Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should the GP not have been able to do this?

206 replies

ohthatbloodycat · 09/07/2021 20:35

This strikes me as a bit ridiculous, but do correct me if you feel I'm in the wrong.
My 15 year old got her ears pierced as a birthday treat a week ago. I think the earring on one side had been fitted a bit too tightly; it had always been tender, but got sore last night. My plan had been to go to the piercing place in the morning to ask their advice.
This morning when my daughter woke up, the stud part at the front had completely embedded itself in her lobe. All you could see was the butterfly sticking out the back. Her ear became swollen and very painful, unsurprisingly enough. I should add that she cleaned them each day religiously, and the other ear was fine.
Because the skin had closed over it in the night, I wasn't able to pull it out myself. I phoned our GP surgery for some advice. The receptionist checked and then came back to say that the GP wouldn't do it, and the practice nurse was busy all day. I then had the faff of phoning 111 (on GP's advice) and they eventually sorted me out an appointment at the A&E hospital miles away. There was no time to take the bus (I don't have a car currently), so I spent £20 on a taxi there. And then the bus on the way home. My daughter wasn't numbed up, or anything like that. The nurse warned her that it would be painful, as he pulled the stud through the skin of her ear. And it was, but over quickly thankfully!
This seemed like a palaver for a simple procedure, that surely the GP could have carried out. Rather than leave the paediatric A&E department to sort it out, particularly as Covid cases have risen in my city. Confused
Even the NHS phone operator sounded surprised that they had refused to do it.
AIBU?

OP posts:
Zilla1 · 09/07/2021 22:50

@TheBodyPiercer that's interesting. What problems have you seen with surgical steel? I've only ever seen a couple of patients with problems with that and one said she reacted to 'everything, gold too'.

TeaSoakedDisasterMagnet · 09/07/2021 22:49

This happened to me as a child. I did the turning and the cleaning and everything, but it got infected despite that and then the skin closed over the butterfly of the earring. Despite my mum trying her best, i had to have it cut out at a&e. GP wouldn’t touch it and that was 25 years ago,

SchadenfreudePersonified · 09/07/2021 22:47

@maddening

Nhs own website say to call the dr for an urgent gp .

The GPs office should have a nurse that can deal with minor injuries rather than fill up a&e.

think you got a contrary pile on group op

Our GPs surgery has a lot of staff - including Drs and nurses - off/isolating at the moment due to covid. They could just be short-staffed.
Zilla1 · 09/07/2021 22:47

GP’s surgeries are barely open, they have never been less stretched.

What a fabulous generalisation. Well, we've never had a working day inn 2020 or 2021 when we've not seen patients face to face as well as the remote consults some patients prefer. We're up to date on all reviews and and QOF-able services which is a good job since the government have moved those goalposts back while we've been delivering a PCN vaccination program which we'd still be happy to continue if the government hadn't sabotaged that. We're now planning for a September COVID booster and 'flu program. The physical and emotional cost on some of the HCPs and PM team and receptionists has been collossal but we regularly remind ourselves what Lord Bethell in effect told us, 'payrise/bonus...lucky to have a job'.

TheBodyPiercer · 09/07/2021 22:45

[quote Zilla1]@BungleandGeorge IME plain studs but the key thing is that they are made out of surgical steel or solid precious metal but be careful that the butterfly/clip isn't an allergenic metal as this often causes problems hence the reaction presents initially at the back of the ear.[/quote]
As a professional I wouldn't recommend surgical Steel. You want implant grade titanium or solid gold only. No butterfly backs at all regardless of material.

Please use the safe piercing site for more info and help in recognising a safe piercer.

Branleuse · 09/07/2021 22:44

when my dds earrings became embedded we ended up at the hospital. She needed gas and air before she would let anyone touch them, so im not sure why youre getting grief for calling the doctor.

Darkstar4855 · 09/07/2021 22:42

GPs don’t do this sort of thing as they don’t have the equipment and if it goes wrong and starts bleeding everywhere they’re not the best people to deal with it. I work in A&E and here or a Minor Injuries Unit are the best equipped places to deal with it, we also have ENT specialists on site who deal with the really nasty ones that have formed abscesses and/or small children where general anaesthetic is sometimes required.

It’s very frustrating that some piercing salons don’t train their staff to sort out complications and expect the NHS to pick up the pieces after they’ve pocketed their money.

vegas888 · 09/07/2021 22:41

Do you not have a walk in centre where you live?

OppsUpsSide · 09/07/2021 22:39

What a bloody waste of NHS time.

The very point of the NHS is preventative care, so you’re wrong.

ohthatbloodycat · 09/07/2021 22:38

@Blindstupid

So now let me be really rude: toddle off and get a life!

OP posts:
worktrip · 09/07/2021 22:37

Some GPs do minor injuries, but not many. It's what it is.

Imascarecrow · 09/07/2021 22:36

I remember I had the exact same thing happen to me when I was 13 and had them pierced for the first time. My mum took me straight to our local A&E where they sprayed my ear with this freezing cold spray and cut it out.

