Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder who these hooligans are?

142 replies

Sandinmyknickers · 12/07/2021 11:45

I'm sure we are all sickened by some of the footage and images of horrendous, violent antics by some England fans last night. I really dont have the words to describe them- thugs, hooligans, vandals, Neanderthals...take your pick

But AIBU to ask...are any of them your DS or DP/DH? And if so, what are your thoughts on their behaviour?

Everyone seems to be outraged at their behaviour.. but yet noone seems to know them? They all must be someones DS or maybe DP surely? They must have families? And looking at the footage there were loads of them?!

Did any of your male family members (I know there were some women but it is overwhelmingly male) go out causing havoc on the streets last night throwing bottles, fighting, getting naked etc (not just general pub beers)? How do you feel about it? I genuinely cant get my head around it. Are they respectable people normally?

OP posts:
MotionActivatedDog · 12/07/2021 16:30

@iamtopazmortmain

I think that people like to assume these thugs are from some kind of marginalized group - unemployed, poorly educated, mindless vandals. Some of them will be. But some will be professional family men who hold down full time jobs. It is easier to see them as 'the other' the we can all distance ourselves from them - but they are not. They may include people that live on our street, work in our building or belong to our families.

Just look at the man who harassed Chris Witty - he was an estate agent. As app has said it costs money to but football tickets, travel to football matches and buy that much alcohol. If we pretend that only unemployed, illiterate men are hooligans then will allow those who are not to slip under the radar.

This!

People need to stop with “othering” and “they’re not fans”- it’s denial. These people are from your own streets, your own workplaces, your own football clubs, your own families.

iamtopazmortmain · 12/07/2021 16:22

I think that people like to assume these thugs are from some kind of marginalized group - unemployed, poorly educated, mindless vandals. Some of them will be. But some will be professional family men who hold down full time jobs. It is easier to see them as 'the other' the we can all distance ourselves from them - but they are not. They may include people that live on our street, work in our building or belong to our families.

Just look at the man who harassed Chris Witty - he was an estate agent. As app has said it costs money to but football tickets, travel to football matches and buy that much alcohol. If we pretend that only unemployed, illiterate men are hooligans then will allow those who are not to slip under the radar.

skodadoda · 12/07/2021 16:20

I doubt very much if any of the bad guys lead moral and upstanding lives away from football

I think you would be surprised how many of them do lead ‘respectable’ lives. Causing trouble at football matches is their idea of recreation.

whychangethehabitofalifetime · 12/07/2021 16:16

My DH is appalled by this behaviour. He's a huge football fan. Pre children he used to be part of the supporters club and had attended many World Cup and Euro tournaments over the years around the world. He has a few beers, he sings daft chants, he swaps 'banter' with friends regarding different teams that they support. What he doesn't do is behave like a thug or abuse anyone.

He's disgusted that as an England fan now he wouldn't dream of taking our children to a stadium to watch a game. He'll likely never share the game he loves with them (if they wanted to go, they're before still little atm) like his Dad did with him as a child because he (rightly) doesn't consider it a safe or appropriate environment for them.

We've just been talking about the behaviour of the 'fans' (they're not fans) and the abhorrent abuse that the team have suffered. Honestly in his circle of friends I do not know one of them, even the much more rowdy and juvenile ones - of which there are a few - who would damage property, abuse anyone or hurt anyone. They just want to go to the games, have fun and come home in one piece at the end of it.

I don't think these idiots are the norm for fans. They're thugs and reprobates looking for an excuse to behave badly. Obviously they must have families but to be honest if they behave like that publicly then their families and social circles are likely (not definitely!) not too bothered by this sort of thing and probably join them.

EverythingWillFallInLine · 12/07/2021 16:13

@Iknowtheanswer agree that there's always a crossover in personnel - some fans display elements of hooliganism if minded, some hooligans settle down and become legit fans.

But there's still an element of shout goes out, trouble goes down, and that's from the firms.

MotionActivatedDog · 12/07/2021 16:11

[quote ParsleyDill]**@MotionActivatedDog* and @AnotherKrampus*, but why are these civil servants, teachers and radiographers you list so unafraid of any employment consequences (which could involve dismissal for gross misconduct, breach of contract, impact on credibility of being able to discharge their role etc) for their violent and/or antisocial behaviour, given that they're clearly relatively invested in their careers?[/quote]
If love to know! Arrogance? There’s definitely that in abundance. The idea that they’ll always land on their feet even if they do get sacked they’ll sort themselves out with something else just as cushy. One person I know has been to prison for a racially aggravated assault. It wasn’t football related but same type of person as the others I’ve described. He was employed prior to going to prison, while he was inside his father started up a business doing the same work the son was doing before and when the son came out it was all handed over and he is making an absolute fortune as a business man with his own team of employees. Getting convicted and sent to prison actually improved his life and income. He hasn’t changed as a person though. Same arsehole he always was.

EverythingWillFallInLine · 12/07/2021 16:07

Btw when I say more loosely affiliated, I mean the clubs don't condone/need them but they're still around because they're a self perpetuating movement that's been there long enough that they have their own momentum, traditions, codes, shibboleths etc.

DeeCeeCherry · 12/07/2021 16:06

Yeah everyone knows but nobody knows them. Strange, that.

I've seen that a few have been outed on Twitter for disgusting racial remarks. One in particular a manager who works for Savills - racist comments, and 'jokes' about Brit wives being battered after the game.

It's men across the board, even though the powers that be would have us believe it's a 'limited intelligence lower working class' thing (not my descriptive, saw it written somewhere in relation to this).

Nobody's going to call out their dad/son/brother/nephew/cousin and so on, they'll go with the usual that it was self defence or just lads letting off steam it's all part of the beautiful game

Iknowtheanswer · 12/07/2021 16:06

I think that a lot of last night's trouble wasn't organised gangs (although I absolutely agree that gangs/firms were a massive cause of violence in the 80's 90's until they were cracked down on hard - I knew boys in my class at school who got sucked into our local team's firm, and one ended up spending time in prison as a result).

A lot of last night was sheer thuggery
As I said upthread, I know two boys who were there. I get on with them fine, but they have no respect for their parents or teachers. I am certain that my friend (one boy's mum, who is an absolutely lovely person) has no clue where he was, as he would've lied to her, but she always defends him anyway.

Think your classic "son can do no wrong" on the primary school threads. By secondary, he was always in detention, but not backed up at home because it was "always the teacher's fault".

Now, at 16, he's running around Wembley, pissed, until all hours, no doubt getting carried away with the violence.

babbaloushka · 12/07/2021 16:05

[quote FlaminEckVera]@Sandinmyknickers YANBU. This behaviour is putrid and vile, but I am actually wondering if the majority of it is orchestrated by far right factions, who have recruited people to make up twitter accounts specifically to abuse people of colour. Because I don't know a soul in real life who behaves this way, OR posts this kind of grim and nasty shit on social media. Not ONE.

I know it happens (and it HAS happened,) but I just don't know who these people are, and as I said, I am very suspicious about it all, and wonder if much of the racist abuse is orchestrated by far-right racist hate groups.

I really genuinely believe that the majority of white people are not racist, and all this shit is boiling my piss, because it's painting us all as racist bigots, and most of us are not.

Most of us are thoroughly disgusted and upset at the abuse aimed at the young black England players at last night's EuroCup final, and do NOT fit into the category of racist gammon, as some people have called white people today.

It is a minority of white people who are like this, thank God, but even ONE white person behaving like this, is one too many.

I really feel for these young black football players, and any other person of colour who receives racist abuse. But it's out of order to say or imply that all white people are racist and bigoted (as some people are saying on twitter, and have said on here today..) As I said, the majority of white people are disgusted by this behaviour.[/quote]
White people don't need defending, you don't need to proclaim that you're not gammon, if you weren't spewing racist vitriol at the black players, then they're not talking about you. Acting injured by anti-racism doesn't do much to ease tension, and your insistence that it is a minority sounds like a denial of the racism and xenophobia here. You might not see or experience it, but my family, and all the other ethnic minorities have a very clear view of just how prevalent racism is in the UK.

rainbowunicorn · 12/07/2021 16:05

@FloconDeNeige

So, this is actually women’s fault, then? WTAF? Can’t men take responsibility for their own atrocious behaviour?
What the hell are you talking about? Did you read the OP as your answer has nothing to do with it.
Waxonwaxoff0 · 12/07/2021 16:01

My DS is 8 so certainly wasn't him. I'm single and divorced, my ex husband does not like football and was working yesterday driving the fans around on the trains. I am NC with my dad, so I'd have no idea if he was there, he does have form for fighting but doubt he'd be in London.

ShitPoetryClub · 12/07/2021 15:55

DH, and both young adult DS's were here watching at home with me last night. My lads are more likely to be the victims of thuggery than participate in it.
Both are mixed race, one is also gay.
They know exactly the demographic of men who would be involved in these incidents. The same ones who were the bullies at school.

EverythingWillFallInLine · 12/07/2021 15:52

I've posted about this on another thread but been ignored so I'll share what I know here instead.

Hooligans are gang members. The gangs are firms associated with clubs. When football clubs were first established they were pretty closely affiliated with the finances of clubs. These finances tended to be from non establishment sources. (Remember, this was a time when "establishment" sources of money were pretty fucking ropey too what with slavery and all.) The firms were a way of protecting interests. They're more loosely affiliated now.

The same happened in other countries too. This isn't just an English thing.

So in Scotland you get the orange firms, in Italy the fascist firms, in Russia the neo nazi firms, in Colombia and Brazil the drug firms etc.

Hooligans are separate from fans. There is sometimes a crossover of personnel but the set up and motivations are different.

Hooligans are kind of like mercenaries in a way. Just as a mercenary will fight for a flag, a hooligan will fight for a club. It's the fighting that counts though. It's about territorial establishment and intimidation.

The club hooligans funnel into the national hooligans ie it's some of them but not all of them.

The FA here has actually done a decent job of rooting them out. They're way more of a problem in former Eastern Bloc countries and the Balkans. And ofc in some parts of South America they'll actually kill players and not just attack each other.

Youarestillintherunning · 12/07/2021 15:52

Not mine, but I am praying that the police find out who was involved and managed to make some arrests. Seeing the footage of Engliah fans attacking black people and Italian fans last night has honestly heartbroken me. It goes to show how close to the surface racism in this country really is. Absolutely devastating to see.

FlaminEckVera · 12/07/2021 15:49

@Sandinmyknickers YANBU. This behaviour is putrid and vile, but I am actually wondering if the majority of it is orchestrated by far right factions, who have recruited people to make up twitter accounts specifically to abuse people of colour. Because I don't know a soul in real life who behaves this way, OR posts this kind of grim and nasty shit on social media. Not ONE.

I know it happens (and it HAS happened,) but I just don't know who these people are, and as I said, I am very suspicious about it all, and wonder if much of the racist abuse is orchestrated by far-right racist hate groups.

I really genuinely believe that the majority of white people are not racist, and all this shit is boiling my piss, because it's painting us all as racist bigots, and most of us are not.

Most of us are thoroughly disgusted and upset at the abuse aimed at the young black England players at last night's EuroCup final, and do NOT fit into the category of racist gammon, as some people have called white people today.

It is a minority of white people who are like this, thank God, but even ONE white person behaving like this, is one too many.

I really feel for these young black football players, and any other person of colour who receives racist abuse. But it's out of order to say or imply that all white people are racist and bigoted (as some people are saying on twitter, and have said on here today..) As I said, the majority of white people are disgusted by this behaviour.

VettiyaIruken · 12/07/2021 15:47

Thugs are always thugs. They aren't decent men magically transformed by football. They are the loudmouthed yobs out on the piss. The ones getting pissed in magaluf, fighting and groping women.
Football is their excuse of the day. It's got nothing to do with the match itself and everything to do with the fact they are nasty, inadequate yobs who like to fight.

YellowandGreenToBeSeen · 12/07/2021 15:45

Coke. A lot of the behaviour is fuelled by a vile combination of alcohol and coke. Both require money. This sickening behaviour is not the work of the unemployed.

DasPepe · 12/07/2021 15:45

Hi OP. I made a similar comment on another thread.
The not all men/not all fans line is really not cracking it anymore. I see no difference between the football thugs and the guys who assaulted Chris Whitty.

Leary, full of entitlement, would take the credit but not contribute, sexist, aggressive, xenophobic, homophobic. . When they think they can get away with it.
These people aren’t like that ALL the time. But we have allowed a culture where there is no society pressure not to put your feet on seats, throw litter, spit and urinate in the street etc etc etc. and that pressure used to come from society including peers.
I’m just waiting for some of these culprits to be caught and the line round to block of people to say what a great person they are and they would do anything for anybody blah blah blah.
Accountability is severely missing

ChainJane · 12/07/2021 15:40

@x2boys

I used to go to school with someone who received a, prison sentence about 20 years ago for football hooliganism, he was always a bully It's a subculture of people, and I bet most don't even care about football their main aim is violence
I think you and a previous poster who said "they're not football fans" are both wrong.

Being a hooligan/thug does not prevent someone being a football fan too. Many of the thugs genuinely love their team, almost as much as they love the violence and destruction they create when opportunities arrive.

The idiots who tried to storm Wembley yesterday were highly unlikely to have been there trying to force their way in if they had no interest in football.

Time and again politicians and the media claim hooligans aren't true football supporters. That's utter nonsense. Their love for their team is genuine. Loving a team and being a thug are no more incompatible than loving your team and being a stamp collector or model train enthusiast are.

Personally I think the thuggery has a lot to do with wanting to exercise control. They are testosterone-fuelled louts who are used to getting their own way, whether it's beating the wife if she burns your dinner or having a punch-up in the pub because someone looked at you funny. With football, especially when your team is involved in a final or in a position to win at title - you have zero control over what happens. You are weak, you are powerless. The team's PR department can make sure the players and managers spout the usual bollocks about the fans being the 12th man on the pitch, but ultimately as the football fan you are powerless to influence the game unless you smuggle a laser pen in.

The violence is a way to show that actually, you do have control of something at least. It shows that you matter, that people can't ignore you. Especially if you lose, but even if you win.

It's an idiotic stance to take, but then the thugs weren't exactly going to be watching Mastermind instead, were they.

Boood · 12/07/2021 15:36

Because in our culture, there are two ways for men to express their anger that other men turn a blind eye to. The first is getting drunk and abusing women, and the second is getting drunk and abusing an opposing football team and its fans. I’m pretty sure that there’s an enormous overlap between the two, so the answer to the question is, these men are everywhere. And the men around them stay out of it because they don’t see the problem, or don’t see it as their business, and the women appease them so that they don’t become the target.

remy3 · 12/07/2021 15:36

I think there is an element of these individuals who just go out hoping for a fight - they don’t care about the football or who wins or loses. It’s like a tribal psyche, or something like that? They get excited in the anonymity of crowds. They want to smash up people and property and use the football as an excuse?

remy3 · 12/07/2021 15:31

But if you have a job you’re reasonably happy with and you have children and a family etc, why would you do this? Surely you have too much to lose? What is the actual point?

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 12/07/2021 15:29

@Flugbustingbiz

Lol all the defensive posters - you're sure it wasn't your H breaking into Wembley Grin

No one would admit it op! I was watching them all on Twitter yesterday and was wondering who procreates with these cretins, someone must

Ive video evidence 🙂
x2boys · 12/07/2021 15:24

I used to go to school with someone who received a, prison sentence about 20 years ago for football hooliganism, he was always a bully
It's a subculture of people, and I bet most don't even care about football their main aim is violence

Swipe left for the next trending thread