Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To mainly consider having a second child as a potential playmate for DS?

135 replies

Rosebud1302 · 10/07/2021 08:26

I think I know the answer to this. But I'm so conflicted. I know these posts have been done to death so I apologise in advance.

DS is nearly 3. I wouldn't consider having another child until he is in school because I just can't think of having two small kids at home, it just isn't for me.

But to be honest, I don't have any burning desire to have another child at all. I love my son, but I'm not a woman who has always wanted multiple children. I am not "natural" in motherhood. To me, we are just starting to get the funding for nursery so I'm getting some money back. Although we are not struggling by any means, I am looking forward to the financial childcare burden lifting. Obviously if I have another, it will come back again full force (I don't want to be a SAHM).

Which leads me onto another point. There is potential for progressing in my job which I have wanted for a long time. But that can only happen if I increase my hours which I will be able to do when DS goes to school. If I have another child I will have to reduce again after maternity as I can't afford full time childcare fees (the nursery is expensive).

My son was a tricky baby and I struggled so so much, wondered why I had done this to myself. All the normal. I worry about feelings these things again with another baby. I'm not sure I can go through it again (had mild depression).

But on the other hand. I feel sad that DS won't have a little sibling to play with. This is naive though isn't it? Or is it. I know they might not get on but I feel at least it would be another child he can interact with. Or would the age gap (4+ years) be too much for him to see that child as a playmate anyway? I'm definitely not trying for a baby until he is in school so a smaller gap is out of the question.

Is it unreasonable to have a child in the hope it will give the first child some company?

Can I have some opinions and experiences from people who maybe felt like me and how it turned out? I know no one can decide for me of course but it would help to hear thoughts!

P.S, DP is relaxed and not strongly leaning one way or the other either.

Thank you!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
fibreglass · 11/07/2021 21:34

A 4+ year age gap can be quite awkward to manage. They might play together in the house or at the beach, but many other activities have age limits so you will be stuck with not being able to take the older one to certain activities, unless you can get your DH/other childcare to take the younger one, and vice versa. E.g. films, theme parks, sports activities, theatre, extracurricular, holidays etc. When the youngest is very young they'll be too boring to be a playmate for a 4/5 year old, then when the older one hits 10 the age gap will feel even bigger as they'll just be into completely different things and want a different level of independence. There will be a small window when they're in primary that they might play together, plus when they're much older (late teens onwards) where that age gap disappears.

olympicsrock · 11/07/2021 21:04

I was in your position, had struggled had PND and didn’t want to go through it again. We had a happy little accident and DS 2 was born with 3 years 8 months between them.
I can honestly say it was the best thing ever ( even though I got PND . DA1 was thrilled to be a brother, they get on really really well , play together all the time, there is no competition because of the age gap and DS1 was out of nappies and a helpful preschooler who slept well when DS2 was born.
I feel sorry for only children as I know how much mine love each other. Everyone is different but I’m so glad we had a second

letsallbemermaids · 11/07/2021 20:57

We're only 4 months in but I feel really happy with the age gap. My son is at school full time - he is completing his final week of reception this week - and I've been able to go to baby classes, coffees with other mums on mat leave and lots of walks without having to pay for a nursery place for him to do all of these things. I've been able to offer similar experiences to those I had with my first born to my new baby and my eldest has had lots of stability from a strong and consistent routine during the week with school. Most of his classmates have siblings who are 2 to 3 years younger/older but this age gap is great for us. He is independent and capable, he sleeps wonderfully, and our baby has just slotted into our life. I'm sure there will be challenges ahead when they want to do different things but I think we probably would have had those challenges even with a smaller gap, having had a son first and a daughter second. He will be in year 5 when she starts reception which seems enormously different but we'll make it work.

I struggled with my mood for years after DS was born due to a lack of sleep. He only slept through consistently from 3.5 years old. I have a full-on job and I couldn't have dealt with two night waking children without falling into a severe depression. Fortunately DD is a much easier baby than DS was and sleeps fine.

All of this is to say that having this age gap is great for many, many reasons but one of those reasons isn't that they will be childhood playmates into the same toys and games at the same time.

Rosebud1302 · 11/07/2021 14:47

Thanks everyone for more thoughts. To be honest unless things dramatically change in the next year I think he will remain an only.
@shouldistop no he will be in nursery 3 days and home with me for 2 plus weekends.

OP posts:
warmfluffytowels · 11/07/2021 14:42

Having multiple DC is for the parents, not the existing children. Unless you want another, don't do it.

They could be best mates, but equally they could grow up never speaking and/or fighting constantly. My DH is one of five - he only speaks to a couple of them and hasn't spoken to his eldest sister in well over a decade - and she only lives round the corner!

Piglet89 · 11/07/2021 14:35

But ultimately, OP: if YOU do not want another child, do not have one.

Piglet89 · 11/07/2021 14:34

@Fleetw00d

As an only child, I would have hated a sibling and would have been an awful and cruel big sister and very resentful towards my parents attention being diverted from me.

I am also an only child and I think I would have felt the same. However, I think having a sibling is a life changing event which actually shapes your personality, helps you realise you’re not the centre of the universe and “knocks the corners off you”. I never had that and struggled to get on with others and make friends at school and remained odd, over-sensitive, self unaware and, frankly, emotionally unintelligent right into adulthood.

I say this as someone who plans to stop at one myself (horrendous PND) - but the way I parent my son will be very different from the approach my parents took with me, and he is obviously a very different person from me!

shouldistop · 11/07/2021 14:01

I just can't think of having two small kids at home, it just isn't for me

When he's 3 will he not basically have the same amount of hours at nursery as he would at school?

Bunnycat101 · 11/07/2021 14:00

Given your posts I’d stick with one . Mine do play with each other but that only really happened from 2. We had a few times when my eldest said she’d wished the youngest hadn't been born etc. I always wanted 2 but it was much harder than I expected and my children’s needs are more different than I was expecting with a gap just under 3 years. That said, I have friends that have a 4 year gap and love it- they enjoyed having the baby once the eldest was in school and were able to meet the different needs nicely.

Maggiesfarm · 11/07/2021 13:23

@letsallbemermaids

I've got a big age gap between my two children (4.5 years) and it really works well for my family but I'm under no illusions - they are at different stages and won't play together that much. However, I am confident they will have a nice sibling relationship throughout their lives and I love having them both. For career and mental wellbeing reasons, a smaller age gap was never a possibility.
That is not actually a huge gap. Plenty of people have five years between themselves and a sibling and enjoy it. The older child tends to be very 'maternal' or male equivalent towards the younger (sometimes bossy), and, as they get older, the difference is less noticeable. It's nice to have one at school when a new baby comes along, makes life easier.
Pipitypop · 11/07/2021 10:14

Remember this is an entire person you are bringing into existence. A person that has to live their entire lives, experiencing shit they go through because you decided to bring them into it. At the very minimum you'd hope your parents actually want you. If you don't, then please just don't do it.

ThornAmongstRoses · 10/07/2021 22:08

The main driving factor behind me having a second baby is because I didn’t want our first baby to be an only child.

My husband was very resistant and it took about a year before he agreed to try for another.

I do have health problems that impacted
on my first pregnancy and birth, which I knew would also be the case in the second pregnancy but I still wanted another baby.

We have a 3.5 year age difference and they absolutely adore each other. They have such a special relationship and having a second was the best thing we ever did.

However, it really doesn’t sound like you particularly want another child and those feelings have to take priority over a hypothetical sibling relationship.

SlothinSpirit · 10/07/2021 21:44

There are so many variables. I agree that you should only have another child if you want one, not just as a playmate for your existing DC.

I disagree that a 4+ year age gap means that they won't play together and will have nothing in common. It will depend entirely on their personalities. While the nature of their relationship will be different and it's more likely to be a 'big sibling-little sibling' type of relationship than similar-aged playmates, that can be equally rewarding. Older children are more capable of getting excited about the prospect of a new baby and can be more involved in preparing for it's arrival. They have more going on in their lives independently of their parents (school, playdates etc.) so there is less likely to be rivalry and they may like to 'help' with caring for their younger sibling. A younger sibling may be more 'special' to an older child than to a 2 year old who sees them as a rival for their mummy and daddy's attention. Of course, none of that may be true and the older child may resent the younger one, but the point is that you cannot predict it!

letsallbemermaids · 10/07/2021 21:27

I've got a big age gap between my two children (4.5 years) and it really works well for my family but I'm under no illusions - they are at different stages and won't play together that much. However, I am confident they will have a nice sibling relationship throughout their lives and I love having them both. For career and mental wellbeing reasons, a smaller age gap was never a possibility.

