Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask questions about autism.

282 replies

coodawoodashooda · 09/07/2021 19:06

About 10 years ago i was in a meeting about autism. The leader said something like, 'if the child could......... then they didnt have autism. What was the quality that was being referred to? Was it empathy? I cant remember and for various personal reasons id really like to know.

OP posts:
Lougle · 09/07/2021 21:46

@Mummadeze

I don’t know if my DD is autistic. She is 12 and very shy and anxious and does display traits that might be indicative of autism. She finds comfort in fiddling with something at all times, goes into dream world’s, and often walks behind me. She has intrusive thoughts which I think is OCD so I don’t know if that is relevant. She does struggle to make eye contact and to make small talk with people she doesn’t know very well. But I am not sure how to tell the difference between general anxiety and autism. Her counsellor at secondary school has very recently suggested we investigate further but I am unsure whether to go down that road again as she had an assessment at primary school and autism was not diagnosed. To be honest, I find it a bit worrying and confusing, but above all want her to be happy. Does anyone have any advice?
@Mummadeze if someone is suggesting referral for assessment, I would do it. It will take a couple of years to get to the top of the list anyway. Sometimes children don't score highly enough when they're young, but as they grow their difficulties become more obvious. DD2 was 11 by the time she was diagnosed and at first she was doing well in her ADOS (I sat in because she wouldn't go without me). As they moved from concrete tasks to more abstract ones, her difficulties became obvious.

DD1 (15) has SN and has always gone to special school. She's finally being assessed for ASD soonish... Just waiting for a date.

ObviousNameChage · 09/07/2021 21:45

@coodawoodashooda

Okay. And please dont be harsh on me if this is offensive, im not trying to be controversial but i really want to understand the benefit of a diagnosis. So, you remember there was a thread a few weeks ago about imposter syndrome? Basically everyone felt that we were all experiencing a sense of feeling odd or out of sorts from our community. I guess im saying, do we not all feel, 'odd' in our own way? I mean, how many people laughing at the in joke actually thought it was funny?
Ok , let's say the bones in your hand grew differently to everyone else's. You can do some things, but not others . You can't write neatly or sow no matter how much you try. There's judgement and comments sometimes even from yourself... lazy,messy,stupid. Just not trying hard enough. What is wrong with you?

You don't know. You know you're different. But you don't know why. You get told over and over again that what you can do is just not good enough. That your best is not good enough. That it's easy. If only you'd just try. They show you. Again and again. You practice again and again. You know the theory. You know how to hold that stupid pen, what moves to make, how to form the letters. You see it in your head how it should look. It never works. And you just can't understand why.

Then one day you get an xray and it shows exactly why . That it's not you. You're not stupid or lazy or not listening or trying. Your hand is different, so your handwriting will always be different and that's ok.

lakesummer · 09/07/2021 21:45

I have a dyslexic diagnosis and ds has an ADHD one.
Our diagnosis allow us to understand ourselves without the judgment that comes from failing to achieve some NT activities.

For me it means I automatically use a calculator and spellchecker because I understand it isn't just a lack of effort on my part that means I can't spell or do mental arithmetic.
As a dc unsure why I was the only kid in class unable to do basic tasks having a diagnosis was transformative to my self esteem.

For my ds it means that he understands why he needs breaks, struggles to focus sometimes and over focuses at other times as examples.

It means as his parent I can be really clear with his school what he needs to support him.
I also understand my parenting hasn't failed because he hasn't learned some skills other dc have.
It gives me a clear steer about how to parent him effectively.

I'm not speaking for anyone with an autism diagnosis but for my ND family our diagnosis are important.
Therapy wouldn't change the way either of our brains functioned.

x2boys · 09/07/2021 21:45

@RickiTarr

Autistic people mostly don't like using functioning labels such as lower/higher and the now not diagnosed Asperger's.

Please don’t presume to speak for “most” autistic people @behindanothername - you’re not our elected representative and you’re wrong in that one. I’ve had innumerable conversations in which we all lamented the retirement of Aspergers as an available dx in the publication of the DSMV. So presumably opinion is split?

Quite I can only speak for my child who is non verbal but nobody else can speak for him
RickiTarr · 09/07/2021 21:42

@coodawoodashooda

Okay. And please dont be harsh on me if this is offensive, im not trying to be controversial but i really want to understand the benefit of a diagnosis. So, you remember there was a thread a few weeks ago about imposter syndrome? Basically everyone felt that we were all experiencing a sense of feeling odd or out of sorts from our community. I guess im saying, do we not all feel, 'odd' in our own way? I mean, how many people laughing at the in joke actually thought it was funny?
Right forget the “joke” part of the analogy for a minute. Just concentrate on what she said about foreign language.

It’s like everyone else is speaking a slightly different dialect to the one you speak and understand. So you’re having to work quite hard to follow the conversation and fill in the gaps and every now and then they all get up and react to something you didn’t catch at all and you wonder what they’re all doing. At the same time they’re all strangely illogical and overreact to things and indulge in strange pointless customs that have no real point to them, but you get that it’s their thing so you spend a lot of time playing along with silly things.

When you find out your dialect and culture is a real one with a name and there are other people like you to hang out with sometimes, and you even give birth to some, it’s an enormous relief.

x2boys · 09/07/2021 21:41

Autism is a massive spectrum and everybody on it is impacted to some degree, you would have to be to be diagnosed
However some people are massively impacted and some are not and there is everything in between

bitheby · 09/07/2021 21:38

CAN'T

bitheby · 09/07/2021 21:37

@coodawoodashooda

Tgis is very helpful. Thank you. The part i cant fathom is that if you hadn't had a diagnosis but instead had therapy; through the therapy youd come to the conclusion that you had various strengths and weaknesses. Would that not have served the same purpose?

No.

I got diagnosed at 40. The previous decade I spent thousands of pounds on different therapies. Still found that I was struggling with the same stuff. Turns out that you can cure autism with therapy.

RickiTarr · 09/07/2021 21:36

Autistic people mostly don't like using functioning labels such as lower/higher and the now not diagnosed Asperger's.

Please don’t presume to speak for “most” autistic people @behindanothername - you’re not our elected representative and you’re wrong in that one. I’ve had innumerable conversations in which we all lamented the retirement of Aspergers as an available dx in the publication of the DSMV. So presumably opinion is split?

SylvanianFrenemies · 09/07/2021 21:36

@TeenMinusTests

I have no idea what the trainer said, but I suspect he was wrong.
This. There are outdated views that people with autism aren't empathetic/can't lie/never make eye contact. Generalisations aren't helpful.

A diagnosis is often useful in helping someone understand why the world can seem so hard, can aid self acceptance etc.

Busygoingblah · 09/07/2021 21:35

@behindanothername this is diagnostic criteria, - it’s all about social communication and restrictive and repetitive interests - www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/hcp-dsm.html

The tricky thing is recognising what those look like when so many neurodiverse people, particularly women and girls, are so incredibly good at masking it.

The restrictive and repetitive interests bit could be so incredibly different in different people - it might be a limited diet, it might be a hyper focus on hobbies, it might be a need for routine, it might be anxiety around changes of plans, it might be stimming, it might be subtle sensory difficulties like needing to cut labels out of clothes etc. The brilliant thing is though that so many high functioning adults can channel those restrictive and repetitive interests for good and be truely passionate about their jobs, hobbies or interests.

Lougle · 09/07/2021 21:34

"To the person asking their child to make eye contact with the lollipop lady, please be aware forcing your autistic children into uncomfortable behaviours can cause masking which is really not a good idea."

It has given her a tool that allows her to blend in more. For her, that is crucial, because the thing she hates more than anything else is to be 'seen'. She doesn't actually make eye contact. She looks at somewhere near the eyes but not at the eyes. Still, it's enough that it stops people noticing.

RickiTarr · 09/07/2021 21:33

@coodawoodashooda

Okay. And please dont be harsh on me if this is offensive, im not trying to be controversial but i really want to understand the benefit of a diagnosis. So, you remember there was a thread a few weeks ago about imposter syndrome? Basically everyone felt that we were all experiencing a sense of feeling odd or out of sorts from our community. I guess im saying, do we not all feel, 'odd' in our own way? I mean, how many people laughing at the in joke actually thought it was funny?
No it’s much more profound and pervasive than imposter syndrome.
RickiTarr · 09/07/2021 21:32

@5zeds

High functioning just means you have an IQ over 70, anyone using it to mean anything else doesn’t understand the meaning of the term. It is very pertinent for people who appear to be low functioning but actually have higher IQs.
Yea that’s why I am happy I was diagnosed with Aspergers, when that dx was still available, as the distinction between Aspergers and Autism then was whether there were speech and language difficulties or not, which, for me, was a useful delineation.
coodawoodashooda · 09/07/2021 21:30

Okay. And please dont be harsh on me if this is offensive, im not trying to be controversial but i really want to understand the benefit of a diagnosis. So, you remember there was a thread a few weeks ago about imposter syndrome? Basically everyone felt that we were all experiencing a sense of feeling odd or out of sorts from our community. I guess im saying, do we not all feel, 'odd' in our own way? I mean, how many people laughing at the in joke actually thought it was funny?

