Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask questions about autism.

282 replies

coodawoodashooda · 09/07/2021 19:06

About 10 years ago i was in a meeting about autism. The leader said something like, 'if the child could......... then they didnt have autism. What was the quality that was being referred to? Was it empathy? I cant remember and for various personal reasons id really like to know.

OP posts:
BlankTimes · 10/07/2021 10:25

I don't think that I have the right to get a label for anyone
Why do you consider a medical diagnosis of autism to be a label?
Labels are things that you stick on jars of jam or suitcases. Medical diagnoses open doors to support.

School have suggested he's assessed, that's likely to be because he needs funding for the support they wnt to give him, without a dignosis and the extra funding that brings, they may not be able to meet his needs.
Caveat, we all know this shouldn't be the case, but very often it is.

particularly if it changes the opportunities that life can offer
What changes would those be?
The ONLY professions that will not at present accept someone with a diagnosis of Autism are the Armed Services.
The Police welcome autistic applicants and even have their own Autism Association www.npaa.org.uk/
STEM, Academia and IT have a high percentage of neurodiverse employees.

I think that is an adult decision for him to make about him. Not me
You have already received first hand accounts on this thread from autistic people whose life would have been made so much easier if they had been given a childhod diagnosis which explained WHY they were different to their peers. I'd suggest you research this further on other sites so you can understand what a vast difference early diagnosis can make to an autistic person's life.

IF he is autistic, he was born autistic and will be autistic all of his life. No-one can change that and no-one can change him. He is who he is.
You have the opportunity to find out whether he is autistic and IF he is, to have strategies put into place to support his individual needs.

If he is not autistic, he will not receive diagnosis.

Why don't you go down the assessment route and tell the team that you believe he has PTSD, not autism and ask them to do screenings for both?

You'll need to be prepared for the possibility that he may actually have both.

espressomartiniftw · 10/07/2021 10:12

I have found the podcast '1800 seconds on autism' incredibly helpful in helping me to manage DH better.
It's presented by 2 people with autism, one with more obvious difficulties than the other.
It's given me a lot of insight.

One of the comments above resonated as DS says 'See you later Alligator' and DH can't get that he has to say something different.
Often he repeats back to DS 'See you later Alligator' but sometimes remembers he's supposed to say something different.

toconclude · 10/07/2021 10:12

@BlueSurfer

I’m not sure there is any one specific thing that nobody with ASD can do. It’s a spectrum that everyone is on somewhere.
No, everyone is NOT on the autism spectrum. I am beyond tired of this being trotted out. It diminishes the very real struggles of too many autistic people.
5zeds · 10/07/2021 10:11

Ok so what would concern me in your situation is can he access support for PTSD if he has a dx of ASD? If not it would seem prudent to take advice on how to proceed. Here (SW) I know anecdotally that some children have found it harder to access CAHMs services with dx (though I’m talking 5+ years ago and thing may have changed).

coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 10:08

Im certain that had my marriage not been abusive my son wouldn't struggle the way he sometimes does. There is also a significant change/improvement in his behaviour when he returns from his father.

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 10:03

5zeds

Thats an excellent post. Excellent. Further to that my abusive xh finally, when the net was closing in, decided that i was the abuser. I guess I have a real aversion to this become I despise being labelled like this.
The impact of coercion and mental cruelty is impossible to explain to people who haven't experienced it. I relate to my child's behaviour as part of my own recovery. I am years out of the abuse but my children are not. They still have to stay overnight and manage the invisible nature of the abuse, and come down from the regime. In the whole thread i see nothing that has been mentioned in my son as asd except occasionally the eye contact. I attribute this to copying his father who im certain is a hardcore and sinister bad person.

OP posts:
5zeds · 10/07/2021 09:59

No need to apologise @WeatherwaxOn but all the people you are talking about appear to be those who are fairly articulate. That’s a very small subset of the autistic community. It’s a bit like only asking female leaders of industry about feminism and female issues. They may not have much insight into less educated and articulate women’s lives.

AlfonsoTheMango · 10/07/2021 09:55

@BarrenFieldofFucks

With regards the empathy thing. The little boy I work with is 'very' autistic, and very capable of empathy. He notices and worries for those who are upset, he just doesn't quite know how to fix it. So he might draw a picture of one of his great loves to give them...which is totally logical because drawing that picture has made him happy and cheers him up when he's sad, so receiving it will do the same for the sad person.
That's lovely.
5zeds · 10/07/2021 09:53

Getting back to the focus of the OP, which I think is really what OP can do to help her dc who is struggling to the point it has been highlighted at school by a teacher(how experienced they are and how old the child is would influence how seriously I took that).

As I see it either,

  1. the child is fine and someone is over reacting to a blip in behaviour. Given both Mother and school have voiced concerns this is unlikely but these things can feed off each other and kids do go through bumpy patches

  2. the child has PTSD OP thinks this is the case and in my experience Mums do know their children, however it can’t be overlooked that OP must have had a fairly traumatic time and contemplating disability on top may make her resistant to that outcome. I know one (out of many) parent who did not see the autism at all and for whom it was a surprise.

  3. the child is high functioning autistic and has now reached an age where his coping skills are not enough to hide his stress.

  4. the child has PTSD and HFA and while very able he cannot cope with both.

I would go through each of these scenarios and think about how a diagnosis/assessment would impact outcomes.

ExtraOnions · 10/07/2021 09:49

My daughter has just turned 15, we have years of her being anxious, stressed and worried about things.. finding hard to go to school… hard to be organised … difficulty regulating her emotions. I thought it was just “growing up”, until post lockdown when she had a number of highly distressing panic attackers, refused to go to school .. spent about a month where she wouldn’t get out of bed, her hygiene was questionable, and she was impossible to talk to.

We got a CAHMS referral, and whilst we were waiting a local organisation arranged some therapy for her. It was this therapist who said to me, when you meet with CAHMS, mention high functioning autism. The upshot being we are in the assessment process.

The mentioning of autism and neuro-diversity has brought my daughter a lot of peace, she’s had years of “what’s wrong with me”, and being depressed and anxious because if it. Now it’s like “ah, I get it”, and now we have a better langauge to talk about her problems. She’s now knows there us nothing “wrong” with her, she’s sees the world a bit differently, and she needs to learn how to interact with the world.

Since it got mentioned she is happier, calmer, we talk a lot more … a “label” has worked for us.

Lougle · 10/07/2021 09:39

If someone has autism, they have it, whether they choose to accept a diagnosis or not. It is far harder to access support once you turn adult, so it really is important to get the assessments while there is a system that allows access to them.

WeatherwaxOn · 10/07/2021 09:38

5zeds sorry if it came across that way. I have several autistic friends who use similarly defining language.

In terms of how I refer to people, I was unclear about context. In a social setting I obviously would not introduce anyone as, "X who is autistic" or "This is X, they have autism". I was relaying how those of my acquaintance wish to be referred to if the autistic element requires discussion.

Agree that it is very much necessary to see the person first and apologies if any offence was caused by that not being clearer.

5zeds · 10/07/2021 09:31

@WeatherwaxOn Essentially if you have met one autistic person, they don't form your template nor set your baseline for what an autistic person is it does. and yet you seem to be using your experience of one friend with an asd diagnosis to extrapolate into all autistics.

Personally I use person first language when in situations where I think the audience are failing to see the person, and “autistic” when trying to highlight we are autistic through and through. I don’t feel any affiliation to one form or the other and mostly call people by their names.

coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 09:22

5zeds

Thank you for your post.

OP posts:
WeatherwaxOn · 10/07/2021 09:06

[quote MoMuntervary]@WeatherwaxOn

The 'person with' thing is a tricky one as others will object to being called autistic. Once you know an individual, you can use their preferred language but when talking about a group it's hard!

I'm disabled and don't mind being called disabled or a person with a disability but I know people who dislike one or the other of those![/quote]
I'm learning daily how to choose my words wisely as yes, different people wish to be referred to differently. I'll always aim to use a person's definition of choice.
Getting language to cover all bases is a bit of a minefield! Smile

ObviousNameChage · 10/07/2021 08:34

@coodawoodashooda

RickiTarr

Ptsd wouldn't be treatable until we can shake off the abuser. That comes in the form of his father andcwe have a good few years before we'll be able to do that.

It could be PTSD, it could be autism ,it could be both(they're not mutually exclusive). It could be neither and something else. The thing is you won't know until you start the ball rolling and get him assessed.

It's not labelling, it's finding the cause of his behaviour,identifying his needs and ideally getting him support and strategies to cope.

Therapy can be a useful tool, but it needs to be targeted and focused. Even if it was PTSD .

Streamingbannersofdawn · 10/07/2021 08:33

I wanted to say as well that some professionals and so called friends asked a lot why I wanted a label for my child and what it would achieve.

But society had already labelled him...odd...difficult....strange...disruptive...the naughty child...'that child'...weird.

You'll forgive me for securing a "label" that might explain or help him.

Streamingbannersofdawn · 10/07/2021 08:29

I have two children with Autism (both very different, I mean they would be anyway but honestly, like polar opposites.) and I work with children, some of whom have Autism or various challenges.

The "Why do you need a label?" question is very annoying for me. We don't get this angst over anything else. Nobody worries about diabetes or arthritis or migraines being a "label".

A diagnosis can be useful for understanding yourself, understanding your child, sometimes for accessing services and support...I don't go into the chemist and explain the exact nature of my headache and how it effects me I say its a migraine and we are both in the same book if not exactly on the same page. Its a starting point.

The diagnosis certainly doesn't describe all of a person or define them but it's a beginning to work form...as a parent when my children were very young I could look for strategies to help them and communicate with them on Autism specific websites, before that I was just trying stuff and struggling.

Also in my personal experience with my younger son, schools were so awful in supporting him we could have done with a literal label on his jumper so he wasn't told off for putting his hands over his ears when it got loud.

