Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XDH won't help support DD now she's 18

332 replies

AbsolutelySure · 10/07/2021 18:50

We're divorced but amicable. We had a court order for him to pay maintenance until she leaves secondary education. I thought this would be August when she receives her A level results and child benefit stops but he checked with her school and they said she was no longer on the register from June so he stopped paying. I didn't argue the toss but asked if he could help me support her financially until she goes to Uni or would he consider either giving her the money direct or help by going 50/50 on getting her set up at Uni. He said no. I'm disappointed for her that he's acted this way. DD has not got a job because I wanted her to focus on her studies. She's applied for jobs since leaving school but has so far been unsuccessful.

OP posts:
AbsolutelySure · 11/07/2021 09:47

@Rebornagain what does NRP mean? XDH does have the finances, he doesn't support DD emotionally either. Not sure if you've read the post or just scanned it

OP posts:
Rebornagain · 11/07/2021 09:41

Why is it expected to help financially whilst a child is at uni?

What if the NRP doesn't have the money to assist? Support doesn't have to be financial but when it comes to NRPs it is always expected.

BasicDad · 11/07/2021 08:09

@AbsolutelySure he sounds like a weasely turd. I didn't mean to imply you specifically had set the scene for poor co-parenting. You sound like you've done a fine job of supporting your kids and their relationship with their dad.

SlothinSpirit · 11/07/2021 08:04

OP, of course YANBU to think that he should support her but YABU to expect it, I'm afraid, given his history.

What I would say is this. You're in a great position, although things may be temporarily difficult. You're coming to the end of the hard slog period of raising kids. You're the one who will have your DC in the house for Christmas, who can make plans with them, who will be involved with weddings and grandchildren and hearing about their first jobs and anything else that happens in their lives in the future. You have all this to look forward to while it sounds like your eldest DD will soon choose to see her father less and less (and the youngest already has the measure of him). Well done, you have done such a great job and your children know this.

AbsolutelySure · 11/07/2021 07:56

@Vrnyoop and others. I will look at the links you have provided though I don't want to go down the route of trying to claim money from him after this whole starting university thing is cleared up. That will fuel his resentment. I will be there to support DD as much as I can, when she needs it and I will put money aside each month. I'll support her when she asks as she's very comfortable asking me. I would like her to try to manage on her own and I know that's what she'll try to do but I'll be there if she's struggling and if it gets too much I will see if he will help at that time.

OP posts:
knittingaddict · 11/07/2021 07:50

@Rebornagain

Maybe I'm missing something but when I went to uni I didn't get any financial help from parents. They helped me move etc but when your 18 you are an adult and isn't the whole point of going to Uni is to learn to live and move away from Parents?
Yes you are missing something. Why do you think part of the student loan is means tested using the parents income? Answer, it's because the government expects parents to financially support their adult children through uni.

Even with a student loan, a part time job in term time and a full time job in the holidays the income wouldn't cover our daughter's basics. We had to provide the short fall. It's what decent parents do if they can afford it. The op's ex can too, but has chosen not to.

AbsolutelySure · 11/07/2021 07:50

Thank you to everyone for their support. It's such a shame that there are many people in the same boat, giving such a bad name to those parents who are separated but continuing to support their DCs financially and emotionally as parents should.

@BasicDad it would be great had we co-parented. I didn't work for 12 years as I brought up our DCs whilst he set up his business. Over time he began to resent supporting us whilst he worked and I looked after the family, so I went back to work as soon as DCs were in secondary school. We split shortly after due to his infidelity. He had that little involvement in parenting, that DCs did not realise that he'd moved out for the first three months (he came back at weekends and they accepted my story of him 'working away').

XDH has a son, my DSS, he counted down the days until he was 18 and paid the final payment pro rata. We weren't together at that time but I remember him rubbing his hands with glee. I always knew he wouldn't support DDs after the final maintenance payment though he had agreed it made sense to pay until end of august but then went to the school for clarification and made his last payment in May.

If XDH had paid his maintenance until august this thread wouldn't exist (by me) as I'd have used that money to help set up DD. No 'nukes' have been set off, there has been no frosty exchange of words so no relationships broken, DD is aware that payments have stopped and although disappointed she still obviously loves her dad.

My last comment to him by email was to do what he felt was the right thing to do by his daughter. His comment was that he felt he should stick to the court order. I wait for clarification from my solicitor regarding the date for finishing secondary school.

OP posts:
Londonnight · 11/07/2021 07:40

Sounds like we have the same ex! Mine stopped paying the day our son finished college, said he doesn't need to pay anymore, even though at the time son wasn't working and I was on minimum wage. He refused anymore help at all.

He didn't even tell me he was stopping payments, he just cancelled the standing order.
You don't stop being a parent once your child reaches 18.

Arsebucket · 11/07/2021 07:35

Ha, yes mine also told me he was counting down.

He had no intention of ever paying post 18 to anyone regardless of what ds decided to do.

“I’ve supported him long enough, now it’s your turn is his way of thinking”.

The thing is, some men don’t see maintenance as something that is for their children. They see it as something they are giving their ex partners and it kills them to do it.

The children don’t come into it. it’s just the resentment for having to give their ex
money.

Menora · 11/07/2021 07:30

My ex did count down the days with glee!
Also thinks he has a good relationship with DD1 and DD2 can’t stand him and barely has anything to do with him

Are there carbon copies of these men out there? Mine bought a 450k house that he’s doing up, which is why he can’t help his own DC out with £10 a week

knittingaddict · 11/07/2021 07:23

@Doghead

I don't really understand. Why do you think she'll need more money? My son got maximum student loan and never needed more money from anyone
You can't use your imagination and think that not everyone is in the same situation as your son?

Our daughter had a student loan which didn't even cover rent for her student accommodation and she had a job all through uni. She is very good with money, but we still had to transfer £300 a month to support her with the basics.

Father's like this are disgraceful.

tallduckandhandsome · 11/07/2021 07:18

@HollowTalk

My XH agreed to pay until they finished university and did, even though they stayed on to do MAs. But then I had something on him that he didn't want the OW to know so that gave me great leverage. Grin
Oh you have to tell us what, even obliquely! Other other woman maybe?
pilingup · 11/07/2021 07:18

This isn't really answering your question (but your ex is a dick) has your dd tried temping agencies? A lot of them are supplying staff to vaccination centres and test centres, my DS has found summer work that way.

Arsebucket · 11/07/2021 07:14

@chaosmaker

There are usually jobs doing care work. Very much needed at the moment.
That sort of job is not for everyone though.

That’s the work I do. The amount of people who have come in, worked a shift and got though it gagging and having to run to the loo being sick while changing pads and dealing with other bodily fluids and then not come back the next day.

I wouldn’t go there as an option for a teen unless they knew what to expect from the job.

Rhubarbcrumblerules · 11/07/2021 06:37

[quote AbsolutelySure]@FunMcCool when we were together she was the apple of his eye, he then did the dirty and he left, she sees him every couple of months, more her choice - he lives five mins away. We have another DD who is 16 and she stopped speaking to him three years ago after the way he treated me in particular. He hurt her dearly and he's not made any attempt to reconcile with her.

He thinks he has a great relationship with DD1.....[/quote]
I could have written this exact same post word for word my ex has done the same. Youngest DD17 now suffering with her mental health because of him, eldest DD21 tolerates him sporadically but says she has no love for him. He financially and mentally backed out years ago and I supported them both through some pretty rough years. He thinks he had a good relationship with eldest and blames me for filling youngest head with 'my side of the story' as she won't speak to him. He cant see that it was how he behaved that has affected her.

He lost his job during covid so of course any (smaĺl) payment for the youngest stopped abruptly, yet it doesn't matter that I still have to support DD, which I do willingly, I would.give my last penny to help my children.

Vrnyoop · 11/07/2021 05:34

Shame on your exDH OP.

As others have said it’s time to make an application under the Children Act 1989. The Act also covers children aged over 18 who are in or about to be in full time education.

Here’s a brief explanation scraped from the web

events.lawsociety.org.uk/uploads/files/7888b166-a77e-468e-b114-cd62bc514b3a.pdf

You can make the application yourself OP - no need to pay legal fees.

This great charity can help you free of charge

www.supportthroughcourt.org/

Classica · 11/07/2021 04:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

mathanxiety · 11/07/2021 03:52

@SD1978, she apparently asked her dad for the loan of £30 to get herself a pair of jeans earlier this year and he hounded her for repayment.

I would say his behaviour then would put her off ever trying again.

CJsGoldfish · 11/07/2021 02:58

I am so angered by these fucking disgusting men who are counting down the days to when they can switch from doing the bare minimum to doing fuck all to support their own children
There are just as many women counting down the days until their husband/partner can stop paying for children that aren't 'theirs'

OP, my ex-h did the same but I knew he would. It's rare that they pay half of the true cost of the children anyway so life as a single parent is generally mum picking up the slack.
I've helped my children with anything they've needed but they also have always worked to make it easier for me. They see their father for who he is. He always, always has the newest and best of everything but has never given them a single penny since he stopped paying. Disappointing, and tough at times because I STILL will do anything they need and he does not.
None of them have a good relationship with him. Two have changed their name to mine. They do their obligatory once a month visit but no one wants to. I encouraging them to keep some kind of relationship because he is their father, no matter how shit he is. His wife is lovely and I think they feel she was well and truly sucked in by him. It kinda makes me mad that SHE is being robbed of the relationship she could have had with them because he's a twat.

Anyway, what I really wanted to say was I totally 'get' the disappointment but it is you who they will always remember being 'the one'. Their true rock.

GingerScallop · 11/07/2021 02:35

@Macncheeseballs

That is a bit mean, but do you need the money
Surely it's DD, his daughter needing the money rather than OP.

he lent her the money and then kept texting to find out when she was going to pay him back which totally stressed her out.
What a pusy oozing dickhead! They will come home to roost in a few years. And he will pretend he does not why or that you influenced DD

frazzledasarock · 11/07/2021 02:32

And there are plenty of just shit, useless excuses of sorry sperm donors in the world.

Far too many fathers think they’re oh so clever dodging paying for their children once a relationship breaks down anyway. I can’t imagine for the life of me ex agreeing to put away any money for my DC 😂

Both parents financial responsibility should legally continue towards a child in education not just the parent who’s always there.
Because not being able to enforce ex to contribute towards DC’s maintenance means DC loses out.

chaosmaker · 11/07/2021 02:30

There are usually jobs doing care work. Very much needed at the moment.

SD1978 · 11/07/2021 02:28

Any reason why she can't ask her dad, given her age, as opposed to you? If she needs financial support as a (young) adult who has left school, and going forward needs financial support during further education, it's her responsibility to talk to her dad, not you.

BasicDad · 11/07/2021 02:16

I'm waffling on about communication and expectations between co-parents.

I'm talking about my experience, as we're setting those expectations and talking. Despite a shitty fractured relationship.

I've also at least tried to say not everyone has the opportunity to be a good co-parent. There are plenty that nuke bridges though.

EverythingWillFallInLine · 11/07/2021 02:11

We're talking about a guy who is refusing to support his daughter. Wtf are you waffling on about pride for?