Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'Where Are They Now' if AIBU threads?

716 replies

MolyHolyGuacamole · 12/07/2021 14:06

Do you even find yourself suddenly remembering a particular scenario, and wondering where the people involved are today, if the behaviour is still carrying on, did she ever LTB, etc?

Even if the thread had a resolution to the scenario, if things ever repeated again?

The one that came into my mind vividly today was about a woman who'd gone to collect her child (believe it was a DD) and came home to find that her husband had left the key in the door on the other side meaning they couldn't get in, and despite being able to see 'D'H in the window and signalling to him, he refused to come and open the door as he was on a work call? From memory they were left waiting for about an hour and DD had to wee in the garden.

I remember feeling so outraged for her, and find myself wondering now if it was just a one off or if the bastard has continued doing shitty things to them.

Any other ones that have left an impression?

OP posts:
Teaandjam · 16/07/2021 22:06

I alway wonder about the poster that found something on her husbands phone that she didn’t like. Lots of people were telling her to LTB. I always wonder if she did and how she feels now.

Perching · 16/07/2021 20:28

Gentleotter and their farm in Scotland with a mean landowner

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 16/07/2021 18:32

At the end of the 90s, the BBC thought it would be a great idea to open messageboards for all their programmes and all sorts of other topics. Steep learning curve! The cost of moderation must have been huge. They moved rapidly away from that model. Many commercial competitors complained that the BBC was offering all this free stuff and it wasn't fair. I don't think they have any left now.

bruffin · 16/07/2021 17:11

@HaveringWavering
Not really, they were a persistent poster on 3 other parenting sites i was on and they used the same username!
I was bored and googled the username and it turned up MN as well asking for kilts for school girl uniform.
Parentscentre was a government run parenting site and it was a fetishist dream. They closed it down in the end as it was so badly run.

Ijsbear · 16/07/2021 16:41

It used to be quite interesting to correlate IPs and pieces of info and such like. Not new news, but it is amazing and scary just how much you can find out about an individual given 3 pieces of random info.

Ijsbear · 16/07/2021 16:32

[quote Biscoffbiscou]@HeyDemonsItsYaGirl

But if no one is verifying their suspicions with any solid evidence, how do you know it’s not just circular confirmation bias?

I.e. there’s a belief that certain types of threads ‘seem’ like trolls, which is then its own justification for taking them down (whether they’re really troll threads or not), which then reinforces the original belief that any thread with X characteristic must be a troll thread.

I had a thread removed in the past with a confident message left in its place stating that the thread wasn’t genuine – but that was incorrect – I was a genuine person with a real life situation, and the thread had been removed based simply on a ‘hunch’.[/quote]
I used to moderate forums too.

You're right, but so is heyDemons. Some people really have a distinctive style that you get to recognise, both linguistic and in terms of content and attitude. You can be pretty certain about them.

But sometimes it's more of a guess and you aren't always going to get it right as a Mod, which mean innocent people get treated unfairly.

If you don't ~try~ to keep on top of the hairy handed though, things spiral downwards very badly. Normal board readers might not obviously detect a troll but when a board is too infested with them, a certain plastic feel arrives and real people stop posting. And when you're dealing with the charmers who try to con people out of money, you have to do something.

HaveringWavering · 16/07/2021 16:13

@bruffin

I found MN because of a troll that posted on all parenting sites. They had a fetish for school girl kilts, and large toddlers in cloth nappies. (Liked their safety pins) they still crop on MN well over 10 years later
But why did that lead YOU to MN? Shock. I feel there’s a bit if story missing here Grin
Queenie6655 · 16/07/2021 15:53

@Oldbutstillgotit

Does anyone remember the OP whose husband upgraded his flight and left her and her DC with no money in America ( I think) can’t remember full details but it stuck with me for ages. Also the OP whose husband made her eat paper .
Think often about both of these stories

How sad

Felt so angry that people can treat others so badly

Belledan1 · 16/07/2021 15:50

The lady whose teenage daughter was being harassed by an older guy at work. They told the boss in the end. Always wondered if the girl was ok as I know planning to go back to work.

bruffin · 16/07/2021 15:40

I found MN because of a troll that posted on all parenting sites. They had a fetish for school girl kilts, and large toddlers in cloth nappies. (Liked their safety pins) they still crop on MN well over 10 years later

AlternativePerspective · 16/07/2021 14:54

But if no one is verifying their suspicions with any solid evidence, how do you know it’s not just circular confirmation bias? you don’t, but tbh often It becomes apparent as time goes on.

So e.g. a poster posts some kind of thread which may or may not be believable, and it is reported and deleted. Said poster then creates a new account and posts another, entirely different thread on a different subject, which again is reported, and so a picture builds.

Also there are trolls who don’t just stick to one site. So e.g. Dizzymare who posted about losing twins and who was outed as a troll was banned from here, but carried on posting on other sites including baby loss forums. She then started posting pictures of her dead babies on one of those forums, and someone confirmed that the pictures had in fact been lifted from the internet. So she was officially outed about 6 months after she was banned from MN, but even though there wasn’t any concrete proof when she was banned from here, she was 100% a troll.

The same with Oliver’s army, another who lifted pictures from online.

Oldbutstillgotit · 16/07/2021 14:00

Does anyone remember the OP whose husband upgraded his flight and left her and her DC with no money in America ( I think) can’t remember full details but it stuck with me for ages.
Also the OP whose husband made her eat paper .

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 16/07/2021 11:30

But if no one is verifying their suspicions with any solid evidence, how do you know it’s not just circular confirmation bias?

I don't. Nobody does, unless there's something concrete like an inconsistent posting history. It's just balance of probabilities.

whynotwhatknot · 16/07/2021 11:11

@CoolCatTaco thats it brian-she was about to leave and he persuaded her to stay and she never came back to the thread i do worry about her

ToffeePennie · 16/07/2021 08:43

I always wonder about a lady (I think her name had pink or purple in) with the horrible daughter in law who wouldn’t let her see her grandson. I remember she was desperate to have some kind of contact, even if it’s just a cuddle with the daughter in law supervising, but OP had been labelled toxic or something by the daughter in law. I often wonder if that baby has grown up with his grandma in his life.
I also wonder about the mad lady who was going around with a men’s cycling group and the OP was the wife. I genuinely think that the lady in question was gunning for one of the chaps. It was just too bizarre!

rantymcrantface66 · 16/07/2021 08:22

I remember one where a family was on a holiday of a lifetime OP had saved for and it was OP's dream experience the next day. OP's husband was not taking his medication or had changed it and was having a severe manic episode. OP and dc were frightened and I was very worried about them getting home safely. Not sure how that ended and if OP got her experience trip.

Another poster always stands out. Can't remember the original subject of the post but she was catering to the every whim of her 7 or 8 year old ds cooking fancy meals that he then wouldn't eat so she'd make a new one. He spent all the time in his fancy bedroom on computer and OP ended up posting loads of pictures of this hugely extravagant house, describing fancy holidays yet didn't work and was a single parent. I'm sure she posted again that the older ds had snapped and hurt the younger and no longer wanted to stay at home. There was a huge issue about patio furniture because she wanted her mum to come over and intervene with the boys but due to covid the stuff she had didn't allow for distancing without moving it and she didn't want to move it and have it looking not perfect. I'm sure she denied being the same poster but the scenario, the pictures of a super posh house, and the writing style was identical. I wonder if she's still around.

Trixie1602 · 16/07/2021 08:15

@Biscoffbiscou from the hints & clues she was giving , I thought it was nigella lawson

I'd love to know how OP is getting on. She seemed so strong in a shitty situation

Thekindofwindowsfaceslookinat · 16/07/2021 01:04

I always found BertrandRussell to be a bit of a douche tbh

Don't think that's in the spirit of the thread tbh.

Thekindofwindowsfaceslookinat · 16/07/2021 00:59

Can confirm that the woman who got it together with the gardener ("Green eyed Gardener") was the same poster who "found" 10K in the hedge

No! I literally just came back to this thread to see if anyone had found my favourite gardener thread...is this the one where she was glimpsing him shyly through the window and they went to the pub on a date??

It was my fave feel-good, gardening-related thread Grin

Biscoffbiscou · 15/07/2021 23:07

@trixie1602

I remember one of the first threads I read on Relationship boards when I went on maternity where OP was convinced her DH was having a affair with a famous woman who he knew from childhood The thread went on forever , people trying to guess who it was & offer support I stayed up until 3am reading the whole thing I was gripped ! I accidentally lost the post when I removed it from the watch section

I often find myself wondering what happened next / who the celebrity was

I remember that one Trixie!
Biscoffbiscou · 15/07/2021 23:02

@HeyDemonsItsYaGirl

But if no one is verifying their suspicions with any solid evidence, how do you know it’s not just circular confirmation bias?

I.e. there’s a belief that certain types of threads ‘seem’ like trolls, which is then its own justification for taking them down (whether they’re really troll threads or not), which then reinforces the original belief that any thread with X characteristic must be a troll thread.

I had a thread removed in the past with a confident message left in its place stating that the thread wasn’t genuine – but that was incorrect – I was a genuine person with a real life situation, and the thread had been removed based simply on a ‘hunch’.

itcouldhave · 15/07/2021 22:44

@bruffin

They can tell if the ip address has been used before under different accounts Usually stories don't make sense or there is NCing with glaring inconsistencies etc
This isn’t the case any more because IP addresses are roaming so you don’t have the same one fixed to your device.

As someone who previously ran a forum, trolls are usually identified in a number of ways, mainly to do with subject matter, posting style etc. Once you have your eye in, so to speak, they’re easily spotted.

However, there are always outliers who manage to get away with it for longer. This is where it’s helpful to distinguish between troll types. You get the post and run twats who lob a contentious thread in then sit back and enjoy the frothing, but you also get people who create a whole alternate life online because they feel their real life is lacking somehow.

MN is a also well known platform for both women chatting about day to day stuff and one of the few places feminism is discussed so MRAs and TRAs target it. Pistonheads, for example, has members who are MRAs and have trolled MN for fun.

My point is that trolls are not all of the same stripe and posters should be extremely wary of posting personal info.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 15/07/2021 22:25

@bruffin

They can tell if the ip address has been used before under different accounts Usually stories don't make sense or there is NCing with glaring inconsistencies etc
And there's a certain way troll threads go. Like "The Script" when a man is cheating.
itcouldhave · 15/07/2021 22:23

@messybun101

Remember the woman who asked others 'AIBU to ask what your vulva looks like' ... she was soon told yes, this is absolutely unreasonable to ask
MN is a magnet for perverts trying to get women to share stories about stuff they can get off to. This ranges from asking for descriptions of babies’ and toddlers’ genitalia under the guise of being worried about development to posting about teenage girls wanting to wear stockings or asking for ‘advice’ on giving BJs.

The naive earnestness with which posters eagerly respond to these threads is disappointing. If you ever try and suggest that perhaps it might not be the best idea to describe your kid’s genitals on a public forum with a total stranger, they get all aggrieved and either try to pretend it’s all fine or deny that perverts could possibly target MN.

CallmeHendricks · 15/07/2021 21:14

Actually, maybe it wasn't that name, as I've just AS'd it and it seems to be someone else. Sorry, if so.

Swipe left for the next trending thread