Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who these hooligans are?

142 replies

Sandinmyknickers · 12/07/2021 11:45

I'm sure we are all sickened by some of the footage and images of horrendous, violent antics by some England fans last night. I really dont have the words to describe them- thugs, hooligans, vandals, Neanderthals...take your pick

But AIBU to ask...are any of them your DS or DP/DH? And if so, what are your thoughts on their behaviour?

Everyone seems to be outraged at their behaviour.. but yet noone seems to know them? They all must be someones DS or maybe DP surely? They must have families? And looking at the footage there were loads of them?!

Did any of your male family members (I know there were some women but it is overwhelmingly male) go out causing havoc on the streets last night throwing bottles, fighting, getting naked etc (not just general pub beers)? How do you feel about it? I genuinely cant get my head around it. Are they respectable people normally?

OP posts:
Flugbustingbiz · 12/07/2021 15:15

Lol all the defensive posters - you're sure it wasn't your H breaking into Wembley Grin

No one would admit it op! I was watching them all on Twitter yesterday and was wondering who procreates with these cretins, someone must

SlothMama · 12/07/2021 15:10

I'd happily report anyone if I saw them behaving like that

ParsleyDill · 12/07/2021 15:02

@MotionActivatedDog and @AnotherKrampus, but why are these civil servants, teachers and radiographers you list so unafraid of any employment consequences (which could involve dismissal for gross misconduct, breach of contract, impact on credibility of being able to discharge their role etc) for their violent and/or antisocial behaviour, given that they're clearly relatively invested in their careers?

AnneElliott · 12/07/2021 14:57

It's an interesting question op. I've been at polo e operations for football (not the Euros) and yes most of the people arrested had jobs - a majority had white collar jobs and families.

The police view was that it was a very tribal thing, often family/friends related and they see the violence as part of the fun. Something to do on a Saturday afternoon. Some of the men were in their 50s which surprised me.

Bumblenums1234 · 12/07/2021 14:50

Nope DS is 14 months so was in bed and DP was in bed as he doesn't care about the football

doesparentingsuck · 12/07/2021 14:41

@Itsprobablynotcominghome

The problem is that as a society we think these people are a tiny minority.

We sweep it away, blame social media, blame alcohol, blame lockdown, blame anything or anyone but ourselves.

This exactly
doesparentingsuck · 12/07/2021 14:40

@doesparentingsuck

OP I have been thinking the SAME thing everyone so quick to condemn the behaviour and disassociate themselves from these people but they have families and jobs and wives and children and mothers - someone must know something about this? And be quietly complicit. Who are you? Speak up!
And fathers before anyone jumps on it! They just have work colleagues and friends. SOMEONE knows these people!!
doesparentingsuck · 12/07/2021 14:39

OP I have been thinking the SAME thing everyone so quick to condemn the behaviour and disassociate themselves from these people but they have families and jobs and wives and children and mothers - someone must know something about this? And be quietly complicit. Who are you? Speak up!

AnotherKrampus · 12/07/2021 14:38

A lot of these thugs are supposedly professionals. Arrests in previous situations showed a lot of white-collar office workers, some city bods etc which is infuriating because the stereotypes are usually blaming 'low-class' yobs. Around my way, it was a lot of Hooray Henris and their drunk female counterparts.

Councilworker · 12/07/2021 14:31

I went out with a bloke about 12 years ago who was obsessed with casuals and hooligan culture. He was a Bolton supporter and I think quite idolised the 80s football hooligans in a way as he saw it as some sort of proof of your devotion to a club and a level of camaraderie between your fellow crew members. He was white middle class went to university for a first and was a lower grade Civil Servant. Whilst he probably wouldn't have started a fight I don't think he would break one up. He probably would throw beer and climb up a statue or onto a barrier sing loudly and badly and possibly show his arse. He would describe himself then and now as a blokey bloke.
Men from all social classes have been arrested for hooliganism in the past. It's not something that ABC1Ss never do and only the lowly manual or unskilled workers do. It's machismo and alcohol that make the lethal combination with a good sprinkling of tribalism.

babbaloushka · 12/07/2021 14:29

Some of DD's Instagram "friends" were there, she says they have girlfriends.

A woman I used to work with's son trashed a local venue during the Germany game, so much so that it had to close for the next match, and a photograph of him holding a flare on the stage circled on several local news sites. She was sharing them, joking about him getting royalties and generally egging him on, this was publicly on FB.

Jokes on them now though, as the flare sent another fan to hospital with an asthma attack, and he has been banned from the venue. Not a nice lad and his mum needs some sense knocking into her, she's raised a misogynistic thug who will get himself into some real trouble soon, and he'll deserve it.

DynamoKev · 12/07/2021 14:25

@Itsprobablynotcominghome

The problem is that as a society we think these people are a tiny minority.

We sweep it away, blame social media, blame alcohol, blame lockdown, blame anything or anyone but ourselves.

blame anything or anyone but ourselves.

Eh? How exactly am I to blame for the actions of thugs?
What do I need to do differently to prevent them from doing it?

MotionActivatedDog · 12/07/2021 14:20

@remy3

It’s a good question, “Who are the hooligans?” and one we shouldn’t ignore.

To my mind they are the suck undeveloped of British society. The following circumstances will apply to most of them -

  • uneducated / low intellect
  • unemployed or in dead-end jobs they hate, yet they don’t have the wherewithal or motivation to do anything about it
  • they prefer to blame others for their shit lives, rather than do anything about it themselves
  • insecurity masquerading as belligerence
  • tribal mentality - “splitting” - “them and us attitude” - xenophobia - racism - misogyny
  • Brexiteers (see above)
  • poor health with associated problems of alcoholism; obesity, etc
  • angry about their lot in life, but it’s easier to blame everyone else than take any responsibility for anything.
  • for these men, negative attention is better than no attention at all
I obviously can’t speak for all of them but none of this applies to the people I know that do this sort of crap. University educated- think radiographer, teacher etc. Very confident, arrogant, lovely lives, very much a “take whatever you can get attitude- fuck anyone else” and just loves the chance to get in with their feet. The football doesn’t fight back enough for them Hmm
WednesdayIsPurple · 12/07/2021 14:18

@remy3

It’s a good question, “Who are the hooligans?” and one we shouldn’t ignore.

To my mind they are the suck undeveloped of British society. The following circumstances will apply to most of them -

  • uneducated / low intellect
  • unemployed or in dead-end jobs they hate, yet they don’t have the wherewithal or motivation to do anything about it
  • they prefer to blame others for their shit lives, rather than do anything about it themselves
  • insecurity masquerading as belligerence
  • tribal mentality - “splitting” - “them and us attitude” - xenophobia - racism - misogyny
  • Brexiteers (see above)
  • poor health with associated problems of alcoholism; obesity, etc
  • angry about their lot in life, but it’s easier to blame everyone else than take any responsibility for anything.
  • for these men, negative attention is better than no attention at all
it is so dangerous to stereotype like this - to think that it can only be poor, uneducated people

when one of the clubs investigated racist behaviour of its fans abroad, there was a wide array of jobs but the ring leader was a solicitor in the city who subsequently lost his job. Someone who posted racist abuse this morning was (allegedly) outed as a building manager at Savills.

These are not uneducated, unemployed people.

Someone we knew through work was on TV at a football match and arrested for racist behaviour - I didn't know him socially but I was surprised. He also lost his job (he was an engineer).

These people walk among us

ParsleyDill · 12/07/2021 14:18

[quote Travelledtheworld]@WhyTheEffNot I too had a football Yobbo boyfriend in the 1980s. He loved going to a match for a good fight and some mindless vandalism. It was learned behaviour and peer pressure, fuelled by alcohol. Young men are very tribal in their behaviour and the weak point in any Seemingly civilised society .

Fortunately I personally was never at the receiving end of a beating to commemorate a team loss. But many women are, hence the 38% increase in domestic violence reports after a big name team lose.[/quote]
So why did you go out with him once you knew what he was like, @Travelledtheworld?

Not being arsy -- a genuine question, in line with the question of the OP, about how football hooligans have friends and wives and parents and children and workmates. You're one of the only people on the thread to have identified yourself as having had a relationship with someone who went to matches for fighting and vandalism. I know it's a long time ago, but can you say why you were ok with it then?

TooOldandTired · 12/07/2021 14:14

@Sandinmyknickers

I'm sure we are all sickened by some of the footage and images of horrendous, violent antics by some England fans last night. I really dont have the words to describe them- thugs, hooligans, vandals, Neanderthals...take your pick

But AIBU to ask...are any of them your DS or DP/DH? And if so, what are your thoughts on their behaviour?

Everyone seems to be outraged at their behaviour.. but yet noone seems to know them? They all must be someones DS or maybe DP surely? They must have families? And looking at the footage there were loads of them?!

Did any of your male family members (I know there were some women but it is overwhelmingly male) go out causing havoc on the streets last night throwing bottles, fighting, getting naked etc (not just general pub beers)? How do you feel about it? I genuinely cant get my head around it. Are they respectable people normally?

I think you will find that a good proportion of these families of these people are also subject to the same abuse in their homes so maybe they are more worried about staying alive rather than calling out what they are doing outside. The police need to look at the footage and identify and arrest as many of them as possible, that is the only way it will stop.
Thewiseoneincognito · 12/07/2021 14:09

One of the many reasons I can’t stand football is the fans. Too many scumbag ones, it truly brings out the worst in so many of them. I wonder how many wives, gfs and daughters are nursing injuries after having the loss taken out on them. Horrendous.

FirstIn50s · 12/07/2021 14:09

This makes for awful reading: www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/07/09/domestic-violence-surges-after-a-football-match-ends

It's one thing to see those ideas thrashing the place, but I fear for their families when they get home.

MotionActivatedDog · 12/07/2021 14:06

The reality is that the partners/mothers/sisters etc of the people who behaved like that will have probably become accustomed to it if not grown up with it. They’ll have reasons to justify and minimise. I saw footage last night of people storming into Wembley and then people who were already inside seeing a chance for a bit of action rushing over, shouting “fuck off, pay your fucking money” and then getting stuck in with pulling people over, punching and kicking. Those men (it was all men) will have justified their actions to themselves, probably with a bit of fudging of the truth (this lad started on me/the stewards needed a hand) and then gone home and regaled their families with their heroics. Their families, even when faced with the footage will say “but but but reasons!” I know people like this. Ive seen people I know make the news for fights at local football matches and the families always have reasons to justify it. It’s never their sons/brothers/husbands fault he had to kick a mans head in. Hmm

remy3 · 12/07/2021 14:01

“sick underbelly” that was meant to read (though they are underdeveloped, I guess).

Sorry, should read before posting!

remy3 · 12/07/2021 14:00

It’s a good question, “Who are the hooligans?” and one we shouldn’t ignore.

To my mind they are the suck undeveloped of British society. The following circumstances will apply to most of them -

  • uneducated / low intellect
  • unemployed or in dead-end jobs they hate, yet they don’t have the wherewithal or motivation to do anything about it
  • they prefer to blame others for their shit lives, rather than do anything about it themselves
  • insecurity masquerading as belligerence
  • tribal mentality - “splitting” - “them and us attitude” - xenophobia - racism - misogyny
  • Brexiteers (see above)
  • poor health with associated problems of alcoholism; obesity, etc
  • angry about their lot in life, but it’s easier to blame everyone else than take any responsibility for anything.
  • for these men, negative attention is better than no attention at all
TiddyAndFletch · 12/07/2021 14:00

hat was that awful club full of student later mps at Oxford called?

The Bullingdon Club. Boris Johnson was a member ...

Thirtyrock39 · 12/07/2021 13:56

Rugby fans aren't immune to this behaviour either tbf I think it's groups of blokes fuelling each other- what was that awful club full of student later mps at Oxford called? They behaved as badly burning £50 notes in front of the homeless and trashing restaurants
A lot of blokes are very interested in it as well and apparently the real trouble makers don't wear the football shirts it's the ones in designer clothes you watch out for.

Pootles34 · 12/07/2021 13:47

A boy I was seeing as a teenager was a football hooligan - an Aston Villa supporter, they used to arrange fights with other groups etc. Needless to say I ran for the hills as soon as I found out!

You really wouldn't have known - or perhaps that me being a naive teenager! I remember him being very into his Keats weirdly - he really didn't come across as a thug.

Iknowtheanswer · 12/07/2021 13:42

A friend's son and his friends were there last night. I don't know if my friend knows, tbh, but my ds showed me the snapchat stories. I just hope that they got home in one piece, and didn't get sucked into the violence.

They are massive football fans, and, as they can't afford tickets to internationals or their club games, they often just go the the grounds for the atmosphere.

Sounds all well and good, but they are only 16 - there is no way on earth my ds would try that without telling me. (he went to a garden party with a big screen, some of them still manged to get drunk and stupid, but at least it was in a garden).

Swipe left for the next trending thread