Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU disabled DC and school trip

333 replies

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 00:10

My DC class is going on a school trip at the end of term. They school are refusing to take them due to disability ( tube fed )
We have had medical clearance from health team and she has a trained 1–1.
AIBU to believe ( this is now nearly 4 years of never attending a school trip ) that it’s getting ridiculous. She is so sad about it and waited a long time to go.

OP posts:
Terhou · 11/07/2021 20:40

She's not being excluded. They have just asked her mum to go

Are they telling non-disabled children that they can only go if their parents can leave work in the lurch and go? Apparently not. So it is clearly discriminatory and unlawful.

Terhou · 11/07/2021 20:36

No its not. It depends on where they are going. A school environment is totally different to a school trip to some where they have never been.

Before a school arranges any school trip, it must do a risk assessment. Unless it's somewhere they have been to before, that will include a visit to the venue. The person visiting the venue must consider all risks, including those affecting any disabled pupils. They're not venturing into some scary unknown jungle, @scrambledcustard

The OP states she has had to fight for her dds education from the start so obviously this child is classed as high risk. They have just asked that her mother attends to safeguard them all

And that is disability discrimination, given that they are funded by the LA to have a trained 1-1 TA to deal with the child. Why is it fine for parents to cope in unknown environments but not trained school employees?

roundtable · 11/07/2021 20:00

The EHCP is a legal document so if your dd has a 1to1 it is a legal requirement. They're breaking the law and discriminating against your daughter.

Not on. Oh and to the ignorant poster going on about insulin - either the child does it themselves or a trained member of staff goes. The only time ive known this not to happen I when a child developed diabetes during the academic year and the nurse couldnt get into school in time to give training to staff before the school trip. (No other diabetic children in the school at that time)

I'm shocked that we're still hearing from some 'but mum should go'. No she shouldn't. Thankfully most of the comments aren't like that and it's heartening to hear that other school staff are backing the op.

So are you going to contact the head or governors op? They are acting unlawfully.

DumplingsAndStew · 11/07/2021 19:47
Mickarooni · 11/07/2021 19:36

@lljkk

Sounds like having another domestic adult giving support would make more things possible for OP.
That’s what the 1:1 is for!
lljkk · 11/07/2021 19:10

Sounds like having another domestic adult giving support would make more things possible for OP.

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 19:05

@lljkk

I'm gonna ask the stupid question because that's what MN threads are for....

Does this child only have one parent? And no other adult relatives who can help?

Irrelevant because it’s a school issue not a home issue
lljkk · 11/07/2021 18:59

I'm gonna ask the stupid question because that's what MN threads are for....

Does this child only have one parent? And no other adult relatives who can help?

SofiaAmes · 11/07/2021 17:42

This kind of situationmakes me grateful to be in the litigious USA. If a special needs child is being discriminated against or the school isn't following the rules, you just sue them. And it's amazing how money makes people jump. It's sad that it comes to that, but it does get SEN children the support they need.

And for those posters who say "why don't you just..." you clearly have no idea how much time and energy goes into being the parent of a SEN child. I read a study recently that said that the parent of a chid without medical/SEN needs spends on average 3.5 hours a week caring for that child and the parent of a child with special needs spends on average 53.5 hours a week caring for that child. Personally I had to stop working as it got to the point where I had reduced my hours so much to meet my ds' needs that there were no hours left to cut back on.

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 16:49

If an ehcp is in place then school are legally required to provide what is in that. Not their own version where they use the support allocated as it works for them. It’s about the child not anyone else

itsgettingwierd · 11/07/2021 16:27

Scrambled have you actually got any direct experience of tube feeding?

There's absolutely no reason why a child with peg/gastroscopu cannot climb and run. You can cover it up for a start to protect it.

And the most important thing is this child has a funded 1:1. They can supervise the child should anything be inaccessible due to her disability.

That's why they have a funded 1:1.

Parents CANNOT be asked to provide educational provision - its law.

itsgettingwierd · 11/07/2021 16:22

@AlternativePerspective

Seriously - if you genuinely have no idea what it's like to raise a disabled child or all the unfair disadvantages your family have that they shouldn't have please find out. I'm sure beyond anything those laments caring for a disabled child would love the company and someone willing to support them - it's a very lonely place. No no no. They’d rather tell you that “I couldn’t do what you do.” In order to justify their ignorance.
Not all do.

I have parents of disabled children as friends and parents without.

I manage to have equal relationships with both.

10brokengreenbottles · 11/07/2021 16:18

To be fair, it could be that, during certain activities at school, your dd is fine with a TA working elsewhere in the classroom with another child

This shouldn't happen. If 1:1 is specified and quantified in section F it must be provided, regardless of what the school think, or what other children need. If it isn't provided the parents can enforce the EHCP. A good 1:1 builds independence rather than creating dependency.

Similarly, if 1:1 during trips is specified and quantified in section F, with no vague or woolly wording, then you can enforce it, via Judicial Review if necessary. Regardless of whether the 1:1 is funded by the LA or school it is the LA who are ultimately responsible for ensuring provision in EHCPs is provided.

shewalkslikerihanna · 11/07/2021 16:18

Got to be discrimination
Surely
Your poor child 😥

fourminutestosavetheworld · 11/07/2021 16:10

@Manic20201

I should also add have recently had issues with her not having a 1-2 when she is ratio of 1-1 in her ehcp for certain school activities because school think that she didn’t need the ratio of 1-1 and needed independence but then won’t take her on trip with a 1-1 it’s all very conflicting.
To be fair, it could be that, during certain activities at school, your dd is fine with a TA working elsewhere in the classroom with another child, since you say there are no behaviour or learning needs, or that they've noticed a worrying increase in dependence, but still feel that she'd need 2:1 for walking in the countryside and den building. Ask what aspect of the risk assessment revealed that this trip could not be adjusted and made safe for your dd.
DanceFortheSummer · 11/07/2021 15:16

[quote Manic20201]@ddl1 no diagnoses learning difficulties etc
She struggles with reading and writing. She has no behaviour problems. She is very protective of her tubes.
She does not pull etc[/quote]
My DD is exactly the same. No diagnosed learning need but has an EHCP due to a problem with her hips.

School have literally never said she cannot do anything. One trip she was excluded from one activity due to problem but 2 other children where due to their needs so the TA took all 3 off to do something else related to the trip for that part which I was happy with (think rock climbing where if my DD had fallen she'd had fractured her hip/leg and been in pain so it was too much of a risk).

I'd fight this as far as you can.

Mickarooni · 11/07/2021 15:11

@scrambledcustard

I’d be interested to know if you have any personal or professional experience of this. Children at SEN schools go on trips and outings and not necessarily with 1:1 adult care.

Hercisback · 11/07/2021 15:04

Then you need to speak to the LA. The 1_1 may not be insured to be elsewhere. I'd be checking that.

LotLessBovver · 11/07/2021 14:57

I'm a 1:1 in a primary school.

I can only think of one occasion when a parent has gone on a school trip specifically because of their child's disability. The parent requested to be allowed to go as they were worried about how their child would cope on their first ever school trip (EYFS). They were very much reassured by the experience and haven't been on one since.

The only time a child hasn't gone on a trip is when the parent refused to give permission. The child had no additional needs but the parent was worried about their child going to London only a couple of weeks after the attack on the London Bridge.

We have also taken several insulin-dependent children on trips. We always have two trained adults attending. The care they need isn't that much different to when they're in school, other than extra monitoring of their levels.

It's true that we don't get paid a lot but it's the job that we've signed up to do. I enjoy my job and it's rewarding to see all of our children (whether or not they have disabilities) enjoying being out in a different environment for the day. Depriving a child of that because a school has allocated their 1:1 elsewhere is an awful thing to do.

Sirzy · 11/07/2021 14:57

In that case the LA should certainly be making sure she is doing what she was employed to do!

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 14:54

@Hercisback employed and paid for directly by LA.

OP posts:
DobbyIsAFreeElf · 11/07/2021 14:49

I worked as a 1-1 for a number of years. Whenever we went on school trips I was still allocated to the single child and were were part of a group with another adult. So there were 2 adults to the group of 6/7 children. Only once did I go on a trip with my 1-1 and had a group but this was only a group of 4 sensible children who were good friends with the child with SEN.
Also I struggle to see how health and safety comes into it, we often took a child who uses a wheelchair or crawled to nature reserves/wooded areas, they never missed out and we just made adaptations and reasonable adjustments or took a slightly different route around areas if needed.

Hercisback · 11/07/2021 14:33

How is the 1-1 not employed by the school? That is an out of the ordinary set up. Does this mean 1-1 is employed by you? In which case you say 1-1 can't go on the trip as she will be caring for dd in school.

Peoniesandpeaches · 11/07/2021 14:32

That is the epitome of shiftiness and absolutely not on. There is no reason someone with a tube can’t go on the majority of field trips- it’s not like it’s a water park they are going to! I hate when schools try to use a child’s career to make up their staffing shortfalls. What do they expect your daughter to do if her 1-1 is swanning off on a field trip with the other children?

mummyh2016 · 11/07/2021 14:31

@scrambledcustard so the OP should miss the important medical meeting relating to the child in question, although she has already said it has to be done before the end of term (which in my area is in 10 days time) and cannot be rearranged to enable her child to go on a school trip because the school can't be arsed? If the 1:1 does not feel comfortable looking after the child out of school she/he is in the wrong job.

Swipe left for the next trending thread