Fleetw00d · 10/07/2021 21:24

As an only child, I would have hated a sibling and would have been an awful and cruel big sister and very resentful towards my parents attention being diverted from me (I'm a dream I know). If you don't want a second child Don't have one, your son will not be missing out, he'll have friends and cousins to play with. I'm also considering just sticking to my one dd but my partner wants a second so we'll see how we feel in a few years!

MaryShelley1818 · 10/07/2021 21:22

We have a DS who is now 3. I hated the baby stage, had crippling PND and struggled every single day, not a natural and definitely couldn't be a SAHM but as DS got older our relationship and bond developed and he is without a doubt the best thing in my life, he's excellent company and I adore him. He managed perfectly well as an only and played independently very well.

The only reason I considered another was for him to have a sibling (rightly or wrongly). Lockdown really really intensified that too as DH and I wfh and he spent most of the day playing completely alone which broke my heart.

We now have DD age 5mths, early days but 100% the right decision. Totally a breeze compared to my first experience (less of a shock to the system). DS is obsessed with her, he completely adores her and is a different child. Watching their relationship develop has given me more joy than I ever imagined. The thought of them having each other on days out and holidays, building sandcastles together, is just lovely.

Of course there's the chance they won't get on, that's just life. But there's also the chance it will be wonderful.

Planty13 · 10/07/2021 21:03

Wrong, wrong reason. I had a second 5.5 years after my first. They have a wonderful relationship but it’s not guaranteed (they are both still young, 2.5 & 8.) But my eldest had a wonderful life as an only and he would have thrived without a sibling. I can’t afford the extra curricular activities I used to be able to, if that is a concern for you.

I know many, many siblings who do not get on, are not close and do not share as adults. More so than know of those with close relationships with their siblings by far.

Playmate seems too weak considering they might not even like each other as kids 🙈

I’d spend my energies helping the friendships they form blossom and encouraging new relationships.

Pipitypop · 10/07/2021 20:57

At that age gap yes yabu. Some people have said to me that they wanted to have more than one so that when they die the children would have each other. Lot of assuming they'd be close really.

Dishwashersaurous · 10/07/2021 20:55

Social pressure and familial norms. Versus what you want.

Knowing what we actually want as individuals, as opposed to what society expects us to want, is often the hardest thing

Dishwashersaurous · 10/07/2021 20:53

Five years age gap is too big for a natural playmate. Seven year old are doing intricate lego whilst two year old can't be in the same room in case they eat it.

Which is completely fine if you really really want another child.

But if you don't, don't bother.

Very soon in the next few years weekends will be filled with activities.

Focus on having children round to play once he starts school

WhereYouLeftIt · 10/07/2021 18:49

He won't be a playmate, the 4+ years gap will see to that. At best, they will grow closer as adults when that age gap becomes inconsequential.

Rosebud1302 · 10/07/2021 18:10

Sorry - he ISNT a child who particularly loves being around other kids.

OP posts:
Rosebud1302 · 10/07/2021 18:09

I have read all of your replies and want to thank you all so much for your thoughts. I think, deep down, I know the answer. I know I would be so happy with my gorgeous boy being an only. Ironically, I am an only. And did fine. So why do I question it with him? Social pressure I think plays a part of it - "when are you having another?" And certain family saying "oh but he will be lonely, and what about when you get older, he will care for you all alone" which make me worried about his future. But I know I shouldn't let that influence me. He does not have cousins and is unlikely to for a while, if ever. Which also worries me. But he is a child who particularly loves being around other kids, but I suppose he is still young. I know the right answer. So why is it still in my head so much?! Thank you all for taking the time to share your experiences. It has really helped x

OP posts:
Rosebud1302 · 10/07/2021 17:48

Wow thank you so much for all of your responses! I have been out today hence the silence. I really appreciate you all commenting and I'm going to read them all now.

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 10/07/2021 13:25

Yabu. It's too big a gap - elder will be at school all day so won't have as much time to form a bond with younger.

I've got just over 2 and a half years (two school years) between my two and I wouldnt want a gap bigger than 3 years if you expect children to really play together a lot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread