Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask if anyone has ever had a BBC Complaint upheld?

91 replies

Nachorancho · 09/07/2021 20:46

Just that really and this is really not intended to be a "BBC bashing" thread.

On the odd (less than ten over past six/seven years) occasions I have raised a complaint it has always been dismissed and the reasoning is always the same: "we have acknowledged what you say but we think you are wrong (to paraphrase)"

So my question is has anyone ever made a complaint and the BBC have held their hands up and said "yes I think to are right OP"?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SilverDragonfly1 · 10/07/2021 17:17

I complained about a news article concerning young children being used as 'suicide bombers' by radical groups- literally referred to as child suicide bombers as though a ten year old has the agency to decide independently to murder a lot of other people and themselves!

Pointed out to them that these children are just as much murder victims as those killed by the bombs and that it was not appropriate to brand them murderers just because of their race/ religion- after all, if a white child had done this in a market in London, there would be a very different slant to the coverage.

Anyway, they first said they stood by it, but would mention it to their 'Africa Desk' (I was told on here at the time that there isn't any such thing) and when I replied that I wasn't satisfied with their response they said they weren't going to reply further. That paints a picture of me having sent multiple sweary, lunatic rants I know, but I promise that wasn't the case at all. You can probably still search the thread I made on here at the time for verbatim responses.

SnowdaySewday · 10/07/2021 16:04

Complained once about a chat show host. Host was interviewing an older gentleman and made sexist and ageist comments about the man's wife. Then cut, without giving the guest a chance to respond on camera, to the Green Room where his wife was, who had clearly heard these things and went on to make derogatory comments to her about being upset.

Apparently it was ok as the guest (the husband) wasn't upset and viewers should know that the host was edgy and shouldn’t watch if they were easily offended.

Orf1abc · 10/07/2021 13:29

Well as I've NEVER complained in 40 plus years of being alive, yes 10 in 6-7 years is very excessive. You need more to do.

Holding publicly funded bodies to account is important. I'd rather someone complain occasionally, than roll over and accept that people are being manipulated by biased coverage.

Weebleweeble · 10/07/2021 13:26

Ofcom

Weebleweeble · 10/07/2021 13:26

If I'm said tens of thousands of complaints - but that is unlikely to be ten thousand different complaints.
It's better than nothing - I doubt you can pick up the phone to the boss of Netflix etc

RavingAnnie · 10/07/2021 13:21

[quote Nachorancho]**@thinkningaboutit* @Nachorancho*

A complaint less than once a year is excessive?!

For varying reasons - dismissive attitude to BAME issues, poor reporting, inaccuracies, misogyny, stereotyping, typos, lazy journalism, bias, unconscious bias ... I think I have been fairly conservative in my complaints

Not that it matters as none have been upheld![/quote]
Well as I've NEVER complained in 40 plus years of being alive, yes 10 in 6-7 years is very excessive. You need more to do.

newnortherner111 · 10/07/2021 10:50

No, not that for me the issues were as serious as some raised above.

SpnBaby1967 · 10/07/2021 10:28

OFCOM were on sky news the other day & said out of tens of thousands of yearly complaints, 48 had an investigation opened & 16 were upheld.

So I doubt the BBC cares any more than OFCOM would.

Honestly, if I see something I dont like I just change the channel. I wouldnt complain, a waste of energy

DGRossetti · 10/07/2021 08:51

My last complaint was about the changes to the iPlayer that made it really clunky and harder to use.

The reply was "We know. Get over it."

Laugh ? I nearly paid my licence feel.

OhTheTastyNuts · 10/07/2021 08:46

I complained once when an online news article referred to 'child porn'. It was subsequently changed to 'images of child sexual abuse'.

Sharkology · 10/07/2021 08:05

Yes, I had one upheld - regarding the number of people in intensive care beds with COVID - they changed the article and corrected the figure (which was something like 100 x over what the actual numbers were...)

They never responded to me though.

Redbottle · 10/07/2021 08:01

I complained about a factually incorrect report covering a government information gathering exercise. The complaint was upheld, but not until after the deadline for submissions had passed.

Geamhradh · 10/07/2021 07:46

@Taliskerskye

You’ve complained 10 times in 6-7 years! What the fuck for. I can’t think of anything that gets me upset on the bbc, that is genuinely worth a complaint. An eye roll maybe.
Aye. They've probably got a special file for "disgruntled of Tunbridge Wells" people.

