Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What would you have done in this situation?

35 replies

Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 14:00

I’m just curious to know if my view is in the minority here. My mother dropped me off to a train station for a celebration event related to finishing my degree. In the car I had a necklace in my hand which I was going to put on before getting out of the car. As I get on the train I realise that I did not put it on but also do not have it in my bag or remember putting it down anywhere. I text my mum and ask if she would please look in the car for it as I would be very upset if it was lost ( given that it was a 21st present from her) She texts back and says that it is indeed in the car, so relieved I just carry on with my day. Later that night when she collects me from the station she tells me that she didn’t find the necklace and did not want to tell me and ruin my day. I was really annoyed as if she had said it wasn’t in the car I would have asked her to go back to the station car park and have a look on the floor where we were parked ( this is the only other logical place It could be) but by that point a whole day had gone by and unfortunately the area is not one where things are likely to be handed in. I feel that it is worse having that false sense of relief only to be told later on that she lied. She cannot see the problem and stands by her decision. So if you were her would you have told the truth or lied to stop it from ruining the day?
( we haven’t fallen out over it because I accept that she didn’t lie to be horrible but I still think it was wrong)

Am I being unreasonable to be annoyed at the lie?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jobsharenightmare · 10/07/2021 16:00

She should have told the truth so you could have gone back to look for it.

Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 15:48

@NeedNewKnees

It came from a good urge - to let you enjoy your evening and celebrate your graduation. She's obviously proud of you and thinks you deserve your celebration.
It really did and I understand that, we haven’t fallen out over it. It’s just that if she had told me the truth I would have asked her to go back to the station car park and see if it had fallen on the floor by the car. To be honest I probably would have got off the train at the next stop and gone back to look myself as there was a lot of sentimental value in it. Of course then being relieved that it wasn’t lost and finding out that wasn’t the case I think made it worse.
OP posts:
NeedNewKnees · 10/07/2021 15:22

It came from a good urge - to let you enjoy your evening and celebrate your graduation. She's obviously proud of you and thinks you deserve your celebration.

Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 15:14

Just to update as some have asked. She saw my text asking her to look for it when she got home( as I knew she’d be driving ) she didn’t go back to the car park to look for it but spent a while checking the car to see if it had gone down the seats etc

OP posts:
ObviousNameChage · 10/07/2021 15:13

Can you please show me where she has blamed her mum? Her mum lied and possibly ruined her chances of finding it!

How? OP had no chances finding it being on a train and then on a night out.
The only one who could do something about it was her mum, and maybe she didn't feel it was worth it going back for it or couldn't. The necklace was lost by then anyways and if the parking lot probably gone too as it doesn't sound like a couple of minutes time frame, so no point in ruining her daughter's night.

thisplaceisweird · 10/07/2021 15:11

Very very strange. I wouldn't be able to not ask her about it ... E.g. wtf were you thinking

Jenny70 · 10/07/2021 15:10

I'd be cross as she taken away the slight chance you might have found it. It might have been caught in your sleeve, or loose in your bag (for example), and if you known it was lost you'd check yourself (and ask her to check the station for you) as well. It may have still been lost, but at least you'd know you'd done everything to find it.
Have you checked the car as well, could have slipped deep down, slithering into an unexpected place?

Bumzoo · 10/07/2021 15:07

Phone the station. If I found it I would have handed it in.

notacooldad · 10/07/2021 15:00

She was trying to be nice, focus on the thought. It's all you can do xxx
I agree with this.
In your mum's position I think I would have said something like " I cant see it yet, I'll have a good look when I get chance'

Highfive2021 · 10/07/2021 14:59

That seams like quite strange behaviour then she couldn’t have though much of the present she bought for you Confused

Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 14:56

@Highfive2021

I’d be more upset about the lie if the necklace wasn’t from her. Did she check the car park and ask at the station?
No she was already back at home when she was able to read my text asking if she would check the car for it. She didn’t go back to look and seeing as I thought it was found I didn’t ask her to.
OP posts:
Highfive2021 · 10/07/2021 14:53

I’d be more upset about the lie if the necklace wasn’t from her. Did she check the car park and ask at the station?

Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 14:47

@Bluntness100

She obviously had the best of intentions, so that’s what matters, I do t understand why you didn’t put the necklace on, it’s very odd behaviour to just sit holding it. Is there a reason?
This isn’t really what the post was getting at but for some context... My mum was waiting in the car for me , I take the necklace from the dressing table and was going to ask her to secure it on for me as it has a difficult clasp. So I have it in my hand.. a phone call that I had to take comes through and by that time I’ve arrived at the station and simply got distracted. That is my fault , I’m not denying that and I feel very guilty that it is lost. The post is in regard to what happened after that.
OP posts:
HideousKinky · 10/07/2021 14:47

If I'd been your mum I would have told you it was not in the car and gone back to look in the station for you (if able to without being late for work or whatever)

OneMamaAndHerGirl · 10/07/2021 14:41

@2bazookas

Stop blaming your mum. Recognise that the loss of your necklace is your fault not hers. You're not a child any more.
Can you please show me where she has blamed her mum? Her mum lied and possibly ruined her chances of finding it!
Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 14:41

@PocketSize

Why didnt you just put it on in the car?
I was about to , I then had a phone call come through and got distracted, by that time I’d got to the station and have no idea what happened.
OP posts:
OneMamaAndHerGirl · 10/07/2021 14:41

@PocketSize

Why didnt you just put it on in the car?
And the award for the most unhelpful comment goes too............ Hmm honestly
Bluntness100 · 10/07/2021 14:40

She obviously had the best of intentions, so that’s what matters, I do t understand why you didn’t put the necklace on, it’s very odd behaviour to just sit holding it. Is there a reason?

SirGawain · 10/07/2021 14:37

@PocketSize

Why didnt you just put it on in the car?
A less than helpful comment!
Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 14:32

She was definitely trying to be nice , I accept that and we are fine, both sitting here together reading these now. I was only curious to know if anyone else shared my view in that lying wasn’t the best thing to do as it made me feel worse when she told me. We don’t usually have such differing opinions like this so I was just interested in the views of others x

OP posts:
TillyTopper · 10/07/2021 14:32

Is she usually that bonkers?! I'd have said no, not in the car and gone back to the station to have a look and told you so you could check your collar/pockets/bags etc. I'd be pissed off with her.

Roodicus21 · 10/07/2021 14:30

I think she was trying to be nice, however I would have expected her to have gone and looked for it also.

Brogan78 · 10/07/2021 14:28

Never in that post have I blamed her for it? What you’ve said is completely unrelated to the question I posted. Loosing the necklace- all my fault , I feel guilty enough so thank you for reinforcing that for me. No I’m not a child, thanks for clearing that up.

OP posts:
MrsToothyBitch · 10/07/2021 14:28

She was trying to be nice, focus on the thought. It's all you can do xxx

2bazookas · 10/07/2021 14:21

Stop blaming your mum. Recognise that the loss of your necklace is your fault not hers. You're not a child any more.