Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XDH won't help support DD now she's 18

332 replies

AbsolutelySure · 10/07/2021 18:50

We're divorced but amicable. We had a court order for him to pay maintenance until she leaves secondary education. I thought this would be August when she receives her A level results and child benefit stops but he checked with her school and they said she was no longer on the register from June so he stopped paying. I didn't argue the toss but asked if he could help me support her financially until she goes to Uni or would he consider either giving her the money direct or help by going 50/50 on getting her set up at Uni. He said no. I'm disappointed for her that he's acted this way. DD has not got a job because I wanted her to focus on her studies. She's applied for jobs since leaving school but has so far been unsuccessful.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 11/07/2021 12:03

@Kanaloa

Well the lack of effort he has put in now will be repaid to him in full when he realises he has a poor relationship with his own child. It’s awful though but nothing you can do.
Yes, some day he will be sad and lonely with only his money for company. Some hope for the Ghost of Christmas Past to pay him a visit.
shouldistop · 11/07/2021 11:54

He sounds like an absolute dick head. I suppose there's not much you can do about it though.

EverythingWillFallInLine · 11/07/2021 11:51

@Doghead if a parent has means to contribute then a student shouldn't be accessing that level of student finance anyway. If op was earning over the threshold for max finance would you say it was ok for her dd to use student finance and for op to pay nothing?

HollowTalk · 11/07/2021 11:46

Don't be ridiculous, @Doghead. Hall fees take up a huge % of the loan and if parents aren't giving money regularly then students have to work. It's very different for students who live at home for free and keep their existing part-time jobs.

Doghead · 11/07/2021 11:38

The student finance more than covers all living expenses. Any student that says it doesn't is trying it on

EverythingWillFallInLine · 11/07/2021 11:35

@StrangeToSee op can absolutely force him to contribute as her dd is in full time education. There is express provision for that in the Children Act. Why on earth should student finance provide for a young person when her parent has means to do so? It's a misuse of funds.

DdraigGoch · 11/07/2021 11:34

[quote AbsolutelySure]@DrinkFeckArseBrick no she won't ask him, a couple of years ago she plucked up the courage to ask him if she could 'borrow' £30 for a pair of jeans, he lent her the money and then kept texting to find out when she was going to pay him back which totally stressed her out. [/quote]
What a caring father.

EverythingWillFallInLine · 11/07/2021 11:31

@Rebornagain you need to take your question to student finance and benefit assessors.

As previously explained, both are set up with the expectation that parents support young people until 21 years old. So an 18 yo can't claim benefits. And student finance is based on parent income. Unless the parent formally declares that they are financially estranged from their child. So a parent is actually obliged to support an adult child. Where the parent is non resident and the adult child is in education or is disabled, the court can order support (schedule one mentioned above). Where the parent is resident, they are required to support.

JeansShirtJeansJacket · 11/07/2021 11:03

*Horrible and lonely

It was not bloody lovely lol.

JeansShirtJeansJacket · 11/07/2021 11:02

@Ideasplease322

There is a strange attitude from some on mumsnet about parental support.

Some weren’t given a penny after 16 or 18, some were even kicked out of the home to fend for themselves. Some see this as a badge of honour and get angry if anyone else is given support, almost scoffing at these snowflakes whose parent feed them, or help out with transport, rent or other living costs.

They can’t see beyond their own personal experience and any on who approaches it differently is wrong.

It is really sad that your ex doesn’t want to help his children.

Totally agree with you @Ideasplease322

I was one of those kids that was basically kicked out the door at 18, having already been pretty much feeding for myself for years.

It was horrible and lovely and I really struggled. I am not close with my parents now and they very rarely see their grandchildren. I don't want this for my own children. Of course I want to raise them to become independent, but that doesn't require me washing my hands of them once they turn 18.

AbsolutelySure · 11/07/2021 10:58

@DontBiteTheBoobThatFeedsYou yes whilst studying for A levels she wanted to concentrate on her studies (which was throughout Covid anyway) but since finishing her studies, she has applied for jobs unsuccessfully so far.

OP posts:
SusannahSophia · 11/07/2021 10:58

OP, have you looked into whether your DD might be eligible for a bursary from her uni? DS1 got a bursary from his uni which came as a surprise to us as we hadn’t checked it out. He automatically qualified through agreeing thar Student Finance could share household finances with the uni. With DS3 we actively checked which unis gave the best bursaries and what their criteria were. Each uni seems to do this differently and we weren’t eligible at all of them. They ranged from £0 - £2000 a year.

It doesn’t solve your immediate situation, nor make your ExH a better person, sadly, but might give your DD a bit of cheer.

If you Google bursaries at your DD’s firm and insurance unis you should get some info.

DontBiteTheBoobThatFeedsYou · 11/07/2021 10:53

To be fair, you said in the OP that she doesn't want to get a job because she wants to focus on her studies.

But she has applied for jobs.

Either way the dads a dick

TheWeeDonkey · 11/07/2021 10:53

@Ideasplease322

There is a strange attitude from some on mumsnet about parental support.

Some weren’t given a penny after 16 or 18, some were even kicked out of the home to fend for themselves. Some see this as a badge of honour and get angry if anyone else is given support, almost scoffing at these snowflakes whose parent feed them, or help out with transport, rent or other living costs.

They can’t see beyond their own personal experience and any on who approaches it differently is wrong.

It is really sad that your ex doesn’t want to help his children.

I agree with this 100% but I do find it sad that so many people think its normal to not have supportive parents.
CastawayQueen · 11/07/2021 10:49

@Ideasplease322

There is a strange attitude from some on mumsnet about parental support.

Some weren’t given a penny after 16 or 18, some were even kicked out of the home to fend for themselves. Some see this as a badge of honour and get angry if anyone else is given support, almost scoffing at these snowflakes whose parent feed them, or help out with transport, rent or other living costs.

They can’t see beyond their own personal experience and any on who approaches it differently is wrong.

It is really sad that your ex doesn’t want to help his children.

If anything having gone through it people shouldn’t want their DC to. I don’t at all…
NCBlossom · 11/07/2021 10:48

@Ideasplease322

There is a strange attitude from some on mumsnet about parental support.

Some weren’t given a penny after 16 or 18, some were even kicked out of the home to fend for themselves. Some see this as a badge of honour and get angry if anyone else is given support, almost scoffing at these snowflakes whose parent feed them, or help out with transport, rent or other living costs.

They can’t see beyond their own personal experience and any on who approaches it differently is wrong.

It is really sad that your ex doesn’t want to help his children.

I think 99% of those saying they fended for themselves still had some help from one or both parents. They just don’t want to admit it or have ‘forgotten’.
NCBlossom · 11/07/2021 10:45

At least your DD has one parent, who is supportive and a parent. She will appreciate that and it will massively help her take that next step.

Even the poorest parents would still offer their kids a roof over their heads for holidays or when they needed it when they either went to college or into a job. It’s a transition phases - the emphasis on transition - not push off the edge of a cliff and turn your back!

I know because my Dad did push me off the edge of a cliff. It’s taken me years to realise how awful that was. Now I have zero respect for him.

StrangeToSee · 11/07/2021 10:19

Most students find a part time job whilst working. Everyone I know did this and we all managed to focus on our studies and pass with top grades.

Also there are student loans.

I don’t think you can force him to keep paying, unless he owes you back payments?

Ideasplease322 · 11/07/2021 10:18

There is a strange attitude from some on mumsnet about parental support.

Some weren’t given a penny after 16 or 18, some were even kicked out of the home to fend for themselves. Some see this as a badge of honour and get angry if anyone else is given support, almost scoffing at these snowflakes whose parent feed them, or help out with transport, rent or other living costs.

They can’t see beyond their own personal experience and any on who approaches it differently is wrong.

It is really sad that your ex doesn’t want to help his children.

faithfulbird20 · 11/07/2021 10:15

Tell him his children didnt divorce him!

Well eventually you reap what you sow and when he needs helps in his old age, your kids will turn their back!

ijudgeyou · 11/07/2021 10:13

Some shockers on this thread. DHs dad was the resident parent and as he was a high earner DH's loan didn't even cover accommodation. He had a job from age 12 (not sure that's even legal) so that he could feed himself so it wasn't a shock when no help at uni was offered.

It's not really about legal obligation though. If ops exH can provide financial support in order to make his DD's uni experience easier/more enjoyable why on earth wouldn't he. Just because some posters provided solely for themselves through uni it doesn't mean that everyone else should where there's the option not to. DH certainly won't be advising our DC to start working every day after school from age 12 just because he did.

AbsolutelySure · 11/07/2021 10:05

@Flibbitygibbit that's actually a really valid point. Yes he would, without question.

OP posts:
Flibbitygibbit · 11/07/2021 10:02

Mine did exactly this . If you were still married he’d be contributing wouldn’t he ? Wankers !

Ideasplease322 · 11/07/2021 09:55

@Reallyreallyborednow

I don't really understand. Why do you think she'll need more money? My son got maximum student loan and never needed more money from anyone

This. I completely supported myself through uni. Worked in the holidays. My mum never offered, i never asked.

Unless loans have changed and they’re based on both parents incomes now?

If you don’t want her to get a job to focus on her studies then that’s you taking away an income stream.

Your mum didn’t offer to to help you in any way? That’s tough - was she in a precarious financial position.

Did you go home in holidays? If so did you pay for your own food and share of the bills?

I understand some parents simply can’t afford to help their children, but in this case it sounds like the dad just doesn’t want to. Which is douse his right but it does sound mean.

I worked through university, but lived at home So my parents covered food, living expenses and paid for some basics like public transport.

ineedaholidaynow · 11/07/2021 09:52

@Rebornagain surely support, financial or otherwise, should be given by parents. That is the role of any parent, resident or non-resident