Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Piercing a 2yr olds ears..

337 replies

Thelogicescapesme · 09/07/2021 23:29

It's not a cultural thing in this case, more so the toddler is being treat like a fashion accessory. Mum had it done because mum thinks it's "pretty and girly"

As an adult whom has had to have two piercings surgically removed and antibiotics for complications post procedure I think it's fucking bonkers that anybody would inflict it on a small child.

AIBU and what are your thoughts?

OP posts:
Quaggars · 10/07/2021 00:57

I had my ears pierced aged 4 - by my 13 yo older sister with an ice cube and a sewing needle!

Grin Anyone else totally be put in mind of the Grease scene?! "Can somebody please fetch some ice to numb her earlobe?!" lol

I wouldn’t recommend it - but I don’t think it’s child abuse and it didn’t hurt much. She was just a very daft 13 yo. We laugh about it now

That's not the same though
As in it's basically a child, being left alone with a child, expected to be a grown up.
If you are the parent punching holes in a baby/toddler, different dynamic

LST · 10/07/2021 00:57

@Grenlei

Funnily enough OP, in countries where infant ear piercing is commonplace theres not thousands of babies with the piercing problems you allude to. In my own family babies ears have been pierced for many generations without incident. So I don't accept that injury, infection or other unfortunate consequence is inevitable.
Doesn't matter about the after effects. Having them done at all is vile. It causes unnecessary pain to a baby. Horrible. And I am not a judgey person, but anyone who has a baby with pierced ears I would judge harshly
PuffinDodger · 10/07/2021 00:57

@Quaggars

I’m not even from here and even I know that it’s widely accepted and culturally normal in the UK. Just because it might be culturally the norm, does that make it OK? I'll have to argue I don't think it is in the UK, there's a lot of people who don't have them pierced as babies or toddlers.
No it doesn't but the argument that it's OK in other countries because it's cultural but not here is silly
stampo · 10/07/2021 00:56

@Quaggars but we all put our beliefs onto our children.. people baptising their kids, circumcising them, i think they shave babies heads in Argentina when they're a few months old, raise them vegetarian in accordance with religion, don't vaccinate them if they don't believe in vaccines, refuse blood transfusions etc etc

I'm always in the minority on this topic, i think earrings look lovely on little kids.

WorraLiberty · 10/07/2021 00:55

As an adult whom has had to have two piercings surgically removed and antibiotics for complications post procedure I think it's fucking bonkers that anybody would inflict it on a small child.

AIBU and what are your thoughts?

My thoughts are why are you excusing this behaviour if it's cultural?

Does 'culture' mean you therefore suddenly think it's not "fucking bonkers that anybody would inflict it on a small child"??

You can't have it both ways OP.

LST · 10/07/2021 00:54

@PuffinDodger

It's still cultural if its done in the UK if its the norm in a particular social group. It's not logical to say it's fine for a Spanish person to do it because cultural but wrong if a UK person does it
It's wrong fullstop
Maggiesfarm · 10/07/2021 00:54

I think it is horrible.

Quaggars · 10/07/2021 00:53

I’m not even from here and even I know that it’s widely accepted and culturally normal in the UK.
Just because it might be culturally the norm, does that make it OK?
I'll have to argue I don't think it is in the UK, there's a lot of people who don't have them pierced as babies or toddlers.

TableFlowerss · 10/07/2021 00:52

Absolutely vile.

PuffinDodger · 10/07/2021 00:51

It's still cultural if its done in the UK if its the norm in a particular social group. It's not logical to say it's fine for a Spanish person to do it because cultural but wrong if a UK person does it

Quaggars · 10/07/2021 00:50

Big deal, I don’t remember it and now

OK, fair enough, but the fact you don't remember is that they decided to make that choice for you - to put holes in your ears.
Not for any medical reasons, presumably they thought it looked good or was the "right" thing to do.
Personally I'm glad I had the right to choose

Shadedog · 10/07/2021 00:48

In some cultures it's expected you pierce a child/babies ears and widely accepted

I’m not even from here and even I know that it’s widely accepted and culturally normal in the UK. That’s why there is a Claire’s on every high street. Culture isn’t just for us foreigners you know.

Yellownotblue · 10/07/2021 00:46

I had my ears pierced aged 4 - by my 13 yo older sister with an ice cube and a sewing needle!

I wouldn’t recommend it - but I don’t think it’s child abuse and it didn’t hurt much. She was just a very daft 13 yo. We laugh about it now. I’ve offered to babysit her DDs many times, but she knows better 😁

CrackOnOrGoHome · 10/07/2021 00:44

@Thelogicescapesme

The piercings were done at Claire's accessories too, so same place as PP above. They don't have the best reputation when it comes to this.

I think there's probably good reason reputable piercers wouldn't go sticking needles in toddlers but that logic escapes Claire's obviously.

No the mum isn't my DIL but a close relative. I spend alot of time with the child so know that it's a disaster waiting to happen, pulling on the jewellery etc.

I was walking through a shopping centre a few years ago and could hear toddler screaming and crying (guessed at the age of the child by the pitch) and when I got to Claire's Accessories I could see through the shop front two women literally holding down a girl of about 2 years old while her ears were being pierced. She was screaming, crying and struggling so hard - it took two adults to hold her down. It was so awful to witness so I sent a message to Claire's head office and they basically told me to myob. That poor child was so obviously distressed, how could they have done that to her when she so clearly didn't want it done? Where was her accountability and consent?
Quaggars · 10/07/2021 00:39

Children can not legally give consent. You wouldn't ask a toddler to consent to surgery either, you'd ask the parent.

How is that the same though?
Surgery is to help them, presumably they're ill.
Of course you'd give consent then.
Punching a hole in their ear as your culture says it looks cool or is the right thing to do or whatever?
Not so much,

Thelogicescapesme · 10/07/2021 00:39

Do you think it's acceptable to pierce a babies nose or face @Grenlei

If not then why the ears?

OP posts:
Grenlei · 10/07/2021 00:37

And a poster makes a comparison to FGM... bingo.

Unbelievable.

snowwhit3 · 10/07/2021 00:37

@Quaggars
Exactly this! Not many people in the UK would say "I know FGM is vile but if it's a cultural tradition then that's different, crack on"

Cultural tradition as an excuse for deliberately hurting babies /toddlers/children is BS

Thelogicescapesme · 10/07/2021 00:37

@TracyBeakerSoYeah

Ok for all those who think piercing a babies ears is acceptable, how would you feel as an adult someone coming along & piercing your ears without your consent? As basically that's what it boils down to consent.
Yep exactly.

Most people would call the police, me included.

OP posts:
FlyingBattie · 10/07/2021 00:36

@TracyBeakerSoYeah

Ok for all those who think piercing a babies ears is acceptable, how would you feel as an adult someone coming along & piercing your ears without your consent? As basically that's what it boils down to consent.
Thats comparing apples and oranges. Children can not legally give consent. You wouldn't ask a toddler to consent to surgery either, you'd ask the parent. Up to a certain point, parents can decide what happens to their child. I'm not a fan of piercing children, but in the grand scheme of things it's really not something to get worked up about.
TracyBeakerSoYeah · 10/07/2021 00:34

Ok for all those who think piercing a babies ears is acceptable, how would you feel as an adult someone coming along & piercing your ears without your consent?
As basically that's what it boils down to consent.

Thelogicescapesme · 10/07/2021 00:34

@Grenlei

Funnily enough OP, in countries where infant ear piercing is commonplace theres not thousands of babies with the piercing problems you allude to. In my own family babies ears have been pierced for many generations without incident. So I don't accept that injury, infection or other unfortunate consequence is inevitable.
Atleast %20 of all piercings end up infected, so I would safely say that there will thousands of young children who've had problems with their piercings.
OP posts:
Quaggars · 10/07/2021 00:32

Something being a “cultural tradition” doesn’t mean that some people get a pass whilst others don’t. It’s not right either way

Exactly this

This is going to be really controversial so I don my hard hat
but
when it comes to "cultural norms" it all goes on what your culture deems "right" (for want of a better word!)
FGM is absolutely vile, it's in no way comparable so please no-one get me wrong, but it's still the same kind of behaviour - why is ear piercing babies seen as A'OK by lots?
My comparison is only in the sense that both of them put your beliefs on a child when it affects their bodies and not yours.

Grenlei · 10/07/2021 00:29

Funnily enough OP, in countries where infant ear piercing is commonplace theres not thousands of babies with the piercing problems you allude to. In my own family babies ears have been pierced for many generations without incident. So I don't accept that injury, infection or other unfortunate consequence is inevitable.

FlyingBattie · 10/07/2021 00:29

I wouldn't, but I couldn't care less if other people do.
There is actual, real child abuse going on, and ear piercing is not it.