PercyPigForPM · 09/07/2021 22:35

You are being a bit unreasonable. I wouldn't have expected my doctor to do this , to answer your original question. Personally I'd have told my daughter ' this is going to hurt a bit!' and done it myself

SunnyAgain · 09/07/2021 22:35

The GP refused to get a splinter out of my son’s leg after one became embedded under the skin , and sent us to the minor injuries unit. They failed to be able to get it out and advised a trip to A&E. I couldn’t face going to A&E with something that seemed so trivial, so I put some drawing paste on it, and after a few days managed to break the skin and get it out.
I have a feeling the GP wouldn’t carry out any procedure that involved breaking the skin. Maybe this was why the GP wouldn’t help in your case?

Blindstupid · 09/07/2021 22:35

People jumped because the OP was rude to them. Complaining they hadn’t read properly, when actually, it was the OP who didn’t say the ‘true’ version. The OP made a mistake then berated others for getting it wrong.

Rosesareyellow · 09/07/2021 22:35

Thanks. It has been a shit day all in, and I regret posting on here, and some of the replies have got me down. I don't think I understand Mumsnet very well at times. Ah well, at least her ear is now sorted, which is the main thing.

You’ve had a lot of unnecessarily shitty replies, it’s quite unbelievable. But sometimes you just never know what triggers the mumsnet nuclear button. Steer clear of mentioning piercing guns in future - at least your daughter is 15 and not 5 otherwise you would have gotten 10 times the abuse. Piercings I have found are a triggering subject in general. I only found out recently on here that my fairly conservative and sensible seeming mum was in fact a raging child abuser because she let me get my ears pierced when I was 5... until I joined mumsnet I was complete oblivious to the extreme psychological harm and physical mutilation that had befallen me!

ohthatbloodycat · 09/07/2021 22:33

@GoldieLow

Thanks Smile

OP posts:
zuzu11 · 09/07/2021 22:33

[quote Sadsiblingatsea]@Summersun2020 “an already stretched GP”... are you a comedian? GP’s surgeries are barely open, they have never been less stretched.
Some of them even have time to develop lucrative side-hustles, like Dr Julia Grace, who is busy designing and flogging face masks.
Ain’t life grand![/quote]
She's a psychiatry trainee, not a GP the Hmm

ohthatbloodycat · 09/07/2021 22:32

True, but I think the original point is long gone! Grin

OP posts:
GoldieLow · 09/07/2021 22:32

It amazes me how rude people become on here over the simplest of things. The OP asked a question and people jumped.

Not many GPs will do stuff like this now unfortunately because it can be classed as minor surgery. A hospital has much more sterile, routine cleaning happening to be able to do these kinds of things but a GPs will rarely be allowed to do this kind of stuff unless it's planned, prepared and you still have to sign a consent form.
My friend is a nurse at a GPs and she does the blood pressure stuff and blood tests and flu jabs etc. She once told me GPs were told they aren't insured to get involved in these kinds of things, they're there to diagnose and refer. If your daughter had gone to the GPs they'd have likely sent her to A&E after seeing her.
It does seem unnecessary but their rooms are not "surgery" ready. Anything with an open wound or bleeding or breaking skin requires a minimum level of cleanliness.

I hope your daughter's feeling better now Grin

EarringsandLipstick · 09/07/2021 22:31

It wasn't even the substantive point of your AIBU tho bloodycat! You were asking if the GP should have been able to do it.

ohthatbloodycat · 09/07/2021 22:30

@Blindstupid

earrings …. And some of us actually do read the OP’s posts and call her out on it, she then gets stroppy and telling us to read correctly - that she actually did go to piercer - yet she NEVER said this until page 4! 4 pages before she changes her story to suit herself.
I've already agreed that I didn't make myself clear on that particular point.
OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 09/07/2021 22:29

@Blindstupid

earrings …. And some of us actually do read the OP’s posts and call her out on it, she then gets stroppy and telling us to read correctly - that she actually did go to piercer - yet she NEVER said this until page 4! 4 pages before she changes her story to suit herself.
She said it in her third post. A whole 9 or so minutes after she posted. I am on the app, not the website, so don't know how many pages in that was, but either way, you can select all OP's posts & read them, one after another.

The things people find to beat a poster up about. 🙄

ohthatbloodycat · 09/07/2021 22:28

@NumberTheory

I think YABU, not because you should have gone to the piercer or jumped through whatever other hoop random MNers who treat AIBU as sport have thought up, but because I think your expectations for GPs are probably a bit out of date. Even though they are "General" Practitioners, GPs clinic seemed to have specialised roles a lot more in recent decades by bringing in non-Dr qualified HCPs to do a significant range of procedures that are often better when done with the sort of skill that comes from repeated practice. And when you have other people doing those tasks for you, you become much less good at them yourself because you don't get any practice. The GP may have feared they'd be as clumsy as you feared you be.

So if the person at the surgery who has those skills, the practice nurse in this case, had no availability then sending you elsewhere makes sense. It wasn't that the clinic wasn't able to deal with that type of issue, it was that they didn't have the capacity when you needed it.

That is absolutely fair enough, and a very good point.
OP posts:
Grenlei · 09/07/2021 22:28

I don't think YABU OP, it seems the sort of thing a GP should easily be able to do if you couldn't manage it yourself.

Then again my (childhood) GP was the one who pierced my ears Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread