Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To mainly consider having a second child as a potential playmate for DS?

135 replies

Rosebud1302 · 10/07/2021 08:26

I think I know the answer to this. But I'm so conflicted. I know these posts have been done to death so I apologise in advance.

DS is nearly 3. I wouldn't consider having another child until he is in school because I just can't think of having two small kids at home, it just isn't for me.

But to be honest, I don't have any burning desire to have another child at all. I love my son, but I'm not a woman who has always wanted multiple children. I am not "natural" in motherhood. To me, we are just starting to get the funding for nursery so I'm getting some money back. Although we are not struggling by any means, I am looking forward to the financial childcare burden lifting. Obviously if I have another, it will come back again full force (I don't want to be a SAHM).

Which leads me onto another point. There is potential for progressing in my job which I have wanted for a long time. But that can only happen if I increase my hours which I will be able to do when DS goes to school. If I have another child I will have to reduce again after maternity as I can't afford full time childcare fees (the nursery is expensive).

My son was a tricky baby and I struggled so so much, wondered why I had done this to myself. All the normal. I worry about feelings these things again with another baby. I'm not sure I can go through it again (had mild depression).

But on the other hand. I feel sad that DS won't have a little sibling to play with. This is naive though isn't it? Or is it. I know they might not get on but I feel at least it would be another child he can interact with. Or would the age gap (4+ years) be too much for him to see that child as a playmate anyway? I'm definitely not trying for a baby until he is in school so a smaller gap is out of the question.

Is it unreasonable to have a child in the hope it will give the first child some company?

Can I have some opinions and experiences from people who maybe felt like me and how it turned out? I know no one can decide for me of course but it would help to hear thoughts!

P.S, DP is relaxed and not strongly leaning one way or the other either.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Daphnise · 10/07/2021 09:27

Not the right reason to give birth to a human being.

SleepingStandingUp · 10/07/2021 09:26

Mine was 4.5 when the twins were born and they get on great / fight over everything. I think they'll have a lovely bond. But I wanted a baby. DH wanted a baby. We didn't have one as something to give DS. In your shoes I wouldn't.

KingdomScrolls · 10/07/2021 09:24

I have a brother we get on ok, we don't have much in common and he takes no real responsibility for anything so there's no way he's a built in support system, when my parents have had medical issues and needed support it's been on me and they're not even over seventy yet.

Wrotten · 10/07/2021 09:23

I was in a similar situation. I have a son and he's asked for a sibling for a while.

I'd ruled it out as he was almost 5, and now I'm unexpectedly pregnant so here I am.

He's over the moon and I'm bloody terrified, wondering if I've made a big mistake!

I'll come back and let you know how it's going. 🤣

KingdomScrolls · 10/07/2021 09:21

I have two DNs they fight like cat and dog, the eldest was a much calmer happier child without a sibling, so I wouldn't do it just for that reason. DS is an only, we've made sure he has lots of interaction with other children, he's confident, sociable and fits none of the only child stereotype. Older DN asks to come to our house to stay without sibling and they play together brilliantly

ThursdayWeld · 10/07/2021 09:21

I would. It's lovely having a sibling as you get older.

(Yes yes, I know all siblings don't get on, but loads of them do!)

Frazzled2207 · 10/07/2021 09:20

I think the age gap will be too great. Have lots of friends with kids with 4/5 year gap and they don’t really play although one advantage is when they are much older the older child can be relied on to babysit.

Ours are great playmates but they are only 21 months apart

HoldingTheDoor · 10/07/2021 09:19

Not just a playmate, siblings are for life! You'll be giving him a support system pre-made.

That's far from a guarantee. A friend just lost one sibling and far from being supportive and helping to organise the other two are actively being awkward and demanding, constantly squabbling and just generally making funeral planning and everything harder. She's been left to shoulder the hard work.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 10/07/2021 09:18

if you want companionship for him then get a pet.

AlexaShutUp · 10/07/2021 09:17

No. Think how unfair it would be to your second child to not be wanted as anything other than an accessory to the first.

Your ds doesn't need a sibling. My dd is 16 now and has always loved being an only child. If she wants time with other kids, she has plenty of friends. And there is no guarantee that they would get on/ play together anyway, especially with a four year age gap.

There is a lot of social pressure to have a second because of all of the negative stereotypes about only children, but we haven't found any of those to be borne out in reality, either with our own dd or other only children we know.

Stick with one. You won't regret it.

EnjoyingTheSilence · 10/07/2021 09:16

If you want another baby have one. Don’t have one to be a playmate for your 1st! They’re not going to be able to ‘play’ together for a long time and if then they may not get on.

Peppallama · 10/07/2021 09:16

We have a 4 yr age gap and only had the second to ensure DD wasn't alone on adulthood coping with me having dementia etc. Again we knew it wasn't guranteed, my own siblings are flakes but I felt consumed with sadness about her being alone.

What we didn't realise was how much they'd get on. She loves her brother so much and he idolises her. She's very tolerant and they play a lot together. It's been fabulous.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 10/07/2021 09:15

By far the easiest solution would be to host regular playdates.

Turquoisesea · 10/07/2021 09:15

Only have another child if you want one, not for your DS. I wanted 2 DCs and have a DD and DS, there are 3.5 years between them. They have never really got on and never played together really. Even now as teenagers they just about tolerate each other. I’m sad they never played together really but I always wanted 2 DCs and I’m glad I have them but I think both would prefer it if they were an only child!

Redwinestillfine · 10/07/2021 09:14

Not just a playmate, siblings are for life! You'll be giving him a support system pre-made. That said, do make sure you think through practicalities and if you don't want to, don't.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 10/07/2021 09:14

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

It’s only on mn where siblings don’t get on…:my niece and nephew don’t have loads in common, v diff people but they can keep each other company at dinner, go round a holiday resort together….way easier for the parents
Possibly because you only know a relatively small number of people with more than one DC, and/or not all of them are going to say in public "God, my kids are making my life miserable."

There are a lot of people on MN, and people on an anonymous forum are more likely to be honest about the shitty aspects of parenting.

For me, I don't want another DC and I'm pretty sure I wouldn't cope that well. So DS might gain a sibling, but he'd lose the (relatively) chilled out, loving, cheerful mum he's got now.

HoldingTheDoor · 10/07/2021 09:13

It’s only on mn where siblings don’t get on…:my niece and nephew don’t have loads in common, v diff people but they can keep each other company at dinner, go round a holiday resort together….way easier for the parents

That's utter nonsense. I know plenty of siblings IRL who don't get along. I also know some who do get along but it's far from uncommon for siblings to dislike each other.

Personally I wouldn't have another as you don't particularly want another. This idea of having a sibling for a child, like they're some kind of toy, has always seemed odd to me. If you want another then fine, but if not I don't understand why you'd do it when there's no guarantee that they'll get along or have any interest in each other. Especially with a considerable age gap. They could be best friends, enemies if anything in between. So you could have all the stresses and strains of having a second child without having achieved your goal of providing a playmate for them.

It is perfectly possible to be a happy only child. I'm one. Personally I'd concentrate on providing opportunities for them to make and maintain friends.

LizJamIsFab · 10/07/2021 09:13

I think you will find when they start school and make friends doing out of school activities that they can have lots of company without siblings.

Nogoodusername · 10/07/2021 09:12

I have a 4 year age gap. There were a few years where they played brilliantly together and were extremely close, but when the eldest hit the tween years it decreased and even more so during the teen years - so DH and I became the play mate again. I didn’t want two close in age so went into it knowing they they were likely to be playmates only for a few years, and it wasn’t my reasoning for having a second so all fine

RainingZen · 10/07/2021 09:11

Yes if you arent a natural mother, don't enjoy playing with your child, don't enjoy spending time with children, a companion for your lonely DS would be great.

Maggiesfarm · 10/07/2021 09:10

Never have another child to give your child a sibling, that is too ridiculous for words. I've never heard such nonsense. Have a child because you want one.

MyCatWouldChaseYourCat · 10/07/2021 09:08

I wouldn’t do it unless you actually want a second child. We have a 4.5 year gap between ours and the driving force for me was that I really wanted a second. The other considerations, eg around siblings, were secondary.

With this age gap (DC2 was born when DC1 was in reception), it feels like a huge step back - you’re just at the point where life has got easier, you can leave the house without needing all of the stuff, etc, and then wham, you have a newborn again.

Also, the longer you leave it, the longer your child has to get used to being the only child. DC1 has really struggled with becoming a big brother and I think he would have anyway but I also think it would have been easier to introduce a sibling when he was younger.

ErrolTheDragon · 10/07/2021 09:06

I've got an only - it gets easier as they get older, as others have said. Once they start school they'll find playmates their own age. Mine is now grown up, with many friends and good social skills.

You pretty clearly don't really want another kid, and that's absolutely fine. There are definite upsides to having, and being, an only.

What you can do,of course, is to support your child to participate in activities with other kids, have schoolmates and local friends around for play dates etc.
You may spend more time chauffeuring or making cakes ... better than making a whole new demanding unpredictable human!

OwlinaTree · 10/07/2021 09:06

Don't have a baby to do a job. Have a baby because you want another child. It's fine to stop at one and have a career.

SE13Mummy · 10/07/2021 09:05

There's a 4.5 year gap between my two and whilst they get along well most of the time, they've never really played together. They have some shared interests but because of the age gap, they've never coincided.

Swipe left for the next trending thread