Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask questions about autism.

282 replies

coodawoodashooda · 09/07/2021 19:06

About 10 years ago i was in a meeting about autism. The leader said something like, 'if the child could......... then they didnt have autism. What was the quality that was being referred to? Was it empathy? I cant remember and for various personal reasons id really like to know.

OP posts:
RaspberrySchnapps · 10/07/2021 23:04

for my DS it was the process, Because he already knew, but it was an intensely private thing that took all his energy to hide from everyone but me and DH. Talking to the HCPs during the assessment was a revelation.

The thing I didn't expect about the various bits of assessment is that they can be quite enjoyable for DC. Try not to fear them OP, I did and I was wrong, its not the Spanish Inquisition. Mine loved the Ed Psych battery of tests, especially as it got him out of a games lesson. Occupational Therapy also was particularly good, she understood him and that was a huge deal for him.

With appropriate support in place DS is still himself, just much calmer from not putting so much energy into masking and coping. He used to let rip at home to decompress after masking all day at school, now he doesn't do that at all really.

Radio4ordie · 10/07/2021 23:02

@Nayday

Applied behavioural analysis - contraversial 'therapy' where kid is taught to be NT through drills and repetition. Stimming etc is stopped. Many autistic people see it as abusive and on a.par with homosexual conversion therapy.
Many non autistic people also view it as abusive. Awful, awful treatment of people. Should be banned. What’s even more terrible is that it plays on the vulnerability of parents who think they are helping their child when they are complicit in the abuse and often funding it at great expense.
WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia · 10/07/2021 22:50

Autistic people mostly don't like using functioning labels such as lower/higher and the now not diagnosed Asperger's

How many autistic people did you survey?

(Btw some autistic people prefer “person with autism” over “autistic person” if you’re so keen to be inclusive)

Nayday · 10/07/2021 22:47

Different perspectives on the diagnosis label VA support, for me as a parent it's the support I'll be able to fight to get (as opposed to closed door) and give my child a chance at thriving.. autistic kids are massively prone to low self esteem and it makes sense - you're different, find things harder and no idea why. As an adult it's probably less the support and more the a-ha! I can relate to that, I'm not diagnosed but most of the boxes I'm ticking for my son apply to me which has made me a bit 'ohhhh'. I won't pursue diagnosis unless the opportunity drops in my lap but it has made a few things make sense in a very comforting way...

Nayday · 10/07/2021 22:40

Applied behavioural analysis - contraversial 'therapy' where kid is taught to be NT through drills and repetition. Stimming etc is stopped. Many autistic people see it as abusive and on a.par with homosexual conversion therapy.

Aspinelli · 10/07/2021 22:36

@coodawoodashooda

Youve all been amazingly helpful. Thank you. So is it the process of the diagnosis that provides the clarity that gives so much comfort, or is it the support afterwards? Remember, im thinking out loud, not trying to upset anyone.
I was diagnosed as a child, so had support through education and allowences and as an adult the clarity has really helped me be more forgiving to myself.
coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 22:31

Whats ABA?

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 22:17

Youve all been amazingly helpful. Thank you. So is it the process of the diagnosis that provides the clarity that gives so much comfort, or is it the support afterwards? Remember, im thinking out loud, not trying to upset anyone.

OP posts:
Nayday · 10/07/2021 22:07

The education system (I'm assuming you're UK) has very little funding available for SEN. Be prepared to fight to have his needs met in mainstream, or to get him into a specialist provision. The special provision I'm looking at is for average/above average attainments with class sizes of 6 and a team around the child. My son could thrive there but it won't be easy. That takes time, and a certain amount of fight, it can take years. Starting the process in secondary school has obvious disadvantages.

Another point is that if your son has ASD and is undiagnosed + not having his needs met in school, autistic burnout is not uncommon at transition to secondary school and at other points through secondary. It can appear like a 'sudden' breakdown, but it isn't really sudden but the result of years of masking. It's not pleasant, synonym like a depressive breakdown, and takes time to recover from, I wish I'd spotted this sooner for my child.
Y
Finally your child may get to his teen years, need help, but not recognise this himself and refuse to engage with assessment. A difficult position for you as a parent, and not uncommon.

Unmet needs lead to problems, dealing with this in the teenage years with puberty is unlikely to be in anyway easier - and there is precious little support if things do go 'bang'. Not looking to be doom and gloom but most people looking to get diagnosed as teens is because there are significant issues that need attention, if I could compare it to something it would be elective vs emergency c section, same operation but one is much more stressful...

toastantea · 10/07/2021 22:06

@theDudesmummy

Yes, a certain form of therapy does change the impact (not the fact) of autism. It is called ABA.

ABA is horrific. It's not therapy, it's fucking abuse.

theDudesmummy · 10/07/2021 21:59

Yes, a certain form of therapy does change the impact (not the fact) of autism. It is called ABA.

theDudesmummy · 10/07/2021 21:57

Please stop saying everyone is on the autistic spectrum. That is entirely untrue.

toastantea · 10/07/2021 21:57

It's difficult. Hearing that your child has a life long condition that is going to affect every part of their lives, is a difficult thing to hear.

This is where parents need to step up and out their children first though. Yes it's difficult but ultimately denying your child a diagnosis or at the very least an assessment because its difficult to face as a parent isn't doing the best for the child.

It is not similar to diabetes, which can be managed by medication and diet. Autism requires months-years of therapy to improve aspects of their quality of life.

Therapy? Therapy doesn't change autism.

RaspberrySchnapps · 10/07/2021 21:55

DS (13) has been assessed as HFASD. For him the process has been empowering. He says it makes sense.

We weren't keen on labelling him, we didn't want him to find out and restrict himself to a set of traits but its not really like that. When he went through the assessment he met different HCPs who understood him and asked questions about things he thought nobody else knew about or could see in him. Masking is exhausting, it was a huge relief for him to let go of that in those assessment meetings too, it made him feel understood, accepted and valued.

And he has boatloads of empathy, he's like a heartstring when it comes to other people. He just doesn't broadcast it in the same way. The empathy thing ie a red herring.

For those who say its a spectrum that 'everyone is on somewhere' (eg the useless HT at DS last school who should know better 🙄), or that therapy can make a difference (when it really can't), try and look at it instead as some people are PCs, some people are Mac. Or Linux.

secular39 · 10/07/2021 21:47

@FayeFayeFayeFayeFaye

A diagnosis or ‘label’ isn’t a negative thing. It’s a positive. It’s better than being labelled naughty or the class clown or being expelled, because that’s what used to happen. See it as a positive thing as it can access support. It’s not something I would wait til secondary school for as if your child has asd, you’ll want that support in place already.

And like pp said, if he’s not autistic he won’t get a diagnosis. Maybe it will open other kinds of support he needs.

Our school said that parents often refused to hear it when they mentioned it, they didn’t want their child labelled. I never had an issue with it, yes I was upset about it, but I never saw it as a negative thing. If it was diabetes or asthma then no one would question it, yet somehow because we can’t ‘see’ autism (so to speak) it’s somehow different.

Also it was only when I had my next child I realised something wasn’t quite right.

It's difficult. Hearing that your child has a life long condition that is going to affect every part of their lives, is a difficult thing to hear. It is not similar to diabetes, which can be managed by medication and diet. Autism requires months-years of therapy to improve aspects of their quality of life.
Lougle · 10/07/2021 21:14

For DD1 it's been really empowering. She knows now, that there is a reason she feels the way she does. She understands that her feelings of complete exhaustion after school arise from the extra effort it takes her to fit in at school. She is happy that she has her very small group of friends and she doesn't feel the need to try and be friends with everyone.

It's not all plain sailing, but it has given her confidence in herself.

lakesummer · 10/07/2021 21:04

When my ds had his assessments which as I said included assessment for autism he was very much the center of the process and a knowing participant.

