Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Guilty and very uncomfortable about it. How many of you feel guilty for not contributing financially to the home? Married or not is a family unit and...

61 replies

Flowersandteaforall · 10/07/2021 11:11

Just that really.
We manage with one income and not a lot of disposable money but still doable. I do 90 percent of the house chores and we are both very involved in raising our only child. He is a great dad and is very generous with his money too. I feel bad for not contributing financially (I used to work self-employed so earnings were inconsistent and little) to sum up he is the main earner and I'm a sahm that feels the guilt.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brainwave89 · 10/07/2021 20:18

In my house the reverse is true. My husband was a SAHD. Providing you have discussed and agreed the approach, and you have respect for the role each partner has it works- and did work for us. That being said, I would always encourage a partner to return to work when the kids are at school. Although our arrangement was great, in some cases my friends went through the classic scenario of being dumped for a younger model having spent years looking after small children. At this point, it is really difficult to start again, and lower paid work and poverty can sometimes result. It often comes as a shock how little a man needs to pay when he walks away from a family.

MiddleParking · 10/07/2021 19:35

I don’t think you should feel guilty at all, but I do think it’s too much sacrifice (and all on your part) for you to make if you don’t feel wholly comfortable with it.

Lemonmelonsun · 10/07/2021 19:00
  • caveat, I'm not much of a cleaner but I find it hard to keep even an even keel without having more time which impacts us all
Lemonmelonsun · 10/07/2021 18:58

Op with small children I was a sahm for many years and to be honest I don't know how we would have got through it as a family with all the stresses had I worked at that time, sleepless nights etc.
Now they are older but still young I work and it is much harder to keep one top of things.. I can't deny.. House is messier etc.. Harder to keep on top of all the bitty things they do, it's stressful for both of us it would be much easier if I had even one day off.

Your a also contributing in so many other almost intangible ways.
They are small for so so very short a time.. You can work till the day you drop dead and your also sacrifice your own pensions I imagine and work career experience.

Etceteraaah · 10/07/2021 18:30

I'm a SAHP and have been for almost 4 years. I have two children aged 7 and 3. I feel no guilt for not contributing financially at the present time because due to my DH's working hours 1) I do most of the day to day parenting and kid related stuff, 2) I do nearly all of the housework and cooking and 3) I hold us all together and keeping everything running smoothly and calmly. If I was working at the current time then it would be chaotic in our household (because I am not a naturally organised person) and, besides, everything would be dumped on me- kids, cooking, cleaning, working, and I'm not prepared to make life harder for myself when I don't have to.

I think it also helps that my dh appreciates everything I do and he knows that being at home is hard work but in a different way to if I were out doing paid work. He's very much like "work if you want to, don't work if you don't want to". However, when my youngest starts school in a year's time then I'll return to work part time. I miss work.

Flowersandteaforall · 10/07/2021 18:29

#RaindropsOnRosie
"A day of cleaning is equal to a day of meetings"

I'm going to frame that sentence. It means a treat to my low self esteem. Very well put so thank you!

OP posts:
AliasGrape · 10/07/2021 17:50

*torn on this one too

GAAAAAH FAT THUMBS!

AliasGrape · 10/07/2021 17:49

I’m torn on this one to.

I’m in the unpaid bit of mat leave now. I was working via a supply agency previously albeit continuously with one long term placement after another.

Originally we talked about me staying home for 2 years at least, possible until free childcare hours kick in at 3. DH is very happy with that idea, no issue with it.

We can afford to live on the one salary although not extravagantly. Our outgoings are fairly low. We have reasonable savings and they are split between both our names/ accounts and we have no debt. We have equal access to spending money after bills are paid.

I do the lion’s share of parenting and house stuff but by no means all, DH is definitely an active and involved dad but the mental load is definitely mine (although a lot of that is self inflicted as I like to be the one making the decisions about things like sleep, weaning etc)

I very much want to be at home with my daughter and in theory there’s nothing stopping me and I’m unbelievably fortunate in that respect.

BUT I just don’t feel right with it still and have started looking at childcare and options for going back to work at least part time.
Then I feel hideously guilty about thinking about leaving DD when I don’t have to. I feel guilt either way and then I get pissed off with myself for feeling like that too.

DramaAlpaca · 10/07/2021 17:36

I was a SAHM for 9 years, raising the DC while DH worked long hours building his career. I never felt guilty for a moment. We are a team, both bringing different things to our relationship and our family. DH was as hands on as he could be when he was around and he never made me feel like I should be earning as all income was shared. I went back to work part time when my youngest started school and full time when he went to secondary, but I don't regret my SAHM years at all.

RaindropsOnRosie · 10/07/2021 17:30

I don't feel guilty at all. I met my husband 6 years ago and I stopped working 6 months after we met and moved in with him. He has paid for everything since then and I've done all housework, shopping,etc.

We've recently welcomed a daughter to our family and the easiest part of adjusting to our new lives is having our solid routine and finances. We both share looking after her, we don't have to work out who's buying her school uniform or who's paying for the zoo tickets. We don't even argue over who puts her to bed or who cleans up her toys.

But in no way are either of us getting the easy or difficult part of the bargain. We both work just as hard and don't owe each other anything. A day of cleaning is equal to a day of meetings

Hankunamatata · 10/07/2021 15:39

Isn't it how your husband/dp feels about you being a sahp

Pashazade · 10/07/2021 13:50

Actually that is a though as mentioned by a pp. If you can afford it decent health insurance is a good idea if this will be long term. If heaven forbid my DH were to die the mortgage would be paid off and there would be enough income for us to live until I was able to get a job.

worktrip · 10/07/2021 13:23

You are working equally hard, so no reason to feel guilty.

PumpkinPie2016 · 10/07/2021 13:07

I am the main earner in our family and DH is more or less a SAHD now (he did work full time when we first met and until our son was 2 but gave up for health reasons). He does some freelance work very part time that he does around DS (who is now 7).

It doesn't bother me at all and the arrangements work very well for us all. DS always has his dad to take him to school and collect him so no breakfast/after school club. If I need to work late, it's not a problem.

I get all school holidays with them as I am a teacher so that's an added bonus.

It's not about who earns more. It's about what is best for the individual family. If you and your husband are happy with the set up, that's all that matters.

babyblues21 · 10/07/2021 13:05

Guilt is my default emotion since having kids.

I can relate

QuidcoQueen · 10/07/2021 13:02

Guilt is my default emotion since having kids.

I work 3 days a week and I have done since going back after my first Mat Leave 6 years ago.

I feel guilty for going to work and leaving the kids, I feel guilty that I enjoy leaving them, I feel guilty that I don't earn that much and feel guilty that the main financial burden is on DH.

I am mentally exhausted. Juggling everything even only on part time hours.

Right now as much as I'd get frustrated having the kids 24/7 I would give up work in a heartbeat.
I'm overwhelmed.

If it works for you and your family try not to feel guilty. We do what we think is best.

Findmeatthebeach · 10/07/2021 13:00

You really are doing the most important job of all. I was a sahm mum for 7 years and now work very part time. I do all the house chores, all the shopping, cooking and can attend any school activities and be involved with the PTA. For us a family it's a perfect balance. I don't feel guilty in the slightest but I do feel greatful that I am able to do it.

ACPC · 10/07/2021 12:54

I work a couple of nights a week, we could manage without it, but I feel better contributing and it means I have access to work which is important as a woman I think. I'm happily married but that could change. My children are older though so I'm not as knackered in the evenings as sahms with little ones!

namechange90832 · 10/07/2021 12:53

What's stopping you go back to work?

ssd · 10/07/2021 12:51

I think you are being unreasonable

Your family sound happy, where's the problem?

OhRene · 10/07/2021 12:51

I'm saving my husband a bloody fortune on childcare, a cleaner, a cook and a PA to deal with his life admin. Lucky man.

Roomonb · 10/07/2021 12:49

I don’t feel guilty AT ALL, I’m bloody knackered!

beigebrownblue · 10/07/2021 12:48

Would echo the point about thinking ahead, i.e. what you would do if relationship went pear shaped, or DH died.

Not nice things to think about but it is very sensible.

I was feeling just ready as a single parent to re-enter the paid workforce when the pandemic struck last March - and the schools closed. But my health took a turn for the worse and I was faced with 10 months home schooling so had to put my plans on hold.

Difficult and took a toll on my self confidence, but out the other end of GCSE year now and I'm not sorry it was that way, as it was an investment for DD's future as I see it.

Hoping my divorce settlement will come through soon and wil lthen have a bit of money behind me, and hopefully time for the pandemic to ease somewhat and work from home perhaps.

I guess as a mother there is always something you could potentially feel guilty about...working/not working/in a relationship/not in a relationship...providing/not providing enough...

As others have said, guilt doesn't really produce anything useful although I'm sure we all feel it at times. If you ask me it is societal conditioning.

I remember the days of the Superwoman book Shirley Conran who later said she regretted writing it at all because it was an unrealistic view of women that they could 'have it all' and made women feel inadequate.

Being a good enough mother is enough.

Flowersandteaforall · 10/07/2021 12:42

Very supportive replies, thanks! I feel a bit better and definitely less lonely.

OP posts:
Gatehouse77 · 10/07/2021 12:42

DH and I agreed before having children that we wanted one parent to be at home when they were under 5. Practically, and financially, it made sense for that person to be me.

I felt bad at times. As did DH for missing out on some things. But, providing a stable home environment, being there for emotional support and keeping a balance was just as important as providing financially.

I have worked part time (or an hourly rate) at times but have, also, needed to be on hand to deal with certain situations (mental health issues for family members, my mum’s deteriorating health/death, etc.).

We’ve had our ups and downs but try to keep the wider picture in mind.