Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU Buying ex out

57 replies

Charlotte7706 · 11/07/2021 22:06

I'm in the process of buying my ex out of our mortgage & want to ensure I'm not being unreasonable.

House valued: £250k
Remaining mortgage: £173920.77
Net property value: £76,079.23
His share of Deed of Trust: £13,000
My share of Deed of trust: £66,000
Remaining value in property:
-£2920.77
Early repayment/exit fee:£6210.75
Remaining value in property:
-£9,131.52 (loss)

My solicitor friend advised we should split the loss.

However, I've offered to still pay him his original £13k & let him take the expensive TV system in light of me keeping the rest of the furniture.

The only furniture of significant value (bar the TV system I'm giving him) is some garden furniture which cost £2800 & a grill hut that cost £2700 (which he bought with money received from the sale of his car). He's back living with his parents so it's easier for me to retain furniture.

I'm (my family) are buying out the mortgage, paying off the remaining value owed on a further advance (£6k), paying the £6k early exit fee & the solicitors fees (currently unknown).

We both earned similarly & put money into the savings account (which has £44k but we owe £50k on the further advance which needs to be repaid).

However, he got bonuses (£200 extra than me a month here & there) so he might've put more in monthly than me.

On the other hand, I put in £33k to renovate the house when we first moved in, September 2017. I also put £5000 in from my grandmother last year.

He left me (out of the blue, after 7 happy years) to deal with a half renovated house, all the responsibility of canceling the wedding he wanted, sorting all this legal house/mortgage stuff, medical problems & our bills on my own ...but seems to feel he is the victim, as though I somehow orchestrated his leaving me so I could take the house from him. The house I put the majority of the capital into.

In all honesty, I strongly suspect he's had a breakdown as he's behaving completely out of character (but you can't help those who won't help themselves). He was struggling at work, quit his job but went back (against my advice), he then started drinking more & had begun shouting & smashing things up round the house in tantrums whilst at work (we were both working from home). I did my best to support him & he was always so clear about how much he loved me & our life....however, he has now decided after a bad week that the problem is that he doesn't love me. Given how he's acted, I'm inclined to believe him; the kind stable man I loved is gone & I'm happy to see the back of this one.

I have no concerns that I did anything to deserve this, as I was incredibly good to him (too good by all accounts, which has been nice to hear) but it's still hurtful to be treated this way. I'm just anxious that my hurt hasn't impacted my ability to be fair, as I want to keep my dignity.

I'm trying to get the fairest deal for him, whilst also ensuring I don't lose my home because he wants an unrealistic return on investment (he feels he should get a profit over £20k, even though the house doesn't have any profit).

Sorry for the long winded question & probably unnecessary details but does my suggestion about the £13k & TV sound unreasonable? I gather if we followed the legal route, he'd have to absorb half the £9,131.52 loss & pay solicitor fees, so he would likely come out even worse off.

I really don't want my hurt to make me a bad person.

Thank you

OP posts:
Gemma2019 · 12/07/2021 14:01

When does the early repayment charge end?

BillMasen · 12/07/2021 14:00

Something doesn’t add up or im missing something

House was bought for 217, you put 66 in, he put 13 in. So mortgage roughly 138?

It’s now worth 250 with mortgage of 174 ish?

You invested another 33 in renovations, not added to the mortgage?

I can understand on the face of it him thinking it’s gone up so there should be a profit? What am I missing?

Charlotte7706 · 12/07/2021 13:51

Yes, I guess I should count myself lucky that I'm in the financial position to be able to offer to "play nice". The house is half renovated, with no ceiling & half dismantled coloured bathrooms, so the notion we'd make a profit on it (after only 3+ years) never crossed my mind. It's funny how things are blessings in disguise, as we had a few setbacks (pipe burst, the ceiling fell in & they found asbestos), which meant we had to delay finishing the renovations...if we'd finished the work, based on house prices on our street, we would be in profit & I'd have more of a struggle to buy him out. Thanks for your input as I do need to hear that I'm too sift sometimes (as I often feel like I'm being too harsh)

OP posts:
Morechocolatethanbarbara · 12/07/2021 13:23

I guarantee you he will feel hard done by and be telling people that you swindled him of you give him £0, £10,000 or £100,000.

The absolute best thing is to get it sorted legally and give him/get him to pay the legal amount due.

You will be MUCH better off giving a solicitor a few thousand to sort it all properly than leaving the door open to accusations and repercussions further down the line.

Get a solicitor to work out the figures and resolve it that way, you won't just be better off financially, but you'll be mentally better off too as he can't argue that he was short-changed if the legal system (rather than you) decides how much he gets/pays.

Caramellatteplease · 12/07/2021 13:18

Also check your deed of trust usually mortgage+fees gets paid before deed of trust

Caramellatteplease · 12/07/2021 13:14

Tbh in his shoes I wouldn't agree to a sale. One or other of you needs to hold onto the house and pay rent on the others share.

Or you need to sell to an independent 3rd party

Caramellatteplease · 12/07/2021 13:12

How have you made such a humongous loss on the property in a rising market?!?! How much did you buy it for and when?

Either you massively overpaid initially or the valuation is massively underinflated

FinallyHere · 12/07/2021 13:00

Hi, sorry you are going through this. I think you are bending over backwards to be fair, possibly even to your own detriment.

I agree with PP that you should not set out everything you are prepared to give, in your first proposal. One thing I have seen over and over is that one partner makes a sensible suggestion for a split, the other makes outrageous requests so that the negotiation is then conducted between the sensible and the outrageous offers, which is absolutely not fair.

Keep some 'jam' back in your initial proposal so that you can offer that in order to close the negotiation. Your backstop would be taking it to court where he will get a lot less than you are offering.

All the best.

Rangoon · 12/07/2021 12:58

Maybe your ex can get the idea that the house went up in value but there were significant amounts spent on it which were borrowed and have to be paid back. You have £6,000 of the advance to pay back, plus the early break fee of £6,000 and from the figures it would seem that your "main mortgage" has also risen. So the rise in price was funded by borrowed money - in fact you got a very poor return given the money spent on the place. There was at least the £50,000 advance spent on it as well as your inheritances of £38,000 but the rise in value was only £34,000. I'd be a bit careful about overcapitalising in the future. By the way, far too many women who are taught to "play nice" and "keep their dignity" seem to be content to take less than their due and that has far-reaching consequences through their lives, it affects their lifestyle and whether they are comfortable or scrimping and when they can afford to retire and what sort of retirement they can have.

Hoppinggreen · 12/07/2021 10:56

This must be heartbreaking but it sounds like you are pretty switched on and have good family support so I’m sure you will be able to make a fantastic new life for yourself (and the cats)
Just don’t let him come back when he wakes up and realises what he threw away

Charlotte7706 · 12/07/2021 10:49

Self medicating with weed & cider, so he probably is suppressing his smarts. It's been incredibly painful to watch someone I loved & was so proud of throw his life away & become someone I'm ashamed of. However, everyone's kind support had really made me feel better, so thank you

OP posts:
Charlotte7706 · 12/07/2021 10:45

Thank you, that's so kind ♥️

OP posts:
Charlotte7706 · 12/07/2021 10:32

Thank you ♥️

OP posts:
Charlotte7706 · 12/07/2021 10:31

Thank you, yes, we got a further advance to extend & repair the house, which is why we've got more to pay back. I was worried I onky felt he was behaving appallingly because he'd hurt me, so I feel bolstered that it doesn't appear to be the case

OP posts:
Charlotte7706 · 12/07/2021 10:29

Thank you so much! No children, I thought there was going to be a child involved at one point, which was scary but it's just me and 4 cats (& having seen this behaviour from him I count myself lucky, as he's shown himself to be a coward when it counts). Thank you for your support ♥️

OP posts:
billy1966 · 12/07/2021 08:39

@RealBecca

Dont let "keeping your dignity" cost you thousands. Youve sought legal advice amd put am offer on the table. His family aren't legal advice. Get him to come up with a professional counter offer
This.

