Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be tempted to visit a medium?

33 replies

TeddingtonTrashbag · 12/07/2021 14:45

I am totally non-Woo, but a friend’s birthday is soon and when consulted she said she would really like to visit a medium again. She. believes in all that stuff but says she has only ever been convinced by two mediums and is keen to book one of them for her snd ne, if we can get him on that day. I am tempted, mainly because I want to see what questions he asks me for cold readingI have already said that if we go, I will go first so he can’t read anything from her about me and want yo give a false name so he can’t check me our on SM.
What do you think?
YABU - forget it -you are a sceptic and he’ll clock that, so get her a spa day instead
YANBU - it’s her treat, be respectful and go by with the flow

OP posts:
BerriesAndLeaves · 12/07/2021 15:31

I saw two of them about 20 years ago. I went as I was intrigued by what they would say. It certainly didn't convince me they could tell the future. One of them who was supposed to be really good, i could tell what tricks she was using. Neither of them were proven to be right or predicted anything momentous or useful that has happened. I could have done with one of the telling me to suggest my dh get a health check but they didn't

TeddingtonTrashbag · 12/07/2021 15:25

make sure you remove anything that can give them info about you ie ; wedding / engagement ring , St chris' crucifix , high brand clothes
Lol have no branded clothes other than George Asda😀)
Good point.

OP posts:
AlCalavicci · 12/07/2021 15:12

If your friend is really keen on the idea and it would spoil her B'day if you didn't join in then go along with it but make it very clear to her that you think it is all a con and she should not take there word for anything.

If you do go ahead with it , make sure you remove anything that can give them info about you ie ; wedding / engagement ring , St chris' crucifix , high brand clothes ( um put other clothes on , dont just remove the expensive stuff Blush ) etc

tintodeverano2 · 12/07/2021 15:11

@TeddingtonTrashbag

a fake name and persona and playing along as if it’s correct with whatever the medium makes up about you Yes
I've seen a medium a couple of times. Each time giving her a fake name, and she doesn't ask any questions until the end. Spookily accurate. She kept mentioning a particular name and said it was a grandmother. I said no I have no idea who that is and she was pretty insistent that it was correct (not a common name either!). When my nan listened to the recording she said it was her grandmother.

I've seen plenty that ask leading questions and then play up to the replies, like winding these up, especially when it's a public reading! Wink

Whatinthelord · 12/07/2021 15:00

I just couldn’t pay money to these people. I could get it might be interesting. As a skeptic I’d love to see them in action and how they work. End of the day though I wouldn’t want to give them my hard earned cash and make them seem more legitimate by being one of the people to pay for the ‘service’s

TeddingtonTrashbag · 12/07/2021 14:58

a fake name and persona and playing along as if it’s correct with whatever the medium makes up about you
Yes

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 12/07/2021 14:50

I wouldn’t arrange this, simply because it lends credence to the idea that these people are genuine and, whilst it might be a bit of fun for your friend right now, who knows how her life might change in later years, and whether she might seek out mediums for help with serious problems or sorrows, and do you really want to have played any part in helping her to believe in this rubbish?

But if you really want her to have this treat then make it clear that you think it’s rubbish peddled by charlatans and that you’ll be giving yourself a fake name and persona and playing along as if it’s correct with whatever the medium makes up about you.

BastardMonkfish · 12/07/2021 14:47

Ah go with it - it's a bit of fun and it is her birthday.