Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU disabled DC and school trip

333 replies

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 00:10

My DC class is going on a school trip at the end of term. They school are refusing to take them due to disability ( tube fed )
We have had medical clearance from health team and she has a trained 1–1.
AIBU to believe ( this is now nearly 4 years of never attending a school trip ) that it’s getting ridiculous. She is so sad about it and waited a long time to go.

OP posts:
thing47 · 11/07/2021 12:45

Her right to go does not depend on whether her mother can go too – that is explicitly against the law (someone even posted the link for you).

We got endless excuses: 'it's not fair on the staff/not fair on the other kids/she won't enjoy it/we can't accommodate her need for private space to administer her medicines' etc etc etc. We just kept telling the HT that it was illegal to exclude her, on repeat until they got the message.

DumplingsAndStew · 11/07/2021 12:45

@scrambledcustard

She's not being left behind. She can go.

No she can't, because her mother isn't going.

You'd argue the sky was yellow, too, wouldn't you?

Spikeyball · 11/07/2021 12:45

" if OP takes this to court, she will be asked why she wouldn't meet the school half way."

A sendist disability discrimination tribunal won't say that. What is your experience and training in special educational needs education law?

DumplingsAndStew · 11/07/2021 12:43

@scrambledcustard

Also if OP takes this to court, she will be askedwhyshe wouldn't meet the school half way.

The Equality Act and the statutory guidance for "Supporting pupils at school with medical conditions" (as linked upthread) completely disagree with your 'opinion'.

Exclusion on this basis is not legal, no matter how many times you insist it's okay.

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 12:40

The school aren’t trying to work with mum at all. The school are trying to take the easy option for themselves.

Do you really think it’s right that a child can’t access part of their education without mum there? Do you not think it’s important that young people get to experience things away from their Mum?

GaspGulpScream · 11/07/2021 12:39

I'm shocked at some of the responses on here. Some people should be ashamed of themselves
The trip should be for everyone
I've done lots of school trips with children who have additional needs and it's really no big deal. She certainly won't want her mum coming along. Bloody hell what kid would

scrambledcustard · 11/07/2021 12:37

@NoSquirrels

It depends on where they are going. A school environment is totally different to a school trip to some where they have never been.

Good teachers will have visited the place they want to take a trip with an eye to assessing its suitability and risk factors.

Good teachers will plan a trip with the least able of the class in mind.

Good schools will not accept teachers planning trips that don’t include everyone.

It’s basic bullshit to say it’s not possible to include 1 child ever on trips unless a parent is available.

Plan different trips that are doable without the parent coming, with the 1-1 doing 1-1 that they’re trained for and capable of doing, and the adult ratio made up by other parent volunteers if extra TAs or teachers are not available.

What does it teach the kids in class that one of them is always left behind? They might want to reflect on what lesson is most valuable to the majority - whatever’s at the end of that school trip, or fostering a social environment where everybody is valued and included.

OP, if your child was in my class I’d be right by your side insisting they change the trip.

She's not being left behind. She can go.
scrambledcustard · 11/07/2021 12:35

[quote DumplingsAndStew]@scrambledcustard

And no one here really knows to what extent the childs needs are.

You are wrong. The OP knows what the child's needs are, and so does the child's medical professional.

They have both deemed it safe for the child to attend this trip, and neither have stipulated this is only on the basis of having the OP present.

But you know better, and the OP is just being cruel and skiving off. Obviously.[/quote]
It doesn't matter what the mother or the hospital have said. The school can't turn around and say 'but mum said it was ok' if there was ever a disaster. They have to do their own risk assessment completely independent of mum and hospital because the buck stops with them.

The school are trying to work with mum this isn't a blanket "no"

Also if OP takes this to court, she will be asked why she wouldn't meet the school half way.

NoSquirrels · 11/07/2021 12:28

It depends on where they are going. A school environment is totally different to a school trip to some where they have never been.

Good teachers will have visited the place they want to take a trip with an eye to assessing its suitability and risk factors.

Good teachers will plan a trip with the least able of the class in mind.

Good schools will not accept teachers planning trips that don’t include everyone.

It’s basic bullshit to say it’s not possible to include 1 child ever on trips unless a parent is available.

Plan different trips that are doable without the parent coming, with the 1-1 doing 1-1 that they’re trained for and capable of doing, and the adult ratio made up by other parent volunteers if extra TAs or teachers are not available.

What does it teach the kids in class that one of them is always left behind? They might want to reflect on what lesson is most valuable to the majority - whatever’s at the end of that school trip, or fostering a social environment where everybody is valued and included.

OP, if your child was in my class I’d be right by your side insisting they change the trip.

wavecatcher · 11/07/2021 12:22

SENDIAS are really helpful and will help you fight this, kick up a huge fuss honestly this is awful on the schools part.

FreezerBird · 11/07/2021 12:20

@scrambledcustard here is a list of some of the things my daughter (tube fed, poor balance, heart condition, Deaf, speech delay, learning difficulties, continence issues) has done on school trips (including residentials):

Kayaking
Stand-up paddle boarding
Terrifyingly high zip wire over a lake
Abseiling
Climbing
High ropes course thing
Rollercoasters (not really scary ones but she was little at the time. Heaven knows what she'd want to do now)
Laser quest shooty things in the dark
Archery
Go-karting (apparently she's a bit of a speed demon)
Assault courses

As well as swimming every week in primary with the other kids.

Her tube has never come out. When she does things where that feels a bit risky (like assault course type stuff where you have to pull yourself along the ground on your stomach) her TA made the radical adjustment of... sticking a bit of tape over it. All good.

I've never been on any of these trips (she'd be mortified) and neither have school asked me to go.

It doesn't feel like OP's daughter's school is really trying.

1DoesNotSimplyWalkIntoMordor · 11/07/2021 12:20

The school are really tying themselves up in knots over this.

The child has an EHCP, a funded 1-1 and written confirmation from Medical Professionals that there is no reason why the child cannot go on the trip.

The school are saying that the child requires 2-1, this is the schools problem to solve not that of the OP.

The school are also saying that the TA is going to be used for the general staffing ratio, therefore will not be going for the sole purpose of supporting the child as per the EHCP so the child won't have 2-1 support anyway even if the OP goes (which she can't do).

This is direct discrimination, a direct contravention of Equality Act 2010, and is maladministration.

If the child remains in school then they must provide an alternative 1-1, if they don't that is also maladministration

If the school state that they don't have a TA to support her 1-1 and she can't go to school, then that is also maladministration.

This needs challenging.

OP, take a look at the IPSEA and SOS!SEN websites they both have good advice and model letters and the relevant sections of the Equality Act that you can use to challenge it, in the meantime email the head confirming what has been said, start the complaints process now, this starts a paper trail which you will need to escalate this through the correct channels, your dd has potentially another 3? years at this school and if you don't challenge it then it will continue.

I had exactly the same issues with my Son's school 10 years ago (direct discrimination and victimisation).
Initially they took him on trips with his 1-1, then said that he couldn't go unless I went at the same time removing his 1-1 to use her as general staff - child ratio, then refused to take him unless I transported him to/from the location in my own car, then they refused to allow him on the trips altogether whilst also saying that he couldn't go into school instead because their was no TA for him (at this point he was funded for 32.5 hours per week and had extra funding for 2-1 when necessary). Their arguments for this discrimination were weak to non existent.

Good luck OP.

HereticFanjo · 11/07/2021 12:17

Your child's one to one is hers if she does full hours with your child. However the LSA might be being shared between two children. If solely there for your daughter they are using her provision to make up numbers and excluding her in the process. This is totally wrong. They need another staff member there. I really would escalate this up to and including legal action if necessary but check that the LSA is solely there for your child.

SusannahSophia · 11/07/2021 12:17

It’s not legal and the school not following the statutory guidance. There have been previous legal actions taken against such schools to provide precedent.

Complain to the governors following the school’s complaint procedure as it hasn’t been resolved by the SLT on this and previous occasions.

The guidance is as linked by a PP, assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/803956/supporting-pupils-at-school-with-medical-conditions.pdf

School trips are specifically mentioned, including on pages 22 and 23

‘ Unacceptable practice
25. Governing bodies should ensure that the school’s policy is explicit about what practice is not acceptable...
... • prevent children from participating, or create unnecessary barriers to children participating in any aspect of school life, including school trips, e.g. by requiring parents to accompany the child.’

It’s there in black and white. They have no excuse.

DanceFortheSummer · 11/07/2021 12:17

This is awful, YADNU OP.

My DD has some medical needs which include a mobility problem, she's about to go into Year 3 and apart from the very first trip in Reception so that they could see how things needed to be handled outside of school I've never had to attend, and there's been no question DD would go. I might have to have a pre-trip meeting so that they can explain whose going (adults) and who DD will be with but that's about it.

My DD is at risk of falling and fracturing a hip or ankle, but school deal with it. No talks of ambulances or 2-1. She has 1-1 on trips but not in school. It's in her EHCP as such (she's with an adult at all times at school but sometimes has 1 or 2 other DC with her).

I'd be seriously considering a different school.

LincolnshireYellowBelly · 11/07/2021 12:14

The 1-1 is there for your child’s needs and will be funded because of her needs. It is 100% discrimination if she cannot go, and this definitely needs to be escalated. Ask to see the risk assessment of the trip, and how your daughter impacts the trip. Ask to see what adjustments they will need to put in place in order to make the trip viable. If they cannot make any adjustments then complain.

Sleepyblueocean · 11/07/2021 12:13

"This child might be medically ok to go on trip but her needs are complex and the school feel this is too high risk for them to manage it alone."

If a parent can do it then another trained adult can do it. It is incredibly risky for a child to expect their parents to be the only people who can meet their medical or other needs related to disability.

DumplingsAndStew · 11/07/2021 12:13

@scrambledcustard

And no one here really knows to what extent the childs needs are.

You are wrong. The OP knows what the child's needs are, and so does the child's medical professional.

They have both deemed it safe for the child to attend this trip, and neither have stipulated this is only on the basis of having the OP present.

But you know better, and the OP is just being cruel and skiving off. Obviously.

thing47 · 11/07/2021 12:12

Oh sorry, I see it's not a residential trip, just a day one. Even more ridiculous then!

thing47 · 11/07/2021 12:10

OP, this is illegal. Ignore all those saying that the school is being reasonable or has the right to override The Equality Act for health and safety reasons or any other such rubbish as they clearly don't understand the law.

FWIW I have been there, done that and got the T-shirt. A school must make accommodations for disabled children to go on school trips, attend musical concerts, play in sports matches and go on residential trips. There is no exclusion clause.

Whether a child with a disability should go on a residential trip is a pertinent question – but it is a question for the medical professionals and the parents, not the school. In this instance, if the medical professionals are happy for the child to go on the trip, and the child and her mother are both happy for her to do so, she cannot be excluded from it.

Of course, a school always has the option to cancel a trip entirely; what it cannot do is discriminate against an individual child. This is all enshrined in law, you need to tell the school they are acting illegally.

galaxyfairy · 11/07/2021 12:04

That can't be legal can it? All children should have equal access to education regardless of disability. I'd take it further than the school tbh.

AlternativePerspective · 11/07/2021 12:00

School is respite. Parents are denied restpite care on the basis that school is seen as their respite.

The time when the child is at school, (where all other children are,) with a 1-1 is considered the time for parents to be allowed time to themselves. So if they want time to themselves in addition to that then tough shit, because the LA are already providing respite in the form of an education, except when the school deem that to not be possible and want the parent to come along.

Now go and educate yourself. You’re just embarrassing now, and are coming across as really an unpleasant person.

Stath · 11/07/2021 11:57

Absolute bastards.

Some excellent advice on this thread @Manic20201 as well as some unfortunate ignorant claptrap from certain posters Angry

The school are also ‘stealing’ provision from your daughter by using the 1:1 on trips when DD isn’t there.

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 11:55

You would imagine wrong then.

Ds has been tube fed for the past 3 years. He can play and do whatever he wants. It has only come out twice in that time (fully inflated somehow!) neither of them where while playing and it was just a sign that he was ready for the next size up.

ExitThisWay · 11/07/2021 11:55

It’s exhausting just reading this thread. I can’t imagine what it must be like to have a Disabled child and have to fight for them just to be able to go on a school day trip. I can’t believe other people think the original poster should take a day off work / re arrange things that are to do with her child’s care so she can attend.
We have disability legislation for a reason. The school are acting unlawfully. In our society we say this shouldn’t happen. It’s awful that the original poster has to fight this. It shouldn’t be the case.

Swipe left for the next trending thread