Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To install an open fireplace?

36 replies

Arrrghh · 11/07/2021 10:02

Just bought a victorian terraced house and want to open up the fireplace. We always had an open fire when I was a child and I love it, it feels like a presence in the room. I live alone and I find it comforting.

I know heat-wise it is inefficient, but I actually don’t want it for the heat, it’s having the open flames that I like. I also know that there are rules coming in about what we’re allowed to burn due to air pollution, and am more than happy to only burn approved fuel.

But do you think iabu? Is this a really backward thing to do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Flylilly · 11/07/2021 13:14

We live in a Victorian terrace and reinstated the open fire. It cost us approximately £2k for a flue liner, slate hearth, reclaimed cast iron fire surround and we got a mantle from friends. I can honestly say it’s the best thing we’ve done and we don’t regret it at all- it’s lovely to have although we don’t actually need it for heating. I do worry about it from an environmental point of view and am unsure if we would do it now for this reason but I don’t regret it in any way.

xsjrx · 11/07/2021 12:41

We got rid of an old school Art Deco fireplace and put a multi fuel stove in at start of year. I'm used to an open fire too as my folks have one, they also have a multi fuel in another room. We found less mess and it's shut off so no draughts but as PPs have said you can get things to block...chimney plates for open fires. Happy hunting :)

TheSmallAssassin · 11/07/2021 12:35

@Arrrghh - from 2025 new build homes won't be allowed gas boilers, I think there will be a move to heat pumps? Not sure, but we will have to start using less gas to meet our emissions targets so I am thinking that we shouldn't be adding more gas appliances to our house.

MaskingForIt · 11/07/2021 12:31

@TheSmallAssassin

I want one to just look at the flames too, so we were thinking of a gas flame effect fireplace, but given that gas will be going in the next decade, I am wondering about a bio ethanol grate, anyone got one of those?
Gas isn’t going to go in the next decade. Millions of people rely on it for their heating and hot water and they can’t all afford to replace it with an air source heat pump.
Arrrghh · 11/07/2021 12:24

@farawayplanet that sounds like a good idea!

OP posts:
Arrrghh · 11/07/2021 12:23

I think the harmful emissions are more to do with what you butn, aren’t they? I’m happy to burn ethanol logs or whatever is eco friendly!

OP posts:
farawayplanet · 11/07/2021 12:21

Get a multi fuel stove instead. These allow you to burn smokeless fuel and you can put the odd seasoned log on for effect as well if you like.

They're cleaner, less dusty and more efficient than open fires.

Dongdingdong · 11/07/2021 12:18

When had to have the house re-roofed we were at the same time advised to either rebuild top of chimney or remove. We went for the remove option. We still have the chimney breast and fire surround etc and don't intend to remove that.

A shame you removed it IMO - I always think an older house without a chimney looks odd, especially when neighbouring houses still retain theirs. I also think it's rather strange to keep the fire surround when you don't have a chimney!

Livingintheclouds · 11/07/2021 12:17

I have had log burners in last couple homes and love them. However, the recent press about the harmful emissions (which are worse in open fires) means I won't be getting one in my next home. It has a gas fire though, and I'm happy with that.
As for new regulations about gas in the future- it will be like electric cars. New systems will have to be electric, but you won't have to get rid of gas if you already have it (eventually they will stop selling it though, forcing you to change)!

Sallycinnamum · 11/07/2021 12:13

We opened our fireplace up in our 30s semi and it cost £500 to put the new fireplace, grate and hearth in.

I absolutely love our fireplace and in the winter it's so comforting. I buy coffee logs from Amazon as they're really efficient and take ages to burn through.

The fireplace is one of the things I love lost about our house and when it's cold outside and the fire is going I don't want to be anywhere else!

Notcontent · 11/07/2021 12:09

They look pretty it they are really bad for your health and for the environment.

AgathaX · 11/07/2021 12:04

We have both an open fire and a word burner in our house. The wood burner does give off heat quicker, but it's a hungry beast and get through lots of wood. The open fire uses less coal, money wise, and it's so lovely to have lit in winter. We use it most nights in winter. We live in a very old, cold house though, so it is fairly essential.

Arrrghh · 11/07/2021 12:01

@TheSmallAssassin gosh will gas really be going in the next decade do you think? What will everyone do about their central heating systems?

OP posts:
Arrrghh · 11/07/2021 11:58

Thanks! I actually have a study next to the living room and was thinking of having a log burner in there! The chimney breast has an ugly vent thing in it that I want to get rid of, so I don’t want to leave it as it is. I thought a logburner in both of my reception rooms might be overkill? It’s only a small terraced house! I thought if the study had the logburner, the living room could have a fireplace.
It does sound like it will be very expensive to have both done though 😬

OP posts:
TheSmallAssassin · 11/07/2021 11:51

I want one to just look at the flames too, so we were thinking of a gas flame effect fireplace, but given that gas will be going in the next decade, I am wondering about a bio ethanol grate, anyone got one of those?

OneEpisode · 11/07/2021 11:38

As pp, I’ve changed the ancient open fire to a wood burner (inset). The house is just so, so much warmer. Less spot. And uses far less wood.

GOODCAT · 11/07/2021 11:36

Our house had one working fireplace left when we moved in. Used it once, but found I didn't enjoy the smoke. We had as open fire as a child so thought I would love it, but would avoid it now.

When had to have the house re-roofed we were at the same time advised to either rebuild top of chimney or remove. We went for the remove option. We still have the chimney breast and fire surround etc and don't intend to remove that.

If you haven't spent an evening with one recently, you might want to sit next to someone else's for a night first to make sure it doesn't adversely affect you. I never thought it would me.

Brainwave89 · 11/07/2021 11:35

I have had both an open fire and a log burner over the years (I live in rural Norfolk). I would strongly recommend a log burner. So much easier, little mess and really chucks out heat. Also quite economical to run so worth the investment. The law no says you cannot burn wet wood, so you need to be careful where you source supplies from, but either smokeless fuel or dry wood is fine.

DdraigGoch · 11/07/2021 11:31

I removed a gas fire, opened up the fireplace from it's 1930s size to it's pre-Victorian proportions and installed a wood burner. Work was quite extensive, including a new hearth and a new lintel (original was removed when the fireplace had been filled in) which meant getting acro props in. I've not even added up how much it cost in the end but it must have been more than £1.5k for the building work, plus £1.8k to purchase and install the stove itself. Well worth it though.

You'd still get the effect of the flames with a woodburning stove as you're after with an open fire.

crimsonlake · 11/07/2021 11:28

I have an open fire which I love, but real fires are the most expensive form of heating so I rarely use it. This means due to the fact I have a huge room I rely on radiators to heat the space up and it is never really that warm.
I am kind of swaying towards putting a gas fire in which would mean when I get home after work I have immediate heat.

OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 11/07/2021 11:20

Love ours. Our old house was solid fuel heating and while I liked having a stove i still missed an open fire. When we bought this place we uncovered an original fire in one of the bedrooms and had it moved to the living room. I love lighting a fire at the weekend in the winter. The fireplace has a throat plate but that by itself isn't great for stopping the air flow so I use a chimney sheep too which does the job nicely.

MaskingForIt · 11/07/2021 11:13

Do it. The whole “less efficient “ thing is a load of bollocks. I remember 10 or 15 years ago when all the wannabes were installing wood burning stoves and going on about “how efficient” they were, I would make a point of asking how much money they saved compared to an open fire, or how many fewer logs they used. Funnily enough not a single one could answer.

Aprilx · 11/07/2021 11:07

I have an open fire place, it is lovely to have a fire in winter. However if it wasn’t already there, I wouldn’t have put it in, it limits what you can do with the room layout.

Arrrghh · 11/07/2021 10:31

Thanks, glad most of you think it’s reasonable, will look into the chimney flaps!

By the way, those who have done this, how much roughly has it cost you to donthe whole job start to finish?

Thanks! Smile

OP posts:
Babdoc · 11/07/2021 10:26

As PPs have said, get a fireplace that includes a chimney flap, which you close when the fire is unlit, so there are no drafts and no heat loss.
I installed one in my modern (1970’s) house, after a ten hour power cut in a Scottish winter with no heating when the temp was minus 15C outside!
Since then it has been lovely to sit beside on winter evenings - and invaluable when the gas engineers had to cut off my supply (and therefore my central heating) for ten days while dealing with a leak.

Swipe left for the next trending thread