Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL just turning up

112 replies

WITW7 · 10/07/2021 20:31

Wondering if it’s just me who’s annoyed by this….

I’ve just moved in with my partner and I’m 15 weeks pregnant. My partners mum keeps randomly turning up at the house at any time throughout the day without texting or calling beforehand and without being invited. This is usually for no real reason and she hovers about.

She’s nice and we get on but she’s really nosy and I can’t help thinking she’s developed some sort of fear of missing out on something mentality.

Prior to meeting me my partner was a single NR Dad and she did a lot to help him, washing and food shops etc but it’s like she can’t get used to the fact he doesn’t need that help anymore. Not that he even did in the first place- he just used to allow her when she offered.

Obviously with a baby on the way am I wrong to expect some boundaries? Partner had already said he’d have a word. Is this normal, just turning up at people’s homes?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1498572889 · 12/07/2021 16:59

@Nanny0gg
My daughters complain if I’m in the area and dont pop in to see them. Sometimes I have to be in stealth mode because I don’t want to be out for ages. Both my daughters and my sister live within half a mile of each other so a quick pop to the shops can quickly become a day out. One of my daughters has a FIL who likes to rearrange the furniture and cupboards when he is looking after DGD. It drives my daughter mad. Makes me laugh.

Canigooutyet · 12/07/2021 16:02

Lol @corinna projection much?
Didn't you hear they are planning to elope? They don't want the overbearing clueless family members there.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 12/07/2021 16:01

@WITW7

Wondering if it’s just me who’s annoyed by this….

I’ve just moved in with my partner and I’m 15 weeks pregnant. My partners mum keeps randomly turning up at the house at any time throughout the day without texting or calling beforehand and without being invited. This is usually for no real reason and she hovers about.

She’s nice and we get on but she’s really nosy and I can’t help thinking she’s developed some sort of fear of missing out on something mentality.

Prior to meeting me my partner was a single NR Dad and she did a lot to help him, washing and food shops etc but it’s like she can’t get used to the fact he doesn’t need that help anymore. Not that he even did in the first place- he just used to allow her when she offered.

Obviously with a baby on the way am I wrong to expect some boundaries? Partner had already said he’d have a word. Is this normal, just turning up at people’s homes?

What's a 'single NR dad'?

I can empathise entirely, OP, cos i've had the same thing with my fil.
I love him dearly, don't get me wrong, but using his key to let himself in, whenever he felt like it just isn't cricket.

There was one occasion, when I didn't even know that he was planning to pop in. Luckily i was just working at my desk, but man alive! What if I wasn't??

I found myself having to leave my own key in the bloody lock to stop him doing it. So he'd have to knock on the door, and when it got to that point, I basically just blurted it out one day.

Best of luck, OP. 👍

gillysSong · 12/07/2021 15:03

Stop answering the door, or tell her you'd prefer her calling to ask if you are free.
Maybe she started this when visiting her grandchild, how often does your partner see his child?

Royalbloo · 12/07/2021 15:02

C0RINNA hit a nerve???

Royalbloo · 12/07/2021 15:01

I'd go out or be in the bath...often...

Billandben444 · 12/07/2021 14:55

@CORINNA
i think you should just say it as it is and not beat about the bush...
Seriously though, this is a great post with a lot of truth in it.

BackforGood · 12/07/2021 14:54

With the existence of universal mobiles and email just "turning up" can be massively inconvenient and is simply rude.

......you forgot to put in in my opinion

As you'll see from any of the hundreds of threads on this over the years, some people think it is rude, and some people don't.

It is fine for people to have different opinions and feelings about things.
I don't see how it is inconvenient though. As Canigooutyet says - if someone calls on the off chance, then you just let them know you haven't got time today.

ineedaholidaynow · 12/07/2021 13:51

@BackforGood some people think it is fine that people can literally pop in, so they either have a key or the door isn't locked. So there wouldn't be an option to not open the door, the visitors will have already come into the house

C0RINNA · 12/07/2021 13:07

@WITW7 it might help you to see it from another perspective . Of course I don’t know your MIl so I’m only guessing .

But this is her sons house - he is her legal and blood relative and next of kin. Her son has been using her for years to do his housework and care for his children .

I’m assuming he is not disabled nor works away for weeks at a time so I’m wondering why he doesn’t do his own housework ? Don’t you think it’s a bit exploitative for a man in his ? 30s to have his mother in her ? 60s doing his grunt work?

So he’s been happy to use her like this for years. Then you come along - bands new Gf suddenly pregnant . You have NO legal rights to live there. You are not on the mortgage and you don’t own it. You might be there for a week or 20 years - who knows - it’s up to him. He can kick you out without notice.

Suddenly you expect his long standing domestic arrangements to change for you. You claim that he no longer needs his housework and child care done . You don’t explain why that is - has he hired a nanny or a cleaner ?

Why would your MIL and Dp Change all their plans for you?

What are your plans for when this baby is born? who is going to support it, pay for childcare once you go back to work? Who is going to support you during your maternity leave ? Or do you have an employer who pays full wages for the 6 months ? what about your pension contributions for any unpaid maternity leave ?

Unless you have sorted out all these things and have an agreement / legal contract then I suggest you have a lot more things to worry about than how often your partners family visit his house.

I know you will hate me saying this. You want everyone to say

“ yeah she’s a total cow, lock her out and you become his new servant instead “.

But that won’t help you and your child when things end with the father.

Nanny0gg · 12/07/2021 12:49

@Yondergoat

My ILs used to constantly pop in; then sit there expecting to be waited on for hours.

It was literally decades later I discovered that these visits were prearranged with DH and he didn't tell me because he thought I would be annoyed. So while I was ranting to him about how rude they were just turning up, I expect they were saying how rude I was for not wanting to sit for hours and wait on them.

What the hell? How dare he!
pinkcircustop · 12/07/2021 12:30

YANBU. I wouldn’t be putting up with that.

If she doesn’t ask first before she can come then she doesn’t get let in.

Yondergoat · 12/07/2021 12:30

My ILs used to constantly pop in; then sit there expecting to be waited on for hours.

It was literally decades later I discovered that these visits were prearranged with DH and he didn't tell me because he thought I would be annoyed. So while I was ranting to him about how rude they were just turning up, I expect they were saying how rude I was for not wanting to sit for hours and wait on them.

Canigooutyet · 12/07/2021 12:25

think if WFH does become the norm, there will be less popping in. It’s not like your DM/MIL would normally (I hope) just pop into your workplace and make themselves a cup of tea

😂😂 that's wishful thinking.

I have a childminder friend until they put their foot down, lots of family fallouts, grudges still held years later, after People were told bluntly to stop. They wouldnt just walk into the nursery, plonk themselves down on the sofa and ask/demand a cuppa, so why are they doing it now.

Same with term time workers. People find that out and for some bizarre reason you become a magnate to people who think you don't have anything else to do.

memberofthewedding · 12/07/2021 12:24

I really don't get this modern obsession with having to announce that you are going to call on someone. I grew up in the era where you just popped in - if people really didn't want visitors they simply didn't answer the door

When I was a kid and young woman back in the 1950s and 1960s there were no mobiles and many people were not on the phone at all! Few people even had cars. At the same time shops and cinemas etc were closed on sundays and there was little to do except go to church and visit. This was the day when people "dropped in".

Its not so much a modern "obsession" as the fact that we now lead much more complex lives with many commitments. With the existence of universal mobiles and email just "turning up" can be massively inconvenient and is simply rude.

Canigooutyet · 12/07/2021 12:15

When I meet people and get round to the swapping addresses bit, I am clear that it you pop round it's a risk you take.

I detest all this mind reading crap. It's normal to have boundaries that differ to others. People's feelings get hurt they will get over it. If the want to sulk treat them like an overgrown toddler, ignore and carry on doing what you was doing.

People overstaying their welcome ask them if they have a home to go to. Never understood that one as a child, other adults just popping around, then spending hours almost in silence watching the tv.

And why as a NR did he need so much help that she is not coping?
If it's cos she's lonely or whatever, not really your problem.

ChargingBuck · 12/07/2021 11:50

@ineedaholidaynow

I think if WFH does become the norm, there will be less popping in. It’s not like your DM/MIL would normally (I hope) just pop into your workplace and make themselves a cup of tea
You'd think so, but ...

I've been WFH for 20 years now.
Constantly gobsmacked at the array of people who imagine that my work hours are actually leisure time, & that I 'ought' to tolerate their dropping-in, phone calls, & even requests to do favours on my company time.

None of these offending parties would have dared to behave this way if I had been working for a 'proper' company with premises & a boss. I know this, because I asked 'em.

This was the most insulting realisation of all - that the 'poppers in/random phone chatters' actually had more respect for an imaginary boss than they did for me, & my company's time.

Holly60 · 12/07/2021 11:46

@PinkiOcelot

So pleased I have daughters so I don’t need to put up with a daughter in law.
I adore both my DSIL and my DDIL but out of the two my DSIL is by far the pricklier character. I don’t just turn up without asking first but I know DDIL would be far more relaxed about it than DSIL. It’s not a gender thing- it’s a personality thing. It’s taken longer to get round DSIL’s natural reserve and DDIL is from a large family so totally relaxed with the way we do things. Obviously love them both but more naturally like my DDIL than my DSIL
BeyondMyWits · 12/07/2021 11:45

I assume people who either pop into other people’s homes or don’t mind other people popping in, can’t have busy lives....

Why?
I have a busy life, if someone comes round I am capable of letting them know if I'm busy, or giving them a job to do alongside me, or sitting down with a cuppa and cake. People who come round unannounced generally realise that.

Some like spontaneous drop ins, some don't.

BackforGood · 12/07/2021 11:18

@PiggyMelon - then presumably they wouldn't answer the door.

PussGirl · 12/07/2021 11:10

My ILs turned up unannounced about a month after our wedding & caught us in bed on a Sunday afternoon - they never did it again Grin

PiggyMelon · 12/07/2021 10:51

@Mandalay246

I wouldn't turn up at my own daughters' without warning.

I think that is terribly sad. What sort of a world are we living in when you can't just drop in on your own children?? Or they can't just drop in on you??

What if they're shagging in the living room?

CrouchEndTiger12 · 12/07/2021 10:46

I have wfh for many years and unfortunately people do not respect the boundary of you working at home and will ring up, pop in etc in a way that they never would if you were in an office.

This is what I found and why i hate wfh and am glad we are going back to the office. We are already back half the time anyway now.

People cannot hassle you or ask you to do things if you are not physically at home. No one can intrude in your office.

CrouchEndTiger12 · 12/07/2021 10:44

@PinkiOcelot

So pleased I have daughters so I don’t need to put up with a daughter in law.
I'd give my own mother wrong if she just showed up at my home multiple times unannounced and uninvited.

Your daughters might be gay and you could have a DIL.

I feel sorry for the women or men your dugters end up with

BackforGood · 12/07/2021 10:40

For information - I lead a full and busy life. I've been in paid employment for 40 years, I've raised 3 dc and I volunteer in more than one organisation and I have interests and hobbies and friends. I have spent a lot of the week wfh for several years before COVID.
That's the thing with dropping in on someone when you are passing - you are completely aware it might not be a good time or they might not be in, and that is fine. Equally when people pop in on us, you are able to tell them you are working / just going out / have only got a minute and that is fine too. Obviously, if I were traveling to somewhere, then I'd check if they were in first. I'm talking about if you are passing somewhere.

@memberofthewedding I don't think we are talking about people letting themselves in - that is a completely different line. We are talking about people knocking on the door or ringing the bell.
@Cattitudes - I don't find that at all. People that know me well know when my working days are, and people who don't know that about me are less likely to pop in anyway. Plus, in my job, if I'm not in a meeting at that point, it often would be perfectly feasible to take a tea break whilst having a chat to a friend and then finishing a bit later that evening. I realise not everyone can do that, but many wfh people can.

Swipe left for the next trending thread