OP posts:
5zeds · 09/07/2021 21:29

High functioning just means you have an IQ over 70, anyone using it to mean anything else doesn’t understand the meaning of the term. It is very pertinent for people who appear to be low functioning but actually have higher IQs.

Pumpkinstace · 09/07/2021 21:22

My diagnosis validates me as a person,

I am an autistic person, I am not a failure.

behindanothername · 09/07/2021 21:22

@Aisforharlot

I got diagnosed literally yesterday. Do any of you know of a womens community online?
On Facebook there are a few, mums on the spectrum, autism inclusivity is great for hearing and learning from adult voices, neurodiverse Uk. I generally wouldn't recommend autism friendly Uk as it is more parents of than autistic voices which means a lot of the information isn't ideal. Autism late diagnosis support is another along with autistic safer space.
MoMuntervary · 09/07/2021 21:19

If anyone is interested, this is a good article on autism and empathy.

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1362361319883506

It's not the easiest read but I found it really interesting, especially the research around empathy between people with autism being 'better' than between people with autism and neurotypicals.

behindanothername · 09/07/2021 21:18

I am autistic with ADHD. I wasn't diagnosed until I was 37. To the person who said we wouldn't be diagnosed unless we were showing communication challenges or repetitive patterns, I am afraid that isn't true, I didn't show either.

To the person asking their child to make eye contact with the lollipop lady, please be aware forcing your autistic children into uncomfortable behaviours can cause masking which is really not a good idea. Just because society and your expectations say they should make eye contact doesn't mean it is the right thing to do for them, that is a very ableist way of looking at the world and is like behavioural therapy which is really disliked by the autistic community. Just because neurotypical people don't think brushing hair can be painful doesn't mean it isn't for your child.

I was diagnosed late on, I have an autistic child who is growing up where we are very open about who we are. Our explanation has been that different people have different brains just like people have different coloured hair. His brain doesn't like loud noises or sticky things but is amazing at climbing and working things out, my brain means sometimes I need time to myself because there are too many noises and I need my brain to calm down.

I have had a job all my life, I have a very successful career, I am social, my networking skills are very good, I am over empathic to a point where I get upset and sad at ridiculous things on tv.

Autistic people mostly don't like using functioning labels such as lower/higher and the now not diagnosed Asperger's. This is because it takes away from the incredibly different ways we experience the world and face challenges in it. Someone could be non-verbal, have low motor function yet hold 3 phds and run rings round most of us mentally, yet society would call them low functioning and treat them as such because they don't see past the outward appearance. Simultaneously no one sees the challenges I face, I would be considered high functioning in old terminology yet I face daily challenges. We are all disabled purely because the word disabled means that the world around us is not designed or adapted for us.

I do this advocacy and work as part of my day job. There are so many things for people to learn about neurodiversity and being neurodivergent. First stop should always be the adult voices, ask questions, hear what they are saying, they are your child grown up. Yes some of us may not be as diplomatic as you would like, yes we make you uncomfortable or tell you what you are doing is wrong, we do it to help teach, to make sure those without a voice or who can't explain yet are heard.

WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly · 09/07/2021 21:10

I have no idea what the trainer said, but I suspect he was wrong.

This.

No, therapy wouldn’t have the same effect, I’m not sure why you think it might? It wouldn’t tell someone how they are wired and help them understand why they react in certain ways or feel different?

ahoyshipmates · 09/07/2021 21:06

@coodawoodashooda

And, when experts say, 'the child needs a diagnosis because they need a better understanding of themselves,' what exactly are they referring to? I cant see why a neuro diverse person or a neuro typical personal wouldn't all need to have a deeper understanding of themselves.
I don't know about diagnosis in children, but I do know about me. As I said to my GP only a few weeks ago (who was assessing me prior to a referral): "Well it would explain a lot".
Aisforharlot · 09/07/2021 21:04

I got diagnosed literally yesterday.
Do any of you know of a womens community online?

coodawoodashooda · 09/07/2021 21:04

ThePontiacBandit

How do you embrace it?

OP posts:
Unreasonabubble · 09/07/2021 21:00

@ThePontiacBandit - that is so well written and also so sad. I wish I had the courage to be diagnosed. I just think all the time I am (almost) coping I will carry on.

I am also very lucky to have a massively understanding Boss who does not mind me working from home, coming in late etc as long as I do my job. This helps me an awful lot.

Swipe left for the next trending thread