I've complained about the lies told by Dr Hilary whatsisname on ITV. He did issue a statement not exactly retracting what he'd said, but at least doing a grovelling yeah but no but statement. I think thousands need to complain about something openly wrong for it to be upheld though. (his was about breastfeeding being only for mothers after 6 months iirc)

TidyDancer · 10/07/2021 07:42

Never complained to the BBC (although should've done about various things over the years I'm sure) but I did once complain to the ASA about a massive billboard in my town which was advertising some sports brand but the tag line and the photo made it seems as if the model had been attacked and enjoyed it. Can't remember the words or the brand now, must've been about 10 years ago. They were very dismissive and said that after investigating, they found that wasn't the intention of the advert. Er no, but that's certainly what it looked like!

Ifitquacks · 10/07/2021 07:42

@Macncheeseballs

It's never occurred to me to contact a TV station about anything good or bad
They’re not just a TV station. They also report news. I made a complaint about a victim blaming headline in a news article. They acknowledged their fault and changed the headline.
FoxgloveSummers · 10/07/2021 07:02

Yes twice. Once was when a friend of mine had died in a high profile accident - they’d labelled the photos wrongly (mixed up which name and which photo went together). The other was about a news story re: a man who had killed his wife then committed suicide. The coverage initially included a weirdly positive headline and lots of quotes about what a lovely man he was - like he’d sadly been run over or something rather than murdering an innocent woman before choosing to end his own life. I pointed out that perpetrators of these crimes usually have a long history of domestic violence and either way they were writing an apology for a wife killer - they did change it! Bet lots complained though, it was horrible.

CovidKids · 10/07/2021 06:41

@ScrambledSmegs

I complained about the persistent use of the phrase 'child porn' in several different articles on the BBC website.

The response was hugely disappointing, they basically justified it as easier to understand and pithier than saying 'images of child sexual abuse' and they continued to use the phrase for quite a while afterwards.

This is a good example of where your complaint did make a difference, because despite the appalling reply to your personal complaint (I wonder when you complained?), the BBC did eventually change this. There was a directive that the phrase should not be used again. I think with the BBC that quite often happens. The weight of complaints is massive but it is logged for trends. When complaints are consistent over time (not always over a short time as a political party rousing its members happens and is quite obvious as all the emails are the same), they are evaluated again.

A lot of the complaints (not you OP!) can be quite bigoted (a black TV presenter is “unsuitable”, a woman reporter “is shallow / doesn’t understand the issues”, a gay family in a drama is “inappropriate“) which I think is why when the complaints about trans rights activism /
Mermaids started the initial responses were so unhelpful. But eventually they were looked at again and changes have been made.

Weebleweeble · 10/07/2021 06:35

I sent an angry email to the Today prog at the time of debates in immigration and many immigrants drowning in attempts to cross the Med. Always interviewed the opposition who ranted about how cruel the Tories were, immigrants were dying etc. I said ask THEM how many immigrants they would allow in the country. Evan Davies did that the next day - the Labour MP evaded the question - but at least it was asked.

Weebleweeble · 10/07/2021 06:32

I've complained to BBC, other media outlets and retailers about not knowing which places are in London

Used to annoy me that if they went out of London broadcasting eg on education the furthest they'd get is Oxford - rest of the country always ignored.
Changing now though.

Weebleweeble · 10/07/2021 06:30

I can't believe anyone takes them seriously after the scandals and then that repulsive women on breakfast mocking people.

Was that on BBC1,2,4, Radio 1,2,3,4,5,World Service, 4X,6 - I think I missed it unfortunately?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/07/2021 06:30

@Lettitbee

I complained about Homes under the Hammer repeatedly implying that female developers would spend too much on decorating etc. (It was a specific case but I don't think it was unique.) I was told that that was my perception and I was wrong. I don't think I've ever had such a dismissive response to a complaint, usually they at least pay lip service to considering what you say. Clearly the BBC always know best and can't be bothered!
That is hardly down to the Beeb, though! I’ve seen HUTH buyers do daft things many times - if anything they serve as a warning of what not to do. Inc. yes, decorating to their own particular taste instead of neutral, or e.g. not putting a bath into an obviously family home, because they don’t personally like baths, not to mention buying at auction without even having seen the place.
RedMarauder · 10/07/2021 06:23

I've complained to BBC, other media outlets and retailers about not knowing which places are in London. They just tend to correct them with no reply as it's clear other people have complained.

I've also complained about pictures the BBC use to represent the prison population. They just edited the articles and removed the pictures. Again it's clear other people have complained.

Cavalierqueen · 10/07/2021 06:12

My only complaint about the BBC is that it's a waste of money. Corrupt, woke and disorganized waste of space. I can't believe anyone takes them seriously after the scandals and then that repulsive women on breakfast mocking people.

Cavalierqueen · 10/07/2021 06:10

I think it's sad that people complain about programmes made before the new world kicked in. It IS of its time. We shouldn't cancel everyone and everything just because a few professional offenders make a fuss, most people don't care.

silvergoldstars · 10/07/2021 06:09

@eminem120176

Get a life
I wonder how you think things change?