Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

94 year old gran sat in room all day

116 replies

fugginhell · 10/07/2021 21:21

Haven't seen my lovely grandma since pre covid, she has deteriorated badly and now she isn't even coming downstairs.

My auntie is her full time career she is quite hot headed so we don't usually say anything to her. My grandma is looked after well but it just broke my heart when I went upstairs she was just sat on her chair with a radio on the room was quite warm it's broke my heart.

AIBU to think my auntie should of thought of turning downstairs into a bedroom or making her bedroom a bit better for her TV/fan ect.

I am going to get her a tv tomorrow and bring it down on my day off.

OP posts:
carcarbinks · 11/07/2021 08:46

Try looking after her for a week or two yourself then you may be lass critical.

Hallyup6 · 11/07/2021 08:40

Could you get a stair lift installed for her if she can't manage the stairs and wants to get out of her room. If you were to get social services involved they can send someone to assess her needs and possibly provide funding for adaptations.

warmfluffytowels · 11/07/2021 08:33

It's probably not practical to have her downstairs. If your nan is 94 your aunt is probably in her 60's or 70's - could she cope if your nan fell and got injured?

Also if he bathroom is upstairs it makes sense for her to be there too.

I know it can be a real shock at how quickly elderly people deteriorate but your aunt has been caring for your Nan alone for months with no break - that's bloody hard going for anyone, let alone during a pandemic.

Don't go in all guns blazing and criticise - if you think your aunt is struggling and your Nan is trapped in her room due to failing health then it may be best to get adult social services involved.

Looubylou · 11/07/2021 08:31

Tread very carefully, and don't assume you know best. Unfortunately, this reminds me of working on elderly care wards, and relatives who had moved away returning to "sort everything out", before buggering off again. A difficult situation on both sides. My elderly relative has lost all interest in TV - she can't follow it anymore, due to hearing loss and cognitive decline. There might be other things that could make her day better, eg regular visits and calls. A basic mobile, that your aunt could manage for her for eg?

rose69 · 11/07/2021 08:25

Sadly old people can go down hill quite quickly. Is there a downstairs loo she could use if she did come down? There is another three on here about funding stairlifts.

Billandben444 · 11/07/2021 08:25

Give your auntie a fortnight off. Show her how she’s been getting it wrong.

This ⬆️

If you want to offer constructive help, ask Auntie if there's anything you can get or do to make life better for both of them. I'm sure more visits from you would be near the top of the list if that's viable but I'd be very careful wading in with anything that criticises Gran's care.

4PawsGood · 11/07/2021 08:22

If she’s trapped upstairs maybe it’s time to get social services involved.
Or in the short term get her a bedroom set up downstairs.

fugginhell · 11/07/2021 08:18

Hey, I'm not judging my auntie it was just a shock for me how much she has deteriorated she barely remembered me. When I seen her just sat there on a chair it really shocked me to think she does that all day.

She normally watches all her soaps and the news I thought she would be missing all of that.
My gran wanted to come down stairs we managed a few stairs but then she didn't think she could do it and we brought her back.

OP posts:
Mandalay246 · 11/07/2021 05:52

You sound kind to care about your gran, but I agree with several earlier posts. Older people feel the cold, and it's quite common for them to want to be in an (to us) overheated room. Your gran might not want a TV, I know my DM lost interest in it in her latter years. At 94 she might not even want to go downstairs. Unless she has said she is unhappy I think you should leave your aunt to look after her without comment.

KihoBebiluPute · 11/07/2021 05:36

Don't judge your auntie so harshly, it is really tough being a fulltime carer and perfection should not be required.

Your granny may not want a tv. My gran didn't like the tv as the screen triggered some migraine-like symptoms for her. In her final couple of years she couldn't cope with the radio or books either so was mostly alone with her thoughts (in between regular drop-in from carers and family). Sittimg still and quiet all day in a warm safe place isn't such a bad situation when you are 94 as it might be when you are in your 40s. You are projecting that you yourself would be bored to tears in that situation and assuming that your granny is too. She might be perfectly content but by all means do make efforts to find out what she would enjoy and try to help make it happen - but do so in a way that is respectful to all the work your aunt is doing.

Maybe you could suggest that you spend a few days there and take over all the caring responsibilities while your auntie has a holiday away somewhere. That would give you a chance to really understand what would be genuinely helpful.

supersonicsue · 11/07/2021 04:43

Your poor aunt. Obviously she is quite elderly herself and to be a full time carer during a pandemic is no picnic. Especially with no help or support from her family due to lockdown and likely reduced care from professional services too. And now criticism from her family who should be so grateful to her. I assume that as your grandmother's age means they have had to shield for most of last year also. No outings or visits from friends/usual support network either during this time. Unless you have been a full time carer you cannot know the stress it can bring, and the exhaustion from knowing it really is a 24 hour a day job...especially during the last 18 months we have all had.

As others have said the best thing to do is for you to be the carer (but do remember that is 24 hours a day, 365 days a year and another lockdown would mean no family help either). You seem a marvellous person with tons of compassion and knowledge, so there is no doubt you would do an excellent job. And I'm sure from the ONE visit you have made during the last 18 months you already know everything there is to know. So do your grandmother AND aunt a favour and take over the caring role ASAP.

M1rror7ImageL · 11/07/2021 04:28

Images of 94 year old Gran PRE covid in a punk band, riding motorcycles....

DavidTheDog · 11/07/2021 04:21

Give your auntie a fortnight off. Show her how she’s been getting it wrong.

Rainbowqueeen · 11/07/2021 04:15

Op it’s lovely that you care so much for your gran but I do agree with the others on this thread.

It sounds like she is well care for by a solo carer who doesn’t get much support and who is no spring chicken herself.

Your aunt deserves a lot of praise, support (including respite) and the opportunity for some self care.
I’d send her a message thanking her for all she is doing, saying that it seems your gran has deteriorated and asking what you can do to help. Tell her your budget and say you’re happy for her to decide how best to spend it but say that you would be happy for her to use it for respite as she deserves it. Then tell her when you will next busy, how long for and say you’d be happy for her to make plans to go out by herself during that time.
I’m sure your gran loved seeing you and would rather see you more often how that is possible.

PhilSwagielka · 11/07/2021 03:40

Does she actually want a telly? She might just be happy with the radio.

Flgbusterhereagain · 11/07/2021 01:35

You're being a bit harsh on your aunt here op. Being a full time carer is hard work. It's not fair to just stride in and decide what's best. Have you spoken to your Aunt and Nan? Maybe start there.

mellicauli · 11/07/2021 01:07

My parents are late 80's. They would both be wearing jumpers on the sunniest day. It was probably the right temperature for her.

My parents don't really watch TV either (although they have one and can go up and down stairs OK) but they love listening to the radio. It has a slower pace than TV which they like. I guess that's all they had when they were growing up . Although they had TV later on, they think most of the stuff is rubbish and will only watch it if there's an opera on.

Be careful with blaming your aunt. Sometimes when we feel upset we look for someone to blame. But it's not her fault that your lovely grandma is deteriorating.She must have cared for her pretty well to make it to this point and it is going to happen at some point in your 90s.'

Friendofdennis · 11/07/2021 00:20

Do you have a car ? Why not offer to take your gran out for a drive somewhere Give your aunt the opportunity to have a break

1forAll74 · 11/07/2021 00:15

My late Mum, didn't like much tv, she only ever watched the news on BBC, She use to say it was mostly twaddle and rubbish on TV.. she played her little music tapes instead, whilst knitting all the time, and then did her crossword puzzles..

Cowbells · 11/07/2021 00:07

As others have said: please feel free to take over her full time care if you think your auntie isn't doing it right. Hmm If she is clean, comfortable, warm and dressed, sitting in a chair not in bed, listening to the radio, then your auntie is doing an excellent job, Old people feel the cold which is why the room was warm. You'd know that if you cared for her yourself.

shivawn · 10/07/2021 23:49

94 year olds feel the cold badly especially if she is frail and deteriorating as you say so a warm room is unlikely to be a problem. Buy her the TV if you feel she would like it but you could well find she has very little interest. I worked in a nursing home as a college student and it was so hard to find things to stimulate most of our residents, they just don't care what's on TV or have the energy to read or do any activities. It's very sad to see elderly people sitting in a chair and staring in to space so I can understand why you were upset.

I do hope you'll take other posters comments on board too. Being a full time carer is an incredibly hard job, unimaginably hard. I don't think I could do it although I've worked in care homes and loved my job, to do it 24/7, never get the chance to clock off and to be doing it all alone is an entirely different ball game. Your aunt has made massive sacrifices to her own life to care for your nan so please be kind to her.

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2021 23:38

@CrouchEndTiger12

I'm sure your gran would be happy to move in with you op. If you'd like to take over the caring as your auntie is clearly lacking.
This.

You do know very old people feel the cold, OP? My parents’ house was tropical.

shiningstar2 · 10/07/2021 23:35

If your grandma is 94 it seems likely that your aunt is late 60s or even into her 70s. If she is a full time carer she will be exhausted, even if on your rare visits you feel she isn't doing enough. The sheer monotony of her life as a carer is hard to imagine unless you have experienced it yourself.

Often long repetitive days with little opportunity to get out at all and not always appreciated by the extended family. I think that you should check with your aunt whether a tv upstairs would be appreciated. If you think any alterations to her bedroom or downstairs might be a good idea, you could tactfully bring it up, but only if this comes with an offer to do most of the changes, maybe decorating, moving furniture, cleaning ext. You could also offer to stay in with your grandma for a day/afternoon while your aunt goes out somewhere. She might appreciate the opportunity, preferably with a friend, but even for a coffee and look around the shops on her own.

Your grandma would appreciate the change in company, your aunt would feel more appreciated for all she does and you would probably have a greater understanding of some of the problems she faces on a daily basis. Flowers

HappyDays40 · 10/07/2021 23:32

Im with the your Aunt is working really hard camp. Why don't all family members chip in to help say a couple of days each then it might help your Auntie to feel better too.
I don't think you have room to complain its sounds tough for your aunt.

DeathByWalkies · 10/07/2021 23:28

My own nonagenarian is also always cold. Her house is heated to tropical temperatures and I once caught sight of the annual gas bill - it was £4k Shock

Can she manage the stairs? If not a stairlift would likely be appropriate - they're much cheaper than they once were and you can get reconditioned ones.

Have you asked why she hasn't got a TV? There may be a good reason.