When we got the results they were explained firstly to him and then later to us as parents.

This wasn't a process that was just done to him.

FayeFayeFayeFayeFaye · 10/07/2021 19:11

A diagnosis or ‘label’ isn’t a negative thing. It’s a positive. It’s better than being labelled naughty or the class clown or being expelled, because that’s what used to happen. See it as a positive thing as it can access support. It’s not something I would wait til secondary school for as if your child has asd, you’ll want that support in place already.

And like pp said, if he’s not autistic he won’t get a diagnosis. Maybe it will open other kinds of support he needs.

Our school said that parents often refused to hear it when they mentioned it, they didn’t want their child labelled. I never had an issue with it, yes I was upset about it, but I never saw it as a negative thing. If it was diabetes or asthma then no one would question it, yet somehow because we can’t ‘see’ autism (so to speak) it’s somehow different.

Also it was only when I had my next child I realised something wasn’t quite right.

coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 19:03

Im waiting to hear back from the gp. I trust her. So far.

OP posts:
ObviousNameChage · 10/07/2021 19:01

@coodawoodashooda

I think my struggle is mostly because i think 'asd' is being bandied around because there is so little under about how we were persecuted by my xh. My kids still regularly experience this. The fear and heightened escalation of fear, the desperate feeling of trying to please him etc etc. I also am not saying a diagnosis should wait til adulthood but certainly early secondary school years. I think. So much has been done to my child against his will. I want him to be active and knowingly part of the process.
Are you seeking a PTSD diagnosis then?
Lougle · 10/07/2021 18:53

A diagnosis does help. DD1 has SN. She's always been to special school. Her behaviour has seemed to baffle the teachers, until I raised the possibility of ASD. Now they've seen her in a whole new light and her behaviour makes sense to them.

Lougle · 10/07/2021 18:50

@coodawoodashooda

I think my struggle is mostly because i think 'asd' is being bandied around because there is so little under about how we were persecuted by my xh. My kids still regularly experience this. The fear and heightened escalation of fear, the desperate feeling of trying to please him etc etc. I also am not saying a diagnosis should wait til adulthood but certainly early secondary school years. I think. So much has been done to my child against his will. I want him to be active and knowingly part of the process.
Honestly, the assessment process is so thorough. It isn't a case of 'social difficulties' = ASD or 'differences=ASD'. It's about observing behaviours that are subtle and then putting them in a context. For example, with one of the assessment tasks, DD2 needed to ask for help from the assessor. The situation had been manufactured by the assessor, but watching DD2, I could see her weighing up her options. She either had to not finish the task, or she had to ask for help from the assessor. She obviously decided that not finishing the task was worse, but her difficulty with the decision was obvious.

They don't assess alone, either. We had two Specialist SALTs and a clinical psychologist.

toastantea · 10/07/2021 18:50

@Justrealised

I don't think the diagnosis is worth anything any more, if means too many different things to too many people. People who are able to live independently, have families, jobs etc are completely different to those who can't. Getting the help and support people need is more important than any label.

You don't get the help without the diagnosis in many many circumstances. I had to wait until I was over 40 before I was able to ask for reasonable adjustments. I had to wait all those years. The diagnosis is worth more then gold to me, and to my children who also have benefited from extra help and adjustments where needed. Please don't minimise that.

coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 18:47

I dont feel like the normal way of bringing him up isn't working. I feel that the, 'come down' from coping with being with his weird controlling bastard father sets him on edge and that he is exhausted from being in a constant state of trying to please his father and gain his love so that he will be nice.

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 18:39

I think my struggle is mostly because i think 'asd' is being bandied around because there is so little under about how we were persecuted by my xh. My kids still regularly experience this. The fear and heightened escalation of fear, the desperate feeling of trying to please him etc etc. I also am not saying a diagnosis should wait til adulthood but certainly early secondary school years. I think. So much has been done to my child against his will. I want him to be active and knowingly part of the process.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread