Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU disabled DC and school trip

333 replies

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 00:10

My DC class is going on a school trip at the end of term. They school are refusing to take them due to disability ( tube fed )
We have had medical clearance from health team and she has a trained 1–1.
AIBU to believe ( this is now nearly 4 years of never attending a school trip ) that it’s getting ridiculous. She is so sad about it and waited a long time to go.

OP posts:
scrambledcustard · 11/07/2021 13:34

@thing47

The equality act doesn't over rule health and safety regulations.

It absolutely does in a case like this. It is exactly what the 2010 Equality Act was designed to do, to place disability discrimination above such issues as as health and safety regulations.

There aren't any exemptions or exceptions, it's not a grey area which organisations can disregard. Take it from someone who has personally fought this battle with an ignorant school.

Your wrong.

Although the Equality Act 2010 prohibits discrimination because of the protected characteristic of sex, para.2 of sch.22 to the Act in effect provides that any action taken to comply with health and safety legislation that concerns the protection of women in relation to pregnancy or maternity, or any other circumstances that give rise to risks that specifically affect women, will not amount to unlawful discrimination. Similarly, para.1 of sch.22 to the Equality Act 2010 in effect provides that any action taken to comply with health and safety legislation will not amount to discrimination because of the following protected characteristics: age, disability, religion or belief, sex or sexual orientation

And this is why the school have now said its 'health and safety' because they know the legalities of it.

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 13:33

To answer a few more questions.
The trip is a day trip no residential, local ( they have a school bus and it’s around 15 minute drive )
The trio it self is outdoors probably equal to that of going to the park but without the climbing frames.

OP posts:
thing47 · 11/07/2021 13:33

They have adjusted. The asked the parent to go. Just like parents who are asked to go on trip when their children may need insulin injections.

Ah, you've now stumbled onto an area where I am, unfortunately, the world's expert Smile.

You're conflating 2 subtly separate issues here. You are correct that the school has no responsibility to supply medical expertise, so in the case of an insulin-dependent diabetic either the child itself has to be able to check their blood sugars and administer injections, or a parent or other adult has to be prepared to attend in order to do so.

However, that cannot legally be made a condition of the child undertaking the trip, so if a parent cannot attend, the school has to make other arrangements. If they can't or are unwilling to do so, the trip has to be cancelled.

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 13:31

In terms of daughters level of needs. The LA will not list a SEN school at all even if I wanted to. She is full able to attend main stream school. The school
Accepted her ehcp and agree they could meet her needs.

OP posts:
Spikeyball · 11/07/2021 13:30

"The school have to show they have made reasonable adjustments - and they have."

Saying a parent has to go to enable their child to go is NEVER a reasonable adjustment.
You are arguing with experts on here who have many years experience and knowledge of special needs and disability education law.

motogogo · 11/07/2021 13:25

It's disability discrimination and we've suffered it too, very different reasons (lea/statement refused 1:1 but she couldn't be trusted not to bolt) I went on every trip until she was 8 and she changed schools, new school found a ta to be with her plus she stopped bolting/more reliable.

The only reason I can imagine to refuse would be due to hygiene/infection etc making the trip unsuitable but that would apply even if you came. I'm sure they could recruit an additional parent to come, ifs it's a sen school it's even more ridiculous.

NoSquirrels · 11/07/2021 13:23

The duty to make reasonable adjustments in education is 'anticipatory'. This means schools must consider in advance what they need to do to make sure all disabled pupils can access and participate in the education and other benefits, facilities and services they provide for their pupils.

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/family/education/discrimination-in-education/disability-discrimination-in-schools/

They shouldn’t be planning a trip that excludes OP’s DC. They should be able to anticipate her needs and plan around them from the get-go.

DumplingsAndStew · 11/07/2021 13:22

Oh ffs, it's like speaking to a sea cucumber.

The reasonable adjustment isn't asking the parent to go.

Even if it was, the parent cannot fucking go. Now what?

Imagine if a workplace tried to sack an employee because they couldn't access their desk in a wheelchair.
They would be expected to make a reasonable adjustment.
Now, imagine the first suggestion made is that the employee just learns not to use the wheelchair.
"Sorry boss, can't do that."
"Oh well, we tried. We offered that solution, you're not working with us. You're sacked."

Do you think the employment tribunal would ask why the employee could learn to not need the wheelchair in order to meet them in the middle?

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 13:22

If a child needs insulin then a staff member should be trained and be able to do that on the trip too.

Parents should not be expected to accompany children on trips. That is not a reasonable adjustment.

thing47 · 11/07/2021 13:21

The equality act doesn't over rule health and safety regulations.

It absolutely does in a case like this. It is exactly what the 2010 Equality Act was designed to do, to place disability discrimination above such issues as as health and safety regulations.

There aren't any exemptions or exceptions, it's not a grey area which organisations can disregard. Take it from someone who has personally fought this battle with an ignorant school.

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 13:20

Hi sorry I have just come back and had to read through everything.

I’m not going to go in to specific details on DD. However she is cognitively abled. She has health needs yes, however the school do not need to do any medical cares in school hours. During the trip she will not be attached to anything. Her 1-2 is fully funded and employed from outside due to previous issues with funding. She is trained in emergency pack in case any tube etc is dislodged as well as the other members of the class.
She is fully funded for 32.5 hours direct 1-1.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 11/07/2021 13:19

The school is required to 'make reasonable adjustments' to ensure the child can go on the trip.

They have. they asked the childs parent to go.

That’s not the school making ANY adjustment at all.

How can you not see that?

Reasonable adjustments the school could make are planning trips not inherently unsuitable (although how a fucking park trip could be risk assessed as too difficult is beyond me), or getting an extra staff member or other parent helpers in the ratio, or adapting the trip to avoid the risky issues…

Putting the onus back on the parent is discriminatory and not a ‘reasonable adjustment’.

You’re wrong.

scrambledcustard · 11/07/2021 13:18

@Aspinelli

*The school is required to 'make reasonable adjustments' to ensure the child can go on the trip.

They have. they asked the childs parent to go.*

That's not a reasonable adjustment.

Depends on who is viewing that. Its very common for parents to attend school trips with children who need extra support. OP will have to prove why she is different.
scrambledcustard · 11/07/2021 13:17

@NoSquirrels

I’ve no idea why you’re so insistent on this scrambled unless you have some sort of vested interest. The OP has done everything they can and the school are the ones not adjusting.

It’s 100% on the school to solve this and include all their pupils, not on the OP.

They have adjusted. The asked the parent to go. Just like parents who are asked to go on trip when their children may need insulin injections.

This isn't new.

Many people have brought their own issues to this thread and are pushing for OP to get a lawyer and kick up a stink. Which I think is unfair and I know for a fact that the Equalities act does not over rule Health and Safety Legislations. The school have to show they have made reasonable adjustments - and they have.

OP has to work with the school on this one.

Aspinelli · 11/07/2021 13:16

*The school is required to 'make reasonable adjustments' to ensure the child can go on the trip.

They have. they asked the childs parent to go.*

That's not a reasonable adjustment.

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 13:14

Expecting Mum to attend the trip is not reasonable adjustment.

Reasonable adjustment is school putting in place what is needed not expecting Mum to do their job

danni0509 · 11/07/2021 13:12

@Sleepyblueocean

"Because “mum will do it” seems to often be the easy option.

Well the easy option for everyone other than Mum and Child obviously."

Well we are 'special parents' don't you know. Or shit parents if we don't do everything everyone else expects us to do, however unreasonable the expectation is. And not forgetting 'difficult parents' if we dare to mention the law.

This fucker with gold shiny bastard bells on. 🤣

If I could like a post I would do a thousand times.

scrambledcustard · 11/07/2021 13:10

[quote DumplingsAndStew]@scrambledcustard

Also if OP takes this to court, she will be askedwhyshe wouldn't meet the school half way.

The Equality Act and the statutory guidance for "Supporting pupils at school with medical conditions" (as linked upthread) completely disagree with your 'opinion'.

Exclusion on this basis is not legal, no matter how many times you insist it's okay.[/quote]
The equality act doesn't over rule health and safety regulations. I'm sorry but it doesn't.

The school is required to 'make reasonable adjustments' to ensure the child can go on the trip.

They have. they asked the childs parent to go.

Looneytune253 · 11/07/2021 13:09

So if she didn't go then surely the 1-1 staff member would be staying at school with her? So the school would actually have more staff for the trip if she and the 1-1 went. They are genuinely making life harder for themselves. Or do they think you'll keep her off school if she's not going? I would clarify that ASAP and let them know you'll still be sending your daughter in so she may as well go on the trip

thing47 · 11/07/2021 12:59

Just as an aside, ime children are very rarely bothered by other children's disabilities – inquisitive, maybe, sometimes, but not in the sense of treating them any differently, or thinking they should be treated differently.

(Some) adults could learn a lot from children's natural bent towards inclusivity.

3lovelykids · 11/07/2021 12:57

I find this shocking. I’m an SEN TA who is enteral feed trained. I take children away on residentials and also accompany them to hospital if necessary as their advocate. I really don’t think thry should be using her 1-1 in the numbers. She’s not there for that! You must be raging 😤

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 12:50

It makes me sad that no matter how much we as parents try to instill an attitude of not letting their disability hold them back from things they want to do, or try to do, there are still so many barriers put in place.

The op isn’t asking a lot. She is simply asking her child be allowed to go on the trip like her peers can. Hardly unreasonable is it

NoSquirrels · 11/07/2021 12:49

I’ve no idea why you’re so insistent on this scrambled unless you have some sort of vested interest. The OP has done everything they can and the school are the ones not adjusting.

It’s 100% on the school to solve this and include all their pupils, not on the OP.

DumplingsAndStew · 11/07/2021 12:47

@thing47

That's exactly it. This child is being excluded from an activity accessible by her peers on the basis of how the school perceive her presence to be for others (I.e. staff and other pupils)

Because this is a medical issue, this is not legal.

NoSquirrels · 11/07/2021 12:45

She's not being left behind. She can go.

She can only go if her parent accompanies her.

Her parent is at an important medical meeting for her child that cannot be rearranged.

Therefore the child cannot go and is being excluded. The school could rearrange the trip, reassess the supervision and so on.

They are excluding her, not including her.

Imagine if it was the case that the only children who could go were those accompanied by their parents. There would be general outrage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread