Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To mainly consider having a second child as a potential playmate for DS?

135 replies

Rosebud1302 · 10/07/2021 08:26

I think I know the answer to this. But I'm so conflicted. I know these posts have been done to death so I apologise in advance.

DS is nearly 3. I wouldn't consider having another child until he is in school because I just can't think of having two small kids at home, it just isn't for me.

But to be honest, I don't have any burning desire to have another child at all. I love my son, but I'm not a woman who has always wanted multiple children. I am not "natural" in motherhood. To me, we are just starting to get the funding for nursery so I'm getting some money back. Although we are not struggling by any means, I am looking forward to the financial childcare burden lifting. Obviously if I have another, it will come back again full force (I don't want to be a SAHM).

Which leads me onto another point. There is potential for progressing in my job which I have wanted for a long time. But that can only happen if I increase my hours which I will be able to do when DS goes to school. If I have another child I will have to reduce again after maternity as I can't afford full time childcare fees (the nursery is expensive).

My son was a tricky baby and I struggled so so much, wondered why I had done this to myself. All the normal. I worry about feelings these things again with another baby. I'm not sure I can go through it again (had mild depression).

But on the other hand. I feel sad that DS won't have a little sibling to play with. This is naive though isn't it? Or is it. I know they might not get on but I feel at least it would be another child he can interact with. Or would the age gap (4+ years) be too much for him to see that child as a playmate anyway? I'm definitely not trying for a baby until he is in school so a smaller gap is out of the question.

Is it unreasonable to have a child in the hope it will give the first child some company?

Can I have some opinions and experiences from people who maybe felt like me and how it turned out? I know no one can decide for me of course but it would help to hear thoughts!

P.S, DP is relaxed and not strongly leaning one way or the other either.

Thank you!

OP posts:
NerrSnerr · 10/07/2021 09:05

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

It’s only on mn where siblings don’t get on…:my niece and nephew don’t have loads in common, v diff people but they can keep each other company at dinner, go round a holiday resort together….way easier for the parents
Maybe you just don't know any siblings that don't/ didn't get on. Shockingly your own personal experience isn't always the same as everyone else.
BastardMonkfish · 10/07/2021 09:04

There will be a 4 year age gap between my children. I don't see it as much as will they play together but just having someone else there to share childhood with, and the challenges of school and adulthood when they come of course. DS loves being in company and gets very upset when he has to leave his cousins, it breaks my heart. Yes he has a special bond with me and his dad, and always will have but we will always be parents. We'll never be siblings, nor should we be. I don't really remember my sister and I playing together but she was always there even when we were fighting, and I liked it. Still do - we're the best of friends now.

RubertRoo · 10/07/2021 09:02

I have a 3 year old and always knew I never wanted more than 1. Now shes older and keeps asking for a sibling it has been making me re think but then when I point out to her that a sibling would be a baby and not a ready made 3 year old play mate she soon changes her mind! I couldn't go back to the baby stage again now we've got this far and shes almost 4. Especially as we have more money to do things with her.
We went to a theme park the other day and saw a few families with a 5 year age gap between children and noticed how they basically all had to split up over the day as the children were at different ages so wanted to go on different rides or just had ones whinging they wanted to go elsewhere and it just seemed an annoyance to me! Glad to stick at 1.

NuffSaidSam · 10/07/2021 09:01

You shouldn't have a child that you don't want.

What is your extended family situation like? Does DS have any cousins? You'd be better off putting effort into building a relationship with them if possible. Or otherwise when he's older helping to facilitate friendships as much as possible.

Newmum29 · 10/07/2021 09:00

I wonder if the question should be about whether it’s nice to have a sibling as an adult. I have a 5 and 7 year gap between mine so was raised as an only. Didn’t bother me at all and I’m sure my parents weren’t expecting them to want to play with me. But as an adult I love having siblings. I’m very close to both and can’t imagine being an adult only child.

It’s hard as we have one daughter and I’m not convinced we’ll have another whereas my two nephews love one another’s company now. No guarantee they’ll get on later though.

Figgygal · 10/07/2021 08:58

We have an almost 5 year gap
Ds2 born when ds1 started school
They adore each other but bicker all the time
Don’t play so much eldest wants to play more complex games and the little one can cope with for example
They’ve both found things on TV to watch together but in some way I find that keeps the eldest younger

Saying that there is a year between me and my brother and we don’t speak for months on end have absolutely no relationship and I completely different people. Plenty of people are “onlys”

If you are considering it do it for your whole family not just for the child
based on what you said though I wouldn’t

daisybrown37 · 10/07/2021 08:58

Don’t have a second child unless you and your DP really want it.

There is 4.5 years between my sister and me - we never really played together. We didn’t get on until I hit 18!

Cosybelles · 10/07/2021 08:57

I could have written this post - the job, tricky baby, no desire at all to have another, enjoy life with one. It feels like it would be easier to put lots of effort into arranging for DC to have access to socialising opportunities (clubs, friends over etc) than it would be to have a second child. Ultimately, I cannot bring myself to create life when I don't really want to, just so that DC has someone to play with (which wouldn't be a guaranteed outcome, and can be achieved with friends).

Dudelsack · 10/07/2021 08:55

I had a 4 year age gap with my sister and we definitely weren't playmates. I help look after her and I taught her things but there wasn't really an age when we wanted to play the same things. I thought everything she liked was for babies. If you're lookingfor a playmate I don't think thats likely with an age gap of more than a few years.

Moomala · 10/07/2021 08:54

Sorry I should of said they don't get on maybe 30% of the time!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/07/2021 08:54

It’s only on mn where siblings don’t get on…:my niece and nephew don’t have loads in common, v diff people but they can keep each other company at dinner, go round a holiday resort together….way easier for the parents

AnotherEmma · 10/07/2021 08:53

"I don't have any burning desire to have another child at all. I love my son, but I'm not a woman who has always wanted multiple children."

You obviously don't want a second child for their own sake. If all you want is company for your DS, you can facilitate him spending time with friends and with cousins if he has any. Obviously that wasn't possible during Covid lockdowns but hopefully we won't get (m)any more of those! 🤞

YANBU not to want another child. You would be very unreasonable to have another just to "give" DS a sibling.

(I say this as a parent of two! But I always wanted two and partly so they would have each other but not just for that reason. It's hard work and would be much harder if I'd been unsure in the first place.)

cinammonbuns · 10/07/2021 08:53

Stick with one and ignore all the bs that a child will be lonely. If you let them play with friends, take them out to exciting places and play with them as much as you can it is fine. Nowadays people are shaving less kids due to the cost Andy put are getting to the point whereby they won’t relaly paly together that much. Of course all siblings interact but they won’t likely play with each other for hours as they will be at different stages. If that is the only reason for a second it’s not enough IMO.

Also women should be allowed to think of their career. Mumsnet loves to claim it is a very feminist site but it seems once you have kids a women should never think of a career again. Don’t allow small minded people come on to the thread and convince you you should prioritise having babies over your career.

Also PP also mentioned that second pregnancies and children may not be as easy as you expect if their is birth trauma, PND, additional needs etc. If you aren’t having a second child out of immense desire for one and just because you want a playmate you may end up regretting it.

thethoughtfox · 10/07/2021 08:52

4/5 years between each of my siblings and none of us played together as children. The age gap is too big.

Saoirse82 · 10/07/2021 08:50

4 years between my nephews. They are 10 and 6. Of course they fight like all siblings do but they have a great relationship. I think 4 years is a good age gap, i always though it would be too much a gap because there's only 2 years between me & dsis but there's 4 years between DH and SIL and they are v. close too.

Moomala · 10/07/2021 08:50

In all honesty I don't think you should have another for your ds. The main reason should be because you want another child. It won't necessarily work out that they will play with each other. I have two boys and the get on maybe 30% of the time and there is 3 years age gap.a lot of the time it's little bits of bickering. I've spoke and seen with other parents and I think it's totally the norm and some it's a lot worse. So I think I probably got it good. Now when they are older it may be a better thing perhaps. I asked my mum about myself and my sibling and she said much the same. It was good when we were older though and as adults I love having sibling to share my parents attention with Grin but there are plenty of grown siblings who don't get on and never see each other.

Elginite · 10/07/2021 08:48

If I was in your position, I absolutely wouldn’t be having another. There’s nothing wrong at all with being an only child - in fact, there are loads and loads of things that are great about it! And I agree with PPs that the age gap will be too big to actually be true playmates to each other - they may well adore each other, and your eldest could be a great help, but if it’s a playmate you’re looking for, better to help your son engage in lots of hobbies, playdates, family occasions etc etc. I had a second with a 3 year gap and I’d say they’re definitely close enough still to actually play with each other, but my career has been truly firebombed for various reasons and I’m looking at a long road back. If you don’t actually WANT a second, don’t have one!!

Thadhiya · 10/07/2021 08:48

Really not a good idea.

My kids adore one another, do everything together and joke they will live together (at least I think they're joking.) They're very close.

However, even they notice that that is not always the case. My eldest is saddened by one kid in his class who refuses to anything to do with his sibling at all and speaks of her quite viciously, and by others who fight with, bully and ignore theirs. Their family dynamics seem totally messed up, to be honest, and the kids really do not get along.

You do not have an urge for this child, which is a big sign you shouldn't. You do have an urge to progress in your career.

A child should be much loved and wanted for their own sake, not as a playmate for another. Only children do simply fine.

FrankButchersDickieBow · 10/07/2021 08:45

I am so glad we stuck with one. We contemplated. But decided it the end that our little gang of 3 was perfect.

I have 4 siblings. There is roughly around 4 years between us all and we are all close nowadays, but I never played with any of them growing up. The age gap was too big.

I have a friend who's kids are have a couple of years between them. One is a boy and one is a girl and practically since the day the youngest one could speak, they have fought like cat and dog. It was actually stressful to go around to their house.

Ours is a lovely, peaceful, carefree household, where we can do all kinds of stuff that costs money, which maybe we couldn't do if we had 2 kids. Our main thing is that dd and I love to go the theatre, which costs an absolute fortune. Couldn't do it so regularly with 2 kids.

She has the best of the best and also all our love and attention. She is a well adjusted, kind, funny much loved by everyone, young lady and we're so glad we stuck with 1.

lastqueenofscotland · 10/07/2021 08:45

You’re already getting to the point where the age gap is a bit too big for them to play together, especially unsupervised… ever. And your eldest will not want to be seen with the uncool little sibling once they are 10/11!

Me and my sister are 18 months apart we’ve never really played together, even as tiny children we played and interacted with others in totally different ways, as we got older we enjoyed different activities, and now as adults well share the odd text m but we aren’t close.
Siblings are not guaranteed to get on and having them for the other one to have company is a bit daft.

Sparklingbrook · 10/07/2021 08:43

I thought about waiting until DC1 was at school but worried that he would think he’d been packed off and replaced by the newborn baby.
In the end we had a gap of 2.5 years.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 10/07/2021 08:43

With that age gap they will have nothing in common play wise really as by the time a toddler can play at say age 2 your eldest will be six and well past the stage of CBeebies and toddler toys.
Many siblings simply also don’t get on with each other.
I wouldn’t have a child just for company, better to pick their friends for that.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 10/07/2021 08:43

I wanted two primarily for a play mate- I think realistically that has to be under 5 year’s. I don’t want to be my child’s only source of company, dinner times at 5pm infront of CBeebies, arranging play dates to enable them to play with kids…my idea of hell

HedgeVeg · 10/07/2021 08:42

Most children fight with siblings more often than play with them.
They are not guaranteed to get on, and your DS would likely benefit from the higher level of attention and financial freedom that being an only child would come with.
I often feel a bit sorry for young children who's lives suddenly have to revolve around the needs of a baby; fewer age appropriate activities, having to leave early if the younger child is tired or playing up.

Not to mention that with a 4 year age gap, they won't be on the same level for many, many years - potentially not until they're both adults.

There's a 4 year age gap between my brother and sister, and they hate each other. (I'm 12/16 years older) - I know many many many people who don't have a good relationship with their siblings.

You've described many reasons not to have a second (which should have began and stopped with the "I don't want one") and only one reason to have one, which is not a guarantee.

TheGoogleMum · 10/07/2021 08:42

The age gap would be too big for them to be playmates really. So if that's the only reason I wouldn't have another

Swipe left for the next trending thread