Do not allow him to cost you money he isn't entitled to.

Flowers
RealBecca · 12/07/2021 07:54

Dont let "keeping your dignity" cost you thousands. Youve sought legal advice amd put am offer on the table. His family aren't legal advice. Get him to come up with a professional counter offer

Rangoon · 12/07/2021 07:33

If @ Aprilx means pro rating based on their protected amounts, I don't think this makes any sense given that it would have the result that the person who has the largest protected amount bears more of the loss. I'd split the loss equally. I agree with your solicitor about that. But really who cares if you are fair? His welfare is no longer your concern and your priority should be retaining your house. He has behaved appallingly and you put the majority of the money into that property given £66,000 was protected and you seem to have put in extra inheritances of £38,000. Given that the protected amounts of £79,000 are greater than the equity even with a price rise, did you increase the mortgage or what? I think that is what he finds confusing - how you own less of the house despite the price rise. By the way there is a lot of daylight between your expectations and his - don't cave early. Maybe keep giving him the £13,000 and keeping the furniture could be a fallback position for you so he feels he has managed to get a concession out of you.

Aprilx · 12/07/2021 05:06

*£250k

Aprilx · 12/07/2021 05:05

If I were proposing something I would firstly work out the asset value which is the £76079 less the early repayment of £6210 = £69869.

You don’t have enough to repay both protected amounts, so I would prorate it which would mean he gets about £11500, hence he is absorbing some of the property loss. My only caveat is that you both agree on the valuation which all this hangs off, if the £250 is understated then he is being short changed.

I would deal with split of furniture separately, but you keeping most furniture whilst he keeps the TV system sounds like a good starting proposal as presume he has no immediate need for the furnitur.

SheSaidHummingbird · 12/07/2021 02:21

@Charlotte7706

Thank you so much, it says we'd split the remaining property value 50/50, so I assume that'd include splitting the loss (though, I'm happy to not factor that in....I think in the long run, he's lost enough from walking out; he's lost a brilliant partner, an easy life & is now back living with his parents)
"I think in the long run, he's lost enough from walking out; he's lost a brilliant partner"

You're my new hero.

caringcarer · 12/07/2021 01:10

Be thankful you did not marry him. Your offer is more than generous. He sounds simple tbh if he can't understand the figures you have set out. Is he disputing the figures? Does he not agree with the Valuation? Does he realise their is a penalty on the mortgage? Is he usually this dopey? Is he talking any medication that dims his wits? If he refuses your offer you will have to go to court then their will be legal fees too. I hope you can settle this quickly and move onwards.

Charlotte7706 · 12/07/2021 00:46

Thanks, the Deed of Trust has the fixed figures (so I get the £66k I put in & he gets the £13k he put in) then it says any net balance then due will be shared between us. However, the net balance is negative.

To be honest, he's being a nitwit, we bought in 2017 for £216k & it's valued at £250k now; he thinks because the house value increased, we'll get a profit. He genuinely doesn't understand & appears to be getting bad advice from friends, so now thinks he's being ripped off, no matter how much I try to simplify it for him 🤦🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
LunaMuffinTop · 12/07/2021 00:43

YANBU your being more than fair with what your offering him he’s the one who chose to walk away he can’t act the victim when all this is down to him tell him to either stop being a dick suck it up and take the offer or you will take him to court and he will walk away with a lot less. So sorry your going through all this OP. Good luck with it all certainly sounds like you’ve had a very lucky escape and thankfully you didn’t marry him so cutting ties with him is going to be easier than if you where married. You don’t mention any children in your OP so I’m assuming there are no kids to consider in all this apart from the man child ex.

LittleOwl153 · 12/07/2021 00:24

How long have you had the house and how much did you pay for it? I'm assuming not long and very similar to what it's worth now?

Or is he being a complete nitwit and assuming that an estate agent valuation of £20k more than your paid for it means a £20k profit for him?