causes.

Arsebucket · 14/07/2021 14:07

Shit, tagged wrong person Blush

Arsebucket · 14/07/2021 14:07

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AlanThePig · 14/07/2021 13:42

@Arsebucket

All the talk of vinegar has reminded me of my nan, who used to love a fruit salad covered in salt and vinegar.

My used to ask her if she’d like brown sauce on top too.

My Nan used to do that as well. Must be a generation thing. That said, salt on watermelon is delicious as well.
Nononsense2 · 14/07/2021 13:29

I usually wash my fruit and veg under running water but when I was pregnant, I did the vinegar and water wash because I was told there are links between pesticides in food and miscarriage. You can google and you'll find studies about it.

3Britnee · 14/07/2021 13:03

If I buy a few peaches, and loads of people could have picked them up and squeezed them first, put it near their face to sniff it, of course I'm going to wash that before I eat it. Jesus christ 😂

3Britnee · 14/07/2021 13:00

I don't eat biscuits. I'm diabetic. Since January I've tried to only eat homemade whole food where possible and cut out processed stuff. For health & weight reasons, not germs.

But in factories, they wear gloves and masks and a lot is done by machines. When I talk about people touching it, I mostly mean the great unwashed in the supermarket (as well as the pickers). Many people don't wash their hands and a lot let their dirty snotty kids touch everything too.

Strawberryshitfest · 14/07/2021 11:57

@3Britnee

😂 I do have cloth ones.

But I meant I'm not one of these anal MN'ers that has to boilwash everything after every glance. My house isn't pristine or spotless. My cleaning can be lax. I'm not obsessive about cleaning. I eat stuff past its date using my common sense.

But I'm not going to eat things other people have touched or coughed over without washing it. You wouldn't eat food brought out with the waiters thumbs all over it, so its the same principle but worse because produce could have shit on it

Do you wash all food or just fruit? Surely if you bought a cake, or a bar of chocolate/biscuits or a bag of flour someone in the supply chain has probably touched or coughed on the food at some point. I don’t see how someone handling biscuits and putting them in a packet is any different to fruit (apart from the mud/dirt/manure). You’re just as likely to be eating something someone has touched/coughed on so should we bleach/scrub with vinegar biscuits too. Or just hope that our immune system can deal with eating non sterilised food like it has been for hundreds of thousands of years. Personally I don’t care if my food is covered in bacteria/traces of fertiliser/manure/factory workers germs as long as it tastes good/doesn’t have large amounts of visible dirt and doesn’t make me ill. I’ve never had food poisoning and I’ve never washed anything (I’m even too lazy to wash mushrooms and chuck them in the pan with chunks of mud/manure on them. And I don’t understand how people get grossed out by eating a fly but will happily eat a chicken embryo or a cow-all are dead animals). If the idea of germs/nasties on your food grosses you out then by all means wash things if it makes you feel better, but I think people should understand that we ingest bacteria/traces of poo etc all the time and our immune systems can deal with it-stomach acid will kill more than any washing will. It’s not really possible to wash pathogens off food without ruining it so maybe better to just not think about it and enjoy the delicious food. Ironically I had this username before I saw this thread.
Comedycook · 14/07/2021 11:30

@Arsebucket

All the talk of vinegar has reminded me of my nan, who used to love a fruit salad covered in salt and vinegar.

My used to ask her if she’d like brown sauce on top too.

She was ahead of her time. Strawberries with balsamic vinegar are delicious
Arsebucket · 14/07/2021 11:29

My Dad

Arsebucket · 14/07/2021 11:29

All the talk of vinegar has reminded me of my nan, who used to love a fruit salad covered in salt and vinegar.

My used to ask her if she’d like brown sauce on top too.

Comedycook · 14/07/2021 11:15

@rantymcrantface66

Not sure I'd fancy bleach or vinegar flavoured strawberries even if it is totally safe. Surely when you're the only one that actually does this vs all those that don't you must realise that it's maybe a bit over the top?!
Big difference between bleach and vinegar.

I use vinegar you can't taste it