He now attends a highly specialised Autism Specific school its hard to see how that would ever have happened if he did not have a diagnosis of Autism.

I think in these discussions about "labels" and levels of functioning it's easily forgotten that some people who have Autism are profoundly impacted to the point of needing 24 hour care. Accessing services for them is utterly essential and the NT world would (I hope) be shocked with how much of a fight it is to secure help.

MoMuntervary · 10/07/2021 08:19

@WeatherwaxOn

The 'person with' thing is a tricky one as others will object to being called autistic. Once you know an individual, you can use their preferred language but when talking about a group it's hard!

I'm disabled and don't mind being called disabled or a person with a disability but I know people who dislike one or the other of those!

Borka · 10/07/2021 08:17

@coodawoodashooda

Vanishun

Nobody has explained why it isnt.
I don't think that I have the right to get a label for anyone, particularly if it changes the opportunities that life can offer. I think that is an adult decision for him to make about him. Not me.

If your DS is autistic, getting a diagnosis will improve his opportunities, not limit them.
WeatherwaxOn · 10/07/2021 08:05

toast I will happily be your MN friend/advocate.

My friend has struggled massively with friendships in the past, but we have now been friends for over 10 years.

18 months ago they sustained a head injury with a brain bleed and this is affected their behaviour (increased paranoia, anger management), and 6 months or so ago we had a real problem and nearly properly fell out.
Time and space and open dialogue has resolved this but it made it clear to me then, which I hadn't properly grasped, was how different their perspective of an incident (that I was present at) was to mine.

toastantea · 10/07/2021 08:04

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

I think what OP is getting at is that within the range of NT human experience there's also a huge variety in what we struggle with or find easier, but we are expected to manage & understand that variation in ability without ever being given a diagnosis, a why.

There's a massive range, among NT people in terms of academic ability, emotional resilience, communication skills, physical skills etc. So I think what many NT people who don't have much exposure to autism struggle with is understanding what defines autism, when the current language on web forums is often "no ones autism is the same". Human beings are all different! To define autism there must be common factors among all autistic people so people are asking what those are.

Someone up thread mentioned the triad of impairments and the fact that to be diagnosed as autistic you must have significant impairment in all 3 areas. I personally found that helpful in trying to understand common characteristics of autism.

This is so true. When I was being assessed I had pages of notes detailing all of my autistic traits. The majority were not used. The traits we think of are common autistic behaviours but they are usually not what is used for a diagnosis. It's about that triad and while there is an obvious crossover between the traits a person has and the diagnostic criteria it is surprising what isn't relevant. An example would be my tics. Very come for autistic people to have tics, relevant interns of writing an overall report when making a diagnosis but for the diagnostic criteria my tics were not relevant. The DISCO refers to movement but it's geared up for severe rocking and almost constant hand flapping, my tics were not enough to meet that criteria.

It's important to remember that autism is not diagnosed using traits/behaviour that is seen in everyone. That's why it is diagnosed. It sets us apart.

toastantea · 10/07/2021 08:00

@WeatherwaxOn

My friend is very adverse to being called 'a person with autism'. Their explanation is that it is like saying 'a person with a hat' or 'a person with a suitcase' - the hat or suitcase can be removed/put down, but autism cannot.
As for the ' spectrum' my friend is clear that this is q harmful way of considering things. Essentially if you have met one autistic person, they don't form your template nor set your baseline for what an autistic person is it does.

I could be your friend - I'm definitely not though because I don't have any Grin but this is how I feel. 'With autism' minimises a persons autism. It indicates autism as a bit of a side order with the main meal. It's not something we just bring into play when it suits. It's literally who we are. We can't be 'without'.

The spectrum thing is so misunderstood. 'On the spectrum' makes it sound as if we have all been placed somewhere which in turn makes people think it's an indication of severity from person to person and that's frustrating at best.

WeatherwaxOn · 10/07/2021 07:51

^Just to add to my post, my friend said that when they received their diagnosis, it was as though a light had been switched on.
They had spent over 40 years being told (and railing against) they were naughty, disobedient, disruptive, uncooperative, unintelligent, slow, difficult...
The reality is that they are none of those things.
They have used their diagnosis to research how their autism affects their everyday life so that they can try to work out some mitigation strategies.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 10/07/2021 07:51

I think what OP is getting at is that within the range of NT human experience there's also a huge variety in what we struggle with or find easier, but we are expected to manage & understand that variation in ability without ever being given a diagnosis, a why.

There's a massive range, among NT people in terms of academic ability, emotional resilience, communication skills, physical skills etc. So I think what many NT people who don't have much exposure to autism struggle with is understanding what defines autism, when the current language on web forums is often "no ones autism is the same". Human beings are all different! To define autism there must be common factors among all autistic people so people are asking what those are.

Someone up thread mentioned the triad of impairments and the fact that to be diagnosed as autistic you must have significant impairment in all 3 areas. I personally found that helpful in trying to understand common characteristics of autism.

Swipe left for the next trending thread