Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU disabled DC and school trip

333 replies

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 00:10

My DC class is going on a school trip at the end of term. They school are refusing to take them due to disability ( tube fed )
We have had medical clearance from health team and she has a trained 1–1.
AIBU to believe ( this is now nearly 4 years of never attending a school trip ) that it’s getting ridiculous. She is so sad about it and waited a long time to go.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Terhou · 12/07/2021 08:29

Just to add to @Shuffleuplove's comment, there's some helpful information about judicial review on here - www.sossen.org.uk/information_sheets.php

Shuffleuplove · 12/07/2021 01:31

Gosh, some dreadful discriminatory nonsense on this thread.

I won’t add to the advice save to say that the legal duty to maintain the EHCP is always on the LA and cannot be delegated. If the school are playing fast and lose with your 1:1 then you need to point out that they’re not fulfilling the provision of section F and are *therefore placing the Local Authority at risk of Judicial Review” and say that unless they stop immediately you will be starting the pre action protocol for JR on the LA.

That usually shits ‘em up just enough.

Lockdownbear · 12/07/2021 00:20

I'm no rocket scientist but logic and commonsense has it her 1-1 needs to be with her.

So ask the school some awkward questions have they done a risk assessment for her being in school while the 1-1 is on the trip.

My guess is they are expecting you to keep her home or cave in and go on the trip.

But ultimately she has a right to her education and x many days in school per year. (Someone brighter than me will know the details).

You sound amazing and good luck in your fight.

Boredoutmymind · 12/07/2021 00:18

SUE EM
This is discrimination under the equality act.
If they claim its for health and safety reasons they must tell you what it is.
If there are reasonable adjustments that would make it so your child can go then is is discrimination.

If a business refused service to you child because she is disabled then you could sure em for discrimination. This is the same for school.

The school needs to clarify exactly why your child can't go. They should give you advance notice of trips so if you need additional support for your child you can arrange it.

Send them a request for them to outline the reasons and then seek legal advice.

If your child would be able to go to the place where the school trip is without the business saying no then i cant see why the school should say no.

If its because your child is tube fed then thats wrong. As you can get additional help.

SE13Mummy · 12/07/2021 00:15

I'm so sorry you and your daughter are being put through this. As a teacher I have taken children with all sorts of needs on trips. Crutches with back-up wheelchairs, insulin pumps or injections, epipens and feeding tubes have all featured as have more temporary needs such as a child in a wheelchair post broken tibia and fibia and a child on a residential whose surgical dressing for an exploded abcess needed to be changed daily. Never have I demanded a child's parent accompany them on a trip because of their medical needs; sufficient school staff have always been trained to manage the long-term medical needs and for things like exploding abcesses, I arranged to have training from the school nursing team. If I want/need additional adults to come, I ask for parent volunteers. I would rather not take anyone than leave one member of the class behind because of their medical needs!

Would it be helpful for you to get some quick legal advice so the school is reminded of its responsibilities re: your daughter's access to the curriculum?. this guy has been a huge help to a number of families I know, some of them as a result of the free consultation alone.

malteserheist · 12/07/2021 00:12

@Manic20201

I am just catching up. The fact she is tube fed etc is the reason she has a 1-1, I am not stating that my child is sick. She has a life limiting life threatening illness however day to day she is like every other year 3 child. She would never go to school Unwell and in 4 years has been sent home sick twice and never needed an ambulance . Her 1-1 was employed because the school Felt like they needed someone who was more comfortable so that’s what we fight for and got it. Her 1-1 is medically qualified.
In that case I would be perfectly comfortable kicking up a fuss and continuing to kick up a fuss until it was resolved.

Unfortunately some people won't do the right thing unless forced.

ArnoldBee · 11/07/2021 23:49

It's really not about this one trip but what is right for your daughter. Its unlikely she will be going on this trip and you are probably exhausted but I would do the following:
Follow the schools complaint procedure
Contact you LA and consider legal action
Contact your MP
Contact your local news

It's crap and needs sorting.

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 23:42

I am just catching up. The fact she is tube fed etc is the reason she has a 1-1, I am not stating that my child is sick. She has a life limiting life threatening illness however day to day she is like every other year 3 child. She would never go to school
Unwell and in 4 years has been sent home sick twice and never needed an ambulance .
Her 1-1 was employed because the school
Felt like they needed someone who was more comfortable so that’s what we fight for and got it. Her 1-1 is medically qualified.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 11/07/2021 23:36

You may have to look at a new primary school if this one is being so unhelpful

Hankunamatata · 11/07/2021 23:36

Firstly her 1:1 should be staying in school with her.
Secondly I'd want to see the risk assessment.
Thirdly ask in writing/email that you would like the exact reasons she cannot attend school trip and why.

OldScrappyAndHungry · 11/07/2021 23:27

I’m horrified at the number of posters who seem to think it’s your responsibility to accompany your daughter OP Shock. It absolutely isn’t.

This is blatant discrimination (I’m a primary teacher with SEN experience) and you have every right to push back on school and ask them how they’re going to make this work Sad.

santabetterwashhishands · 11/07/2021 23:27

Go above the headteacher and complain!
My son had a1-1 before he transferred to special education and he never missed a school trip 🤷‍♀️.
I'd be fuming and straight on it and usually I'm really laid back x

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 23:23

@paradyning she has both but nothing goes down nasal one so no worry over aspiration.

OP posts:
DumplingsAndStew · 11/07/2021 23:22

@lunar1

This is absolutely disgraceful and needs sorting out for the long term, but for now is there anyone who can go in your place?

Yes. The trained and paid for 1-1!!

paradyning · 11/07/2021 23:21

And it's a button Op? Not a ng? So not like they have to even worry about aspirates? Maybe your ccn can help push them along too.

Manic20201 · 11/07/2021 23:10

To the person who asked about training.
They are trained on emergency care so if tubes fall out.
She has more than one tube but not used in school.

OP posts:
lunar1 · 11/07/2021 21:28

This is absolutely disgraceful and needs sorting out for the long term, but for now is there anyone who can go in your place?

I go on trips to give 1:1 for a child in a different year to my boys. I can give feeds, meds, unblock or change/replace pulled out tubes in an emergency.

It's nice for the girl not to have their parent on every trip.

Is there anyone else trained to meet her needs, which don't sound like much, who can help out?

Do school actually understand what her needs are?

Terhou · 11/07/2021 21:08

@scrambledcustard's often repeated mantra about H&S legislation not being overridden by the Equality Act is a complete red herring. The only reason the school wants OP to go is that it wants to use the 1-1 paid for by someone else to complete their complement of adults on the trip - they've already said that the 1-1 will go even if the child can't, which is totally unlawful. If they tried to cite H&S legislation as a defence in those circumstances they would be laughed out of the tribunal.

It's perfectly clear that such risk as there is is minimal and exactly what the 1-1 is trained to deal with. The school really cannot claim that it's OK to have a non-medically trained parent to look after the child but not to allocate the 1-1 provided for precisely that purpose to look after her, or that it is safer for the parent to do it than the 1-1.

Terhou · 11/07/2021 20:58

It doesn't matter what the mother or the hospital have said. The school can't turn around and say 'but mum said it was ok' if there was ever a disaster. They have to do their own risk assessment completely independent of mum and hospital because the buck stops with them.

The fact that the expert medic who knows the child and her condition has said it is safe for her emphatically does matter. Apart from anything else, if the school were accused of being negligent for taking her on the trip it would provide an absolute defence. The risk assessment has to take into account medical evidence, otherwise it is in itself negligent.

Also if OP takes this to court, she will be asked why she wouldn't meet the school half way.

No she won't. Because judges in the Special Educational Needs and Disability Tribunal know perfectly well that it is discriminatory to stop a child attending a school trip unless their parent goes with them, given the well established case law that exists to that effect.

Why do you keep insisting that you know better than lawyers, judges, people with experience of supporting tube fed children on school trips, OP's child's doctors and OP, @scrambledcustard? It's really quite bizarre.

lljkk · 11/07/2021 20:56

Another dumb question from me... if the child is never tube fed at school, why are some of her support staff trained to give her tube feeds?

CloudyGladys · 11/07/2021 20:52

OP's DD is being treated less favourably because of her disability, which is against the Law, both if she is prohibited from attending the trip or if her attending the trip is conditional on her parent attending.

Take this up with your Local Authority case worker. Copy in the Head of Special Needs or Head of Education (look on the Local Offer to find the names) and your local County Councillor. If there is a parent partnership officer, copy them in as well.

Is MDT a Multi-Disciplinary Team meeting with her paediatrician? If so, bring this up at that meeting. Obviously bring up at DD's EHCP review, take advice on the EHCP wording, and check any changes agreed have been made when the Note of Amendment is issued.

(Unfortunately, I suspect the school is relying on not being called to account in time to make the necessary re-arrangements for this trip and, if anything, will respond by cancelling the whole thing. I also doubt this will be the last of this type of issue whilst the current headteacher is in post. Whether you want to take on this battle every time there is a special event or prefer to ask the LA to find another suitable school will depend on factors outside this post, but if it's an option, I wouldn't discount it.)

Terhou · 11/07/2021 20:50

The OP didn't state if she was invited or declined to go. I'd imagine a child with a feeding tube - especially a stomach peg playing on climbing bars etc would be classed as high risk.

Oh, stop making things up now, @scrambledcustard. Where does it say this child is going to be climbing bars? OP specifically said it is without climbing frames. Even if it did involve climbing bars, do you seriously imagine it's beyond the wit of the 1:1 to stop her from trying and find something else interesting to do instead? Did you miss the bit where the experts treating the child have said she is not at risk going on this trip?

paradyning · 11/07/2021 20:49

Ffs OP I am so pissed off for you. Surely if it is in her EHCP it is legally binding? Absolute discrimination and the values being demonstrated by the school are foul.

Terhou · 11/07/2021 20:45

If my child had a broken leg and the school said 'your child can't come on the trip unless a parent comes with her' - I'd go.

Hardly comparable to a child with a long term serious disability. @scrambledcustard ,would you go if (a) you were in a job where you would be letting down an awful lot of people by taking a day off and (b) you knew the school was being paid to provide a trained person who was perfectly capable of looking after your child but just wanted to use that person as an extra adult to save themselves some money?

The Equality act doesn't override Health and Safety legislations, schools still have to do risk assessments and they obviously feel it isn't safe to take her alone. That's why they have looked at other ways to ensure this child can go - they asked her mother to come.

The problem with that is their prolonged history of providing totally inadequate and unlawful excuses for not taking OP's daughter on even fairly minor outings; plus the fact that it appears that it's only a risk because they want to divert OP's 1:1 unlawfully to make up the numbers on the trip.

LemonRoses · 11/07/2021 20:44

If she isn’t tube fed at school, what is the reason she needs a 121 and will that have an impact on her ability to stay safe or join in activities?
Clearly 121 isn’t for the tube feeding and that isn’t the reason for the refusal raptors allow her to participate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread