Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

XDH won't help support DD now she's 18

332 replies

AbsolutelySure · 10/07/2021 18:50

We're divorced but amicable. We had a court order for him to pay maintenance until she leaves secondary education. I thought this would be August when she receives her A level results and child benefit stops but he checked with her school and they said she was no longer on the register from June so he stopped paying. I didn't argue the toss but asked if he could help me support her financially until she goes to Uni or would he consider either giving her the money direct or help by going 50/50 on getting her set up at Uni. He said no. I'm disappointed for her that he's acted this way. DD has not got a job because I wanted her to focus on her studies. She's applied for jobs since leaving school but has so far been unsuccessful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CayrolBaaaskin · 15/07/2021 22:29

Your dd can go to court to enforce maintenance for herself. He is obliged to support her while she is in full time education. I think it’s schedule 1 to children’s act in England. Get a solicitor who specializes to assist.

C0RINNA · 14/07/2021 10:44

[quote AbsolutelySure]@C0RINNA I didn't mean it was immoral to go through CMS , I meant that we agreed a figure four years ago and I it doesn't sit right with me to overrule that agreement we had by now going to CMS to gain more for DD2.

@RandomMess it was agreed based on a slightly less income, probably around £10-£15k pa. he was paying much more than other people I know were getting from their XDH so I was happy with the amount. I still am happy with the sum he pays for DD2, I just wanted him to step up and be there for DD1 to help get her started at Uni and if she needed it in the future. [/quote]
So you agreed a figure less than the legal minimum on behalf of your children. Now your ex has failed in his moral duty ( legal in some countries ) to support his older child until she finishes her full time education.

Yet you are clinging to some imaginary moral high ground which involves saving your exs money and depriving your younger daughter of money that she is due Hmm ? Im afraid I’m struggling to understand your morality.

Are you trying to keep on his good side in the hope that you will get back together ? Otherwise why would you put him before your child ?

PearlNextDoor · 13/07/2021 17:08

Yeh that's what galls me about my x. He knows my job is "shit" and he has no way of knowing that she can still go to university without the maintenance and yet he stops paying 🤔
He cannot pat himself on the back for any success she achieves

RandomMess · 13/07/2021 13:57

4 years isn't long in the scheme of things.

I agree it's horrid of him to have zero pride in DD going off to uni and to not want to actually support her SadSadSad

I think I would have to send a comment about how surprised you are that he wants to be as unsupportive as his parents were to him when he had such a chip on his shoulder about it.

AbsolutelySure · 13/07/2021 13:24

@C0RINNA I didn't mean it was immoral to go through CMS , I meant that we agreed a figure four years ago and I it doesn't sit right with me to overrule that agreement we had by now going to CMS to gain more for DD2.

@RandomMess it was agreed based on a slightly less income, probably around £10-£15k pa. he was paying much more than other people I know were getting from their XDH so I was happy with the amount. I still am happy with the sum he pays for DD2, I just wanted him to step up and be there for DD1 to help get her started at Uni and if she needed it in the future.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 13/07/2021 09:03

CMS is actually the LEGAL MINIMUM.

We're the maintenance payments not index linked to account for inflation, has he just had promotion after promotion or did you did take a low point at the time to reduce conflict?

If his salary has notably increased since the settlement then it should have been changed as that settlement was on his circumstances at that moment in time.

He doesn't care about his DC anyway so what have you got to lose?

C0RINNA · 13/07/2021 08:19

@AbsolutelySure

The friction (and that's putting it mildly) would be massive, he'd be incandescent with absolute rage! Could CMS come back with a lower figure than what their calculation suggest? I doubt I could go down this route. I've mentioned his lack of moral standards, this wouldn't sit well within my moral standards.
Why do you think it’s immoral to use CMS? They are a government agency who will calculate the child support due from your ex H ‘s tax returns.

I understand that CMS doesn’t work for many children as their father is paid cash in hand or self employed. But I’ve never heard anyone say it’s immoral Hmm .

AbsolutelySure · 12/07/2021 21:11

I've only needed to declare my own finances Smile

OP posts:
Bollindger · 12/07/2021 21:06

She doesn't have to declare his. Mine didn't.

RandomMess · 12/07/2021 21:03

With student finance you only declare the earnings of the parent you live with.

Mrstamborineman · 12/07/2021 21:02

I am preparing to get flamed for this.
If he is the high earner, maybe consider not putting his name on her student finance forms. She will get less support and need to work to top it up as s a result: unless of course he is likely to support her. ??

RandomMess · 12/07/2021 21:01

If he's employed with wage slips etc they can ultimately issue a deductions of earnings order.

AbsolutelySure · 12/07/2021 20:58

The friction (and that's putting it mildly) would be massive, he'd be incandescent with absolute rage! Could CMS come back with a lower figure than what their calculation suggest? I doubt I could go down this route. I've mentioned his lack of moral standards, this wouldn't sit well within my moral standards.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 12/07/2021 20:41

I believe (but please check) you can halt the court order after a year and go to CMS.

TBH I would go to CMS to help save something to help them both through uni.

AbsolutelySure · 12/07/2021 20:34

@RandomMess I've just done a quick calculation and if believed he would pay double what he pays now, though I'm happy with the amount now he pays. I don't need him to pay more, I just don't like his attitude towards the 'cut off'.

Very interesting though and I would certainly drop it in conversation if necessary. If we have a court order though would the CMS overrule this?

OP posts:
RandomMess · 12/07/2021 18:30

It would be worth considering if you would get more for just your youngest DD switching to CMS now/September so he doesn't pull the same stunt when she finishes!

Or does he pay above the CMS rate even after subsequent pay rises etc?

AbsolutelySure · 12/07/2021 12:38

@ClareBlue good point. I suppose I kind of expected this treatment but disappointed he hasn't proven me wrong

OP posts:
Reallyreallyborednow · 12/07/2021 11:24

My older DC are both changing their names to mine and DH's. if ex ever finds out he will be spitting and all woe is me.🙄

I definitely think we should be moving towards women keeping their names and giving children their mum’s surname.

Men can change their names to match their kids if they want. To quote many women’s reason for name changing- it would show they are “proud to be a husband and father”.

ClareBlue · 12/07/2021 11:24

[quote CastawayQueen]@AbsolutelySure as pp have said the chickens will come home to roost... don't worry.
People regret their misdeeds when old. When they realise what the warmth of family and care for other human beings actually mean.
But when young and rich and focused on work they are selfish... 'all money is FOR ME, I ALONE earned it, family doesn't exist once divorced'

Mine and DP's parents are not like this but one of my uncles was. Children are all now in decent professions, never visit him and he'll be alone in the nursing home .. paid for with his precious money.. for the next few years.[/quote]
This is so true. As I get older I am seeing it more and more.
Nobody has said they wished they had more money when in a nursing home but plenty wish they had better relationships with their family, not made big deals about small stuff and not made up or forgiven petty stuff, had educated themselves and had traveled more when they had opportunities. They seem to be the the big issues when you are reaching life's end.

Arsebucket · 12/07/2021 11:09

@frazzledasarock see, we weren’t married when ds was born, we married a few months later and ds had our surnames double barrelled. Only he’s dropped by name now, just uses his dads. Feels like another kick in the teeth.

Arsebucket · 12/07/2021 11:05

@frazzledasarock

I'm sorry *@Arsebucket* do you think his father will be happy to take him in?

I reckon ex would have but he would have mistreated my DC and not supported them in their studies or wanted them to progress, he was very jealous of anyone having more than he had, he didn't have a degree and would be spitting about my eldest going on to uni.
Ex would have used my DC as unpaid domestic staff I'm pretty sure of that.

My older DC are both changing their names to mine and DH's. if ex ever finds out he will be spitting and all woe is me.🙄

No. The only reason he would want ds is to get one over on me.

He’s only seen ds maybe once a month sat-sun since he as 13, less since he was 16.His wife isn’t ds biggest fan, my fault though as I’m such a terrible mother.

ds is a huge disappointment to him. eh h has four sisters, all their dc see high achievers, at or going to top unis.

Of course, it’s all down to my piss poor parenting that ds isnt.

frazzledasarock · 12/07/2021 10:48

I'm sorry @Arsebucket do you think his father will be happy to take him in?

I reckon ex would have but he would have mistreated my DC and not supported them in their studies or wanted them to progress, he was very jealous of anyone having more than he had, he didn't have a degree and would be spitting about my eldest going on to uni.
Ex would have used my DC as unpaid domestic staff I'm pretty sure of that.

My older DC are both changing their names to mine and DH's. if ex ever finds out he will be spitting and all woe is me.🙄

ClareBlue · 12/07/2021 10:43

[quote AbsolutelySure]@DrinkFeckArseBrick no she won't ask him, a couple of years ago she plucked up the courage to ask him if she could 'borrow' £30 for a pair of jeans, he lent her the money and then kept texting to find out when she was going to pay him back which totally stressed her out. [/quote]
I think this is quite shocking and sad.
Also, for the sake of a couple of hundred quid he is destroying his relationship with his daughter. A daughter who is obviously bright and has a great future ahead. Who should be his pride and joy that he can support whilst she developed as a young women.
But instead he thinks a few pounds saved is more important.
I don't think it is possible to understand this mentality.
The surprise is that you say you are disappointed. Did you really have any expectations to be disappointed about or did you expect this bevaviour?

Arsebucket · 12/07/2021 10:38

@frazzledasarock

As horrible as this sounds, I would offer for your son to go live with his dad, if he has so little respect for you. Nothing tying him down accepting your money earned by your 'thick' job keeping a roof over his head and paying for everything for him.

His dad can clearly pay for everything plus pay (whatever amount of child maintenance he was made to pay) as pocket money.

Your son knows the truth.

And key workers are not thick, you all kept the country ticking over during lockdown.

Ds is very nearly 19 now.

I suspect he will go shortly.

frazzledasarock · 12/07/2021 10:36

As horrible as this sounds, I would offer for your son to go live with his dad, if he has so little respect for you. Nothing tying him down accepting your money earned by your 'thick' job keeping a roof over his head and paying for everything for him.

His dad can clearly pay for everything plus pay (whatever amount of child maintenance he was made to pay) as pocket money.

Your son knows the truth.

And key workers are not thick, you all kept the country ticking over during lockdown.