Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask questions about autism.

282 replies

coodawoodashooda · 09/07/2021 19:06

About 10 years ago i was in a meeting about autism. The leader said something like, 'if the child could......... then they didnt have autism. What was the quality that was being referred to? Was it empathy? I cant remember and for various personal reasons id really like to know.

OP posts:
Dee1975 · 10/07/2021 18:35

Can’t help on the phase. But re diagnosis - A diagnosis gives child (and parents) an understanding of what, why and how in regards to certain behaviours. Before DDs diagnosis we were at our wits end because ‘normal way’ of bringing up your child just wasn’t working for us. And things we did that you ‘would normally’ be able to do with a child was frustrating painful. And we didn’t understand why (think simple stuff like going to the shops). DD was also at her wits end in frustration. Neither of us understood the other. However, a diagnosis has given us all a new lease of life. We understand DD now and life is more manageable.
(And yea I feel, and will do forever, guilty for not ‘understanding’ her earlier. But of course I couldn’t understand what I didn’t know. The diagnosis has literally been a life saver).

Justrealised · 10/07/2021 18:28

I don't think the diagnosis is worth anything any more, if means too many different things to too many people. People who are able to live independently, have families, jobs etc are completely different to those who can't. Getting the help and support people need is more important than any label.

toastantea · 10/07/2021 18:16

it IS absolutely ok not to assess a survivor of domestic violence who is suffering from PTSD.

Ah come on now, that's not what I am saying at all. In fact I previously said...

I would echo the poster who said to speak to your GP. If your child isn't autistic he won't meet the criteria for diagnosis, in fact it's unlikely he would even face a full assessment as the initial findings from school; home and the early developmental questionnaire would rule it out anyway. He could have PTSD and/or ASD though, and there are other possibilities too. GP first call.

However not having an assessment because you fear the 'label' is not ok. Not having it done because you think it's a choice someone should make in adulthood is ridiculous.

5zeds · 10/07/2021 18:04

However judging by the way your posts are going I think you are only looking for justification to deny your child a proper assessment and that's not ok. it IS absolutely ok not to assess a survivor of domestic violence who is suffering from PTSD. I’m fact it’s might be very sensible but it will be harder for OP to judge what is best for her child if people try to shame her into doing what they think is right. Allowing her to explore the situation is a far better idea, if you actually care about what IS best for this child.

KOKOagainandagain · 10/07/2021 17:29

Health care professionals - shock, horror - even doctors can be abysmal. I was told bluntly that DS1 was autistic but that I was lucky because 'he was one of the quiet ones' (selectively mute), that under no circumstances should I seek diagnosis because he would use it as an excuse and that 'mothers' were the most important resource.

I have met many mothers on the Freedom Program whose kids who might have SEND that are refused referral because of DV. DV is known to increase with vulnerability - pregnancy, or physical or mental or developmental issues relating to the mother or children. DV complicates things and makes things worse but it doesn't remove the underlying reality. DV does not cause autism. What behaviours are the school seeing that you think are a result of DV?

If I were you I would bracket the DV and think back over your child's life and development history. Maybe look at the CAST questionnaire.

psychology-tools.com/test/cast

toastantea · 10/07/2021 16:40

@coodawoodashooda

For those of you with an adult diagnosis, what do you feel better about since being diagnosed?

I answered this yesterday and wholeheartedly agree with everything @vanishun has said. However judging by the way your posts are going I think you are only looking for justification to deny your child a proper assessment and that's not ok. Nobody is going to back that OP, nobody. A diagnosis in adulthood changed my peace I had made with my entire past, I had to rework through every bit of hurt and every emotion and if you have the opportunity to prevent your child from even that, aside from intervention then you need to take it. Intervention by the way, even the most minor of adjustments can and do have a massive impact on my life. It isn't something you have the right to refuse someone if they need it.

Vanishun · 10/07/2021 16:35

@coodawoodashooda

For those of you with an adult diagnosis, what do you feel better about since being diagnosed?
At first I was elated - I had an answer, I wasn't broken, I was different.

Then for some time I was sad: I wouldn't change and why, why had this been missed when I was a child? Why had I suffered so unnecessarily for so long? Why didn't people know about autism in girls and women?

Then I adjusted. I've been open about it at work where I had accommodations like a fixed desk in a hotdesking office, and I've worked hard at forgiving myself for the millions of fuck ups in my life.

It's given me the gift of understanding. I like myself now. I love myself. Not in a creepy narcissistic way but in a sincere "I deserve health, happiness" sort of way, I know that I am not a failure. I just literally can't do things that you lot can.

If you'd told me in my teens or 20s when I was suicidal from it all that I could be here, I wouldn't have believed you.

This is probably why I'm so frustrated with your repeated suggestions that therapy is just as good as a diagnosis - it isn't. I'm not looking for validation as a pp said, what bollocks.

The thing is, you can't therapise away the problems where the actual problem is "your body and brain are different". It is actually quite damaging instead and I wasted a lot of time on it and then hating myself for failing it.

FayeFayeFayeFayeFaye · 10/07/2021 16:29

Thing is, having a diagnosis as a child can help you get support for that child. God knows it’s hard enough fighting for your child with a diagnosis, let alone without one.

If I need to say to school my child is autistic you need to be doing xyz, then I will. Same with when they’re in secondary school. Maybe they’ll need more time with exams or need to sit in an environment that suits them. Maybe they’ll need to wear ear defenders at school due to over stimulation or have movement breaks, sensory toys. There’s all sorts of reason that having a diagnosis now can benefit them. I would rather they get a diagnosis now and get support in place than spend years struggling and wondering why they’re different or don’t fit in. It doesn’t mean your child doesn’t have ptsd as well.

Borka · 10/07/2021 16:20

Tal45 lots of people do think that the autistic spectrum means a sort of scale from 0 to 100% autistic and that everyone is on it, not just everyone who's autistic.

coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 16:06

For those of you with an adult diagnosis, what do you feel better about since being diagnosed?

OP posts:
RickiTarr · 10/07/2021 15:43

a typical autistic trait ironically

Not really ironic, TBF. 🤔😁

Tal45 · 10/07/2021 15:42

@BlueSurfer

I’m not sure there is any one specific thing that nobody with ASD can do. It’s a spectrum that everyone is on somewhere.
I think everyone is taking this a bit too literally (a typical autistic trait ironically) - pretty sure BlueSurfer meant 'it's a spectrum that everyone AUTISTIC is on somewhere.' Bizarre to me that everyone jumped on it assuming the opposite after people with ASD were specifically mentioned in the previous sentence.
5zeds · 10/07/2021 15:40

Ignore BBC

5zeds · 10/07/2021 15:39

Yes I know @toastantea but they seem to use DSMv regardless. Our dx was ASD, rather than BBC autism or aspergers

toastantea · 10/07/2021 15:31

ICD10 still has Aspergers as a diagnosis- it's being removed when ICD11 comes into effect in January 2022.

RickiTarr · 10/07/2021 15:29

@5zeds

It would be fairly impossible not to have been a nazi in Germany at that time. He was really me of the few Drs who stayed with their patients so I’m not sure he was to be vilified.

Asperger isn’t un-PC the dx merged with autism.

Agree, the idea that we should abandon any scientific or medical knowledge gained in inter war Germany is laughable.

Especially as nobody seems to mind driving Volkswagens, buying IBM machines or using Krupps equipment etc.

It’s just the name of the chap who first described a certain combination of traits. It doesn’t reflect on the condition.

RickiTarr · 10/07/2021 15:26

@coodawoodashooda

When did aspergers become un pc? I hadn't realised that until lately.
It’s not about PC. It was removed from the DSMV - the manual of psychological conditions that can be diagnosed - so nobody is able to get that diagnosis any more.

Some of us still have it from earlier years, of course.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 10/07/2021 15:19

There are a load of SJWs on social media spreading that Hans Asperger was a nazi and murdered children. The evidence is nowhere near that unequivocal.

The "autism community" is currently a fairly toxic place where lots of different agendas are being spouted as representing all autistic people. Best to take a lot of what is being bandied about with buckets of salt.

5zeds · 10/07/2021 15:16

It would be fairly impossible not to have been a nazi in Germany at that time. He was really me of the few Drs who stayed with their patients so I’m not sure he was to be vilified.

Asperger isn’t un-PC the dx merged with autism.

BlankTimes · 10/07/2021 15:05

Hans Asperger was tied into the Nazi eugenics programme, loads of articles online.

Hankunamatata · 10/07/2021 15:01

I'm finding it tough at the mo to work put what is pc and what isn't. The jigsaw symbol is offensive to some asd people yet lots parents have tattoos etc. I left a parental asd online group as you just got jumped on if you didn't have asd yourself as you possibly couldn't understand.

coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 14:57

When did aspergers become un pc? I hadn't realised that until lately.

OP posts:
RickiTarr · 10/07/2021 13:29

[quote WeMarchOn]@RickiTarr i have a Facebook group for autistic adults and yes a massive amount of us dislike functioning labels!! [/quote]
Oh I don’t doubt it, and I prefer “Aspergers” to the “HF” thing myself.

I was just disagreeing with the word “mostly” and the idea that “Aspergers” is equally disliked.

It’s pretty clear to me that opinion is split.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 10/07/2021 11:55

It's possible to be both traumatised and autistic. In fact as autism is highly heritable, sometimes being raised by (undiagnosed) autistic parent(s) causes trauma in itself. My dad was undiagnosed autistic, cheated on my mother, had extreme emotional and angry outbursts, interspersed with periods of complete emotional detachment and withdrawal. My parents' marriage was awful. My childhood was very frightening and unpredictable and with very little emotional support as my parents were so wrapped up in their own problems.

I had lots and lots and lots of therapy but the anxiety and social stress I feel never resolved. I also have sensory issues. Having spent most of my 20s and 30s blaming myself for not being able to cope as well as other people and driving myself almost insane trying to diagnose myself with various mental illnesses (I identified as bipolar for years - too scared to seek a diagnosis for it), it was a huge relief but also a massive regret to get my autism diagnosis at 40. Literally decades of angst could have been avoided had I known. It could also have helped my parents and siblings if my Dad had realised sooner.

I can see absolutely no disadvantage to getting your son on the waiting list. It'll take years to get seen anyway and plenty of time for life to move on. They won't diagnose him if he doesn't meet the criteria.

By the way, I went to Cambridge as an undiagnosed autistic and met lots of people like me there. I can't see that a diagnosis would have held me back from doing anything that I've done. It might've meant that I avoided the 3 years unemployment on sickness benefits due to total burnout and complete loss of confidence.

LizzieAnt · 10/07/2021 11:53

@5zeds

Ok so what would concern me in your situation is can he access support for PTSD if he has a dx of ASD? If not it would seem prudent to take advice on how to proceed. Here (SW) I know anecdotally that some children have found it harder to access CAHMs services with dx (though I’m talking 5+ years ago and thing may have changed).
I'm in Ireland, not the UK, but my DS has had just this problem. He has a diagnosis of ASD, but also has co-morbid mental health problems that are known to have an increased incidence in the autistic population. CAMHS won't treat for these because they say he needs specialist provision from autism services and the help of therapists who have a lot of experience with autism. However, autism services here don't/can't/won't treat mental health problems of the severity he is experiencing. We've found the gap in services to be really appalling here - hope it's better in the UK.
Swipe left for the next trending thread